NSG 448 Topic 1 picot narrowing paper example

Evidence-Based Project Capstone Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NSG 448 Topic 1 sample paper narrows hospital-acquired infection, in four recorded cuts, to stool tests for C. difficile sent after laxatives on one composite medical floor. It was written for GCU NSG 448, Evidence-Based Project Capstone, catalog code NSG-448, a course in Grand Canyon University's BSN. The broad concern is stated with McDonald and colleagues' IDSA and SHEA guideline. A funnel table records each cut, what was set aside and who would own it. Each cut is justified, with Rock and Maragakis on diagnostic stewardship. The PICOT question is built element by element, after Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt, and what it does not claim is stated plainly.

CourseNSG 448 Evidence-Based Project Capstone
TopicTopic 1
Paper typePractice question narrowing
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NSG 448 Topic 1

1

Four Cuts to a Question: Narrowing Hospital-Acquired Infection to Stool Tests Sent After Laxatives on One Medical Floor

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NSG-448: Evidence-Based Project Capstone

Topic 1 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

October 4, 2027

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names the method and where it ends. A broad concern is narrowed in four labeled cuts, each recording what was set aside and who would own it, until the problem is small enough for one student on one floor to address. The PICOT question is then built element by element. The floor is a composite.
2

Four Cuts to a Question: Narrowing Hospital-Acquired Infection to Stool Tests Sent After Laxatives on One Medical Floor

The Broad Concern

Hospital-acquired infections harm patients, lengthen stays and are publicly reported. Among them, Clostridioides difficile infection is one of the most common in U.S. hospitals, and hospital-onset cases count against a hospital's reported rates. The concern is real, but it is far too large for a capstone project. My position is modest: I have spent eight clinical days on a composite 28-bed medical floor as a student. I am not employed there, have no authority over its practice, and will be on the floor for twelve more weeks. A project I propose must be one the floor's own staff could carry out and one whose effect could be seen in that time.

The Funnel

Table 1 shows the four cuts. Each records what was set aside and who would own it, so the discarded ground stays visible.

Table 1

Narrowing in Four Cuts

CutFromToSet asideOwner of what was set aside
1All hospital-acquired infectionsHospital-onset C. difficile infectionBloodstream, urinary, surgical site and respiratory infectionsInfection prevention department
2Hospital-onset C. difficile across the hospitalOn one composite medical floorOther units, including intensive care and oncologyEach unit's practice council
3All hospital-onset C. difficile on the floorCases identified by stool tests sent for patients who had received laxatives in the prior 48 hoursTransmission, antibiotic use and environmental cleaningAntimicrobial stewardship team; environmental services
4Tests after laxatives, as a countThe practice behind them: samples sent on an order written at night on a report of "diarrhea" without a check of recent laxatives or stool frequencyProvider ordering habits and the laboratory's rejection criteriaHospitalist group; laboratory

Why Each Cut

Cut 1. C. difficile was chosen over other infections because the floor's infection preventionist named it as the floor's leading reported infection, and because the nurse's role in testing is direct. The others remain important and belong to infection prevention.

Cut 2. One floor, because it is the only one I know and the only one where I could observe practice.

Cut 3. Tests after laxatives, because they produce infections that may not be real. C. difficile can colonize the gut without causing disease, and a patient with loose stools from a laxative who carries it will test positive and be counted as a hospital-onset case. Current guidelines recommend testing only when a patient has had at least three unformed stools within a day and no laxative in the two days before (McDonald et al., 2018). In a review of 20 hospital-onset cases on the floor over the prior year, which the infection preventionist shared in aggregate, 7 had received a laxative within 48 hours of the test.

Cut 4. The practice, because it is what a nurse can change. On the floor, a nurse reports "diarrhea" to the covering provider at night, the provider orders a test, and the nurse sends a sample. Nobody in that chain is asked to check whether the patient received a laxative or how many unformed stools there have been, so the test goes out on a report of loose stool alone. Diagnostic stewardship programs have reduced inappropriate testing by building that check into the ordering and collecting steps (Rock & Maragakis, 2019).

What this page is doingThe funnel is drawn as a table with four labeled cuts, and each records what was set aside and who owns it. The reasons for each cut follow, and the highlighted sentence identifies the practice gap a nurse could change. The student's limited position is stated plainly.
3

The PICOT Question, Element by Element

Population. Adult patients on the composite medical floor for whom a C. difficile stool test is ordered.

Intervention. A nurse-completed pre-test check before a stool sample is sent: laxative or stool softener received in the past 48 hours, and number of unformed stools in the past 24 hours. If a laxative was given or there have been fewer than three unformed stools, the nurse holds the sample and contacts the provider using a scripted message.

Comparison. Current practice: samples sent when ordered, without a structured check. The comparison is current practice, not no intervention, because testing will continue either way.

Outcome. The percentage of C. difficile tests sent from the floor that meet guideline criteria, measured by chart review of every test. Hospital-onset infection counts were rejected as the primary outcome because the floor sees about one or two cases a month, too few to show a change in twelve weeks. Tests sent are far more frequent, about 15 a month, and the percentage meeting criteria is something the intervention acts on directly (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023).

Time. Twelve weeks after implementation, compared with the twelve weeks before.

The assembled question. For adults on a medical floor for whom a C. difficile test is ordered (P), does a nurse-completed pre-test check of recent laxatives and stool frequency (I), compared with current practice of sending samples as ordered (C), increase the percentage of tests that meet guideline criteria (O) over twelve weeks (T)?

What the Question Does Not Claim

The question does not claim that the project will reduce infections, only inappropriate tests, which are the step that produces some false infection counts. It does not claim that I will implement it. The floor's practice council, with the nurse manager and the hospitalist group, would decide whether to adopt the check; my role is to bring the evidence and a draft of the checklist. And it does not address the causes of true C. difficile infection, which belong to the owners named in Table 1.

The narrowing also has a cost. By the fourth cut, the project touches perhaps 15 tests a month on one floor, a tiny share of the hospital's infection problem. That is deliberate. A question this narrow can be answered within the project window with data the floor already has, and if the check works, the practice council can offer it to other units. A question left at the level of hospital-acquired infections would have been important and unanswerable by a student in twelve weeks.

References

McDonald, L. C., Gerding, D. N., Johnson, S., Bakken, J. S., Carroll, K. C., Coffin, S. E., Dubberke, E. R., Garey, K. W., Gould, C. V., Kelly, C., Loo, V., Shaklee Sammons, J., Sandora, T. J., & Wilcox, M. H. (2018). Clinical practice guidelines for Clostridium difficile infection in adults and children: 2017 update by the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America (SHEA). Clinical Infectious Diseases, 66(7), e1-e48. https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cix1085

Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

Rock, C., & Maragakis, L. L. (2019). Diagnostic stewardship for Clostridiodes difficile testing: From laxatives to diarrhea and beyond. Clinical Infectious Diseases, 71(6), 1479-1480. https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciz982

Reading the GCU NSG 448 Topic 1 instructions

Topic 1 in NSG-448 asks students to identify a practice problem and develop a PICOT question for the capstone. Strong papers start from a broad concern and narrow it in recorded steps, stating at each step what was set aside and who would own it, so the discarded ground stays visible. Students should justify each cut, build the PICOT question one element at a time with each element specified to the level the unit's data can support and state what the question does not claim, for example choosing a process outcome rather than an infection rate on a single unit. The problem can come from a rotation unit if the instructions allow it.

Inside the NSG 448 Topic 1 example

The narrowing is drawn as a funnel with four labeled cuts. Hospital-acquired infections become catheter-associated urinary tract infections; those become infections on one composite surgical floor; that becomes catheters still in place on the second post-operative day with no indication charted; and that becomes the practice behind it, removal that waits for a provider order written at rounds. Each cut records what was set aside and who would own it, so the discarded ground is visible rather than lost. The student's position is stated plainly: several clinical days on the floor, no employment there, no authority over its practice. The paper ends with a PICOT question built element by element, with catheter days, rather than infection counts, chosen as the outcome because a single floor sees too few infections to show change in months.

NSG 448 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a question narrowed in recorded steps. An Excellent paper starts from hospital-acquired infection and records four cuts in a funnel table, each with what was set aside and its owner. Credit goes to justifying the focus on stool tests after laxatives with McDonald and colleagues' testing criteria and Rock and Maragakis on diagnostic stewardship. The rubric values a PICOT question built element by element, after Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt. Top marks go to stating that the project targets inappropriate tests, not infection rates.

Common NSG 448 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Scope is where the first marks disappear. Reducing hospital infections is a fine concern and an unusable project, because nothing one student proposes can reach it. Narrowing done silently loses marks too: the paper lands on a small problem without showing the cuts, so the reader cannot tell whether it was chosen or stumbled into. A PICOT question with an intervention nobody on the floor could deliver, or an outcome too rare to measure, fails on the element it gets wrong. Some papers claim authority the student does not have, writing as though implementation were theirs to start. Leaving the comparison as no intervention at all, rather than current practice, is a quieter error. The strongest versions show every cut, give the discarded ground an owner and choose an outcome the floor could move within the project window.

Get an NSG-448 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the NSG-448 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, along with the unit type you observed and the broad concern you are starting from. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the narrowing recorded step by step and a PICOT question built and defended element by element, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More NSG 448 papers and BSN samples

NSG 448 Topic 1 questions, answered

What does each letter of PICOT stand for?

Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome and Time. In a capstone proposal the comparison is usually current practice rather than doing nothing, and the time element is the period over which the outcome would be measured, not the length of the project as a whole. Each element should be specific enough that two readers would picture the same patients, the same change and the same measure.

Can the problem come from a unit where I only had clinical rotations?

Usually yes, and in a pre-licensure capstone it often has to. Make that explicit, describe what you observed and over how many shifts, and keep the unit and every patient unidentifiable. Your clinical hours, any practicum log and preceptor evaluations remain your own record; the sample shows only the written reasoning built from what you saw.

Why not use infection rates as the outcome?

Because on a single floor they are usually too rare to change measurably over a short project, so a proposal built on them could not show whether it worked. Catheter days, or catheter use relative to patient days, move faster and sit directly on the causal path, since the infection in question cannot occur without a catheter in place. The infection rate can still be reported as a longer-term aim.

Where can I find a free NSG 448 Topic 1 sample paper?

The question paper for NSG 448 Topic 1 covers the broad concern, the funnel, why each cut, the PICOT question element by element and what the question does not claim. Send your NSG 448 Topic 1 prompt and a paper follows free.

Why record what was set aside in NSG 448 Topic 1?

Because the narrowing is itself evidence of reasoning. Showing each cut and who would own the discarded problem proves the final question was chosen, not stumbled on.