NUR 502 Topic 5 borrowed theory critique example

Theoretical Foundations for Nursing Roles and Practice Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 502 Topic 5 sample paper examines Selye's stress theory, borrowed from the laboratory, asking what it assumed, what nursing carried in and which original conditions no longer hold. It belongs to GCU NUR 502, Theoretical Foundations for Nursing Roles and Practice, listed as NUR-502, offered through Grand Canyon University's MSN. Selye's 1936 rat studies and the general adaptation syndrome are described. Nursing took a physiological basis for whole-person care, visible in Neuman's systems model. The theory carried in a view of the person as reacting to agents. Mason's critique undermines nonspecificity. Lazarus and Folkman's transactional model fits better, and whether the borrowing was shared or taken is judged.

CourseNUR 502 Theoretical Foundations for Nursing Roles and Practice
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeBorrowed theory analysis
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 502 Topic 5

1

Borrowed From the Laboratory: What Selye's Stress Theory Assumed, What Nursing Carried In and Which Conditions No Longer Hold

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-502: Theoretical Foundations for Nursing Roles and Practice

Topic 5 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

April 10, 2028

What this page is doingThe title begins where the theory began, in a physiology laboratory, and follows it into nursing. The paper states the original setting and assumptions before examining the import, and is willing to conclude that nursing uses the theory more loosely than its source supports.
2

Borrowed From the Laboratory: What Selye's Stress Theory Assumed, What Nursing Carried In and Which Conditions No Longer Hold

Where the Theory Began

In 1936, Hans Selye reported that rats exposed to a wide range of harmful agents, cold, surgical injury, spinal shock, excessive exercise and sublethal doses of various drugs, showed the same set of physical changes: enlargement of the adrenal glands, shrinking of the thymus and lymph tissue, and ulcers in the stomach (Selye, 1936). Because the response was the same whatever the agent, he called it a general adaptation syndrome and described three stages: an alarm reaction, a stage of resistance in which the body adapts, and a stage of exhaustion if the harmful agent continues. He later called the agents stressors and the nonspecific response stress (Selye, 1956).

The original setting carried specific assumptions. The subjects were animals. The stressors were physical and usually severe. The response measured was physiological, organ weights and tissue changes. And the central claim was nonspecificity: that the body's response is the same regardless of what causes it.

What Nursing Took

Nursing borrowed Selye's model early and widely. It gave nursing a physiological basis for attending to the whole person, since any stressor, physical or not, could produce bodily effects. It shaped nursing models: Neuman's model pictures the client as a system surrounded by lines of defense and resistance against stressors, language that echoes Selye's stages of alarm and resistance (Neuman & Fawcett, 2011). In practice, the word stress became part of everyday nursing vocabulary for a patient's anxiety, a family's worry or a nurse's workload.

What the move gained. In a clinical setting, the theory helped explain real observations: that surgery, infection and emotional distress can all raise cortisol, suppress immunity and slow healing; and that prolonged illness can exhaust a patient's reserves. It gave nurses a reason to reduce unnecessary stressors, such as noise, pain and sleep deprivation, as part of physical care.

What It Carried In Silently

The theory carried in a view of the person as a physiological system reacting to external agents, with little room for how the person understands the event. It also carried the assumption of nonspecificity: that a death in the family, a surgical incision and a noisy ward produce the same kind of response. And it carried the language of exhaustion, which can suggest that a patient's decline is an inevitable stage rather than something that can be prevented.

Which Original Conditions No Longer Hold

Nonspecificity has not held up well. Mason (1971) reexamined the evidence and argued that many of the responses Selye attributed to physical stressors were produced by the psychological reaction to them, the fear and distress of the animal, and that when the emotional component was removed, the hormonal response to some physical stressors was much reduced or absent. That undermines the central claim that the response is the same whatever the cause. Human responses also depend on how a person appraises the situation: a surgery that one patient sees as a relief may be a catastrophe to another. The theory's laboratory conditions, severe physical stressors in animals and physiological outcomes, do not match most of what nurses call stress in patients, which is psychological, varies with meaning and is measured by self-report.

Nursing therefore uses Selye's theory more loosely than its source supports: the word stress has traveled into nursing far more successfully than the general adaptation syndrome has, and when nurses speak of a patient's stress they usually mean something closer to psychological distress than to Selye's nonspecific physiological syndrome. That looseness is not harmless. A nurse who treats all stressors as equivalent may miss that what distresses a particular patient is the meaning of the event, not the event itself.

What this page is doingThe paper states the theory's original setting and assumptions before examining the import, then identifies what nursing gained and what it carried in without examining. The highlighted sentence reaches the conclusion the analysis earns: nursing uses the theory more loosely than its source supports.
3

A Borrowing That Fits Better

If nursing needs a theory of stress for the patients it actually cares for, a closer fit is the transactional model of Lazarus and Folkman (1984), which was developed from research on people, not animals, and places appraisal at the center. In that model, an event becomes stressful when a person judges it as threatening, harmful or challenging, and judges their resources as insufficient to meet it. Coping is what the person does in response, either to change the situation or to manage the emotions it brings. The model predicts that two patients facing the same surgery will respond differently depending on what the surgery means to each and what support each has, which is what nurses observe every day.

This model also borrows from another discipline, psychology, and it too must be examined before import. Its assumptions include a person able to appraise and report their own appraisal, which does not hold for patients who are delirious, sedated or very young. But its conditions are closer to nursing's than Selye's were. Replacing a loose use of Selye with a careful use of Lazarus and Folkman would give nursing a theory whose original setting resembles the one it is being used in, which is the first test any borrowed theory should pass.

Was the Borrowing Shared or Taken?

A theory used well by two disciplines differs from one that was simply taken. Selye's work was not developed with nursing, and nursing did not contribute to testing or refining it; it was taken, largely as a vocabulary and a general orientation. Physiology and psychology, meanwhile, moved on, toward more specific models of stress hormones and of appraisal and coping. Where nursing has kept up, as in research on the physiological effects of sleep deprivation or pain in hospitalized patients, it has done so by drawing on those later, more specific models rather than on the general adaptation syndrome. The lesson for borrowing is concrete: a borrowed theory must be followed back to its source periodically, because the source discipline may have revised the very claims nursing is still using.

References

Lazarus, R. S., & Folkman, S. (1984). Stress, appraisal, and coping. Springer.

Mason, J. W. (1971). A re-evaluation of the concept of "non-specificity" in stress theory. Journal of Psychiatric Research, 8(3-4), 323-333. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-3956(71)90028-8

Neuman, B., & Fawcett, J. (Eds.). (2011). The Neuman systems model (5th ed.). Pearson.

Selye, H. (1936). A syndrome produced by diverse nocuous agents. Nature, 138(3479), 32. https://doi.org/10.1038/138032a0

Selye, H. (1956). The stress of life. McGraw-Hill.

What the NUR 502 Topic 5 instructions ask for

Topic 5 in NUR-502 asks students to analyze a theory borrowed from another discipline. Strong papers return to the theory's origin in its home discipline, describe what nursing took from it and identify what the theory carried in silently, such as assumptions about the person. Students should examine which of the original conditions no longer hold in light of later evidence, consider whether another borrowed theory fits nursing's patients better and judge whether the borrowing was shared or simply taken. Borrowing is not a criticism of nursing, and finding that a theory fits badly is a strong result when it is argued from evidence. Primary sources from the home discipline should be read and cited.

How the NUR-502 Topic 5 example is put together

The finished example begins where the theory began. A change model from organizational psychology, a stress model from physiology, a learning theory from education, each was written to explain something specific in a setting with its own assumptions, and the example states those before importing anything. The move into nursing is then examined rather than assumed: what the theory gains from a clinical setting, what it silently carries in, and which of its original conditions no longer hold. The example is willing to conclude that a borrowed theory is used more loosely in nursing than its source supports. It closes by asking whether the borrowing is shared, since a theory used well by two disciplines is different from one that was taken.

Where the marks sit in the NUR 502 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward a borrowed theory traced to its origin. An Excellent paper returns to Selye's 1936 rat studies and the general adaptation syndrome. Credit goes to showing what nursing took, through Neuman and Fawcett's systems model, and what came in silently, a person reacting rather than appraising. The rubric values Mason's critique of nonspecificity. Strong papers propose Lazarus and Folkman's transactional model as a better fit. Top marks go to judging the borrowing as taken rather than shared, since nursing did not shape Selye's work. Origins are cited.

Common NUR 502 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

The paper that never leaves nursing is the standard loss, describing a borrowed theory entirely through nursing citations and never establishing what it meant at home. Without the origin there is nothing to compare and the critique has no ground to stand on. The second loss is a critique that finds the fit perfect, which is rarely true and reads as unexamined. Papers lose marks for treating any non-nursing source as borrowed, since a theory jointly developed is a different case. Citing the original author through a secondary nursing summary defeats the exercise. Concluding only that nurses should use theory carefully wastes the analysis that came before it and states nothing a reader could disagree with.

Get an NUR-502 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-502 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the borrowed theory your section assigned if there is one. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the theory cited to its original author, the home discipline's assumptions surfaced and the fit to nursing judged honestly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More NUR 502 papers and MSN samples

NUR 502 Topic 5 questions, answered

Is borrowing a theory a criticism of nursing?

No, and papers that treat it that way misread the topic. Every applied discipline borrows, and a theory that explains human behavior does not stop applying because a nurse is the one using it. What the assignment asks is whether the borrowing was done carefully, which is a question about the user rather than about the discipline's maturity.

How do I find what the theory meant in its home discipline?

Go to the original publication, which is usually findable and often shorter than the nursing commentary about it. Read what problem the author was solving and what population they had in mind. Databases outside nursing will hold the follow up work, and citing one or two of those shows you crossed the border rather than reading about it from this side.

What if the theory fits nursing badly?

That is a strong finding and worth arguing fully. A change model built for corporate restructuring may assume a hierarchy, a timescale and a set of incentives that a clinical floor does not have, and saying so precisely is better work than forcing the fit. Name what nursing would need to add or alter for the theory to hold, which turns a criticism into a contribution.

Where can I find a free NUR 502 Topic 5 sample paper?

The borrowed theory paper for NUR 502 Topic 5 covers where the theory began, what nursing took, what it carried in silently, which conditions no longer hold, a borrowing that fits better and whether it was shared or taken. Forward the NUR 502 Topic 5 prompt you received for a free paper.

Is borrowing a theory a criticism of nursing in NUR 502 Topic 5?

No. Many disciplines borrow. The question is whether the theory fits the patients nursing cares for and whether nursing tested it rather than simply adopting it.