NUR 514 Topic 3 change model analysis example

Organizational Leadership and Informatics Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 514 Topic 3 sample paper compares how Lewin, Kotter and diffusion of innovations diagnose resistance, then tests diffusion against a structured admission assessment rolled out at a composite 200-bed hospital. It forms part of GCU NUR 514, Organizational Leadership and Informatics, catalog code NUR-514, taken within Grand Canyon University's MSN. Lewin treats resistance as inertia, Kotter as missing urgency and coalition, and Rogers as a property of the innovation. The diffusion model predicted acceptance from relative advantage. Two months after go-live, completion within eight hours was 71 percent on days and 48 percent at night. Where the prediction broke down is examined with Greenhalgh and colleagues, and a different diagnosis is considered.

CourseNUR 514 Organizational Leadership and Informatics
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeChange model comparison
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 514 Topic 3

1

Three Diagnoses of Resistance: Lewin, Kotter and Diffusion Compared, and Diffusion Tested Against a New Structured Admission Assessment

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-514: Organizational Leadership and Informatics

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

January 22, 2029

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title separates the models by what each thinks resistance is, since that diagnosis determines the prescription. One model is applied to a specific documentation change, named for the resistance it expects, and then reported where its prediction broke down. The hospital and rollout are composites.
2

Three Diagnoses of Resistance: Lewin, Kotter and Diffusion Compared, and Diffusion Tested Against a New Structured Admission Assessment

Three Diagnoses

Change models differ most in what they think resistance is, and each diagnosis prescribes a different response.

Lewin's model treats resistance as inertia: a group's current behavior is held in place by a balance of forces, and change requires unfreezing that equilibrium, moving to a new level and refreezing it so it holds (Lewin, 1947). The prescription is to weaken the forces holding the old way, strengthen those pushing toward the new, and then stabilize the new behavior with norms and structures.

Kotter's framework treats resistance as a coalition problem: change fails when too few influential people feel urgency and when early momentum is lost. Its steps, from establishing a sense of urgency and forming a guiding coalition through generating short-term wins to anchoring changes in the culture, prescribe building urgency and a coalition, then protecting early wins (Kotter, 1996).

Diffusion approaches treat resistance as a matter of speed: different people adopt an innovation at different times for different reasons. Rogers (2003) described adopter categories from innovators and early adopters to the late majority and laggards, and five attributes of an innovation that affect how fast it spreads: relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability and observability. The prescription is to design and present the innovation so its advantages are visible and its use easy, and to work through early adopters whom others watch.

The Change

A composite 200-bed hospital replaced its free-text nursing admission history with a structured admission assessment in the electronic record. The new build required nurses to complete fall risk, delirium screening, pressure injury risk, nutrition screening and a functional baseline in discrete fields for every admission, with each screen triggering an order or referral when positive. The change affected every inpatient nurse and was planned by a nurse informaticist with the chief nursing officer's sponsorship. The hospital chose a diffusion approach for the rollout, because the new assessment could be piloted on two units before hospital-wide go-live and because informatics leaders believed nurses would adopt it once they saw its benefits.

What the Model Predicted

Applying diffusion theory, the rollout team predicted resistance based on the innovation's attributes. Relative advantage would be clear: automatic referrals would replace manual ones. Compatibility was a concern, since experienced nurses were used to writing a narrative. Complexity was moderate, with about 60 discrete fields. Trialability was high, since the pilot units could try it first. Observability was expected to be high, because early adopters on the pilot units would show others that referrals happened faster. The team predicted that most nurses would adopt quickly once they saw the pilot results, that a late majority of senior nurses would adopt more slowly because the structured format was less compatible with their habits, and that a small group would resist to the end. It planned super-users on each unit, drawn from the early adopters, to model use and help colleagues.

Where the Prediction Broke Down

Two months after go-live, completion of the structured assessment within the required eight hours of admission was 71 percent on day shift and 48 percent on night shift. The resistance the model predicted, from senior nurses who preferred narrative, was present but small. The larger resistance was not about individuals adopting at different speeds; it was about time: the structured assessment took about 25 minutes per admission, compared with 12 for the old narrative, and night shift, which receives most emergency department admissions, had no additional staff to absorb it. Night nurses were not late adopters in Rogers' sense. Many had used the new assessment enthusiastically on the pilot units and understood its advantages; they simply could not complete it for four admissions in a night while caring for their other patients.

Diffusion theory also fit poorly because the change was mandatory. Rogers' model describes voluntary adoption, where individuals decide whether and when to adopt. In a hospital where the old template was removed, nurses had no choice to decline, only a choice to complete the new assessment fully, partly or late. Greenhalgh et al. (2004), in a systematic review of diffusion in health service organizations, noted that adoption in organizations depends heavily on system readiness, resources and the fit between an innovation and existing work, not only on the attributes of the innovation and individual adopters. The rollout team had attended to the attributes and the adopters and missed the system.

What this page is doingThe model's prediction is set out in its own terms before the results are reported. The highlighted sentence identifies why the prediction broke down: the resistance was a structural problem of time, which a model about individual adoption speed was not designed to see.
3

What a Different Diagnosis Would Have Prescribed

Lewin's force field approach would have mapped the restraining forces before go-live, and time would almost certainly have appeared among them, prompting the team to reduce the assessment's length or add night admission support. Kotter's framework would have emphasized short-term wins and removing obstacles to action, and the night shift's workload would have been an obvious obstacle once front-line nurses were in the guiding coalition. The hospital eventually responded by moving nutrition and functional screening to within 24 hours rather than 8, and by adding an admission nurse on nights, after which night-shift completion rose. The lesson for choosing a model is to choose it for the resistance the change is likely to meet, and to ask front-line staff what that resistance will be before assuming it will be about individual preference.

None of this means diffusion theory was useless. It correctly predicted that the pilot units' experience would matter, and super-users drawn from early adopters did help colleagues learn the build quickly. Its attention to observability also paid off: once the referral reports showed dietitians seeing at-risk patients a day sooner, even skeptical nurses cited the result. The model explained how people learned and accepted the new assessment; it did not explain whether they had the time to complete it. A leader who uses it should pair it with a model that looks at the work itself.

References

Greenhalgh, T., Robert, G., Macfarlane, F., Bate, P., & Kyriakidou, O. (2004). Diffusion of innovations in service organizations: Systematic review and recommendations. The Milbank Quarterly, 82(4), 581-629. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0887-378X.2004.00325.x

Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change. Harvard Business School Press.

Lewin, K. (1947). Frontiers in group dynamics: Concept, method and reality in social science; social equilibria and social change. Human Relations, 1(1), 5-41. https://doi.org/10.1177/001872674700100103

Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). Free Press.

Reading the GCU NUR 514 Topic 3 instructions

Topic 3 in NUR-514 asks students to compare change models and apply one to a change. Strong papers compare models by what each thinks resistance is, since each diagnosis prescribes a different response, rather than listing their steps. Students should apply a model's predictions to a real or composite change, report what actually happened with data and explain where the prediction broke down and why. The paper should consider what a different diagnosis would have prescribed and recognize that resistance is not always a problem to manage, since it can signal a real flaw such as added time on a short-staffed shift. Choosing a model suited to technology changes should be argued from the change itself.

How the NUR-514 Topic 3 example is put together

The finished example compares models on the question that separates them, which is what they think resistance is. A three stage model treats it as inertia to be unfrozen; a multi step framework treats it as a coalition problem solved by urgency and early wins; diffusion approaches treat it as an adoption curve where different people move at different speeds for different reasons. Those are three different diagnoses and they prescribe three different responses. The example applies one to a specific system change, a new documentation build or a shift in a workflow, and shows the model naming the resistance it expects. It then reports where the prediction breaks down, usually because a group the model did not anticipate turns out to hold the decision.

Where the marks sit in the NUR 514 Topic 3 rubric

Faculty reward models compared by their diagnosis of resistance. An Excellent paper treats Lewin's resistance as inertia, Kotter's as missing urgency and Rogers's as a property of the innovation. Credit goes to applying diffusion to the structured admission assessment and reporting completion of 71 percent on days and 48 percent at night. The rubric values explaining that the prediction missed time pressure on nights, with Greenhalgh and colleagues on diffusion in health services. Top marks go to showing that Lewin's force field would have found the restraining force.

Common NUR 514 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Comparing models by counting their steps is the shallow version, and it produces a paper that cannot say why anybody would choose one. The second loss is a model applied with no resistance predicted, which omits the thing the topic is examining. Papers lose marks for treating resistance as an obstacle to be overcome rather than as information about what the change costs somebody, since the second reading produces better plans. Selecting a model because it is well known rather than because it fits the change forfeits the argument. Claiming a model will work without naming where it might fail reads as unexamined at graduate level. Models cited to a course slide rather than to their author lose a source mark.

Get an NUR-514 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-514 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the system change you are writing about and any model your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the models compared on their account of resistance, one applied stage by stage and the prediction's weak point named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More NUR 514 papers and MSN samples

NUR 514 Topic 3 questions, answered

How do I compare change models meaningfully?

By what each thinks the problem is. Counting stages tells a reader nothing, because the number is an artifact of how the author divided the work. Asking what each model assumes resistance comes from produces a real comparison, since a model treating it as inertia and one treating it as a coalition problem recommend different first actions.

Is resistance always a problem to be managed?

Not always, and the better papers say so. Resistance often carries information: the people refusing a new workflow may be the ones who know it duplicates a step somebody else already completed. Treating every objection as an obstacle discards that. Distinguishing resistance that reflects a real cost from resistance that reflects habit is worth a mark on its own.

Which model should I choose for a technology change?

One that accounts for adoption happening unevenly, since technology changes rarely fail all at once. A diffusion approach handles the pattern where a few enthusiasts adopt early and a substantial group waits to see, which is what actually happens with a new build. Whatever you choose, argue the selection from the character of the change rather than from what the course covered most recently.

Where can I find a free NUR 514 Topic 3 sample paper?

The change paper for NUR 514 Topic 3 covers three diagnoses of resistance, the change, what the model predicted, where the prediction broke down and what a different diagnosis would have prescribed. Post your NUR 514 Topic 3 prompt and get a free paper.

Is resistance always a problem to manage in NUR 514 Topic 3?

Not always. Night nurses skipping the new assessment pointed to a real time problem, which a change leader should treat as information.