NUR 590 Topic 2 search strategy write-up example

Evidence-Based Practice Project Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 590 Topic 2 sample paper writes the search strategy behind the evidence on protocol-driven potassium replacement for a reader who may disagree. It belongs to GCU NUR 590, Evidence-Based Practice Project, listed as NUR-590, part of Grand Canyon University's MSN. The PICOT question is restated. PubMed and CINAHL are chosen with reasons. Terms are printed as entered. Limits carry justifications, and inclusion criteria are set before screening. Counts are given at every stage: 310 records, 252 after duplicates. A Google Scholar check finds conference abstracts and prompts a revision. The search finds no study from a medical-surgical floor, with Kraft and colleagues and Gennari as background.

CourseNUR 590 Evidence-Based Practice Project
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeLiterature search strategy
LengthAbout 960 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 590 Topic 2

1

A Search Written for Someone Who May Disagree: The Strategy Behind the Evidence on Protocol-Driven Potassium Replacement

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-590: Evidence-Based Practice Project

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

May 21, 2029

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title sets the standard: the write-up must satisfy a reader who was not there and may disagree. Databases are named with reasons, terms appear as entered, limits carry justifications, criteria are stated before screening, numbers reconcile at the end and exclusions are given with reasons. Record counts are illustrative.
2

A Search Written for Someone Who May Disagree: The Strategy Behind the Evidence on Protocol-Driven Potassium Replacement

The Question Searched

The PICOT question asks whether a protocol that lets nurses start potassium replacement, with oral potassium as the default, shortens the time from a low result to the first dose and reduces diuretic or digoxin doses given before correction, compared with individual provider orders, in adult medical-surgical patients whose potassium is mildly low, 3.0 to 3.4 mEq/L, and whose kidneys are working normally. The search was run on May 10, 2029, and the criteria below were written on May 8, before any results were screened, so that no study could be kept or dropped according to whether it suited the project.

Databases, With Reasons

PubMed (MEDLINE) was searched because protocol studies of electrolyte replacement are published mainly in medical, critical care and pharmacy journals. CINAHL Complete was searched because nurse-driven protocols are often reported in nursing journals that MEDLINE indexes incompletely. The Cochrane Library was searched for any systematic review; none addressed electrolyte replacement protocols. Google Scholar was consulted just for its first 100 hits, for gray literature and conference abstracts, and these were logged separately.

Terms, as Entered

PubMed: (hypokalemia[MeSH] OR hypokalaemia[tiab] OR "low potassium"[tiab] OR "potassium replacement"[tiab] OR "potassium repletion"[tiab] OR "electrolyte replacement"[tiab] OR "electrolyte repletion"[tiab]) AND (protocol*[tiab] OR "standing order*"[tiab] OR "order set*"[tiab] OR "nurse-driven"[tiab] OR "nurse-initiated"[tiab]).

CINAHL: (MH "Hypokalemia" OR "potassium replacement" OR "potassium repletion" OR "electrolyte replacement" OR "electrolyte repletion") AND (protocol* OR "standing order*" OR "order set*" OR "nurse-driven" OR "nurse-initiated").

The setting was deliberately left out of the strings. Adding "medical-surgical" would have excluded intensive care studies, which the scoping search showed make up most of the evidence; setting is handled at screening, where its relevance to the floor can be judged.

Limits, With Justifications

English language, because I cannot appraise studies in other languages; this may omit some studies, which is acknowledged. Adults, because the project population is adult and pediatric potassium dosing differs. Publication from 1990 onward, because intravenous potassium safety practices and concentrated potassium restrictions changed substantially after that period, making older practice studies less applicable; the date limit was not used to reduce the count, and a sensitivity search without it added only four records, none eligible.

Criteria, Stated Before Screening

Include: studies of protocols, order sets or standing orders for replacing potassium, alone or with other electrolytes, in hospitalized adults, reporting time to replacement, appropriateness of replacement or safety outcomes such as hyperkalemia; guidelines or reviews on the treatment of hypokalemia in hospitalized adults. Exclude: studies of chronic outpatient potassium management; pediatric or neonatal studies; studies limited to diabetic ketoacidosis or cardiac surgery protocols, where replacement follows different rules; conference abstracts without enough detail to appraise.

Numbers at Every Stage

PubMed returned 214 records and CINAHL 96, for 310. After removing 58 duplicates, 252 remained. Title and abstract screening excluded 229: 97 not about replacement protocols, 61 outpatient or chronic management, 38 diabetic ketoacidosis or cardiac surgery, 21 pediatric, 12 other. Full texts of 23 were assessed. Of these, 18 were excluded with reasons recorded: 7 conference abstracts without enough detail, 5 protocols for magnesium or phosphate only, 4 descriptive reports with no outcome data and 2 studies of rapid intravenous correction in monitored patients without a protocol comparison; the 5 remaining were included, and the numbers reconcile from 310 records to 5 studies.

The five included sources are: a prospective comparison of protocol-driven and physician-driven electrolyte replacement in an intensive care unit (Hijazi & Al-Ansari, 2005); a retrospective before-and-after evaluation of an electrolyte replacement protocol in a medical intensive care unit (Pearson et al., 2018); a retrospective review of hyperkalemia after protocol-based potassium replacement in intensive care patients, split by kidney function (Conley et al., 2021); a review with treatment recommendations for electrolyte disorders in intensive care (Kraft et al., 2005); and a clinical review of hypokalemia that addresses the choice of oral or intravenous replacement (Gennari, 1998).

What this page is doingCriteria are stated before screening, and every stage has a count. The highlighted passage gives the full-text exclusions with reasons and shows that the numbers reconcile, which is what allows a skeptical reader to check the screening.
3

Gray Literature and a Revision

The Google Scholar check found 11 conference abstracts and 3 hospital quality reports describing nurse-driven electrolyte protocols, several on non-intensive care units. They were logged separately and not added to the included studies, because abstracts rarely give enough detail on methods or outcomes to appraise and quality reports are not peer reviewed. They are still useful: two described protocols on telemetry or step-down units, which suggests the approach has been tried outside critical care, and their protocol wording will be consulted when the project's protocol is drafted. Keeping them apart prevents the evidence table from treating an unreviewed report as equal to a published study.

One revision was made during the search. The first PubMed string used only the MeSH heading for hypokalemia and returned many studies of the condition's causes and none of several protocol studies I already knew existed, because those studies were indexed under electrolyte management rather than hypokalemia. Adding the free-text terms for replacement and repletion recovered them. The first string and its count are kept in the log, because the reason for the change is part of how a reader judges the final search.

What the Search Found, and Did Not

No included study was conducted on a medical-surgical floor. The evidence for protocols comes from intensive care, and the evidence for oral replacement as the default for mild hypokalemia comes from review and expert recommendation rather than trials. This is itself a finding the project must carry forward: the protocol will be supported by evidence from a more closely monitored setting, which is why the project includes safety measures such as post-replacement potassium levels. A reader who disagrees with any exclusion can find the study, the reason and the stage in the screening log, and rerun the strings above to check the counts.

References

Conley, R., Rich, R. L., & Montero, J. (2021). Safety of a nurse-driven standardized potassium replacement protocol in critically ill patients with renal insufficiency. Critical Care Nurse, 41(2), e10-e16. https://doi.org/10.4037/ccn2021549

Gennari, F. J. (1998). Hypokalemia. New England Journal of Medicine, 339(7), 451-458. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199808133390707

Hijazi, M., & Al-Ansari, M. (2005). Protocol-driven vs. physician-driven electrolyte replacement in adult critically ill patients. Annals of Saudi Medicine, 25(2), 105-110. https://doi.org/10.5144/0256-4947.2005.105

Kraft, M. D., Btaiche, I. F., Sacks, G. S., & Kudsk, K. A. (2005). Treatment of electrolyte disorders in adult patients in the intensive care unit. American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy, 62(16), 1663-1682. https://doi.org/10.2146/ajhp040300

Pearson, D. J., Sharma, A., Lospinoso, J. A., Morris, M. J., & McCann, E. T. (2018). Effects of electrolyte replacement protocol implementation in a medical intensive care unit. Journal of Intensive Care Medicine, 33(10), 574-581. https://doi.org/10.1177/0885066616679593

What the NUR 590 Topic 2 instructions ask for

Topic 2 in NUR-590 covers the search behind the project's evidence. Strong strategies restate the question, choose databases with reasons, print the terms exactly as entered and justify each limit, acknowledging what a limit may omit. Students should set inclusion and exclusion criteria before screening, report counts at every stage from records retrieved to studies included and check gray literature, revising the search where it reveals a gap. The paper should end with what the search found and did not find, such as no studies in the project's own setting, which shapes how the evidence can be used. Writing for a reader who may disagree keeps the strategy honest. Counts are dated.

How this NUR 590 Topic 2 example is built

The finished example is written for a reader who was not there and may disagree. Databases are named with a reason for each, terms appear as they were entered, and the limits carry justifications rather than being listed. What distinguishes this from a search log is the emphasis on decisions: inclusion and exclusion criteria are stated before the results are screened, so the screening cannot be accused of selecting studies that suited the writer's preference. Numbers are reported at every stage and reconcile at the end. Studies excluded at full text are listed with the reason each was dropped, which is the section a reviewer checks first when they suspect a selection was convenient rather than principled.

Reading the NUR 590 Topic 2 rubric

Faculty reward a search written for a skeptical reader. An Excellent strategy restates the PICOT question and chooses PubMed and CINAHL with reasons. Credit goes to terms printed as entered and limits justified, such as English language acknowledged as a gap. The rubric values criteria set before screening and counts at every stage, from 310 records to 252 after duplicates. Strong strategies check gray literature and revise when conference abstracts appear. Top marks go to stating that no included study came from a medical-surgical floor, with Kraft and colleagues as background. Limits are justified.

NUR 590 Topic 2 help before you submit

Search sections written as narrative are the standard loss, because a paragraph saying that several databases were searched cannot be audited by anybody. The second loss is criteria written after screening, which shows when the inclusion rules describe exactly the studies that were kept and nothing else. Papers lose marks for numbers that do not reconcile, since a reviewer adding the stages is the fastest check available and the arithmetic is expected to hold. Excluding at full text without recording reasons removes the evidence that the exclusions were principled. Limits applied only to reduce a result count are a defect rather than a convenience. A search nobody else could repeat is not a method section, whatever it reports.

Get an NUR-590 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-590 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with your project question and any database access your program provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with terms traced to the question, criteria fixed before screening, every limit justified and the counts reconciling, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More NUR 590 papers and MSN samples

NUR 590 Topic 2 questions, answered

How is this different from the search log in an earlier course?

The audience. A log records what you did; this section has to persuade somebody who may challenge the selection, which puts the weight on inclusion criteria and on the reasons for exclusion. The mechanics are similar and the burden is different, since a project reviewer is entitled to ask why a study that contradicts your intervention is absent.

When should I set inclusion criteria?

Before you screen anything, and write them down at that point. Criteria decided after you have seen the results will match what you kept, which is the appearance every reviewer is trained to look for. Setting them in advance also makes screening faster, because each decision becomes a rule application rather than a judgment made again from scratch.

What if my search returns almost nothing?

Widen deliberately and record what you widened. Loosening the population, extending the date range or dropping a setting restriction are all legitimate and each should be logged with its reason. A search returning three studies may also be telling you the project question is too narrow, which is better discovered now than in the evidence table topic.

Where can I find a free NUR 590 Topic 2 sample paper?

The search strategy for NUR 590 Topic 2 covers the question searched, databases with reasons, terms as entered, limits with justifications, criteria stated before screening, numbers at every stage, gray literature and a revision and what the search found. Share your NUR 590 Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.

When should inclusion criteria be set in NUR 590 Topic 2?

Before screening anything. Criteria written after reading the results can be shaped to keep favorable studies, which a reviewer will suspect.