NUR 621 Topic 5 variance analysis example

Principles of Health Care Financial Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 621 Topic 5 sample paper decomposes a first-quarter registered nurse salary variance on a composite medical unit into volume, efficiency and rate, arguing that one number is not an analysis. It belongs to GCU NUR 621, Principles of Health Care Financial Management, listed as NUR-621, offered through Grand Canyon University's MSN. The headline overrun is set out. The inputs are 2,632 budgeted patient days and 7.32 paid hours per patient day. The decomposition shows 158 extra patient days as a volume variance that is good news in disguise. Causes are traced. A favorable supply variance is examined against a flexible budget. Responses have owners, after Finkler and colleagues and Cleverley and Cleverley.

CourseNUR 621 Principles of Health Care Financial Management
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeBudget variance analysis
LengthAbout 970 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 621 Topic 5

1

One Number Is Not an Analysis: Decomposing a First-Quarter Salary Variance Into Volume, Efficiency and Rate on a Medical Unit

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-621: Principles of Health Care Financial Management

Topic 5 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

November 5, 2029

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title refuses to report a variance as one figure. The total is decomposed into volume, efficiency and rate, each with a cause and an owner; a favorable variance is examined as carefully as an unfavorable one; and responses are assigned to people. The unit and figures are composites and illustrative, following the fiscal year 2030 budget built earlier.
2

One Number Is Not an Analysis: Decomposing a First-Quarter Salary Variance Into Volume, Efficiency and Rate on a Medical Unit

The Headline Number

At the end of the first quarter of fiscal year 2030, July through September, the finance report showed 5 West's registered nurse salary expense at $1,045,830 against a budget of $915,473, an unfavorable variance of $130,357, or 14 percent. Reported as one number, it suggests the unit overspent. Decomposed, it tells three different stories, only one of which calls for correction. All figures are illustrative.

The Inputs

The budget assumed 2,632 patient days for the quarter, one quarter of the annual projection, 7.32 paid registered nurse hours per patient day and an average rate of $47.52 an hour including differentials. The actual quarter had 2,790 patient days, 21,300 paid registered nurse hours and an average rate of $49.10. A flexible budget, which adjusts the static budget for actual volume (Finkler et al., 2013), would have allowed 2,790 times 7.32, or about 20,423 hours.

The Decomposition

Volume variance. The unit cared for 158 more patient days than budgeted. At the budgeted hours per day and rate, those days would be expected to cost 158 times 7.32 times $47.52, about $55,000 more. This part of the variance is not overspending; it reflects more patients, and more patients should require more nursing hours.

Efficiency variance. For the actual 2,790 patient days, the budget allowed about 20,423 hours, but the unit used 21,300, about 877 more hours than the workload standard. At the budgeted rate, that adds about $41,700. This part needs explanation: did acuity rise, or were hours used less efficiently than planned?

Rate variance. The unit paid an average of $49.10 an hour instead of $47.52, $1.58 more on each of 21,300 hours, adding about $33,700. This part also needs explanation: why did the average hourly cost rise?

The three parts sum to the total: $55,000 plus $41,700 plus $33,700 equals $130,400, matching the unfavorable variance of $130,357 after rounding (Reiter & Song, 2021).

Table 1

First-Quarter RN Salary Variance, Decomposed (Illustrative)

ComponentAmountFavorable or unfavorableCauseControllable by unit?
Volume$55,048Unfavorable to budget, appropriate158 more patient days than projectedNo
Efficiency$41,655UnfavorableHigher acuity: 11 patient days of one-to-one observationPartly
Rate$33,654UnfavorableOvertime and 2 agency nurses covering vacanciesPartly
Total$130,357Unfavorable

Causes, Traced

The volume variance is good news in disguise: the skilled nursing agreement began in August as planned, and the unit's census rose accordingly, so the extra spending bought extra care and extra revenue for the hospital. The efficiency variance traces to acuity. In August and September, the unit cared for three patients with delirium and fall risk who required one-to-one observation for a combined 11 patient days, and the unit used registered nurses when no sitters were available. Those 11 days account for about 264 of the 877 extra hours; the remainder reflects a rise in the average number of patients on insulin infusions, which the unit's acuity tool now captures but the 9.2 hours per patient day standard did not anticipate. The rate variance traces to vacancies. Two registered nurse positions were vacant for most of the quarter, and the unit covered them with overtime at 1.5 times base pay and two agency nurses at about $85 an hour.

What this page is doingThe total is decomposed into volume, efficiency and rate, and each part is traced to a cause. The highlighted sentence shows why the largest component is appropriate spending rather than a problem, which a single variance figure would hide.
3

A Favorable Variance, Examined

Supplies came in at $91,800 against a static budget of $100,000 and a flexible budget, adjusted for volume, of $106,000, a favorable variance of $14,200 against the flexible budget. Being under budget is not automatically good (Cleverley & Cleverley, 2018). Investigation found that about $9,000 of the difference reflects a timing effect: a backorder on intravenous start kits in September meant supplies were used from a hospital-wide stock that will be charged back to the unit in October. The remaining $5,000 reflects a real saving from switching to a lower-cost wound dressing approved by the value analysis committee. Reported without examination, the whole $14,200 would have been read as savings, and the October charge-back would then have appeared as a new overspend.

Responses, With Owners

Volume: no response needed for the unit; the finance director will update the hospital's revenue forecast to reflect higher census. Owner: finance director, by the end of October.

Efficiency: the nurse manager will request that the observation program assign trained sitters for one-to-one patients rather than drawing registered nurses from the unit, and will ask the staffing committee to review whether the hours-per-patient-day standard should be adjusted for the new insulin infusion volume. Owners: nurse manager and staffing committee chair, by the second-quarter review.

Rate: the two vacancies were filled in October, with start dates in November, which should end agency use by December. The nurse manager will report overtime hours weekly to the director until then. Owner: nurse manager.

Supplies: the finance analyst will confirm the October charge-back and report the true supply variance at the next review. Owner: unit finance analyst.

What Should Change in How the Variance Is Reported

The first-quarter report caused alarm because it compared actual spending with a static budget. The unit will ask the finance office to report salary variances against a flexible budget adjusted for actual patient days each month, so that a rise in census is shown for what it is rather than as overspending. The report will also show paid hours per patient day and the average hourly rate beside the dollars, so the efficiency and rate components are visible without a separate analysis. If those two numbers had appeared on the July report, the rise in agency use and one-to-one observation would have been visible six weeks earlier, and the vacancies might have been filled sooner. A variance report that shows only a total invites the wrong response, usually a demand to cut hours, when the actual cause is often volume or rate, which cutting hours would not touch.

References

Cleverley, W. O., & Cleverley, J. O. (2018). Essentials of health care finance (8th ed.). Jones & Bartlett Learning.

Finkler, S. A., Jones, C. B., & Kovner, C. T. (2013). Financial management for nurse managers and executives (4th ed.). Elsevier Saunders.

Reiter, K. L., & Song, P. H. (2021). Gapenski's healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (7th ed.). Health Administration Press.

Reading the GCU NUR 621 Topic 5 instructions

Topic 5 in NUR-621 asks students to analyze a budget variance. Strong papers decompose the variance into volume, efficiency and rate components, since each calls for a different response, rather than treating the total as one problem. Students should trace each component to its cause, compare spending with a flexible budget adjusted for actual volume and examine favorable variances as carefully as unfavorable ones, since a saving can signal a problem. Responses should be assigned to owners, and the paper should recommend how variance reporting itself could change, for example by reporting against a flexible budget so that higher census does not look like overspending. Components should be computed in the order volume, efficiency, rate.

Inside the NUR 621 Topic 5 example

The finished example refuses to report a variance as one number. The total is stated, then decomposed, and the decomposition is the analysis: a department over budget on salaries because it treated more patients than projected has a different problem from one over budget because it paid more per hour than planned. The first may be entirely appropriate and even good news; the second needs an explanation. Favorable variances receive the same treatment, since being under budget on supplies while volume fell is not an achievement. Each component is then given a response with an owner, and the example distinguishes what a manager controls from what they merely report. Percentages are reported beside absolute figures, since a large percentage of a small line is rarely the priority.

NUR 621 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a variance taken apart. An Excellent paper splits the salary overrun into volume, efficiency and rate, showing 158 extra patient days as the largest part. Credit goes to tracing the census rise to the skilled nursing agreement starting in August. The rubric values a supply variance judged against a flexible budget of $106,000, with Finkler and colleagues. Strong papers assign owners, such as the finance director updating the revenue forecast. Top marks go to recommending flexible budget reporting, after Cleverley and Cleverley. Owners are named.

Common NUR 621 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Reporting a total variance without decomposing it is the loss the topic is written to prevent, since the total is the one number that cannot direct any action. The second loss is treating every favorable variance as good, which misses the case where costs fell because volume collapsed. Papers lose marks for skipping the flexible budget, because without it the volume component cannot be isolated and the rest of the analysis has no foundation. Explanations that attribute a rate variance to general inflation with no specifics read as guessing. Assigning responses without owners produces a paper that identifies problems and moves none of them. Variances left unattributed to a cause cannot be prevented from recurring next period.

Get an NUR-621 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-621 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the budget report you are analyzing or the figures your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a flexible budget computed, volume and rate components isolated and a response with an owner assigned to each, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More NUR 621 papers and MSN samples

NUR 621 Topic 5 questions, answered

Why split a variance into volume and rate?

Because they call for opposite responses. A salary overrun driven by higher volume than budgeted may need nothing but an explanation, and possibly more budget. The same overrun driven by paying premium rates for agency cover needs a staffing intervention. Reported together they cancel and conceal each other, and a manager reading only the total cannot tell which situation they are in.

Is a favorable variance always good news?

No, and saying so carefully earns marks. Supplies under budget because volume fell short is not a saving, it is a symptom. Salary under budget because posts sat vacant may mean the department ran short staffed all quarter. Judging a variance by its sign rather than by its cause is the shallow reading this topic exists to correct.

What is a flexible budget?

The budget recalculated at the volume that actually occurred rather than the volume that was planned. It is the middle term that makes decomposition possible: comparing actual against the flexible budget isolates rate, and comparing flexible against original isolates volume. Without computing it you can report a total variance and nothing else useful about it.

Where can I find a free NUR 621 Topic 5 sample paper?

The variance paper for NUR 621 Topic 5 covers the headline number, the inputs, the decomposition, causes traced, a favorable variance examined, responses with owners and what should change in reporting. Forward the NUR 621 Topic 5 prompt you received for a free paper.

Is a favorable variance always good news in NUR 621 Topic 5?

No. Spending less on supplies while census rose may mean items were not stocked or used, which can affect care.