| Course | NUR 630 Performance Improvement and Quality in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Root cause analysis |
| Length | About 1,150 words, 6 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 630 Topic 4
The Call Came at 4:41: A Root Cause Analysis of an Overnight Delay in Treating Diarrhea After Chemotherapy
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-630: Performance Improvement and Quality in Health Care
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
February 4, 2030
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
The Call Came at 4:41: A Root Cause Analysis of an Overnight Delay in Treating Diarrhea After Chemotherapy
The Event, in Sequence
The patient, a composite 71-year-old man with metastatic colon cancer, received a fluorouracil-based regimen at the infusion center on a Monday and went home with a portable infusion pump. His discharge instructions said to take loperamide at the first loose stool and to call if he had more than four stools a day above his usual pattern. The sequence on Wednesday and Thursday was as follows, with times from the phone system, answering service log and emergency record.
At 4:41 p.m. on Wednesday, his daughter called the center's triage line. The line had switched to the after-hours answering service at 4:30. She reported six watery stools since morning and that her father felt dizzy when he stood. At 4:46 the operator, following the service's script, recorded a message for the morning nurse rather than paging the on-call oncologist, because the script classified diarrhea as routine unless fever was present. At 8:52 a.m. Thursday, the triage nurse returned the call. The daughter said she had taken her father to the emergency department at 7:10 a.m. He was admitted with dehydration and acute kidney injury and stayed three days. He had not taken loperamide; the prescription sent on Monday had not been filled because the pharmacy was out of stock and no one at the center knew.
The Method and Why It Fits
The analysis uses a causal chain built by asking why at each step, checked against a cause and effect diagram with five categories: people, equipment, environment, process and policy. The chain suits this event because the harm followed a sequence of handoffs in time, and a sequence can be traced link by link. The diagram guards against the chain's weakness, which is that it follows one path and can miss a second cause running alongside it; here, the unfilled prescription was a second path. The review team included the triage nurse, a chair nurse, the pharmacist, the answering service's supervisor, the medical director and the nurse manager, following the recommendation that an analysis include people who know the work but were not directly involved in the event (National Patient Safety Foundation, 2015).
The Causal Chain, Shown Step by Step
Why was the patient admitted with kidney injury? Because diarrhea continued for about 14 hours without treatment. Why was it untreated? Because no clinician heard the report until the next morning. Why not? Because the operator took a message instead of paging. Why did the operator take a message? Because the script said diarrhea without fever was routine. The analysis does not stop at the operator's choice, because the choice was the one the script offered; the next question is why the script said that, and the answer is that the answering service's scripts were written for the general medicine practices it also serves and were never reviewed against oncology triage guidance. Guidelines for diarrhea caused by cancer treatment treat dizziness, vomiting and signs of dehydration as warning signs of a complicated case that needs early, aggressive management (Benson et al., 2004), and oncology triage protocols direct same-day clinical assessment in that situation (Stacey et al., 2013).
The second path runs in parallel. Why had the patient not taken loperamide? Because the prescription was not filled. Why did no one know? Because the center sends prescriptions electronically and has no step that confirms a supportive medication reached the patient before he leaves or within a day after.
Contributing Factors by Category
Sorting the factors into the diagram's categories showed which are within the center's control. People: the operator followed the script correctly, and the daughter called at the right threshold; neither is a cause. Equipment: the phone system switches all calls to the answering service at 4:30 even though two nurses remain in the center until 5:30. Environment: the event began on a Wednesday afternoon, the busiest treatment day, when the triage nurse was also covering chairs. Process: no step confirms that supportive medications are filled, and no clinical review happens on after-hours messages before morning. Policy: the contract with the answering service does not require oncology-specific scripts or any review of scripts by the center.
All but the environmental factor are within the center's control, and even that one can be changed through scheduling.
The Root Causes, Stated as Conditions
Three root causes emerged, each stated as a condition the organization can change rather than as something a person did. First, symptom calls after 4:30 p.m. are triaged by a script that was never written for patients receiving chemotherapy. Second, the after-hours path allows a symptom report to wait until morning without any clinician seeing it. Third, the center has no process to confirm that a patient has the supportive medication his instructions depend on. If any one of the three had been different, this patient would most likely have been treated at home or in the center on Wednesday evening.
Actions Matched to Causes and Ranked by Strength
Each action is matched to a root cause and ranked with the action hierarchy used in root cause analysis, in which physical changes and forcing functions are stronger than standardization and checklists, and training and new policies are weakest because they rely on memory and attention (National Patient Safety Foundation, 2015).
| Root cause | Action | Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Calls wait until morning without clinical review | Reprogram the phone system so any call selecting the symptom option after hours rings through to the on-call oncology nurse; the operator cannot take a message | Stronger: forcing function |
| Script not written for chemotherapy | Replace the service's script for center patients with the center's own triage questions based on oncology protocols, reviewed each year by the medical director | Intermediate: standardization |
| No check that supportive medications are filled | Add a required field in the discharge record, before the pump is connected, confirming the patient has loperamide and antiemetics in hand or at a pharmacy that confirmed stock | Intermediate: checklist built into the record |
| Calls wait until morning without clinical review | Keep the triage line with the center's nurses until 5:30 p.m., when staff leave | Intermediate: staffing change |
| All three | Review the event and the new process with staff and the answering service | Weaker: education |
What Will Show Whether the Actions Worked
The measurement plan from Topic 3 already counts unplanned acute visits after treatment and callbacks within the promised time. Two measures are added for this analysis: the share of after-hours symptom calls reaching the on-call nurse within 15 minutes, checked weekly from the phone log, and the share of patients leaving with a pump whose supportive medications were confirmed, checked from the record. Both should be near 100 percent within a month; if either is not, the action was not implemented as designed and should be fixed before its effect on outcomes is judged.
References
Benson, A. B., Ajani, J. A., Catalano, R. B., Engelking, C., Kornblau, S. M., Martenson, J. A., McCallum, R., Mitchell, E. P., O'Dorisio, T. M., Vokes, E. E., & Wadler, S. (2004). Recommended guidelines for the treatment of cancer treatment-induced diarrhea. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 22(14), 2918-2926. https://doi.org/10.1200/JCO.2004.04.132
National Patient Safety Foundation. (2015). RCA2: Improving root cause analyses and actions to prevent harm.
Stacey, D., Macartney, G., Carley, M., Harrison, M. B., & Pan-Canadian Oncology Symptom Triage and Remote Support Group (COSTaRS). (2013). Development and evaluation of evidence-informed clinical nursing protocols for remote assessment, triage and support of cancer treatment-induced symptoms. Nursing Research and Practice, 2013, Article 171872. https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/171872
Reading the GCU NUR 630 Topic 4 instructions
Topic 4 in NUR-630 asks students to conduct a root cause analysis. Strong analyses lay out the event in sequence, explain the method and why it fits, and build a causal chain step by step until reaching conditions the organization can change. Students should sort contributing factors by category to see which are within the organization's control, state root causes as conditions rather than as things a person did and match each cause to an action ranked by strength, since physical and system changes outlast education and policy reminders. The analysis should say how the actions will be judged, and events from the student's workplace should be heavily de-identified. Name the method.
How the NUR-630 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished example uses a method rather than an opinion. A named technique organizes it, whether repeated questioning of why, a cause and effect diagram, or a causal chain, and the technique is applied visibly so a reader can follow each step. Contributing factors are sorted into categories, people, equipment, environment, process and policy, which forces attention onto the ones a narrative account would skip. The example is disciplined about stopping rules: it keeps asking why until it reaches something the organization controls, and it does not stop at a person's decision, since a decision is a place to continue rather than a place to finish. Actions are then matched to causes rather than to the event.
Reading the NUR 630 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward causes stated as conditions, with actions ranked. An Excellent analysis follows a why chain from kidney injury back to about 14 hours of untreated diarrhea after a 4:41 call. Credit goes to sorting factors into people, equipment, process and other categories. The rubric values three root causes stated as conditions, such as symptom triage scripts lacking chemotherapy-specific questions, with Benson and colleagues and Stacey and colleagues. Strong analyses rank actions by the National Patient Safety Foundation's hierarchy. The best analyses end with measures of whether the actions took hold. Measures follow.
Common NUR 630 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Stopping at human error is what this topic was designed to stop, and it shows as a root cause naming a person's action rather than a condition. The second loss is a method named and not used, where a technique appears in one paragraph and the rest is narrative. Papers lose marks for actions that do not match their causes, most commonly education proposed for a cause education could not fix. Ranking actions by ease rather than by strength produces a plan of reminders and policies, which the improvement literature identifies as the weakest available interventions. Blame framed as analysis is penalized on professionalism as well as on content. Events narrated without times cannot support a causal sequence.
Get an NUR-630 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-630 Topic 4 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the event your section assigned or a de-identified one from your setting. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a named method applied step by step, causes followed past individual action and each action ranked by preventive strength, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More NUR 630 papers and MSN samples
- NUR 630 Topic 1: Quality Aims Application
- NUR 630 Topic 2: External Measure Analysis
- NUR 630 Topic 3: Quality Measurement Plan
- NUR 630 Topic 5: Improvement Model Selection
- NUR 630 Topic 6: Safety Culture Assignment
- NUR 630 Topic 7: Stakeholder and Sustainability Plan
- NUR 630 Topic 8: Benchmark Improvement Project
- NUR 631 Topic 4: Cardiac Mechanism Analysis
- NUR 621 Topic 4: Operating Budget Build
- NUR 634 Topic 4: Chest Pain Differential Diagnosis
- NUR 600 Topic 4: Pharmacology Case Workup
NUR 630 Topic 4 questions, answered
How do I know when I have reached a root cause?
When you reach something the organization can change and asking why again produces an answer outside its control. If your final cause is that a nurse was distracted, keep going: why was interruption possible at that step, why was the task performed there, why does the design permit it. A root cause phrased as a person's action is a stopping point rather than a finding.
Which actions actually prevent recurrence?
The improvement literature ranks them, and the ranking is worth citing. Forcing functions and physical changes that make the error impossible are strongest; simplification and standardization come next; checklists and double checks are weaker; education and policy reminders are weakest because they depend on attention that will not always be available. Most student plans propose the weakest two.
Can I write about a real event from my workplace?
Only heavily de-identified, and many sections supply a scenario precisely so nobody has to. Remove dates, roles that would identify individuals, and anything distinctive about the presentation. Note also that formal reviews in most organizations are legally protected, so writing about one you participated in may carry restrictions worth checking before you start.
Where can I find a free NUR 630 Topic 4 sample paper?
The root cause analysis for NUR 630 Topic 4 covers the event in sequence, the method, the causal chain, contributing factors by category, root causes as conditions, actions ranked by strength and what will show the actions worked. Your own NUR 630 Topic 4 prompt gets a free paper.
Which actions prevent recurrence in NUR 630 Topic 4?
Stronger actions change the system, such as a triage script with forced questions. Weaker ones, such as reminders or training alone, fade over time.