| Course | PSY 810 History and Systems of Psychology |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Omitted contributors analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | PhD in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 810 Topic 5
Who Was Left Out, and How: Calkins, Sumner and Mamie Phipps Clark, and the Mechanisms of Omission
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
PSY-810: History and Systems of Psychology
Topic 5 Omitted Contributors Analysis
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Who Was Left Out, and How: Calkins, Sumner and Mamie Phipps Clark, and the Mechanisms of Omission
Three Cases, Then the Pattern
Histories of psychology have long been histories of a small number of white men in a few universities. Correcting that is not only a matter of adding names; it requires understanding how omission happened. This analysis works through three cases and then generalizes to the mechanisms that produced the omissions.
Mary Whiton Calkins
Mary Whiton Calkins studied psychology at Harvard in the 1890s, attending seminars as a guest because Harvard did not admit women, and working with William James and Hugo Münsterberg. Calkins completed all the requirements for the doctorate, including a dissertation and examinations that the examiners judged outstanding, and was refused the degree because Harvard would not award one to a woman. Later, Radcliffe offered a doctorate as a substitute, which Calkins declined, since the work had been done at Harvard. Calkins founded one of the early psychology laboratories in the United States at Wellesley College, developed the paired-associate method for studying memory and proposed a self psychology. In 1905 Calkins became the first woman president of the American Psychological Association. Scarborough and Furumoto (1987) documented the career of Calkins, and those of other women of the same generation, showing how the denial of credentials shaped where women could work and how their contributions were recorded.
Francis Cecil Sumner
Francis Cecil Sumner became, in 1920, the first African American to earn a doctorate in psychology, at Clark University under G. Stanley Hall. Excluded from positions at predominantly white universities, Sumner built a career at historically Black institutions, and in 1928 moved to Howard University, where Sumner chaired the psychology department and built a program that trained a generation of Black psychologists, including Kenneth Clark. Guthrie (2004) documented Sumner's work and the broader exclusion of Black psychologists from mainstream institutions, journals and histories, arguing that standard histories treated psychology at Black colleges as outside the discipline's story.
Mamie Phipps Clark
Mamie Phipps Clark, while a student at Howard, began research on racial identification in Black children, which continued in collaboration with Kenneth Clark, to whom Mamie Phipps Clark was married. Their studies, including the well-known doll studies in which children were asked to choose between dolls differing only in skin color, were cited in the Supreme Court's 1954 decision in Brown v. Board of Education. The research is often credited to Kenneth Clark alone, in part because Kenneth Clark became the more prominent public figure and testified in the related cases. Benjamin and Crouse (2002) examined the American Psychological Association's response to Brown and to Kenneth Clark's role, documenting how slowly the organization acknowledged the contribution; the joint origin of the research, including Mamie Phipps Clark's initiating role, was often lost in later accounts. Mamie Phipps Clark went on to found the Northside Center for Child Development in Harlem, a major clinical contribution that standard histories rarely mention.
The Mechanisms
The three cases reveal several mechanisms of omission.
The first is exclusion from credentials. Calkins was refused a doctorate already earned; without the degree, Calkins was cut off from positions at research universities that trained doctoral students and produced the lineages historians later traced.
The second is confinement to institutions histories overlooked. Sumner's career at Howard was central to Black psychology but invisible to histories centered on research universities. Women's colleges and historically Black colleges were treated as outside the main story.
The third is credit flowing to a collaborator. Mamie Phipps Clark's work was absorbed into the reputation of Kenneth Clark, a pattern common when collaborators differ in status or visibility.
The fourth is the history-writing itself. Histories written by insiders, focused on laboratories, theories and lineages of doctoral students, reproduced the exclusions of the institutions they described.
Table 1
Three Cases and Their Mechanisms of Omission
| Case | Contribution | Mechanism of omission |
|---|---|---|
| Mary Whiton Calkins | Laboratory, paired associates, self psychology; first woman APA president | Exclusion from credentials |
| Francis Cecil Sumner | First African American doctorate in psychology; built Howard's program | Confinement to overlooked institutions |
| Mamie Phipps Clark | Racial identification research cited in Brown; Northside Center | Credit flowing to a collaborator |
| All three | Contributions omitted from standard histories | History written from inside dominant institutions |
Others the Mechanisms Explain
The same mechanisms account for many other omissions. Inez Beverly Prosser, among the first African American women to earn a doctorate in psychology, studied the education of Black children and died young, and the work was long absent from histories. Leta Stetter Hollingworth challenged claims that women's abilities varied with the menstrual cycle and that women were less variable than men, research that helped undo prejudicial assumptions but was rarely credited in histories of individual differences. George I. Sánchez criticized the use of intelligence tests with Spanish-speaking children who were tested in English. In each case, the contribution was real, and the omission followed one of the mechanisms described above.
What Recovery Requires
Recovering these contributions requires more than biographical sketches added to existing chapters. It requires reading the archives of excluded institutions, such as the psychology departments of historically Black colleges and women's colleges, as part of the discipline's history; tracing collaborations to find whose work was absorbed into others' reputations; and asking how credentials, hiring and publication shaped who could be remembered. Guthrie and Scarborough and Furumoto did exactly this kind of work, and their books changed what later histories include.
Generalizing
The mechanisms generalize beyond these cases. Any account of psychology's history that traces influence through doctoral lineages at elite universities, credits the most visible collaborator and treats excluded institutions as peripheral will reproduce the field's historical exclusions, whatever its authors intend. Correcting the record requires changing the questions historians ask: not only who produced the ideas that later became central, but who was prevented from producing them, whose work was absorbed into others' and which institutions sustained psychology for those excluded elsewhere.
References
Benjamin, L. T., Jr., & Crouse, E. M. (2002). The American Psychological Association's response to Brown v. Board of Education: The case of Kenneth B. Clark. American Psychologist, 57(1), 38-50. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.57.1.38
Guthrie, R. V. (2004). Even the rat was white: A historical view of psychology (2nd ed.). Allyn and Bacon.
Scarborough, E., & Furumoto, L. (1987). Untold lives: The first generation of American women psychologists. Columbia University Press.
Reading the GCU PSY 810 Topic 5 instructions
Topic 5 in PSY-810 asks doctoral students to analyze contributors omitted from standard histories. Strong analyses work through specific cases in enough detail to show what each person contributed and how they were left out, drawing on historical scholarship rather than general claims. Students should then name the mechanisms of omission, such as exclusion from credentials, confinement to institutions histories overlooked, credit flowing to a collaborator and history written from inside dominant institutions, and show how they generalize. Adding names alone is not enough; the analysis should say what recovering these contributions requires. Each case should be documented from historical scholarship, not from summaries.
How this PSY 810 Topic 5 example is built
The finished analysis works through three cases and then generalizes. Calkins completed the requirements for a Harvard doctorate and was refused the doctorate because Harvard would not award one to a woman; she went on to become the first woman president of the American Psychological Association. Sumner, the first African American to earn a doctorate in psychology, built the psychology program at Howard University, which trained a generation of Black psychologists. Mamie Phipps Clark's research with Kenneth Clark on children's racial preferences, cited in the Brown v. Board of Education decision, is often credited to him alone. The paper then names the mechanisms: exclusion from doctorates and posts, citation practices, and textbooks written by those trained under the already famous. Robert Guthrie's Even the Rat Was White is cited as a founding work of this recovery.
Where the marks sit in the PSY 810 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward cases that reveal mechanisms. An Excellent analysis presents Calkins's refused Harvard doctorate, Sumner's Howard program and Mamie Phipps Clark's research cited in Brown, using Scarborough and Furumoto, Guthrie and Benjamin and Crouse. Credit goes to four mechanisms named and tabulated: exclusion from credentials, overlooked institutions, credit to a collaborator and insider history-writing. The rubric values extending the mechanisms to further cases. Strong analyses explain what recovery requires. Top marks go to changing the questions historians ask.
PSY 810 Topic 5 help before you submit
This topic is marked down hardest when the paper becomes a list of overlooked names with a sentence of biography each. Recovery without explanation implies the omissions were accidents, and the evidence usually shows barriers that were deliberate at the time and habits that were inherited afterward. Contributions described vaguely, as pioneering or important, give a reader no way to judge whether the figure was omitted or simply had less influence. Papers treating omission as a single phenomenon miss the difference between exclusion from institutions and exclusion from textbooks. Anachronistic outrage, condemning past psychologists without reconstructing the institutions they worked in, weakens an argument the evidence would otherwise carry. A paper never citing the historiographic work that did this recovery first presents an established literature as its own discovery.
Get a PSY-810 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send us the PSY-810 Topic 5 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and any figures or readings your section named. A custom example comes back written to those criteria, with each contribution recovered in detail, the mechanisms of omission explained and the historiographic literature cited, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 810 papers and PhD in Psychology samples
- PSY 810 Topic 1: System Definition Paper
- PSY 810 Topic 2: Disciplinary Separation Analysis
- PSY 810 Topic 3: Problem Reconstruction Paper
- PSY 810 Topic 4: Transition Narrative Audit
- PSY 810 Topic 6: Progress or Recurrence Dq Post
- PSY 810 Topic 7: Debate Genealogy Paper
- PSY 810 Topic 8: Historiographic Position Paper
- PSY 804 Topic 5: First-person Data Dq Post
- PSY 803 Topic 5: Program Boundary Dq Post
- PSY 802 Topic 5: Falsifiability Dq Exchange
PSY 810 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why was Mary Whiton Calkins refused her doctorate?
Because Harvard did not award doctorates to women at the time, although her examiners, including William James, judged that she had met the requirements. She was later offered a Radcliffe doctorate and declined it. Her case is useful in an omission paper because the barrier is documented and her later recognition, including the APA presidency, shows the contribution was acknowledged by contemporaries.
What is the new history of psychology?
A term Laurel Furumoto used for historical work that moved away from celebratory accounts written by psychologists about their predecessors. The new history favors archival sources, attention to social and institutional context, and inclusion of people the older narratives overlooked. Recovery of omitted contributors belongs to that tradition, so citing it places an omission paper inside an established scholarly conversation.
Is adding names to the history enough?
It is a start, but it leaves the structure of the story intact. If the narrative still runs through the same schools and the same institutions, recovered figures appear as exceptions rather than as evidence about how the discipline worked. Explaining why they were omitted, and what the omission did to the discipline's picture of itself, changes the history rather than decorating it.
Where can I find a free PSY 810 Topic 5 sample paper?
The analysis is shown here complete: three cases, the mechanisms, further cases, what recovery requires and the generalization. Share your PSY 810 Topic 5 prompt for a free analysis.
Why was Mamie Phipps Clark's contribution often lost in PSY 810 Topic 5?
Kenneth Clark became the more visible public figure and testified in the related cases, so the joint research, including Mamie Phipps Clark's initiating role, was often credited to one person.