| Course | PSY 833 Psychomotor Performance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Feedback frequency critique |
| Length | About 970 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | PhD in Psychology |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for PSY 833 Topic 4
A Number After Every Swing: Critiquing a Golf Lesson Built on Constant Launch Monitor Feedback
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
PSY-833: Psychomotor Performance
Topic 4 Feedback Frequency Critique
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Number After Every Swing: Critiquing a Golf Lesson Built on Constant Launch Monitor Feedback
The Lesson
A composite golf instructor teaches with a launch monitor, a device that measures each shot and displays the results on a screen within seconds. After every swing, the student sees carry distance, ball speed, launch angle, club path and face angle at impact. Students strike the ball well in lessons, often hitting consistent shots by the end of an hour. On the course, the same students strike the ball noticeably worse, and the improvement seen in lessons seems not to carry over. This critique asks why, focusing on how often feedback is given.
Two Kinds of Feedback
Motor learning research distinguishes two kinds of augmented feedback, information provided from outside the performer's own senses. Knowledge of results is information about the outcome of a movement, such as how far the ball traveled or whether it reached the target. Knowledge of performance is information about the movement itself, such as the path of the club or the position of the wrists (Schmidt & Lee, 2019).
The launch monitor's output falls mostly into the first category, with some elements of the second. Carry distance and ball speed are outcomes. Launch angle is an outcome of the strike. Club path and face angle are closer to knowledge of performance, describing how the club moved, but they are measured at impact and presented as numbers rather than as a description of the swing. For the purpose of this critique, the key feature is not which kind it is but how often it arrives: after every swing.
The Guidance Hypothesis
Salmoni et al. (1984) reviewed research on knowledge of results and challenged the long-held view that more frequent and more immediate feedback always produces better learning. They noted that many studies had measured performance during practice, when feedback was present, rather than learning on retention tests without feedback. When retention was measured, conditions that provided less frequent feedback often produced as good or better learning. They proposed what became known as the guidance hypothesis: feedback guides the learner toward the correct movement on each attempt, which improves practice performance, but frequent feedback also makes the learner dependent on it. The learner corrects each swing using the external information rather than developing the ability to detect and correct errors from the feel of the movement. When the feedback is removed, as on the course, performance declines because the learner has not built that internal capability.
Evidence for Reduced Feedback
Winstein and Schmidt (1990) tested the hypothesis directly. Participants learned to produce a movement pattern with a lever, receiving knowledge of results either after every trial or after only half the trials, with the frequency faded from more to less as practice continued. During practice, the two groups performed similarly. On a delayed retention test without feedback, the reduced, faded feedback group performed better. Giving feedback less often, and reducing it over practice, produced more durable learning than giving it after every attempt.
Table 1
Feedback Schedules and Their Effects
| Feedback schedule | Practice performance | Retention without feedback | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| After every attempt | Good | Poorer | Learner relies on external information |
| Reduced and faded (Winstein & Schmidt, 1990) | Similar | Better | Learner builds internal error detection |
| Summary after a set of attempts | Somewhat lower | Better | Learner must recall and evaluate several attempts |
Applying the Evidence to the Lesson
The golf lesson provides feedback after every swing, the schedule most likely to produce dependence. Students adjust each swing based on the previous number on the screen, which improves lesson performance, and do not learn to sense from the feel of the swing what went wrong. On the course, where no monitor is present, they lack the internal reference the monitor replaced. The critique does not suggest that the monitor is useless; its information is accurate and valuable. The problem is the schedule.
Several changes follow from the evidence. The instructor could hide the screen for most swings, showing results after every fifth swing or as a summary of the last five. Before revealing the numbers, the student could estimate the result, for example predicting whether the face was open or closed, and then compare the estimate with the monitor, which trains the internal error detection the monitor otherwise replaces. Feedback could be faded across a lesson and across weeks, starting more frequent for a new skill and becoming less frequent as the student improves. And lessons could include a block of swings with no feedback at all, followed by a test, to show the student and instructor what has actually been learned.
Why Constant Feedback Is Popular
Constant feedback is popular for understandable reasons. Students pay for lessons and want to see measurable progress within the hour, and the monitor provides it. Instructors can point to numbers that improve, which is persuasive. And the technology makes constant feedback effortless, so withholding it can feel like withholding value. But the lesson's purpose is better golf on the course, and the evidence suggests that what makes the lesson feel productive may undercut that purpose. Explaining the guidance hypothesis to students, and showing them their results on a no-feedback test, can make reduced feedback feel like part of the service rather than a loss.
Limits of the Evidence
The evidence comes largely from laboratory tasks simpler than a golf swing, and later research has qualified the guidance hypothesis. Very complex skills and true beginners may benefit from more frequent feedback early on, before reducing it. Allowing learners to choose when to receive feedback has also produced good learning in several studies, suggesting that the learner's control matters as well as the frequency. The direction of the recommendation, toward less and faded feedback for students who have the basic swing, is well supported; the exact schedule should be adjusted to the student.
References
Salmoni, A. W., Schmidt, R. A., & Walter, C. B. (1984). Knowledge of results and motor learning: A review and critical reappraisal. Psychological Bulletin, 95(3), 355-386. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.95.3.355
Schmidt, R. A., & Lee, T. D. (2019). Motor learning and performance: From principles to application (6th ed.). Human Kinetics.
Winstein, C. J., & Schmidt, R. A. (1990). Reduced frequency of knowledge of results enhances motor skill learning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 16(4), 677-691. https://doi.org/10.1037/0278-7393.16.4.677
The PSY-833 Topic 4 assignment instructions
Topic 4 in PSY-833 asks doctoral students to critique a feedback practice. Strong critiques distinguish knowledge of results from knowledge of performance, classify the feedback in the case and focus on how often it is given. Students should explain the guidance hypothesis, report experimental evidence that reduced and faded feedback produces better retention, and translate the evidence into specific changes, such as summaries and self-estimates before feedback. The critique should state the limits of laboratory evidence for complex skills and beginners and explain why constant feedback remains popular. A table of feedback schedules and their effects on practice and retention helps faculty follow the critique.
Inside the PSY 833 Topic 4 example
The finished critique opens on a composite golf instructor whose launch monitor reports carry distance and face angle after every swing, and whose students strike the ball well in lessons and noticeably worse on the course. It distinguishes knowledge of results, information about the outcome, from knowledge of performance, information about the movement, and places the monitor's output in the first category. The guidance hypothesis associated with Alan Salmoni, Richard Schmidt and Charles Walter supplies the explanation: frequent feedback steers each attempt and so builds reliance on it. Carolee Winstein and Schmidt's finding that reduced, faded feedback matched full feedback in acquisition and outperformed it on delayed retention is the central evidence. Bandwidth and summary schedules are compared. Evidence that learners who choose when feedback arrives tend to retain more is noted last.
Where the marks sit in the PSY 833 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward feedback judged by its schedule. An Excellent critique separates knowledge of results from knowledge of performance and places the launch monitor's numbers. Credit goes to Salmoni, Schmidt and Walter's guidance hypothesis and Winstein and Schmidt's reduced, faded feedback, in a table of schedules. The rubric values hidden screens, summaries after sets and student estimates before numbers. Strong critiques explain why constant feedback sells lessons. Top marks go to limits for beginners and the case for learner-controlled feedback.
PSY 833 Topic 4 help before you submit
Critiques on this topic are marked down hardest for praising the monitor because students improve while using it, which confuses guidance with learning. A second weakness is recommending less feedback without specifying a schedule, since reduced, faded, bandwidth and summary arrangements differ in how they work and what they have shown. Papers failing to distinguish outcome from movement information cannot say what the monitor actually supplies. Some treat the guidance hypothesis as proven for every task and learner, when the evidence varies with task complexity and experience. Omitting intrinsic feedback misses the mechanism, because the argument turns on what the learner stops attending to. A revised schedule that never removes feedback entirely leaves the critique with no evidence that the golfer can play without it.
Get a PSY-833 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the PSY-833 Topic 4 instructions and rubric along with any coaching scenario your section described. A custom example is written to those criteria, testing feedback after every attempt against the reduced-frequency research and proposing a faded schedule checked by a no-feedback retention test, returned in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More PSY 833 papers and PhD in Psychology samples
- PSY 833 Topic 1: Learning Versus Performance Paper
- PSY 833 Topic 2: Skill Acquisition Stage Analysis
- PSY 833 Topic 3: Practice Schedule Evaluation
- PSY 833 Topic 5: Attentional Focus Dq Post
- PSY 833 Topic 6: Transfer Claim Analysis
- PSY 833 Topic 7: Choking Mechanism Analysis
- PSY 833 Topic 8: Practice Program Proposal
- PSY 831 Topic 4: Confidence Evidence Appraisal
- PSY 802 Topic 4: Object Relations Comparison
- PSY 810 Topic 4: Transition Narrative Audit
- PSY 803 Topic 4: Radical and Methodological Comparison
PSY 833 Topic 4 questions, answered
What is the guidance hypothesis?
The proposal that augmented feedback guides a learner toward the correct movement on each attempt, which helps performance during practice, but that frequent feedback also encourages reliance on it. When the feedback is removed, as it is in competition, performance drops because the learner has not developed the ability to detect and correct errors unaided. Salmoni, Schmidt and Walter set out the idea in a review of the knowledge of results literature.
Is feedback after every attempt ever appropriate?
Early in learning and on complex tasks, frequent feedback may be needed simply to give the learner a workable idea of the movement, and some research suggests the benefits of reducing it are smaller for complex skills. The critique does not argue for withholding information from beginners. It argues that frequency should fall as the skill develops, so that the learner takes over the job of evaluating each attempt.
What is bandwidth feedback?
An arrangement in which feedback is given only when an error falls outside a range the instructor has set as acceptable. Inside the band, the absence of feedback itself tells the learner the attempt was close enough. Because errors shrink as skill develops, feedback becomes less frequent automatically, which produces a faded schedule without the instructor deciding in advance when to reduce it.
Where can I find a free PSY 833 Topic 4 sample paper?
The critique is printed here in full: the lesson, two kinds of feedback, the guidance hypothesis, evidence for reduced feedback, applying it, why constant feedback is popular and limits. Share your PSY 833 Topic 4 prompt for a free critique.
Why do students swing worse on the course in PSY 833 Topic 4?
Feedback after every swing lets them correct each shot from the screen rather than from feel. Without the monitor, they lack the internal error detection the constant numbers replaced.