| Course | SYM 506 Applied Business Probability and Statistics |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Hypothesis test report |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for SYM 506 Topic 7
Did Stocking More Parts Raise First-Visit Fixes? A Two-Proportion Test Reported in Full, Interpreted Statistically and Then Commercially
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
SYM-506: Applied Business Probability and Statistics
Topic 7 Hypothesis Test Report
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Did Stocking More Parts Raise First-Visit Fixes? A Two-Proportion Test Reported in Full, Interpreted Statistically and Then Commercially
The Business Question, in Words First
A composite appliance repair company began stocking each technician's van with the 40 most frequently needed parts at the start of April, at an added inventory cost of about 40,000 dollars a year. The question is whether the policy raised the share of calls fixed on the first visit. In words, the null hypothesis is that the first-visit fix rate after the change is no higher than before; the alternative hypothesis is that it is higher. Only then are they written in notation: H0: p_after minus p_before is less than or equal to 0, and H1: p_after minus p_before is greater than 0, a one-sided test because only an improvement would justify keeping the policy.
Choosing the Significance Level From the Costs of Error
The significance level is chosen by asking what each kind of error would cost. A Type I error would conclude that the policy works when it does not, keeping 40,000 dollars a year of extra inventory for no benefit. A Type II error would conclude that it does not work when it does, abandoning a policy that avoids return trips costing about 95 dollars each. On roughly 3,000 calls a year, a genuine 6-point improvement would avoid about 180 return trips, around 17,000 dollars of direct cost plus the customer goodwill that repeat visits cost. The two errors are of similar size, with the Type II error somewhat worse once goodwill is counted, so the analysis uses a significance level of 0.10 rather than the conventional 0.05, and states that choice before seeing the result.
The Test and Its Assumptions
In the three months before the change, 228 of 300 completed calls were fixed on the first visit, 76 percent. In the three months after, 205 of 250, 82 percent. The appropriate test for this design, as recommended by Montgomery and Runger (2018), compares two independent proportions using a z statistic with a pooled estimate under the null hypothesis (Anderson et al., 2020). Its assumptions are checked against the data. The two samples are independent, since they are different calls in different months. Each group has well over ten successes and ten failures, so the normal approximation is reasonable. The calls are not a random sample but every call in each period, which raises a concern addressed below.
The Result, Reported in Full
The pooled proportion is 433 of 550, about 0.787. Assuming the null hypothesis, the difference's standard error is found by taking the square root of 0.787 times 0.213 times (1/300 + 1/250), about 0.0350. The observed difference is 0.82 minus 0.76 = 0.060, so z = 0.060 / 0.0350, about 1.71. The one-sided p-value is about 0.043.
Table 1
Two-Proportion z Test of First-Visit Fix Rates
| Item | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Calls | 300 | 250 |
| Fixed on first visit | 228 | 205 |
| Proportion | 0.760 | 0.820 |
| Difference | | 0.060 | |
| Pooled proportion | | 0.787 | |
| Standard error under H0 | | 0.0350 | |
| z statistic | | 1.71 | |
| One-sided p-value | | 0.043 |
The Statistical Conclusion
Because the p-value of 0.043 is below the chosen level of 0.10, the null hypothesis is rejected: the data provide evidence that the first-visit fix rate is higher after the change. The result would also be significant at 0.05. A p-value gives the chance of seeing a gap this big or bigger if the policy made no difference; it is not the probability that the policy works, and Wasserstein and Lazar (2016) cautioned against reading it as a gauge of how large or important an effect is. Had the test not rejected, the correct conclusion would have been that the data did not show an improvement, not that the policy had no effect; failing to find evidence of a difference does not prove there is none.
The Business Conclusion
Statistically the improvement is real; commercially its size matters more. At 90 percent confidence, the improvement lies somewhere between about 0.3 and 11.7 percentage points, so the gain could be small or substantial. At the 6-point estimate, the policy avoids about 180 return trips a year, saving roughly 17,000 dollars in direct cost against 40,000 dollars of inventory cost, so on direct savings alone it does not pay. It pays only if the goodwill and repeat business from first-visit fixes are worth more than about 23,000 dollars a year, or if the inventory can be trimmed to the parts that actually drive the improvement.
A Concern the Test Cannot Resolve
The two periods differ in season: January to March brings more heating appliance failures, April to June more refrigeration and air conditioning failures, which may be easier or harder to fix on the first visit regardless of stocking. The test cannot separate the policy's effect from that seasonal shift. A cleaner comparison would set this April to June against the same months last year, or stock half the vans and compare them over the same weeks.
Recommendation
The company should keep the policy for one more quarter while running a cleaner test: stock the full 40-part kit in half of the vans, chosen at random, and a reduced 15-part kit in the other half, then compare first-visit fix rates over the same weeks. That design removes the seasonal confound and shows whether the smaller, cheaper kit captures most of the gain. If it does, the inventory cost could fall by more than half while keeping most of the improvement, and the policy would pay on direct savings alone.
Conclusion
Written out in words, tested at a significance level chosen from the costs of each error and reported with its statistic and p-value, the analysis finds evidence that the first-visit fix rate rose from 76 to 82 percent. Statistically the result is clear; commercially, the 6-point gain does not yet cover the policy's cost on direct savings, and a seasonal confound remains. The appropriate response is a better-designed comparison, not a final verdict. Running that comparison over the next quarter would settle the question with far less ambiguity than the current before-and-after data allow.
References
Anderson, D. R., Sweeney, D. J., Williams, T. A., Camm, J. D., Cochran, J. J., Fry, M. J., & Ohlmann, J. W. (2020). Statistics for business and economics (14th ed.). Cengage.
Montgomery, D. C., & Runger, G. C. (2018). Applied statistics and probability for engineers (7th ed.). Wiley.
Wasserstein, R. L., & Lazar, N. A. (2016). The ASA statement on p-values: Context, process, and purpose. American Statistician, 70(2), 129-133. https://doi.org/10.1080/00031305.2016.1154108
SYM 506 Topic 7 instructions, in plain terms
The Topic 7 assignment in SYM-506 asks MBA students to run and report a hypothesis test. Strong reports write both hypotheses in words before notation, choose the significance level by what each type of error would cost and select a test whose assumptions are checked against the data. Students should report the statistic, standard error and p-value in full, state the statistical conclusion without claiming to prove the null, interpret the result commercially and name any concern the test cannot resolve. A result that fails to reject should be described as a lack of evidence, never as proof of no effect.
Inside the SYM 506 Topic 7 example
The finished example commits before it computes. Both hypotheses are written in advance in the business language of the question, and the example is explicit that the null is the position of no change, which is what the evidence has to overcome. The significance level is chosen and justified against the cost of each kind of error, since a false positive and a false negative rarely cost a business the same. Test selection is argued from the data. The result is then reported with everything needed to verify it, which test was run, on how many degrees of freedom, and the probability itself rather than a comparison against a threshold. It is interpreted twice, once as a statistical conclusion and once as a commercial one, and those are frequently different.
Reading the SYM 506 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty reward a test committed to before the data are read. An Excellent paper justifies a 0.10 level from the relative costs of keeping an ineffective policy and dropping an effective one. Credit goes to a full report of counts, pooled proportion, standard error, z and p, following Anderson and colleagues. The rubric values Wasserstein and Lazar's caution about what a p-value means. Strong papers give a commercial reading with an interval for the gain. Top marks go to naming the seasonal confound and a cleaner randomized design. Faculty also value a design that would remove the confound.
SYM 506 Topic 7 help before you submit
Concluding that a test proves the null hypothesis is the interpretive error faculty check for first, since failing to find evidence of a difference is not evidence that none exists. A second failure is a probability value reported alone, stripped of the statistic and the degrees of freedom that would let anybody check it. Papers lose marks for choosing a significance level with no justification, particularly where the business consequences of the two error types are obviously unequal. Treating statistical significance as commercial importance is the error that matters most in a business course, because a large sample makes trivial differences significant. Hypotheses written after the result is known are not a test and are usually detectable.
Get an SYM-506 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the SYM-506 Topic 7 problems and the rubric your classroom posts, with the data and business question your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with both hypotheses written in advance, the significance level justified commercially, the output reported fully and the result interpreted twice, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More SYM 506 papers and MBA samples
- SYM 506 Topic 1: Business Data Description
- SYM 506 Topic 2: Business Probability Problems
- SYM 506 Topic 3: Discrete Distribution Problems
- SYM 506 Topic 4: Normal Distribution Application
- SYM 506 Topic 5: Sampling Distribution Analysis
- SYM 506 Topic 6: Confidence Interval Report
- SYM 506 Topic 8: Regression and Forecast Limits
- MKT 607 Topic 7: Pricing Strategy Analysis
- ACC 502 Topic 7: Cash Flow Statement Build
- MGT 660 Topic 7: Structure and Governance Fit
- ACC 650 Topic 7: Standard Cost Variance Report
SYM 506 Topic 7 questions, answered
Can a test prove there is no difference?
No, and this is the interpretation faculty examine most closely. Failing to reject the null means the evidence was insufficient to conclude a difference exists, which is compatible with there being no difference and equally compatible with the sample being too small to detect one. The correct phrasing is that you did not find evidence of a difference, which is weaker and accurate.
How do I choose a significance level?
By what the two errors cost. Concluding a change works when it does not may commit a company to expensive rollout; missing a real improvement may forfeit a competitive advantage. Where a false positive is expensive, use a stricter threshold; where missing an effect is worse, a looser one is defensible. Stating the reasoning is what earns the mark, whichever level you pick.
Is a significant result always worth acting on?
No, and the distinction is central in business statistics. With a large enough sample, a difference far too small to matter commercially will register as statistically significant. Report the effect size alongside the test and ask whether a difference of that magnitude would change any decision. A significant but trivial result is a finding about your sample size rather than about your business.
Where can I find a free SYM 506 Topic 7 sample paper?
The hypothesis test report is shown here complete: the question in words, the significance level, the test and assumptions, the full result, the statistical conclusion, the business conclusion, an unresolved concern, the recommendation and the conclusion. Send your business question and data and a test report follows free.
Why use a 0.10 significance level in SYM 506 Topic 7?
Wrongly dropping a policy that works would cost about as much as wrongly keeping one that does not, and slightly more once goodwill is counted. The level reflects those costs.