| Course | ACC 614 Accounting Research |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Issue narrowing exercise |
| Length | About 980 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Individual classes |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for ACC 614 Topic 3
Narrowing "Do We Have a Lease Problem?" in Four Visible Steps Until the Search Returns a Set Small Enough to Read
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
ACC-614: Accounting Research
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Narrowing "Do We Have a Lease Problem?" in Four Visible Steps Until the Search Returns a Set Small Enough to Read
The Broad Concern
Brookfield Home Goods, a composite distributor, signed a five-year logistics contract with Keystone Logistics, a third-party warehouse operator, at $1.2 million a year. The controller's first message to the research team read: "Do we have a lease problem with the Keystone contract?" That concern is real, but as a research question it is useless. It could lead to any of dozens of provisions, and a search on it returns the entire lease topic. The question must be narrowed, and each step is shown with its reason.
Steps One and Two
Version zero: How should Brookfield account for the Keystone contract?
Step one removes the side of the transaction that is not Brookfield's. Brookfield is the customer, buying services and possibly space; Keystone's revenue accounting is Keystone's concern. Version one: Does the Keystone contract contain a lease for Brookfield as customer?
Step two removes what the facts have already settled. The contract commenced on January 1 and has not been modified, so there is no timing or modification issue. Brookfield and Keystone are unrelated, so no related-party guidance applies. Brookfield is a single operating company, so no question arises about which entity is the lessee. Version two: Does Brookfield's five-year logistics contract with Keystone contain a lease of warehouse space under the leases topic?
A Search at Stage Two
A search of the Codification using version two's terms, lease identification and contains a lease, returns the full scope and identification guidance of the leases topic, its implementation examples and several cross-referenced sections, well over a hundred paragraphs (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2009). That is too many to read with purpose. The size of the result is itself evidence that the narrowing is not finished: the question still asks about every element of the lease definition at once, when the facts put only one of them in doubt.
Steps Three and Four
Under the leases topic, a contract is or contains a lease when, for a period of time, it gives the customer control over how an identified asset is used (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2016). The facts settle most of that definition. The contract specifies Building C at Keystone's Riverside campus, 80,000 square feet racked to Brookfield's design. Brookfield decides what is stored, when goods move in and out and how the space is arranged, so it directs the use of the space, and it obtains substantially all the economic benefit from it, since no one else stores goods there.
The one element in doubt is whether the asset is identified at all. Section 6.3 of the contract lets Keystone relocate Brookfield's inventory to another of its warehouses on 60 days' notice. If that right is substantive, there is no identified asset and no lease.
Step three names that element. Version three: Is Keystone's right to relocate Brookfield's inventory a substantive substitution right?
Step four names the specific condition in dispute. A substitution right is substantive only if the supplier has the practical ability to substitute throughout the period of use and would benefit economically from doing so. Keystone plainly has the practical ability; it owns other warehouses in the region. The dispute is the second condition. Version four: Would Keystone benefit economically from moving Brookfield's inventory to another warehouse, given that the contract makes Keystone bear the relocation cost and Building C is racked to Brookfield's design?
The Search Again
Searching on substitution rights and economic benefit from substitution returns the four paragraphs of the leases topic that define a substantive substitution right, and two implementation examples, one involving rail cars and one involving storage space. That set can be read in twenty minutes, and it answers the question. Costs of substitution that exceed its benefits make a right nonsubstantive; relocating 80,000 square feet of custom-racked inventory at Keystone's expense would cost far more than Keystone could gain by freeing Building C. The right is not substantive, the asset is identified, and the contract contains a lease.
What the Narrowing Set Aside
Five matters were set aside along the way: Keystone's revenue accounting, contract timing and modification, related-party considerations, which entity is the lessee, and the other elements of control. None was actually in issue, which the facts recorded at each step confirm. A question narrowed past the dispute would have answered something no one asked; this one stops at the single condition the facts leave open. The lease's classification and measurement, and the allocation of the $1.2 million between the lease and Keystone's warehousing services, were deferred rather than excluded: they become the next questions now that a lease has been found (Kieso et al., 2019).
The reasoning was also tested against the storage example, which is the closer of the two. In that example a supplier could move a customer's goods among interchangeable bays at little cost, and the right was substantive. Building C is not interchangeable with Keystone's other space, because the racking was built for Brookfield's products and moving it would take weeks. The difference in facts, not a difference in rules, produces the different answer.
The Versions Side by Side
Each version is written in full so a reader can see what changed.
Table 1
Five Versions of the Question
| Version | Question | Removed |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | How should Brookfield account for the Keystone contract? | |
| 1 | Does the Keystone contract contain a lease for Brookfield as customer? | Keystone's side |
| 2 | Does Brookfield's five-year logistics contract with Keystone contain a lease of warehouse space under the leases topic? | Timing, related parties, entity |
| 3 | Is Keystone's right to relocate Brookfield's inventory a substantive substitution right? | Elements of control the facts settle |
| 4 | Would Keystone benefit economically from moving Brookfield's inventory, given it bears the relocation cost and Building C is custom-racked? | The practical-ability condition, which is not in doubt |
References
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009). The FASB Accounting Standards Codification and the hierarchy of generally accepted accounting principles (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 168). FASB.
Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2016). Leases (Topic 842) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2016-02). FASB.
Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.
The ACC-614 Topic 3 assignment instructions
ACC-614 Topic 3 asks students to narrow a broad accounting concern into a researchable question. Many papers present only the final question. The assignment rewards exercises that start from the concern as first stated, remove one thing at a time with a reason, and run a search between steps to show when narrowing is unfinished. Students should name the specific element in dispute, report a workable search result, write out every version of the question and confirm that what was set aside is not in issue. Each version of the question should be written in full, and the exercise should close by distinguishing matters excluded from matters that are only deferred until the first answer is known.
How this ACC 614 Topic 3 example is built
The finished example shows every step of the narrowing rather than presenting the finished question. The starting concern is broad enough to be useless, and each step removes something with a reason: a transaction type that does not apply here, a timing issue already settled by the facts, an entity classification that is not in doubt. After the second step the search still returns too much, which the example reports as evidence that the narrowing is unfinished. The fourth step produces a question naming the specific element in dispute, and the search returns a set small enough to read. The example also states what the narrowing excluded and confirms none of it was in issue.
ACC 614 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Faculty grading the narrowing exercise reward each step shown with its reason. Excellent exercises treat an oversized search result as evidence that narrowing is incomplete. Credit goes to isolating the one condition the facts leave open. The rubric values distinguishing matters excluded from matters deferred. The highest level writes every version in full and tests the answer against the closest example. Exercises that stop one step early usually lose marks with graders. Graders check that the final question still contains the real dispute and has not been narrowed past it.
ACC 614 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Presenting a finished question with no narrowing shown is the standard submission and conceals the reasoning the topic is assessing. A second failure is narrowing past the dispute, producing a precise question about something nobody was arguing over. Marks also go for stopping while the search still returns an unmanageable set, since the yield is the available evidence that the question is not yet specific enough. Narrowing steps offered with no reason cannot be evaluated. Questions that name an area rather than an element remain unsearchable. Papers that never report a yield have no way to demonstrate the narrowing worked. Issues narrowed by removing whatever proved hard to research produce a question shaped by convenience. Steps taken in one leap conceal the reasoning the section exists to demonstrate.
Get an ACC-614 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the ACC-614 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the issue your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, narrowed in visible steps with a reason at each, yields reported before and after, and exclusions checked, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More ACC 614 papers and Individual classes samples
- ACC 614 Topic 1: Authority Hierarchy Map
- ACC 614 Topic 2: Research Process Application
- ACC 614 Topic 4: Recognition and Measurement Analysis
- ACC 614 Topic 5: Non-authoritative Source Evaluation
- ACC 614 Topic 6: International Standards Comparison
- ACC 614 Topic 7: Research Memo to File
- ACC 614 Topic 8: Professional Ethics Case
- ADM 630 Topic 3: Mission Statement Analysis
ACC 614 Topic 3 questions, answered
How do I know when a question is narrow enough?
When the search returns a set you can actually read. A question yielding forty sections is still an area rather than an issue. One yielding four or five, all of which bear on the facts, is workable. The yield is the most reliable feedback available and it costs one search to obtain.
Can a question be too narrow?
Yes, and it is a real failure. Narrowing past the point in dispute produces a precise answer to something nobody was arguing about, which reads as thorough and helps no one. Checking that each exclusion was genuinely settled, rather than merely inconvenient, prevents this and takes a paragraph.
Should I show the steps or just the result?
Show them. The narrowing is what the topic is assessing, and a finished question tells a reader nothing about how it was reached. Four steps with a reason attached to each also make the question defensible, because a reader who disagrees with the scope can see exactly which step they would have taken differently.
Where can I find a free ACC 614 Topic 3 sample paper?
The full exercise sits above, with the broad concern, the first two steps, a search at stage two, steps three and four, the search again, what was set aside and the versions side by side. Give us your broad concern for a free worked exercise.
What decided the question in ACC 614 Topic 3?
Whether the supplier would benefit from moving the goods; with custom racking and relocation at its cost, it would not, so the asset is identified.