ACC 614 Topic 5 non-authoritative source evaluation example

Accounting Research Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This ACC 614 Topic 5 sample paper uses three nonauthoritative sources on one construction revenue question and labels exactly how each was used. It was written for GCU ACC 614, Accounting Research, catalog code ACC-614, among the Grand Canyon University Individual classes. The Codification settles progress on a $6.0 million contract, excluding $800,000 of uninstalled elevators at zero margin. A firm publication frames the issue, an industry guide supplies vocabulary and a textbook explains the input method, but none supports the conclusion. A widely followed practice of recognizing no profit until 10 percent complete is traced and found to have no authoritative source.

CourseACC 614 Accounting Research
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeNon-authoritative source evaluation
LengthAbout 980 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramIndividual classes
UpdatedSeptember 2026

Free sample paper for ACC 614 Topic 5

1

Three Useful Sources That Support Nothing, and a Widely Followed Practice With No Authority Behind It: Measuring Progress on a Building Contract

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

ACC-614: Accounting Research

Topic 5 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the paper's two findings: how nonauthoritative sources were used, and a practice that traces to no authoritative origin. The contractor and figures are illustrative composites; the standards and sources are real.
2

Three Useful Sources That Support Nothing, and a Widely Followed Practice With No Authority Behind It: Measuring Progress on a Building Contract

The Question and What the Codification Settles

Summit Ridge Builders, a composite commercial contractor, has a $6.0 million contract to build a medical office building, with estimated total costs of $5.0 million. At year end it had incurred $2.2 million of costs, including $800,000 for two elevators delivered to the site but not yet installed. The question is how much revenue to recognize.

The Codification settles most of it. The contract is a single performance obligation satisfied over time, and Summit Ridge measures progress by costs incurred relative to total expected costs. When an input does not depict progress, such as the cost of materials that are delivered but not yet installed, the entity excludes it from the measure of progress and, if the conditions are met, recognizes revenue equal to the cost of those materials, with no margin (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2014). Excluding the elevators, progress is $1.4 million of $4.2 million of other costs, one-third, giving $1.73 million of revenue on the $5.2 million of contract price attributable to other work, plus $800,000 of revenue at zero margin for the elevators. The Codification does not address one question: how Summit Ridge should document the estimate of total costs, which drives everything.

Three Nonauthoritative Sources

Three sources were consulted. A large accounting firm's publication on revenue recognition for construction contractors, issued by the firm's national office, shows how practitioners commonly frame the uninstalled materials question. The AICPA's industry guide for construction contractors supplies the vocabulary that Summit Ridge's project managers and lenders use, such as cost-to-cost and uninstalled materials. A university textbook explains the mechanics of the input method, which the Codification assumes the reader already knows (Kieso et al., 2019). None of the three is authoritative (Financial Accounting Standards Board, 2009).

Each Source in Use

The firm publication supports this sentence in the memo: "This analysis addresses the treatment of materials delivered but not installed, which practitioners commonly identify as the principal measurement issue on contracts of this kind." It does not support the sentence stating the treatment; that sentence cites the Codification.

The industry guide supports the terminology: the memo uses cost-to-cost and uninstalled materials because Summit Ridge's lender will read it. It does not support any conclusion about recognition.

The textbook supports the worked computation's layout, showing progress as costs to date over total estimated costs. It does not support the exclusion of the elevators, which comes from the Codification alone.

In each case the memo states which sentence a source supports and which it does not, so a reviewer can see that the conclusion stands without it.

Why the Labels Matter

Labeling each use is not formality. A reviewer who sees a firm publication cited next to a conclusion cannot tell whether the conclusion rests on it, and a later reader may repeat the conclusion citing the publication as if it were the authority. Over time, that is how practices without authority spread: each writer cites the one before. Stating plainly which sentence a source supports, and which it does not, keeps the chain of reasoning visible. It also protects the writer. If the firm publication is later revised or withdrawn, a memo that used it only for framing needs no change, while one that rested its conclusion on it would have to be reopened. The same discipline applies to the contractor's own policies, which often carry practices forward long after their original reason is forgotten.

A Practice With No Authoritative Origin

Summit Ridge's controller mentioned that the company, like many regional contractors, recognizes no profit on any contract until it is 10 percent complete, recognizing revenue only equal to costs until then. The practice is widespread. Tracing it produced a chain: the controller learned it at an industry seminar; the seminar materials cited an article in a contractors' trade magazine; the article cited a textbook example from the percentage-of-completion era; and the textbook example described the 10 percent threshold as a common practice, citing no pronouncement.

No authoritative source, current or superseded, sets a 10 percent threshold. The Codification does address a related situation: when an entity cannot reasonably measure its progress but expects to recover its costs, it recognizes revenue only to the extent of costs incurred until it can measure the outcome. The 10 percent practice may approximate that rule for contracts whose outcomes are genuinely uncertain early on, but it applies a fixed threshold where the Codification requires a judgment about whether progress can be measured.

What That Means in Practice

A company that follows the 10 percent practice is not necessarily misstating its revenue, but it is applying a rule no one wrote. If a contract's outcome is reasonably measurable at 4 percent complete, deferring its margin until 10 percent understates revenue; if a contract's outcome remains uncertain at 15 percent, recognizing margin overstates it. A firm relying on the practice should document, contract by contract, that the outcome could not reasonably be measured before the threshold, which turns the practice into evidence for the Codification's judgment rather than a substitute for it. Summit Ridge's medical office contract passed 10 percent long ago, so the practice does not affect this year's answer, but it will affect the next contract.

A Rule for My Own Memos

Background reading goes in the research file; the basis of a conclusion goes in the memo. Every sentence in a memo that states a conclusion cites the Codification or, for a public company, SEC guidance. Nonauthoritative sources may be cited for framing, vocabulary or explanation, labeled as such, with the publisher named, since who issued a document decides where it sits. When a practice is followed because everyone follows it, the memo traces it before relying on it.

References

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2009). The FASB Accounting Standards Codification and the hierarchy of generally accepted accounting principles (Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. 168). FASB.

Financial Accounting Standards Board. (2014). Revenue from contracts with customers (Topic 606) (Accounting Standards Update No. 2014-09). FASB.

Kieso, D. E., Weygandt, J. J., & Warfield, T. D. (2019). Intermediate accounting (17th ed.). Wiley.

The ACC-614 Topic 5 assignment instructions

ACC-614 Topic 5 asks students to evaluate nonauthoritative accounting sources. Many papers either dismiss them or rely on them. The assignment rewards evaluations that state what the authoritative guidance settles, introduce each nonauthoritative source with its publisher and contribution, and show the sentence each supports and the sentence it does not. Students should trace a widely followed practice to its origin, explain what relying on it means and how to document it, and set a rule separating background reading from the basis of a conclusion. The paper should also explain why labeling each use protects both the reviewer and the writer if a source is later revised or withdrawn.

Inside the ACC 614 Topic 5 example

The finished example is precise about the role each source plays. A firm publication is used to understand how the issue is commonly framed, an industry practice guide supplies the vocabulary the client will use, and a textbook explains a mechanism the authoritative text assumes the reader knows. None of the three supports the conclusion, and the example says so directly in the memo language. The interesting finding is a practice followed widely across the industry that traces back to no authoritative source, only to a chain of publications citing one another. The example reports that and explains what it means for a firm relying on it. Nothing in the conclusion rests on any of the three, and the memo language makes that explicit.

ACC 614 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty grading the source evaluation reward every use labeled. Excellent evaluations name each source's publisher and role. Credit goes to showing the conclusion stands without any of the three. The rubric values tracing a common practice through a chain of citations to no authority. The highest level explains how a firm should document reliance and sets a personal rule for memos. Evaluations that cite a firm guide as support for a conclusion usually lose marks. Naming each publisher is expected, because where a document sits in the hierarchy depends on who issued it.

Common ACC 614 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Dismissing non-authoritative sources entirely is as unhelpful as relying on them, and papers doing either miss what the topic is testing. A second failure is citing a firm publication in support of a conclusion, which is the specific error the distinction exists to prevent. Marks also go for using such sources without labeling the use, since a reader cannot then tell what the conclusion rests on. Papers that never test a common practice against its origin accept industry habit as authority. Sources described in general terms, with no sentence they support, demonstrate nothing about how to use them. Conclusions with no authoritative citation are unsupported however well argued. Sources cited with no publisher named leave the authority question unanswerable for a reader.

Get an ACC-614 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the ACC-614 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the sources your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each source given a stated role, its use demonstrated sentence by sentence and one practice traced to its origin, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More ACC 614 papers and Individual classes samples

ACC 614 Topic 5 questions, answered

Can I cite a firm publication?

For framing, vocabulary or background, yes, and label it as such. As the basis of a conclusion, no. The distinction is not about quality, since firm publications are frequently more detailed and more current than the authoritative text. It is about what a conclusion can rest on, and a reviewer will treat a memo resting on persuasive material as unsupported.

What if everyone in the industry does it this way?

Then find out what the practice rests on, because sometimes the answer is nothing. Tracing a common treatment back through its sources occasionally ends in a chain of publications citing one another with no authoritative origin. That is worth knowing, worth documenting, and worth raising, even if the conclusion is that the practice is defensible in the absence of contrary guidance.

How do I show how a source was used?

Attach it to the sentence it supports. If a textbook explains a mechanism the authoritative text assumes, cite it at that explanation and nowhere else. Papers that cite persuasive material at the end of a paragraph containing a conclusion imply support the source cannot give, which is usually carelessness rather than intent and reads the same either way.

Where can I find a free ACC 614 Topic 5 sample paper?

The complete evaluation appears above: the question and what the Codification settles, three sources, each in use, why the labels matter, a practice with no authoritative origin, what it means and a rule for memos. Tell us your question for a free worked evaluation.

Where does the 10 percent practice come from in ACC 614 Topic 5?

A chain of seminar materials, a trade article and an old textbook example, none citing any pronouncement; no authoritative source sets the threshold.