| Course | DBA 831 Analytic Foundations for Business Leaders |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Sample selection critique |
| Length | About 990 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DBA 831 Topic 4
Responders, Nonresponders and a Mandate: What a Franchisee Survey on a New Point-of-Sale System Can Support, and Why 78 Percent Is a Ceiling
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
DBA-831: Analytic Foundations for Business Leaders
Topic 4 Sample Selection Critique
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Responders, Nonresponders and a Mandate: What a Franchisee Survey on a New Point-of-Sale System Can Support, and Why 78 Percent Is a Ceiling
The Reading and the Decision It Supports
A composite quick-service franchisor with 640 franchised restaurants, held by about 210 owners, introduced a new point-of-sale system eighteen months ago and allowed owners to adopt it voluntarily. About half have. The franchisor surveyed every owner about the system and reports that 78 percent of respondents rated it favorably. On that basis, management proposes to require every restaurant to adopt it within a year, at a cost to each owner of about 14,000 dollars per restaurant. This critique asks how the respondents came to be in the sample and what their answers can support. Figures are illustrative.
The stakes of the reading are high. A mandate would cost owners about 4.5 million dollars across the roughly 320 restaurants not yet converted, and it would fall hardest on the owners who chose not to adopt, presumably for reasons of their own. If most of those owners dislike the system, a mandate could damage the franchisor's relationship with a large part of its network, and those owners are the ones whose views the survey is least likely to contain. The question the franchisor needs answered is not whether the system has supporters, which it plainly does, but whether owners who have not adopted would be better served by it.
How the Sample Formed
The sampling frame was complete: the survey went to all 210 owners. Completeness of the frame does not make the sample representative, because the respondents selected themselves. Seventy-four owners replied, a response rate of about 35 percent. A low response rate is not in itself proof of bias; Groves (2006) showed that the link between response rates and bias is weak in general, and that what matters is whether the reasons people respond are tied to the views the survey is trying to capture. In this case they plausibly are. Owners who chose to adopt the system early had already formed a favorable view of it, and owners who had complained about it had reason to doubt their opinion would change anything.
Heckman (1979) made the general point formally: when the process that determines whether an observation enters a sample is related to the outcome of interest, estimates from that sample are biased, and the bias does not shrink with more of the same kind of data. Doubling the number of early adopters in the sample would not tell the franchisor more about owners who have not adopted.
Responders Compared With Nonresponders
The franchisor holds records on every owner, which allows a direct comparison of those who responded with those who did not. A comparison on characteristics known for everyone is the natural first check for nonresponse bias, because it needs no new data.
Table 1
Responders and Nonresponders on Characteristics in Company Records, Illustrative
| Characteristic | Responders, 74 owners | Nonresponders, 136 owners |
|---|---|---|
| Adopted the system in first six months | 61 percent | 22 percent |
| Adopted at any point | 81 percent | 34 percent |
| Filed a complaint about the system | 7 percent | 24 percent |
| Average restaurant sales, thousands of dollars | 1,480 | 1,310 |
| Owns five or more restaurants | 38 percent | 21 percent |
The differences are large and consistent. Responders adopted earlier, complained less, ran higher-volume restaurants and owned more of them. Each difference points toward a more favorable view of the system among those who answered.
The Direction of the Bias
Because every observable difference favors approval, the 78 percent figure is best treated as a ceiling on approval across the network, not an estimate of it. A rough adjustment makes the point. Among responders, approval was about 90 percent among adopters and about 30 percent among nonadopters. If those rates held among nonresponders, whose adoption rate is 34 percent, approval among them would be about 50 percent, and approval across all owners about 60 percent. The true figure may be lower still, because nonresponders who had not adopted, and who had complained, may disapprove more strongly than nonadopters who chose to reply. The adjustment cannot recover the true number. It shows that the survey supports a weaker claim than the one management is making: the system is popular among early adopters, and opinion among other owners is unknown and probably much less favorable.
Can Answers Here Be Freely Given?
The survey also raises an ethical question. Of the Belmont Report's three principles (National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research, 1979), the first, respect for persons, bears on this survey even though the report addressed formal research rather than business polling. Respect for persons requires that participation and answers be voluntary. The franchisor decides whether to renew each owner's franchise agreement, approves transfers and controls supplier terms. The survey was administered by the franchisor's own operations team, and responses were linked to owner accounts. An owner with a renewal due may reasonably fear that criticism of a system management champions will be remembered. Some nonresponse may reflect exactly that fear, and some favorable answers may be less candid than they appear. Neither can be measured, but both mean the survey cannot be treated as the network's free voice.
A Design the Franchisor Could Run
Before deciding on a mandate, the franchisor should run a second survey through an independent third party, with answers reported to management only in aggregate and only for groups of at least ten owners. It should draw a random subset of nonresponders, perhaps 40 owners, and follow them up by telephone and mail until most have answered, since a high response rate within a random subset is more informative than a modest rate across everyone. Results should be reported separately for adopters and nonadopters, with the adoption rate in the network used to weight them. And the questions should ask about specific features and costs, such as speed at the counter, downtime and training time, so that the franchisor learns what to change, not only whether owners approve.
References
Groves, R. M. (2006). Nonresponse rates and nonresponse bias in household surveys. Public Opinion Quarterly, 70(5), 646-675. https://doi.org/10.1093/poq/nfl033
Heckman, J. J. (1979). Sample selection bias as a specification error. Econometrica, 47(1), 153-161. https://doi.org/10.2307/1912352
National Commission for the Protection of Human Subjects of Biomedical and Behavioral Research. (1979). The Belmont report: Ethical principles and guidelines for the protection of human subjects of research. U.S. Department of Health, Education, and Welfare. https://www.hhs.gov/ohrp/regulations-and-policy/belmont-report/index.html
The DBA-831 Topic 4 assignment instructions
In Topic 4, DBA-831 asks doctoral students to critique what a nonrandom business sample can support. Strong critiques separate the sampling frame from the respondents, explain why self-selection matters when the reasons for answering relate to the answers, and compare responders with nonresponders on characteristics already on record. Students should estimate the direction of bias, show roughly how far it could move the headline figure and restate the conclusion the data can carry. The paper should also consider whether respondents who depend on the organization can answer freely, and propose a design that would produce a more trustworthy result.
How the DBA-831 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished critique opens with the franchisor's reading: most respondents rated the new system favorably, so the network approves. It then asks how respondents came to be in the sample. The survey went to every franchisee, but responses came disproportionately from owners who adopted the system early, and franchisees who had filed complaints about it were less likely to reply. The critique states the likely direction of bias, toward approval, and uses the franchisor's own records to compare responders with nonresponders on adoption date, store volume and complaint history. Heckman's work on sample selection is cited for the general point that a self-selected sample can bias estimates when the reasons for responding relate to the outcome. The last section asks whether a franchisee can freely criticize a system the franchisor controls.
Where the marks sit in the DBA 831 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward a headline figure read as a bound. An Excellent critique separates a complete frame from self-selected respondents, citing Heckman on selection and Groves on response rates. Credit goes to a table comparing responders and nonresponders on adoption, complaints, sales and ownership, the standard first check for nonresponse. The rubric values a rough adjustment showing approval nearer 60 percent. Strong critiques apply the Belmont Report's respect for persons to owners awaiting renewal. Top marks go to a third-party survey with random follow-up of nonresponders.
Common DBA 831 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The central weakness graders look for is a sample described as representative because everyone was invited. A complete frame with self-selected responses is still a self-selected sample, and papers that miss the distinction overstate what the approval rate shows. Stating that nonresponse may bias results, with no direction and no comparison, names a concern without estimating it. Critiques that recommend random sampling across the network ignore that the franchisor cannot compel an answer from anyone chosen. Ethics treated as a consent form misses the dependence built into the franchise relationship, which affects the data as much as the respondents. Papers that cite Heckman for a correction method they never apply, or attach findings to him beyond the selection problem, invite questions the paper cannot answer.
Get a DBA-831 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the DBA-831 Topic 4 instructions and your classroom rubric, with the sample, dataset or organizational case your section assigns. We write a custom example to them, with the frame separated from the respondents, responders compared with nonresponders, the direction of bias stated and the ethics of the relationship addressed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DBA 831 papers and DBA samples
- DBA 831 Topic 1: Research Question Refinement Paper
- DBA 831 Topic 2: Claim and Design Alignment Paper
- DBA 831 Topic 3: Construct Validity Critique
- DBA 831 Topic 5: Falsifiable Hypothesis Dq Post
- DBA 831 Topic 6: Inference Assumptions Review
- DBA 831 Topic 7: Rival Explanation Design Defense
- DBA 831 Topic 8: Pre-specified Analysis Plan
- DBA 820 Topic 4: Private Credit Risk Analysis
- DBA 815 Topic 4: Local Pricing Power Analysis
- DBA 805 Topic 4: Theory Evidence Audit
DBA 831 Topic 4 questions, answered
If everyone was surveyed, how can the sample be biased?
Because a sample is formed by who responds, not only by who is invited. When the reasons for answering are related to the question, such as satisfaction with the system being rated, respondents differ systematically from the whole population. A complete invitation list removes coverage error but leaves selection error untouched, and that is the problem the example traces in the franchisor's survey.
How can the direction of bias be estimated?
By comparing responders with nonresponders on characteristics already known for everyone, such as adoption date or complaint history, and asking how those characteristics relate to the outcome. Following up a random subset of nonresponders gives more direct evidence. The example uses both approaches with illustrative figures and treats the result as a bound on approval rather than a correction to it.
Does my study need ethics review if it is only a business survey?
Doctoral research involving people typically requires institutional review before data collection, whatever the setting, and research inside an organization raises particular concerns about consent and confidentiality when respondents depend on the sponsor. Follow the requirements your program and review board set. The example is DBA-831 coursework on a composite franchisor and does not substitute for that review.
Where can I find a free DBA 831 Topic 4 sample paper?
The selection critique is printed here in full: the reading and its decision, how the sample formed, responders against nonresponders, the direction of bias, whether answers were freely given and a better design. Send your survey's figures and a critique follows at no cost.
How does approval fall to about 60 percent in DBA 831 Topic 4?
Responders approved at about 90 percent if they had adopted and 30 percent if not. Applying those rates to nonresponders, of whom only 34 percent adopted, gives about 50 percent among them and about 60 percent overall.