DNP 835 Topic 2 improvement method evaluation logic example

Patient Outcomes and Sustainable Change Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This DNP 835 Topic 2 sample paper evaluates one sedation-scoring prompt, added at the scan of every as-needed opioid on a composite 32-bed surgical unit, two ways: through rapid cycles and through a before-and-after design. It belongs to GCU DNP 835, Patient Outcomes and Sustainable Change, listed as DNP-835, required in Grand Canyon University's DNP. Plan-do-study-act cycles test the change in two-week steps of about 900 doses, after Taylor and colleagues. A before-and-after design introduces it whole against a 12-week baseline, after Speroff and O'Connor. Cycles show when the shift happened, the design how big. The informatics committee needs the magnitude, and a costed hybrid follows.

CourseDNP 835 Patient Outcomes and Sustainable Change
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeImprovement method comparison
LengthAbout 1,050 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramDNP
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for DNP 835 Topic 2

1

When the Shift Happened, or How Big It Was: One Sedation-Scoring Prompt Evaluated Through Rapid Cycles and Through a Before-and-After Design

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

DNP-835: Patient Outcomes and Sustainable Change

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

June 12, 2028

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names the two different claims the two methods can support, which is the comparison the paper makes. The unit, dose counts and percentages are composites.
2

When the Shift Happened, or How Big It Was: One Sedation-Scoring Prompt Evaluated Through Rapid Cycles and Through a Before-and-After Design

The Change and What the Organization Wants to Learn

The change is a sedation-scoring prompt on the composite 32-bed surgical unit described in Topic 1. At the scan of any as-needed opioid, the medication administration record now asks for a Pasero Opioid-Induced Sedation Scale score before the dose can be documented, with a short reminder of what each level means and what to do at level 3 or higher. It targets the first process measure from Topic 1, pre-dose sedation scoring, which stood at 58 percent before any of this work began. The unit gives about 450 as-needed opioid doses a week.

The organization wants to learn something specific. Its informatics committee must decide whether to build the prompt into the record for all nine adult inpatient units, a build that takes an analyst about six weeks and permanently adds a step to every as-needed opioid dose in the hospital. The committee will ask how much documented sedation scoring the prompt produced. The unit, meanwhile, wants to know which parts of the rollout made it work, so it can keep them.

The Change Run Through Rapid Cycles

Run as plan-do-study-act cycles, the change is introduced in small steps, each tested for two weeks with about 900 doses of data. Cycle 1 tested a laminated sedation scale card on each medication cart: documentation rose from 58 to 63 percent. Cycle 2 switched on the prompt as a soft alert that could be dismissed: 74 percent. Cycle 3 kept the prompt, rewrote its wording after nurses said the original text was too long to read at the bedside, and added a 2-minute review of the previous day's missed scores at the morning huddle: 86 percent. Cycle 4 made the prompt a required field for patients in their first 24 hours after surgery: 91 percent. Each cycle's result was plotted on a run chart with the 12-week baseline median, and the shift rule was met during cycle 3.

This evidence supports two claims well. It shows when the shift happened, in cycle 3, and it points to which adaptation mattered: the jump from 74 to 86 percent followed the rewritten wording and the huddle, not the prompt's first appearance. It supports those claims weakly in one respect, because the wording and the huddle were introduced together, so the cycles cannot say which of the two carried the gain.

The Same Change Run as a Before-and-After Design

Run as a before-and-after design, the change is introduced whole: the prompt with its final wording, the huddle review and the required field for the first 24 hours, all on the same day. A 12-week baseline of about 5,400 doses, with sedation scores documented for 58 percent, is compared with 12 weeks afterward, about 5,300 doses, with 88 percent documented. The difference is 30 percentage points, and with samples this large the 95 percent confidence interval is narrow, roughly 28.5 to 31.5 points.

This evidence supports a different claim: how large the difference was, with a precise interval, measured over long enough periods that a few unusual weeks do not drive it. It cannot say which component produced the difference, because all of them arrived together, and it cannot show the shape of the change over time beyond before and after (Speroff & O'Connor, 2004).

What Each Supports and What Neither Does

The rapid-cycle version cannot give a magnitude with any precision. Each cycle's figure comes from two weeks, and each is measured on top of the previous cycle's changes, so the gain from any one step is the difference between two short, overlapping estimates. Asked how much the prompt raised documentation, the cycles can only say that the rise from baseline to the final cycle was about 33 points, with a wide and poorly defined uncertainty. The before-and-after version cannot say which component worked, which is exactly what the unit most needs in order to keep the change alive.

Neither establishes cause on one unit. Both are measured over time on a single unit without a concurrent control, and anything else that changed in the same weeks, such as a new nurse educator or a safety alert after an event elsewhere, could account for part of either result. Rapid-cycle work as reported in the literature often falls short of its own method: Taylor et al. (2014) reviewed 73 published PDSA projects and found that only 14 reported a full run of linked cycles, and that, of the 47 examined closely, 7 used data gathered at least monthly to decide what each following cycle would test. Running cycles well is not the same as running them.

What this page is doingThe two methods are compared on what their data let the team conclude, a timing and a component on one side, a magnitude with an interval on the other, rather than on how each method is diagrammed.
3

Which Claim the Organization Needs

The informatics committee needs the magnitude. It is deciding whether a hospital-wide build is worth six analyst weeks and an added step on every as-needed opioid dose, and a 30-point increase with a narrow interval is the figure that decision turns on. The unit needs the component, because the sustainability of the change depends on knowing whether the huddle review is essential or can be dropped when the unit gets busy. The organization's formal decision rests with the committee, so the magnitude is the claim that has to be delivered; the component question is the one the unit should not give up.

A Hybrid and What It Costs

The hybrid runs short cycles inside a longer measurement frame. The 12-week baseline is collected first, as the before-and-after design requires. The cycles then run as planned, but the huddle review and the rewritten wording are introduced in separate cycles two weeks apart, so their effects can be seen separately on the run chart. After the final cycle, the complete change runs unaltered for 12 weeks, and that period is compared with the baseline to produce the magnitude and interval the committee needs (Provost & Murray, 2011). The cost is time: the evaluation takes about 32 weeks instead of 12 or 20, and the unit must resist adjusting the change during the last 12 weeks, even when nurses suggest improvements, so the magnitude describes a stable intervention. The project will accept both costs, and the suggestions made during the frozen period will be logged and tested afterward.

References

Provost, L. P., & Murray, S. K. (2011). The health care data guide: Learning from data for improvement. Jossey-Bass.

Speroff, T., & O'Connor, G. T. (2004). Study designs for PDSA quality improvement research. Quality Management in Health Care, 13(1), 17-32. https://doi.org/10.1097/00019514-200401000-00002

Taylor, M. J., McNicholas, C., Nicolay, C., Darzi, A., Bell, D., & Reed, J. E. (2014). Systematic review of the application of the plan-do-study-act method to improve quality in healthcare. BMJ Quality & Safety, 23(4), 290-298. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjqs-2013-001862

What the DNP 835 Topic 2 instructions ask for

Topic 2 in DNP-835 asks students to compare improvement methods for evaluating a practice change. Strong papers describe the change and what the organization wants to learn, then run the same change through two methods, for example rapid plan-do-study-act cycles and a before-and-after design. Students should state what each method supports and what neither does, such as the imprecise magnitude from short cycles and the lack of causal proof on a single unit. The paper should identify which claim the decision maker needs and propose a design that delivers it, with its cost in time and data stated plainly. A table setting the two designs side by side helps faculty see the trade-off, and the hybrid's cost should be stated in weeks.

How this DNP 835 Topic 2 example is built

The finished example compares methods by their evidence rather than by their diagrams. Run through a rapid cycle approach, the change produces a sequence of small tests, each with two weeks of data, and the evidence supports a claim about when the shift happened and which adaptation mattered. Run through a before and after design with a longer baseline, the same change produces a single comparison with an effect size and an interval, supporting a claim about how large the difference was. The example is clear that the first cannot give a magnitude with any precision and the second cannot say which component worked. It then chooses on the basis of which claim the organization needs.

DNP 835 Topic 2 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a method chosen by the claim it produces. An Excellent paper runs the prompt through two-week cycles of about 900 doses, starting with a laminated scale card, and through a before-and-after design against a 12-week baseline. Credit goes to stating that cycles cannot give a precise magnitude, citing Taylor and colleagues' review, and that neither establishes causation, after Speroff and O'Connor. The rubric values identifying the informatics committee's need for magnitude before six analyst weeks are spent. Top marks go to a hybrid with its cost.

Common DNP 835 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Describing improvement methods in sequence without applying any is what this topic produces most often and rewards least. A second failure is claiming a rapid cycle approach establishes effect size, when short cycles on small numbers cannot support a precise estimate. Marks also go for treating any single unit design as establishing cause, which none of them do. Comparisons that never state what the organization needs to know choose a method with no criterion. Papers ignoring the cost of a hybrid recommend the most demanding option for free. Methods evaluated with no data described leave the comparison at the level of preference. Evaluations that never say what data a method produces compare frameworks on reputation alone.

Get a DNP-835 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the DNP-835 Topic 2 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the change and methods your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, running one change through two methods, comparing what each supports and choosing on what the organization needs, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.

More DNP 835 papers and DNP samples

DNP 835 Topic 2 questions, answered

Which improvement method is best?

The one producing the claim you need. If the organization needs to know how large the effect was, a longer baseline and a comparison will support that and rapid cycles will not. If it needs to know which component of the change mattered, cycles will show it and a single before and after comparison will not. Choose from the question, not from the framework's reputation.

Can rapid cycles give me an effect size?

Not with useful precision. Each cycle rests on a small number of cases over a short period, which is exactly the situation where chance variation dominates. Cycles are good at showing when something shifted and which adaptation preceded it. Asking them for a magnitude with an interval is asking for something the data cannot supply.

Does any of this establish causation?

Not on a single unit without a control, and saying so protects the whole paper. What these designs establish is that a change was made and an outcome moved, together with the timing that makes the connection plausible. Concurrent changes remain the alternative explanation. Naming them is the honest version of a causal claim at this scale.

Where can I find a free DNP 835 Topic 2 sample paper?

Both evaluation designs for the sedation prompt appear on this page: the change and what the organization wants to learn, rapid cycles, a before-and-after design, what each supports, which claim the organization needs and a hybrid with its cost. Share your DNP 835 Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.

Can rapid cycles give an effect size in DNP 835 Topic 2?

Not with useful precision. Each cycle covers two weeks and sits on top of the previous cycle's changes, so the gain from any one step cannot be separated or measured well.