| Course | DNP 836A Facilitation of Learning in Nursing Education |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Feedback conversation analysis |
| Length | About 1,140 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 836A Topic 6
Three Softenings in Thirty Lines: Analyzing a Feedback Conversation With a Fourteen-Year Nurse After a Deterioration Handover, and What Changed Two Shifts Later
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
DNP-836A: Facilitation of Learning in Nursing Education
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
September 11, 2028
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Softenings in Thirty Lines: Analyzing a Feedback Conversation With a Fourteen-Year Nurse After a Deterioration Handover, and What Changed Two Shifts Later
The Conversation and the Learner
Table 1
The Feedback Conversation, Lines 1 to 30
| Line | Speaker | What was said |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Me | Thanks for letting me sit in on that. Do you have five minutes? |
| 2 | Angela | Sure, before the next round. |
| 3 | Me | How did you think it went? |
| 4 | Angela | Fine, I think. He's been a busy one today. |
| 5 | Me | It was a really good handover overall. Very organized. |
| 6 | Angela | Thanks. |
| 7 | Me | One thing I noticed was the score. You mentioned it was a 6. |
| 8 | Angela | Right, that was the 1500 set. |
| 9 | Me | Maybe it would help to think about including a bit more context around it. |
| 10 | Angela | Context like what? |
| 11 | Me | Just, you know, where it's been. It's a small thing. |
| 12 | Angela | OK. |
| 13 | Me | The respiratory rate you gave was 22. Was that from the chart? |
| 14 | Angela | From the 1500 vitals, yes. |
| 15 | Me | That's what most people do. It's hard to recount every time. |
| 16 | Angela | It is. The aide took those. |
| 17 | Me | Sure. It might be worth counting it yourself sometimes. |
| 18 | Angela | I usually do if something looks off. |
| 19 | Me | Makes sense. You clearly know him well. |
| 20 | Angela | I've had him three days. |
| 21 | Me | The last thing was that you'd already called the hospitalist. |
| 22 | Angela | At 1530, and they're coming up. |
| 23 | Me | That came at the end. Great that you escalated, though. |
| 24 | Angela | Well, a 6 is a call now, isn't it? |
| 25 | Me | It is. You did exactly the right thing. |
| 26 | Angela | Good. |
| 27 | Me | So, just those few small things. Overall, really solid. |
| 28 | Angela | Thanks. Anything else? |
| 29 | Me | No, that's it. Thanks for your time. |
| 30 | Angela | No problem. |
The conversation took place after I observed a handover on the composite hospital's step-down unit, two weeks after the early warning score workshop described earlier in this course. Angela, a registered nurse with fourteen years of experience, handed over a 68-year-old patient with pneumonia whose score had risen from 3 to 6 during the afternoon. The handover was calm and thorough, but it had three specific problems: the score was reported without its trend, the respiratory rate given was the last charted value rather than a fresh count, and the escalation already made was mentioned only at the end. The feedback conversation happened in the medication room fifteen minutes later. I recorded it with Angela's agreement for my own development, and it is reproduced below with the lines numbered.
Three Places the Specific Became General
Feedback helps when it is specific, based on what was observed and tied to what the learner can do differently; general praise and vague suggestions give the learner nothing to act on (Ende, 1983). Read against that standard, the conversation softened a specific observation into something general three times.
Lines 9 and 11 are the first. The observation was precise: the score went from 3 to 6 in the afternoon, and the handover gave only the 6, so the receiving nurse could not tell whether the patient was stable at 6 or still climbing. What I said was "a bit more context" and "a small thing", which gave Angela nothing to change and told her it did not matter much. Lines 15 to 19 are the second. The respiratory rate of 22 came from vitals taken by an aide two hours earlier, and the score depends on it. I excused it as what most people do, suggested counting "sometimes" and then complimented her knowledge of the patient, which closed the topic. Lines 23 to 27 are the third. The escalation to the hospitalist at 1530 was the most important fact in the handover and it came last, where a busy receiving nurse might miss it. I noted the order and immediately praised the escalation itself, so the point about order was lost. Line 27, "just those few small things", summed up three important points as unimportant.
One Line, as Spoken and as Rewritten
Line 9, as spoken: "Maybe it would help to think about including a bit more context around it."
Line 9, rewritten: "You gave the score as 6. It was 3 at 1100. Without the 3, the next nurse can't tell he's climbing. At handover, give the score and the one before it."
The rewrite is shorter and harder. It names the observation, states the consequence for the next nurse and asks for one thing to do differently at the next handover. It contains no hedge and no compliment, because both would weaken it. The same structure would have served lines 17 and 23.
What Fourteen Years Changes
Angela's experience changes what the conversation can assume and what it must not say. It can assume she understands why trends matter, so the rewrite does not explain it; explaining it would be condescending, and a skilled nurse will stop listening when told what she already knows. It must not treat her as a novice being corrected in front of others, which is why the conversation happened privately. Her line 24, "a 6 is a call now, isn't it?", shows she had already absorbed the new rule, which deserved to be named specifically rather than praised in general. What her experience does not justify is softening the feedback. Experienced nurses are more likely than new ones to have habits that no one has questioned for years, such as quoting charted values, and vague feedback lets those habits continue. Feedback delivered as a general judgment of the person, rather than about the task, can even worsen performance (Kluger & DeNisi, 1996).
Two Shifts Later
I asked Angela for a second conversation the next day and gave her the three points in the rewritten form. Two shifts later, I listened to her next deterioration handover. One of the three had changed: she gave the score with its trend, "6, up from 3 at 1100", at the start of the handover. The other two had not. The respiratory rate was again the last charted value, and the escalation, this time to the rapid response nurse, again came near the end. My reading is that the trend point changed because it was a single, specific addition to something she already said. The respiratory rate point needs more than feedback, since counting a rate before every handover competes with everything else at shift change, and it may need a unit-level change in when rates are counted. The escalation order is a habit of narrative, and it may change only with a structured handover format that puts actions taken first. Feedback worked where it asked for one clear change within the learner's control (Ramani & Krackov, 2012).
References
Ende, J. (1983). Feedback in clinical medical education. JAMA, 250(6), 777-781. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1983.03340060055026
Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254-284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254
Ramani, S., & Krackov, S. K. (2012). Twelve tips for giving feedback effectively in the clinical environment. Medical Teacher, 34(10), 787-791. https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2012.684916
The DNP-836A Topic 6 assignment instructions
Topic 6 in DNP-836A asks students to analyze a feedback conversation with a learner. Strong analyses describe the conversation and the learner, then examine the actual words used, finding the places where specific observations became general or softened. Students should show at least one line as spoken and as it could have been said, explain how the learner's experience changes what the feedback can assume and what it must avoid saying, and report what happened afterward, including whether the feedback changed practice. Evidence on effective feedback, including its risks, should guide the analysis, and reporting feedback that failed at first strengthens the paper. Lines should be quoted exactly.
How the DNP-836A Topic 6 example is put together
The finished analysis works on a transcript instead of describing a model. Roughly forty lines of a real conversation appear, and the analysis marks three places where the facilitator softened a specific observation into a general compliment. One line is quoted twice, as spoken and as rewritten, and the rewrite is shorter and harder: the vague praise becomes a named observation, a stated consequence and one thing to do differently at the next handover. The learner in the transcript has fourteen years behind her, which changes what the conversation can assume and what it must not say. A follow up two shifts later is reported, and the honest finding is that one of the three items changed practice while the other two did not.
Where the marks sit in the DNP 836A Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward feedback analyzed line by line. An Excellent paper finds three places in thirty lines where observations softened, judged against Ende's principles. Credit goes to rewriting line 9 from a vague suggestion into the score's rise from 3 to 6 and what that called for. The rubric values considering Angela's fourteen years, avoiding explanations that would condescend, with Ramani and Krackov's twelve tips and Kluger and DeNisi on feedback that harms. Strong papers report a second conversation. Top marks go to the handover two shifts later. The follow-up is reported.
DNP 836A Topic 6 help: mistakes that cost marks
The commonest loss is an essay about feedback models with no conversation in it, which leaves every claim about what works untested. A second failure is feedback written as encouragement, recognizable because the learner could agree with all of it and change none of their practice. Papers that address an experienced nurse in the register of a first placement provoke exactly the defensiveness they were trying to avoid. Analyses reporting only what the facilitator said, with nothing about what followed, cannot show whether the conversation did anything. Questions posed with a single acceptable answer are interrogation wearing the clothes of dialogue. Rewrites offered with no reasoning attached give the reader a better sentence and no principle for producing the next one.
Get a DNP-836A Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-836A Topic 6 assignment instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with any feedback model your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, built on a transcript, with the reassuring lines rewritten for an experienced nurse and the outcome tracked afterward, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DNP 836A papers and DNP samples
- DNP 836A Topic 1: Adult Learner Analysis
- DNP 836A Topic 2: Learning Objectives Set
- DNP 836A Topic 3: Teaching Strategy Comparison
- DNP 836A Topic 4: Clinical Teaching Plan
- DNP 836A Topic 5: Simulation Limits DQ Pair
- DNP 836A Topic 7: Learner Assessment Plan
- DNP 836A Topic 8: Teaching Session Portfolio
- DNP 837A Topic 6: Program Assessment Plan
- DNP 835 Topic 6: Run Chart and Feedback Design
- DNP 838A Topic 6: Program Evaluation Report
- DNP 830 Topic 6: Relationships Between Variables DQ Pair
DNP 836A Topic 6 questions, answered
What makes feedback change anything?
Specificity and a consequence. Telling a nurse she communicated well gives her nothing to act on; telling her that the handover omitted the overnight potassium result, that the day team therefore repeated the test, and that the fix is one line in the report, gives her something she can do at the next shift. The second version is also harder to say.
Is experienced staff really a different conversation?
Yes, in one important way. A practitioner with years behind her has a working explanation for why she did what she did, and unless that explanation is asked for, the correction lands on a decision you have not understood. Start by finding out what she was solving for. Half the time the answer changes what needs to be said.
Do I have to report feedback that failed?
It strengthens the paper. An analysis where all three items produced change reads as a conversation remembered generously. Reporting that two landed nowhere, and reasoning from the transcript about why, shows the writer examining their own practice rather than presenting it. Faculty at doctoral level read an acknowledged failure as evidence of judgment, not as an admission.
Where can I find a free DNP 836A Topic 6 sample paper?
The feedback analysis for DNP 836A Topic 6 covers the conversation and the learner, three places the specific became general, one line as spoken and rewritten, what fourteen years changes and the handover two shifts later. Forward the DNP 836A Topic 6 prompt you received for a free paper.
Is feedback to experienced staff different in DNP 836A Topic 6?
Yes. It can assume the nurse knows why trends matter, so it does not explain them, which would condescend. It must still be specific about what was said and what was missing.