| Course | DNP 837A Curriculum Design and Assessment |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Program assessment plan |
| Length | About 990 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 837A Topic 6
A Sampling Design, Not a List of Measures: The Program Assessment Plan for Six DNP Outcomes, Including One With Too Few Artifacts to Judge
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
DNP-837A: Curriculum Design and Assessment
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
November 13, 2028
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Sampling Design, Not a List of Measures: The Program Assessment Plan for Six DNP Outcomes, Including One With Too Few Artifacts to Judge
What the Plan Has to Establish
The composite post-master's DNP program claims six outcomes for every graduate. The assessment plan exists to test those claims with evidence from learners' work, and it is written as a sampling design: for each outcome, it names the artifact that will be collected, the point in the sequence it comes from, how many will be pulled and how they will be selected. A list of measures says what could be looked at; a sampling design says what will actually be read, by whom, and how much weight the result can bear (Suskie, 2018). The plan covers the most recent graduating cohort, 34 learners, and the cohort before it, 31 learners.
The Sampling Design
Table 1
Artifact Sampling by Program Outcome
| Outcome | Artifact | Point in sequence | Number and selection |
|---|---|---|---|
| O1 Translate evidence and evaluate its effect | Final project evaluation chapter | C11, final course | 30 of 65, stratified random by cohort |
| O2 Lead quality improvement | Implementation log and weekly data report | C10, final year | 30 of 65, stratified random by cohort |
| O3 Manage a population with data | Population analysis with data extract | C7, fourth semester | 30 of 65, stratified random by cohort |
| O4 Collaborate interprofessionally | Stakeholder role log and site mentor's rating form | C10, final year | All 65 forms; 30 logs, random |
| O5 Influence policy affecting access | Policy analysis | C8, elective | All available |
| O6 Project with an underserved community partner | Signed partner agreement and final project report | C9 and C11 | All 65 agreements; 30 reports, random |
Table 1 sets out the design for each outcome.
Why the Artifacts Come From Where They Do
A claim about what a graduate can do needs evidence from the end of the program, so the artifacts for O1 and O2 come from the final-year project courses, C10 and C11, where learners carry out and evaluate a real change. Earlier work, such as the evidence synthesis in C4, would show only what learners could do partway through. O3 draws on C7, a fourth-semester course, because the curriculum map showed that is where the outcome is demonstrated; nothing later asks for it again at the same level, which the plan notes as a weakness. For O4, the plan adds the one artifact not written by the learner: a short rating form completed by each learner's site mentor on how the learner worked with other professions during implementation. It is the only direct evidence the program has for that outcome, and it was introduced this year in response to the problem raised in the previous topic.
Scoring
Each artifact is scored by two faculty members who did not teach the course that produced it, so the scores are not colored by knowing the learner. They use a rubric written for the program outcome, not for the assignment: the O2 rubric asks whether the learner led a change and sustained it, not whether the implementation log was complete and well formatted, which the course rubric already rewarded. Each rubric has four levels, from not evident to exceeds, with the third level defined as meeting the outcome. The two readers score independently. Their agreement is reported for each outcome, as the percentage of artifacts on which they agreed and as a kappa statistic, and disagreements are reported rather than averaged away (McHugh, 2012). An average of a 2 and a 4 produces a 3, which would report an artifact as meeting the outcome when one reader thought it did not. Where the readers differ by more than one level, a third reader scores the artifact, and all three scores are kept.
How the Samples Were Drawn
Samples were drawn by the program's assessment coordinator, not by faculty, from a list of all graduates in the two cohorts sorted by cohort and then by a random number. For the stratified outcomes, 15 artifacts were drawn from each cohort so that neither cohort dominated the results. Artifacts were stripped of names, course section and instructor before readers received them. Where an artifact was missing, because a learner had submitted it in a format that could not be retrieved or had received an extension that was never recorded, the next name on the list was used, and the number of replacements is reported: four across all outcomes.
Thirty artifacts per outcome is a practical choice rather than a statistical one. It is enough to see whether most graduates meet an outcome or most do not, and small enough for two readers to score in a working week. It is not enough to compare subgroups, such as learners whose projects were in underserved counties against those whose were not, and the plan does not attempt that comparison.
Results From the First Cycle
The first cycle has been completed for the two cohorts. For five outcomes, the samples were large enough to report: between 76 and 90 percent of sampled artifacts met the outcome, with reader agreement between 71 and 84 percent. The one clear exception is O5, influencing policy. Because the policy analysis comes from an elective that only about half of each cohort takes, and because several analyses were group work that could not be attributed to an individual, the plan yielded 11 usable artifacts from 65 graduates. Eleven artifacts from a self-selected half of the cohort cannot support any conclusion about what graduates as a whole can do, in either direction. The plan says so plainly and reports no percentage for O5.
Something must change before the next cycle for O5 to be assessable. Either the outcome needs an artifact in a required course, which the revision proposal in the next topic addresses, or the program must narrow the outcome so it does not promise what only half the graduates have been taught. Until then, the program has no evidence for one of its six promises (Allen, 2004).
References
Allen, M. J. (2004). Assessing academic programs in higher education. Anker Publishing.
McHugh, M. L. (2012). Interrater reliability: The kappa statistic. Biochemia Medica, 22(3), 276-282. https://doi.org/10.11613/BM.2012.031
Suskie, L. (2018). Assessing student learning: A common sense guide (3rd ed.). Jossey-Bass.
What the DNP 837A Topic 6 instructions ask for
Topic 6 in DNP-837A asks students to design a program assessment plan. Strong plans state what the plan must establish, then specify for each outcome the artifact, where it comes from, how many are sampled and how they are scored. Students should explain why artifacts come from late in the program, why scorers should not have taught the course and how inter-rater agreement will be checked. The plan should describe how samples are drawn so no one can pick favorable work and, where results exist, report them honestly, including outcomes with too little evidence to judge. Course grades should not stand in for program evidence.
How the DNP-837A Topic 6 example is put together
The finished plan is a sampling design, not a list of measures. For each of six outcomes it names the artifact that will be collected, the point in the sequence it comes from, how many will be pulled and how they will be selected. Two outcomes draw on work produced near the end, because a claim about what a graduate can do needs evidence from the end. Scoring is done by two faculty who did not teach the course, against a rubric written for the outcome rather than for the assignment, and disagreement between the two readers is reported rather than averaged away. One outcome yielded eleven usable artifacts, which the plan states is too few to support any conclusion, and it says what would have to change next cycle.
Reading the DNP 837A Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward a plan written as a sampling design. An Excellent plan tables each outcome's artifact, sample size and scoring, with artifacts from the final project courses. Credit goes to two scorers who did not teach the course, an outcome rubric and agreement checked with McHugh's kappa guidance. The rubric values samples drawn by the assessment coordinator from a randomized list, after Suskie and Allen. Strong plans report first-cycle results of 76 to 90 percent with agreement figures. Top marks go to declaring one outcome unjudgeable with too few artifacts.
Common DNP 837A Topic 6 mistakes, and how to avoid them
The plan that fails at this level reports course grades and calls them program evidence, which is the substitution the whole topic exists to prevent. A second failure is collecting artifacts with no sampling rule, so nobody can say whether the work examined represents the cohort or the eleven files that happened to be accessible. Plans where the instructor scores their own learners against the program outcome have folded two different judgments into one. Marks also go for results with no destination, since evidence that reaches no committee and drives no decision has been gathered for its own sake. Averaging away reader disagreement hides an unclear criterion. Conclusions drawn from a handful of artifacts claim more than the sample can carry.
Get a DNP-837A Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-837A Topic 6 assignment instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the program outcomes and any reporting template your section requires. We write a custom example to those criteria, with an artifact and a sampling rule for every outcome, scoring by readers outside the course, and one thin sample reported honestly, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DNP 837A papers and DNP samples
- DNP 837A Topic 1: Program Outcomes Derivation
- DNP 837A Topic 2: Curriculum Map
- DNP 837A Topic 3: Course Sequence Rationale
- DNP 837A Topic 4: Taught Curriculum Audit
- DNP 837A Topic 5: Assessment Gap DQ Pair
- DNP 837A Topic 7: Curriculum Revision Proposal
- DNP 837A Topic 8: Accreditation Self Study
- DNP 838A Topic 6: Program Evaluation Report
- DNP 836A Topic 6: Feedback Conversation Analysis
- DNP 840 Topic 6: Resource Decision Analysis
- DNP 835 Topic 6: Run Chart and Feedback Design
DNP 837A Topic 6 questions, answered
Why is a course grade not program evidence?
Because it answers a different question. A grade says how well somebody did in a course, blending several criteria and often some judgment about effort. Program evidence has to say whether a graduate can do a specific thing, judged against that thing alone. The two can point in opposite directions, and a program that never separates them cannot report anything defensible.
How much work has to be sampled?
Enough that a reader would accept the conclusion, which is fewer artifacts than people fear and more than most plans collect. What matters more than the number is the rule: random selection from a defined pool beats whatever was convenient to retrieve. Where the pool is small, report the number and limit the claim rather than writing as though it were large.
Who should score the artifacts?
Somebody other than the person who taught the course, and preferably two of them. An instructor scoring their own class against a program outcome is being asked to judge their own teaching, which is a poor design regardless of anybody's integrity. Two outside readers also give you disagreement, and disagreement is diagnostic: it usually means the criterion needs rewriting before the next cycle.
Where can I find a free DNP 837A Topic 6 sample paper?
The assessment plan for DNP 837A Topic 6 covers what the plan has to establish, the sampling design, why artifacts come from where they do, scoring, how samples were drawn and first-cycle results. Forward the DNP 837A Topic 6 prompt you received for a free plan.
Who should score artifacts in DNP 837A Topic 6?
Somebody other than the person who taught the course. Two faculty from outside the course score each artifact so their judgment is not colored by knowing the learner.