| Course | DNP 837A Curriculum Design and Assessment |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Outcome evidence DQ responses |
| Length | About 520 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | DNP |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for DNP 837A Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1 and DQ 2: Initial Posts and a Reply
Papers About Policy and Surveys About Teamwork: Two Program Outcomes Whose Evidence Does Not Show What They Promise
DQ 1: The Policy Outcome Has Evidence of Analysis, Not of Influence
Our composite DNP program promises that every graduate can influence a health or organizational policy affecting access for underserved populations. I pulled every artifact the program's assessment files attach to that outcome for the last three cohorts: 41 in all. Every one is a paper about policy. Thirty-eight are policy analyses written in the health policy elective, and three are reflective sections of capstone papers that mention policy. Not one documents an attempt to change a policy: no testimony, no letter to a legislator with a response, no committee proposal at a workplace, no meeting with a decision maker. The program has good evidence that its graduates can analyze a policy and no evidence that they can influence one, which is what the outcome says. The national standards for advanced nursing education place policy work within the domains of population health and systems-based practice as something graduates do, not only something they study (American Association of Colleges of Nursing, 2021). My remedy is a new terminal measure: a documented policy action in the final project course, with the decision maker named and the result reported, whatever it was.
DQ 2: The Collaboration Outcome Has Evidence, but Only of What Graduates Say
Interprofessional collaboration looks better supported at first, because the program has plenty of evidence for it. But all of it is self-reported. It consists of an end-of-program survey in which graduates rate their confidence working with other professions, reflective paragraphs in capstone papers and a team-member list on the project proposal. The program knows what graduates say about working with other professions and nothing about what they do. That pattern is common: a systematic review of 46 high-quality studies of interprofessional education found that reported outcomes lean heavily toward learners' reactions, attitudes and knowledge, with far fewer showing changes in behavior or benefits to patients (Reeves et al., 2016). Building a direct measure would require observing graduates with other professions at their practice sites, which the program has no faculty time to do. My remedy is the opposite of a new measure: narrow the promise. The outcome should say that graduates can plan a change with representatives of other professions and document their roles, which the proposal and implementation log can actually evidence, until the program can resource observation.
Reply to Classmate
Heather, you argue that your program's quality improvement outcome is well evidenced because every graduate completes a QI project. I agree the project is real evidence, but I wonder whether it evidences what your outcome promises. Your outcome says graduates can lead improvement, and your post says the projects are designed individually and implemented by unit staff while the student collects data. Is collecting data on a change someone else carries out the same as leading it? If your faculty had to choose, would you rather build a measure of leadership during implementation, or change the outcome's verb from lead to design?
References
American Association of Colleges of Nursing. (2021). The essentials: Core competencies for professional nursing education.
Reeves, S., Fletcher, S., Barr, H., Birch, I., Boet, S., Davies, N., McFadyen, A., Rivera, J., & Kitto, S. (2016). A BEME systematic review of the effects of interprofessional education: BEME Guide No. 39. Medical Teacher, 38(7), 656-668. https://doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2016.1173663
The DNP-837A Topic 5 assignment instructions
Topic 5 in DNP-837A asks students to examine whether program outcomes are supported by evidence. Strong responses work backward from an outcome's wording to the artifacts that are supposed to show it and ask whether those artifacts show what the outcome promises, for example analysis rather than influence, or self-report rather than observed behavior. Students should explain why course grades are rarely enough and consider whether narrowing the promise is a legitimate answer. Replies should test a classmate's claim against the exact wording of the outcome, and every post should cite the standards or research it relies on. An echo of the classmate's post earns little; a question about the evidence earns more.
Inside the DNP 837A Topic 5 example
The finished example holds two responses of roughly two hundred words and a reply, and all three name specific outcomes rather than discussing gaps in general. The first post picks the outcome about influencing health policy and shows that every piece of evidence attached to it is a paper about policy, never an attempt to change one. The second picks interprofessional collaboration and argues something harder: the evidence exists, but it is all self reported, so the program knows what graduates say about working with other professions and nothing about what they do. The two posts then diverge on the remedy. One wants a new terminal measure built. The other argues the program should narrow the promise to what it can actually evidence.
Reading the DNP 837A Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward evidence tested against an outcome's wording. An Excellent first response shows that the policy outcome promises influence while every artifact shows analysis. Credit goes to a second response finding collaboration evidence entirely self-reported, citing Reeves and colleagues on interprofessional outcomes and the AACN Essentials. The rubric values proposing either an observed artifact or a narrower promise. Strong posts explain why grades cannot serve as outcome evidence. The highest marks go to a reply that checks whether a completed QI project shows what the classmate's outcome actually says.
DNP 837A Topic 5 help before you submit
Posts observing that assessment gaps are common lose marks because the prompt asked which one, and a response with no outcome named has declined to answer. A second failure is accepting course grades as program level evidence, since a grade aggregates so many things that it establishes almost nothing about a single outcome. Answers that propose a new measure with no cost attached are easy to write and easy to dismiss. Marks also go for treating self reported confidence as demonstrated capability, which is the substitution this prompt most reliably catches. Replies agreeing that the gap is concerning add nothing to the thread. Posts that never say which course was supposed to deliver the outcome leave the gap unlocated.
Get a DNP-837A Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the DNP-837A Topic 5 discussion question prompts and the participation requirements your classroom posts, including length and reply counts. We write custom responses to those criteria, each naming one unassessed outcome, each following the evidence trail to the course meant to deliver it, with a reply that presses on cost, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More DNP 837A papers and DNP samples
- DNP 837A Topic 1: Program Outcomes Derivation
- DNP 837A Topic 2: Curriculum Map
- DNP 837A Topic 3: Course Sequence Rationale
- DNP 837A Topic 4: Taught Curriculum Audit
- DNP 837A Topic 6: Program Assessment Plan
- DNP 837A Topic 7: Curriculum Revision Proposal
- DNP 837A Topic 8: Accreditation Self Study
- DNP 838A Topic 5: Enrollment Decline DQ Pair
- DNP 836A Topic 5: Simulation Limits DQ Pair
- DNP 840 Topic 5: Policy Advocacy DQ Pair
- DNP 835 Topic 5: Cost and Competing Priorities DQ Pair
DNP 837A Topic 5 questions, answered
How do I find an outcome nothing assesses?
Work backwards from the evidence rather than forwards from the promise. Take each outcome, ask what a graduate produces that demonstrates it, and then ask who looks at that product at the program level. Outcomes about leadership, policy and collaboration fail this test most often, because they are easy to teach about and hard to require anybody to do.
Are course grades enough evidence for an outcome?
Almost never. A grade blends participation, writing quality, timeliness and content into one number, so a high mark tells you a learner did well at the course without telling you which outcome they demonstrated. Program level evidence has to be traceable to a specific piece of work judged against the outcome itself, which is a different act from awarding a grade.
Is narrowing the promise a legitimate answer?
It is a defensible one, and posts that take it usually score well because it costs something to argue. A program claiming an outcome it cannot evidence is making a promise to applicants and employers that nothing supports. Either build the measure or amend the claim. What no reader accepts is leaving the outcome in place and hoping the question does not come up.
Where can I find a free DNP 837A Topic 5 sample paper?
Both answers on outcomes without matching evidence appear on this page, followed by the reply to Heather. A post written to your DNP 837A Topic 5 prompt costs nothing.
Are course grades enough evidence for an outcome in DNP 837A Topic 5?
Almost never. A grade combines many things and answers whether a learner passed a course, not whether the specific outcome was shown in the learner's work.