| Course | FIN 650 Managerial Finance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Beta and required return |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 650 Topic 3
A Beta of 0.85 for the Company and 1.75 for Its Plant-Based Project: Estimating, Qualifying and Adjusting Beta Before Setting a Hurdle
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-650: Managerial Finance
Topic 3 Beta and Required Return
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
A Beta of 0.85 for the Company and 1.75 for Its Plant-Based Project: Estimating, Qualifying and Adjusting Beta Before Setting a Hurdle
What Beta Measures and How It Is Estimated
Beta measures how much a company's share return tends to move with the return on the market as a whole. It is estimated by regressing the share's past returns on the market's returns; the slope of that line is the beta. A composite specialty food company's treasurer wants to use beta to set the required return for a new plant-based protein plant. Before using the number, the treasurer has to understand the choices inside it. The estimate depends on the period used, commonly two to five years; the interval, daily, weekly or monthly returns; and the index chosen to represent the market. Each choice is reasonable, and each gives a somewhat different answer.
How Much Estimates Vary
For the company, published betas from three data providers range from about 0.72 to 0.95, and the treasurer's own estimate from five years of monthly returns against a broad US index is 0.85. The spread is typical. Betas also drift over time: estimates for extreme values tend to move toward 1.0 in later periods, which is why some providers report an adjusted beta that pulls the raw estimate partway toward one (Blume, 1975). A common adjustment weights the raw estimate by two-thirds and 1.0 by one-third, which would turn 0.85 into about 0.90. The range bounds the confidence any single figure deserves: the analysis uses 0.85, but treats the company's beta as somewhere between about 0.75 and 0.95.
Table 1
Estimates of the Company's Beta, Illustrative
| Source | Beta |
|---|---|
| Provider A, two years weekly | 0.72 |
| Provider B, five years monthly | 0.88 |
| Provider C, adjusted toward 1.0 | 0.95 |
| Treasurer's estimate, five years monthly | 0.85 |
Business Risk and Financial Risk
A share's observed beta reflects two sources of risk at once. Business risk comes from the company's operations: how much demand for snacks and protein products moves with the economy, and how much of its costs are fixed. Financial risk comes from how the company is financed: debt places a fixed claim ahead of shareholders, so the more debt, the more the shareholders' returns swing for the same swings in operations. A beta measured from share returns, called a levered or equity beta, therefore includes the effect of the company's debt. Two companies with identical operations will show different betas if one borrows more.
Adjusting a Comparable's Beta
This matters because the plant-based plant is riskier than the company's snack business, so the company's own beta of 0.85 does not describe it. The treasurer instead borrows the beta of a publicly traded company that makes only plant-based protein products. That company's equity beta is 1.45, but it has little debt, a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.10, while the specialty food company finances itself at a debt-to-equity ratio of about 0.40. Using 1.45 directly would import the comparable's capital structure. The adjustment first removes the effect of the comparable's debt, using βu = βL / [1 + (1 minus t) D/E] at a 25 percent tax rate (Hamada, 1972): 1.45 / 1.075 = about 1.35. This unlevered beta measures the business risk of plant-based protein alone. It then adds back the effect of the company's own debt: 1.35 x [1 + 0.75 x 0.40] = about 1.75.
Why the Company's Own Beta Would Mislead
Using the company-wide figure would be easy, and it would be wrong in a predictable direction. The company's beta of 0.85 is an average of a large, stable snack business and a small, volatile plant-based business, weighted toward the snacks. Applying that average to a project made entirely of the riskier business understates the return investors would require if they could invest in the plant on its own. Repeated across many decisions, the practice approves too many high-risk projects and too few low-risk ones, so the company's overall risk rises without anyone deciding that it should. The comparable's beta is used precisely because it isolates the business the plant is in.
The Hurdle for the Plant
With a risk-free rate of 4.0 percent, the yield on ten-year US Treasury bonds as of the analysis date, and a premium of 5.5 percent for bearing market risk, the company's own cost of equity is 4.0 + 0.85 x 5.5, about 8.7 percent. The plant's cost of equity is 4.0 + 1.75 x 5.5, about 13.6 percent. The figures are reported to one decimal place because the beta range alone moves them by about a percentage point; quoting them to two decimals would claim a precision the estimates do not have.
Applying the Result
The plant's business case projects a return to equity of about 12 percent. Measured against the company's 8.7 percent, it looks comfortably acceptable. Measured against the 13.6 percent its own business risk requires, it falls short by about one and a half points. The treasurer should not approve the plant on the current projections. The gap is small enough that a lower construction cost or a long-term supply contract with a grocery chain, which would reduce the project's risk, could close it, and the business case should be revised to show whether either is achievable.
Limits
Beta captures only market risk, and its record as a predictor of returns is mixed: Fama and French (2004) report that beta explains average returns less well than the pricing model implies. A single comparable is also a thin basis. The treasurer should repeat the unlevering with two or three other plant-based companies and use the median, and should present the hurdle as a range, not a point.
Conclusion
Beta measures exposure to market risk, but every estimate depends on choices of period, interval and index, and the company's estimates range from about 0.72 to 0.95. Because an observed beta includes financial risk, a comparable's beta must be unlevered and relevered before it can be used. Done properly, the plant's hurdle is about 13.6 percent, not the company's 8.7, and the project as proposed does not clear it.
References
Blume, M. E. (1975). Betas and their regression tendencies. Journal of Finance, 30(3), 785-795. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1975.tb01850.x
Fama, E. F., & French, K. R. (2004). The capital asset pricing model: Theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 18(3), 25-46. https://doi.org/10.1257/0895330042162430
Hamada, R. S. (1972). The effect of the firm's capital structure on the systematic risk of common stocks. Journal of Finance, 27(2), 435-452. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1972.tb00971.x
Reading the GCU FIN 650 Topic 3 instructions
In Topic 3, FIN-650 asks MBA students to explain beta and use it to set a required return. Strong analyses describe how beta is estimated and the choices inside it, report how estimates vary, and separate business risk from financial risk. Students should unlever a comparable's beta and relever it at their own capital structure, source and date every input, avoid false precision and judge a project against the result. Students should also explain why the company's own beta would mislead for a project in a riskier business. Repeating the adjustment with several comparable firms and reporting the hurdle as a range strengthens the result. Every input, including the risk-free rate and its date, should be sourced so a reader can update the hurdle later.
How the FIN-650 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished example explains the measure before trusting it. Beta is presented as a regression estimate, which raises the questions that matter: over what period, against which index, and how stable the figure is. The example reports that betas move over time and differ between providers, so a figure quoted to two decimals overstates what is known. Financial risk from debt is then separated from business risk, since an observed beta reflects both. The estimate is treated as a measurement with error. The hurdle is then computed from the adjusted beta, reported to one decimal and applied to the project's projected return.
Reading the FIN 650 Topic 3 rubric
Faculty reward beta explained before it is used. An Excellent paper tables four estimates of the company's beta and cites Blume on regression toward one. Credit goes to separating business from financial risk and adjusting a comparable's beta with Hamada's formula. The rubric values a hurdle reported to one decimal because the beta range moves it a point. Strong papers note the mixed evidence from Fama and French. Top marks go to rejecting a 12 percent project against a 13.6 percent hurdle. Credit also goes to explaining that the company's beta averages a stable business with a riskier one. Faculty value repeating the comparable analysis with two or three firms and reporting the median.
FIN 650 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Using beta before explaining it is the sequencing error this topic names, since the explanation comes first. Treating a quoted beta as a fixed property ignores that it varies with the window, index and provider. Papers lose marks for borrowing a comparable's beta without adjusting for its different debt, which imports that firm's financing into your project. Carrying a required return to two decimals claims confidence nobody holds, and a return never used to judge anything wastes the calculation. Papers that apply the company-wide beta to a project in a different business, without saying why, answer the wrong question.
Get a FIN-650 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-650 Topic 3 problems and the rubric your classroom posts, with the firm and market data your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with beta explained and qualified before use, business risk separated from financial and the hurdle applied to a real project, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More FIN 650 papers and MBA samples
- FIN 650 Topic 1: Firm Objective and Agency Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 2: Issuer Side Valuation
- FIN 650 Topic 4: Divisional Hurdle Rate Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 5: Investment Criteria Conflict
- FIN 650 Topic 6: Relevant Cash Flow Estimation
- FIN 650 Topic 7: Debt Obligation Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 8: Payout and Working Capital Recommendation
- HRM 635 Topic 3: Build Versus Buy Cost Case
- FIN 504 Topic 3: Risk and Required Return Analysis
- HRM 640 Topic 3: Practice Bundle Fit Analysis
- ECN 601 Topic 3: Cost and Output Analysis
FIN 650 Topic 3 questions, answered
Where does a published beta come from?
From a regression of the security's returns against a market index, which means somebody chose the period, the index and the return frequency. Different providers make different choices and publish different figures for the same company. Knowing that stops you treating the number as a fact about the firm and starts you asking whether the estimate suits your purpose.
How much precision does a required return deserve?
Less than students report. The beta is an estimate, the market premium is disputed and the risk free rate depends on which maturity you pick, so quoting the answer to two decimals asserts a confidence none of those inputs can bear. Reporting a range, or rounding sensibly and naming the sensitivity, is more honest and usually earns more credit.
Where can I find a free FIN 650 Topic 3 sample paper?
The beta analysis is shown here complete: how beta is estimated, how much estimates vary, business and financial risk, adjusting a comparable, why the company's beta would mislead, the plant's hurdle, applying the result, limits and the conclusion. Share your company and comparable and the hurdle follows free.
Why unlever a comparable's beta in FIN 650 Topic 3?
Its observed beta of 1.45 reflects its own low debt. Removing that effect gives the business risk alone, about 1.35, which is then adjusted to the company's debt, about 1.75.
Why not use the company's own beta for the plant in FIN 650 Topic 3?
The company's 0.85 averages a stable snack business with a riskier plant-based one. A project made entirely of the riskier business needs the higher figure.