| Course | FIN 650 Managerial Finance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Investment criteria conflict |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 2 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MBA |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for FIN 650 Topic 5
Three Proposals for One Production Slot: Why the Highest IRR Ranks Last on Value, and How to Tell a Board That Thinks in Percentages
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
FIN-650: Managerial Finance
Topic 5 Investment Criteria Conflict
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Three Proposals for One Production Slot: Why the Highest IRR Ranks Last on Value, and How to Tell a Board That Thinks in Percentages
One Slot, Three Proposals
A composite specialty food company's snack division has floor space and utilities for one new production line, so the three proposals competing for it are mutually exclusive. A co-packing contract would make another brand's products for four years, with most of the cash arriving early. A kettle-chip line for the company's own brand would start slowly and grow as distribution expands. A small seasonal line would cost far less than either. The division's hurdle rate, built from comparable snack companies, is 6.9 percent. The proposals were chosen for review because they rank differently under the two common criteria, and this analysis works through that disagreement rather than around it.
Both Criteria, Tabulated
The co-packing contract costs 20 million dollars and returns 12, 8, 4 and 2 million over four years. The kettle-chip line costs 20 million and returns 2, 5, 10 and 14 million. The seasonal line costs 5 million and returns 3, 2.5, 1 and 0.5 million. Discounted at 6.9 percent, their net present values are about 3.03, 5.15 and 1.20 million dollars. Their internal rates of return are about 15.9, 15.2 and 20.8 percent. By internal rate of return the seasonal line ranks first and the kettle-chip line last; by net present value the order is exactly reversed.
Table 1
Three Mutually Exclusive Proposals, Millions of Dollars
| Proposal | Outlay | Years 1-4 | NPV at 6.9% | IRR | MIRR at 6.9% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Co-packing contract | 20.0 | 12, 8, 4, 2 | 3.03 | 15.9% | 10.7% |
| Kettle-chip line | 20.0 | 2, 5, 10, 14 | 5.15 | 15.2% | 13.2% |
| Seasonal line | 5.0 | 3, 2.5, 1, 0.5 | 1.20 | 20.8% | 12.8% |
Diagnosing the Disagreement
Two different mechanisms produce the conflict, and they should be kept apart. Between the co-packing contract and the kettle-chip line the cause is timing. Both cost 20 million, but the contract's cash arrives early and the line's late. Discounting penalizes late cash more heavily as the rate rises, so the contract looks better at high rates and worse at low ones; the two projects' values cross at about 14.3 percent. At the division's actual hurdle of 6.9 percent, well below that crossover, the kettle-chip line is worth about 2.1 million dollars more. Between the seasonal line and the others the cause is scale. Its 20.8 percent return is earned on only 5 million dollars, so it creates far fewer dollars of value than a lower percentage earned on 20 million.
Resolving in Favor of Value
The resolution follows from the objective established earlier for the firm: making its shareholders as wealthy as possible today. Net present value measures directly how much each proposal adds to that value, in dollars, after paying for capital at the rate its risk requires (Brealey et al., 2020). The internal rate of return measures a percentage yield on the money invested, which is a property of the project, not a measure of what it adds to the company. When only one project can go ahead, the owners are better off with the one that adds the most value, the kettle-chip line, even though two alternatives show higher percentages.
The Reinvestment Assumption
The internal rate of return carries an embedded assumption that becomes visible when cash arrives early. Treating a project's IRR as its return implicitly assumes that interim cash can be reinvested at that same rate. For the seasonal line, that means reinvesting its early cash at 20.8 percent, which the division cannot do; its other opportunities earn about its hurdle rate. The modified internal rate of return corrects this by compounding interim cash flows forward at the hurdle rate and then computing the single rate that links the outlay to that compounded total. On that basis the returns become 10.7 percent for the contract, 13.2 percent for the kettle-chip line and 12.8 percent for the seasonal line, and the kettle-chip line ranks first, as it does on value. Kelleher and MacCormack (2004) argue that unadjusted IRRs routinely overstate returns on projects with large early cash flows for this reason.
Why Managers Still Prefer Rates
The preference for percentages is understandable, not a sign of ignorance. Surveyed financial officers report using the internal rate of return about as often as net present value (Graham & Harvey, 2001). A percentage can be compared at a glance with a borrowing rate or a hurdle without knowing the project's size, it does not require the analyst to commit to a single discount rate before presenting, and it is easy to communicate to people outside finance. Those are real advantages for screening individual projects. They become a liability only when projects compete for the same resource, which is exactly the situation here.
Presenting to a Board That Thinks in Percentages
The recommendation to the board should lead with the decision and the dollars: the kettle-chip line is worth about 5.15 million dollars net of its cost, about 2.1 million more than the next alternative. It should then show the percentages the board expects, but in their modified form, which agrees with the value ranking. And it should explain the seasonal line's 20.8 percent in one sentence: a high return on a small investment, with nowhere to put the early cash at that rate. A table with all three measures side by side, like the one above, lets directors see why the highest headline rate ranks last.
Conclusion
Timing separates the co-packing contract from the kettle-chip line, and scale separates the seasonal line from both. Net present value resolves the conflict in favor of the kettle-chip line because it measures what each proposal adds to the owners' wealth, and the modified rate of return, by replacing an unrealistic reinvestment assumption, reaches the same answer in the form the board prefers. The division should build the kettle-chip line and revisit the seasonal line next year, when it could be fitted into spare capacity on an existing line rather than competing for the new slot.
References
Brealey, R. A., Myers, S. C., & Allen, F. (2020). Principles of corporate finance (13th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
Graham, J. R., & Harvey, C. R. (2001). The theory and practice of corporate finance: Evidence from the field. Journal of Financial Economics, 60(2-3), 187-243. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(01)00044-7
Kelleher, J. C., & MacCormack, J. J. (2004). Internal rate of return: A cautionary tale. McKinsey Quarterly. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/strategy-and-corporate-finance/our-insights/internal-rate-of-return-a-cautionary-tale
The FIN-650 Topic 5 assignment instructions
In Topic 5, FIN-650 asks MBA students to resolve a conflict between investment criteria. Strong analyses choose projects that actually conflict, tabulate both criteria and diagnose scale and timing separately. Students should resolve in favor of value from the firm's objective, state the reinvestment assumption inside the rate measure, introduce the modified rate and explain why managers still prefer percentages. Students should also show how the internal rate of return's reinvestment assumption favors projects with early cash flows. The recommendation should explain how to present the choice to directors who think in percentages.
Inside the FIN 650 Topic 5 example
The finished example goes past the technical resolution. Both criteria are computed on projects constructed to disagree, and the disagreement is explained by scale and timing rather than noted. Net present value is followed and the reasoning is given in terms of what a firm is trying to maximize. The example then does what a purely technical treatment does not: it asks why the rate based measure remains popular with managers despite its known problems, and answers honestly, because a percentage is intuitive, communicates easily to non financial audiences and is comparable across projects of any size. The reinvestment assumption is named and the modified variant addressed. The arithmetic is shown for both criteria on every project.
Where the marks sit in the FIN 650 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward a conflict diagnosed rather than avoided. An Excellent paper tables three proposals with value, rate and modified rate. Credit goes to separating a timing conflict crossing at 14.3 percent from a scale conflict, as Brealey and colleagues frame it. The rubric values the reinvestment assumption and modified rates that agree with value, citing Kelleher and MacCormack. Strong papers cite Graham and Harvey on why rates persist. Top marks go to a board presentation led by dollars. Papers that explain the seasonal line's high percentage in one sentence for a board, a high return on a small outlay with nowhere to reinvest early cash, show the communication skill the topic asks for.
Common FIN 650 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Computing both criteria on projects that happen to agree wastes the topic, since the conflict is the material. A second failure is preferring the higher percentage with no argument, which feels natural and misleads whenever the projects are of different sizes. Marks also go for spotting a disagreement and never diagnosing it, since scale and timing generate it by separate routes and the diagnosis is the actual work. Dismissing the rate measure entirely misses why it persists in practice and reads as academic. Ignoring the reinvestment assumption leaves the technical objection unstated, and omitting the modified variant leaves out the standard response to it. Projects constructed so the criteria agree let the writer avoid the only question the topic asks, and faculty notice which projects were chosen.
Get a FIN-650 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the FIN-650 Topic 5 problems and the rubric posted in your classroom, with the competing projects your section supplied. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a genuine conflict produced, its cause diagnosed, the resolution argued from the firm's objective and the managerial preference explained, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More FIN 650 papers and MBA samples
- FIN 650 Topic 1: Firm Objective and Agency Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 2: Issuer Side Valuation
- FIN 650 Topic 3: Beta and Required Return
- FIN 650 Topic 4: Divisional Hurdle Rate Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 6: Relevant Cash Flow Estimation
- FIN 650 Topic 7: Debt Obligation Analysis
- FIN 650 Topic 8: Payout and Working Capital Recommendation
- HRM 635 Topic 5: Selection Utility Dq Post
- FIN 504 Topic 5: Capital Budgeting Analysis
- HRM 640 Topic 5: Site Consistency Dq Post
- ECN 601 Topic 5: Macroeconomic Indicator Analysis
FIN 650 Topic 5 questions, answered
Why do managers prefer internal rate of return?
Because a percentage travels better than a currency amount. It can be compared against a borrowing rate or a target without any further context, it is intuitive to people without financial training, and it does not require the audience to know the size of the investment. Those are real communication advantages, which is why the measure persists despite its technical problems.
What is the reinvestment assumption?
The internal rate calculation implicitly assumes intermediate cash flows are reinvested at that same rate, which is unrealistic when the rate is high. Net present value assumes reinvestment at the cost of capital, which is more defensible. The modified version of the rate measure lets you state the reinvestment rate explicitly, which removes the objection at the cost of an extra assumption.
How do I recommend on value to a board that wants a percentage?
Give them both and lead with the one that decides. Report the value created as the recommendation and the rate as supporting information, and where the two conflict, explain the conflict in one sentence about scale rather than asserting technical superiority. Refusing to supply the percentage tends to lose the argument rather than win it.
Where can I find a free FIN 650 Topic 5 sample paper?
The criteria conflict analysis is shown here complete: one slot and three proposals, both criteria, diagnosing the disagreement, resolving for value, the reinvestment assumption, why managers prefer rates, presenting to a board and the conclusion. List the projects your case compares and we will resolve them free.
Why does the seasonal line rank last despite 20.8 percent in FIN 650 Topic 5?
Its high return is earned on only 5 million dollars and assumes early cash is reinvested at 20.8 percent. It adds about 1.2 million, far less than the kettle-chip line.