| Course | HCA 360 Health Information Technology and Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Governance gap memo |
| Length | About 860 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 360 Topic 8
Memorandum
To: Chief Operating Officer, Mesquite Regional Medical Center
From: [Author Name], Health Information Management
Date: [Date]
Re: A gap in data governance: who may release patient-level data sets outside the organization, and a proposed rule
The Question Nobody Has Answered
Mesquite Regional has policies for releasing an individual patient's record to that patient, to another provider and to an attorney with a valid authorization. It has no policy answering a different question: who may send a data set containing many patients' information, at the level of individual patients, to anyone outside the hospital? Analysts, managers and physicians produce such data sets every week for quality work, and some of those files are shared with university partners, consultants and vendors. Today the decision is made by whoever happens to be asked, and nothing records that it was made.
What the Silence Permits Today
A recent example shows the gap. In August, a quality analyst was asked by the emergency department director to help a university partner study patients who visit the emergency department frequently. The analyst joined two files that had been collected for separate purposes, the emergency visit log and the patient portal message log, and produced a spreadsheet of 3,412 patients with visit dates, five-digit ZIP codes, age in years, sex and the number of portal messages each had sent. Names and record numbers were removed, so the analyst and the director believed the file was de-identified. The director approved the release by email, and the file was placed on the university's shared drive.
The file was not de-identified under the HIPAA Privacy Rule. The rule offers two methods: expert determination, or removal of 18 specified identifiers, which include all elements of dates except the year and ZIP codes beyond the first three digits in most cases (Office for Civil Rights, 2012). Full visit dates and five-digit ZIP codes are both on that list. Even data that pass the rule can be vulnerable: a modeling study estimated that 99.98 percent of Americans could be correctly re-identified in a data set containing 15 demographic attributes (Rocher et al., 2019). No one in the chain was careless; each acted reasonably with the information and authority they had. The problem is that no rule told them who should decide.
The Proposed Rule
Any release of patient-level data outside Mesquite Regional, whether identified, a limited data set or described as de-identified, requires written approval from the data release officer, a role to be assigned to the director of health information management. Requests are submitted on a one-page form stating the purpose, the recipient, the fields and the retention period. The officer confirms that de-identification meets one of the two HIPAA methods, requires a data use agreement for any limited data set, as the Privacy Rule itself does (Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information, 2024), and routes research requests to the institutional review board. Decisions are made within ten business days and logged. The same approval is required before any analyst joins two files collected for different purposes if the result will leave the organization.
Exceptions are limited to disclosures required by law, such as public health reporting and mandated quality submissions, which continue under existing procedures. Any other exception requires the chief operating officer's written approval.
How the Rule Would Work in Practice
Had the rule been in place in August, the analyst would have sent the request form to the data release officer before building the file. The officer would have asked whether the university needed exact visit dates or whether visit month would serve, whether five-digit ZIP codes were needed or whether the first three digits would do, and whether the study was research requiring review board approval. The likely outcome would have been a smaller, safer file released under a data use agreement within two weeks, with the decision recorded. The analyst would also have learned, before rather than after, that joining the portal log to the visit log created a new data set with its own risks, since message counts can point to individuals as surely as names.
What the Rule Costs
The rule has real costs, and they fall on the people it constrains. Analysts and department directors will lose the ability to send a file the same day, and a university partner may wait up to two weeks for data. Some requests will be refused or narrowed, for example by replacing visit dates with months and ZIP codes with three-digit areas, which will make some analyses less precise. The health information management director will need about four hours a week to review requests, which should be recognized in that role's workload. Against these costs, the rule prevents disclosures that could require breach notification to patients and regulators, and it creates a record of every release that the hospital could produce if asked. The August file should be retrieved from the university's drive and a breach risk assessment completed now, whatever is decided about the rule.
Decision Requested
I ask you to approve the rule above, assign the data release officer role, and announce the change to department directors at the October leadership meeting. I can have the request form and a one-page guide for analysts ready within two weeks of approval.
References
Office for Civil Rights. (2012). Guidance regarding methods for de-identification of protected health information in accordance with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) Privacy Rule. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Rocher, L., Hendrickx, J. M., & de Montjoye, Y.-A. (2019). Estimating the success of re-identifications in incomplete datasets using generative models. Nature Communications, 10, Article 3069. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-019-10933-3
Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information, 45 C.F.R. ยง 164.514 (2024).
Reading the GCU HCA 360 Topic 8 instructions
The final topic of HCA-360 asks students to assess information governance in a health care organization and recommend improvements. Students typically identify a weakness in policies, roles or controls for managing health information, explain its risks and propose a solution, often in memo or report form for a decision maker. The assignment rewards focus on one clear gap rather than a survey of the whole program. Students should show the gap with evidence or a realistic example, connect it to legal and regulatory requirements such as HIPAA, propose a rule someone could actually follow, and explain who will own it and how exceptions will be handled.
Inside the HCA 360 Topic 8 example
The finished memo is short, addressed to somebody who can act, and built around one gap rather than a survey of the whole program. The gap is written as a question nobody has answered: who may release this data set, how long a copy on a laptop may live, whether an analyst may join two files that were collected separately. The memo then shows what that silence permits today, ideally with a concrete instance of the decision being made by whoever happened to be asked. The proposed rule is one paragraph a person could follow, with a named owner and a route for exceptions. What the rule costs the people it constrains is stated rather than assumed away.
HCA 360 Topic 8 rubric: what Excellent looks like
GCU faculty grading the governance memo look for a focused, actionable document. Excellent memos are addressed to someone with authority to act and built around one gap stated as an unanswered question. The rubric rewards showing what the gap permits today with a concrete instance, and it gives credit for accurate use of regulations, such as the two HIPAA de-identification methods. The proposed rule should be short enough to follow, with a named owner and an exception route. The highest level states what the rule costs the people it constrains and ends with a clear decision request.
HCA 360 Topic 8 help before you submit
A memo that recommends establishing a governance committee has proposed a meeting and left the question unanswered. Gaps described as a lack of oversight, or as insufficient policy maturity, name a condition rather than a decision, and nothing in the organization changes on Monday. Versions that never say what the gap currently permits have not shown any harm, so the reader has no reason to act. Rules written at the length of a manual are not read at the moment they are needed, which is the moment they exist for. Proposals with no exception route get ignored the first time they meet a real situation. Memos ending without a named owner leave the new rule in the same condition as the gap.
Get an HCA-360 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the HCA-360 Topic 8 instructions, your classroom rubric and the organization, data set or scenario you were assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the gap stated as a question, the decision it permits named, a rule short enough to follow and an owner attached, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 360 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 360 Topic 1: Health Record Purpose Analysis
- HCA 360 Topic 2: Data Standards Comparison
- HCA 360 Topic 3: Interoperability Report
- HCA 360 Topic 4: Data Stewardship Plan
- HCA 360 Topic 5: Access and Audit Discussion
- HCA 360 Topic 6: Systems Evaluation
- HCA 360 Topic 7: Workflow Impact Review
- HCA 450 Topic 8: Quality Improvement Plan
- HCA 240 Topic 8: Revenue Leakage Audit
- HCA 460 Topic 8: Process Improvement Proposal
- HCA 470 Topic 8: Strategy Measurement Plan
HCA 360 Topic 8 questions, answered
How do I find a governance gap to write about?
Look for a question people answer by asking a colleague. Requests to release a data set, decisions about how long an extract may be kept, judgments about whether two files may be combined, and permissions granted verbally are all places where practice exists and policy does not. The gap is wherever the answer depends on who was available.
Why is proposing a committee a weak answer?
Because it moves the question rather than settling it, and the gap stays open for however long the committee takes to meet. Governance does need a body somewhere, and this topic is asking for a decision instead. Write the rule, name the owner, and say which body should ratify it if your instructions call for one.
Does a memo need citations?
Follow your rubric, which in most classrooms asks for support even in a memo format. Cite the regulation or standard the rule rests on where one exists, and be clear about the line between what an outside requirement obliges and what your organization would be choosing. Those two carry very different weight with a reader who has to approve it.
Where can I find a free HCA 360 Topic 8 sample paper?
This page contains the full governance gap memo, with the unanswered question, the file sent to a university partner, the proposed rule, how it would work and what it costs. A free model memo for your own section's scenario is available.
Why was the file not de-identified in HCA 360 Topic 8?
It kept full visit dates and five-digit ZIP codes, which the HIPAA Safe Harbor method requires removing or generalizing. Removing names and record numbers alone does not meet either of the rule's two de-identification methods.