| Course | HCA 460 Operations and Risk Management in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Process improvement proposal |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 460 Topic 8
Take Out What Nobody Uses: A Process Improvement Proposal to Shorten Assembly of Two Large Instrument Trays, Starting From a Measured Baseline
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-460: Operations and Risk Management in Health Care
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Take Out What Nobody Uses: A Process Improvement Proposal to Shorten Assembly of Two Large Instrument Trays, Starting From a Measured Baseline
The Baseline
A proposal with no starting measurement can never show that it worked, so this one begins with the baseline. Over four weeks, Saguaro Valley Hospital's instrument reprocessing team timed the assembly of its two largest general surgery and orthopedic trays: the major laparotomy tray, with 112 instruments, and the total knee basic tray, with 98. The times came from the tracking system's scans at the start and end of assembly, confirmed by a supervisor's stopwatch study of 20 assemblies of each tray. The laparotomy tray averaged 27 minutes to inspect and assemble, and the knee tray 24 minutes. Together, the two trays are processed about 95 times a month and account for about 40 hours of assembly time, almost all of it on the evening shift, when assembly is the department's constraint. The evening backlog at shift change averaged 14 trays over the same four weeks.
Why These Trays
Assembly time is driven by the number of instruments a technician must inspect, test and place, and many of those instruments are never used. An observational study of surgical trays found average instrument use rates of only 13 to 22 percent across four specialties, and found that larger trays had lower use rates and more errors (Stockert & Langerman, 2014). Saguaro Valley's own observation agreed: in 20 laparotomies, 41 of the 112 instruments were never used, and in 20 knee replacements, 33 of the 98 were never used. Removing instruments that are rarely used shortens assembly without buying equipment or hiring staff, and it acts directly on the constraint.
The Change, Described Operationally
The change happens at one step, tray assembly, and it is made in advance by a review team. For each of the two trays, a team of one surgeon from the specialty, the operating room's surgical technologist lead and the sterile processing assembly lead will review the observed use data. Any instrument used in fewer than 2 of the 20 observed cases will be removed from the tray. Instruments used occasionally will be packaged individually in peel pouches and stocked in the operating room core, so a surgeon who needs one can have it opened within a minute. Instruments never used will be returned to inventory. The sterile processing educator will rewrite the count sheets and photographs for each tray, and the assembly lead will train the evening technicians on the revised trays in a 15-minute huddle. The change will be piloted on these two trays for eight weeks before any other tray is reviewed.
Predicted Effect
The predicted effect is stated in figures that can be checked. If about 35 instruments are removed from the laparotomy tray and about 28 from the knee tray, and assembly time falls roughly in proportion to instrument count, the laparotomy tray would take about 19 minutes and the knee tray about 17. Across 95 trays a month, that saves about 12 hours of evening assembly time a month, or about three hours a week on the constraint. A published tray optimization project reported assembly time reductions of 58 to 66 percent and operating room setup time reductions of 26 to 37 percent (Crosby et al., 2020), so the proportional estimate here is deliberately conservative. The proposal also predicts that the evening backlog will fall from 14 trays to 12 or fewer, and that operating room setup for these two cases will be shorter.
How Success Will Be Measured
Three measures will be tracked weekly for eight weeks and compared with the four-week baseline: average assembly time for each of the two trays, from the same tracking scans; the evening backlog at shift change; and the number of peel-pouched instruments opened during these cases, which shows whether too much was removed. A balancing measure will capture any case in which a surgeon requested an instrument that was no longer available and had to wait more than two minutes. If that happens more than twice in the pilot, the team will return the instrument to the tray. Lean approaches in instrument processing have improved instrument availability when paired with this kind of measurement (Farrokhi et al., 2015).
Implementation Timeline
The pilot runs on a short, fixed timeline so that results arrive before the next budget discussion about evening staffing. In weeks one and two, the review team meets twice for an hour each to agree on the instruments to remove, using the observation data. In week three, the educator rewrites the count sheets and photographs, and sterile processing pouches and sterilizes the loose instruments that will be stocked in the operating room core. In week four, the evening technicians receive their huddle training and the revised trays go into use on a Monday, the lightest surgical day, so that early questions can be answered before the orthopedic block on Tuesday. Weeks five through twelve are the measurement period. The team meets briefly every second week to review the three measures and the balancing measure, and it may return an instrument to a tray at any of those meetings if the data show it is needed more often than the observation suggested. At week twelve, the manager reports results to the operating room committee with a recommendation to extend, adjust or stop.
Cost, Risks and Who Decides
The cost is small: about 20 hours of team time for review and observation, peel pouches and sterilization for loose instruments, and the time to rewrite two count sheets. The main risk is surgeon resistance, which is why a surgeon from each specialty sits on the review team and why removed instruments remain available in peel pouches. The proposal needs approval from the operating room committee, which the sterile processing manager and the director of surgical services will present jointly next month. If the pilot meets its targets, the same method will be applied to the next eight largest trays.
References
Crosby, L., Lortie, E., Rotenberg, B., & Sowerby, L. (2020). Surgical instrument optimization to reduce instrument processing and operating room setup time. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, 162(2), 215-219. https://doi.org/10.1177/0194599819885635
Farrokhi, F. R., Gunther, M., Williams, B., & Blackmore, C. C. (2015). Application of lean methodology for improved quality and efficiency in operating room instrument availability. Journal for Healthcare Quality, 37(5), 277-286. https://doi.org/10.1111/jhq.12053
Stockert, E. W., & Langerman, A. (2014). Assessing the magnitude and costs of intraoperative inefficiencies attributable to surgical instrument trays. Journal of the American College of Surgeons, 219(4), 646-655. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2014.06.019
What the HCA 460 Topic 8 instructions ask for
The final topic of HCA-460 asks students to propose an improvement to a health care process based on the analysis done earlier in the course. Students typically define the problem with baseline data, describe the proposed change in operational terms, predict its effect, explain how results will be measured and address costs, risks and implementation. The assignment rewards proposals that are small enough to be believable and specific enough to start, with a clear pilot and measures. Students should connect the proposal to evidence that similar changes have worked, and should identify who must approve it and who will carry it out.
How this HCA 460 Topic 8 example is built
The finished proposal is small enough to be believed and specific enough to be started. It records the baseline before the change, with the metric, the period and how the figure was obtained, since a proposal with no starting measurement can never demonstrate anything afterward. The change is described operationally, as what happens differently at which step and who does it. The predicted effect is stated in flow terms, meaning what it does to waiting, throughput or the constraint identified earlier in the course. Staff time is counted on both sides, including the time the change itself consumes. A trial runs on one shift or one clinic before anything spreads, and the obstacle to spreading is named.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 460 Topic 8 rubric
GCU faculty grading the improvement proposal look for a measured starting point. Excellent proposals record the baseline metric, the period and how it was obtained, then describe the change as what happens differently at which step and who does it. Credit goes to predicting the effect in figures that can be checked and to defining success measures and a balancing measure. The rubric values realistic cost and risk assessment, a pilot with a timeline, and evidence from the literature. The highest level names who must approve the proposal and explains how the organization will decide whether to extend, adjust or stop.
HCA 460 Topic 8 help before you submit
The most common loss on this topic is a proposal with no baseline, which leaves a department unable to show that anything changed. Improvements described as streamlining a process or improving communication cannot be implemented by anybody, because no step and no person appear in them. Predicted effects stated as increased efficiency avoid the flow language this course has spent its topics building. Counting only the time a change saves, and not the time it costs, produces proposals that look free and get abandoned by the people carrying them. Rolling a change across a department with no trial removes the chance to learn cheaply. Proposals ending at approval, with no rule for continuing or stopping, leave a practice nobody can retire.
Get an HCA-460 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the HCA-460 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the department or process you were given, with any figures available. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the baseline measured first, the change written so a supervisor could follow it, the flow effect predicted and a limited trial designed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 460 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 460 Topic 1: Capacity Analysis
- HCA 460 Topic 2: Process Map
- HCA 460 Topic 3: Staffing Model Comparison
- HCA 460 Topic 4: Supply Chain Analysis
- HCA 460 Topic 5: Demand Variability Analysis
- HCA 460 Topic 6: Risk Register
- HCA 460 Topic 7: Incident Review
- HCA 450 Topic 8: Quality Improvement Plan
- HCA 360 Topic 8: Governance Gap Memo
- HCA 240 Topic 8: Revenue Leakage Audit
HCA 460 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why does the baseline matter so much?
Because without one the department can only report impressions afterward. A measurement taken before the change, over a stated period and by a stated method, turns the later comparison into evidence. Proposals promising to measure results and never establishing a starting point produce a change everybody believes helped and nobody can defend.
How small should the change be?
Small enough that one department could start it next month without permission from anywhere else. Proposals requiring new positions, new systems or capital sit outside what this topic asks for, and they let the writer avoid the hard part, which is designing something that fits into work already fully occupied.
What belongs in the trial design?
Where it runs, how long it runs, what gets measured and the rule for deciding what happens next. The rule matters most, because trials without one continue by default until everybody has forgotten they were trials. Say in advance what result means continue, what result means adjust and what result means stop.
Where can I find a free HCA 460 Topic 8 sample paper?
This page carries the full process improvement proposal, with the baseline, the reason for choosing these trays, the change, the predicted effect, measures, the timeline and approval. Share your own process for a free model proposal.
How are removed instruments handled in HCA 460 Topic 8?
Instruments used occasionally are packaged individually and stocked in the operating room core, so a surgeon can still have one within a minute. Instruments never used return to inventory, and a balancing measure tracks any case that waits.