| Course | HCA 470 Strategic Planning and Implementation in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Discussion post |
| Length | About 410 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 470 Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post
Not Yet: Why a Hyperbaric Oxygen Service Is Not Viable for a Mid-Size Nonprofit Hospital Building a Limb Preservation Program
A hyperbaric oxygen service is not viable for the nonprofit hospital at the center of my course project, at least not for the next three years, even though it would probably make money. Viability for a nonprofit service line has to mean more than a positive margin; it means the service advances the mission at a cost the system can carry, with evidence that it helps the patients it is meant for.
Here is the specific case. The hospital serves a county with about 24,000 adults with diabetes and rising amputations. A management company has offered to install two chambers at no capital cost and share revenue. On margin alone, it looks attractive: Medicare covers hyperbaric therapy for diabetic foot wounds that meet its criteria, when the wound is deep enough to reach grade III on the Wagner scale and standard care has failed (Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, 2017), and a typical course runs 30 or more sessions.
Three things make it the wrong service now. First, the evidence is mixed. One placebo-controlled trial found better healing at one year with hyperbaric oxygen (Löndahl et al., 2010); another found it did not reduce indications for amputation (Fedorko et al., 2016). A service line whose case rests on uncertain benefit is weak ground for a mission-driven system. Second, the county's real gap is earlier care: most patients reach the hospital with infected wounds through the emergency department, and what prevents amputation at that stage is revascularization, offloading and podiatry, which the hospital does not yet organize. Third, the hyperbaric contract pays the operator by volume, and an early service built around session counts would pull the program toward treating more rather than healing faster.
I will concede the strongest case for it. Some patients who qualify now travel 30 miles to the rival center three to five times a week for six weeks, which is a real burden, especially for people who work shifts or cannot drive. If the hospital builds a strong vascular-led program first, a hyperbaric service added later, with outcome-based payment and access for all payers, could become viable and useful for that smaller group.
Question for classmates: is there a service at your organization that makes money but that you would argue is not viable because of what it pulls the organization away from?
References
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. (2017). National coverage determination for hyperbaric oxygen therapy (20.29). Medicare Coverage Database.
Fedorko, L., Bowen, J. M., Jones, W., Oreopoulos, G., Goeree, R., Hopkins, R. B., & O'Reilly, D. J. (2016). Hyperbaric oxygen therapy does not reduce indications for amputation in patients with diabetes with nonhealing ulcers of the lower limb: A prospective, double-blind, randomized controlled clinical trial. Diabetes Care, 39(3), 392-399. https://doi.org/10.2337/dc15-2001
Löndahl, M., Katzman, P., Nilsson, A., & Hammarlund, C. (2010). Hyperbaric oxygen therapy facilitates healing of chronic foot ulcers in patients with diabetes. Diabetes Care, 33(5), 998-1003. https://doi.org/10.2337/dc09-1754
The HCA-470 Topic 5 assignment instructions
The Topic 5 discussion question in HCA-470 asks students to consider how an organization should decide whether a service line is viable, particularly when financial and mission considerations point in different directions. Students typically take a position on a specific service, weigh financial performance against community need and evidence, and support their view with a scholarly source. Initial posts should answer directly and use one concrete example with enough detail for classmates to challenge it. Replies to classmates count toward the grade later in the week, so a post that closes on a live, answerable question tends to draw better replies, and staying within the instructor's length limit is expected.
How this HCA 470 Topic 5 example is built
The example opens by defining viability for a nonprofit service line as more than margin: mission value at a cost the system can carry, with evidence of benefit. It then carries the whole argument on one service, hyperbaric oxygen therapy offered by a management company at no capital cost in a county with rising amputations. Three reasons follow in order: mixed trial evidence on whether the therapy prevents amputation, a local gap in earlier care that chambers would not close, and volume-based payment that would pull the program toward session counts. The post concedes the real burden of long travel for patients who qualify, sets the conditions under which the service could become viable later, and ends with a question for classmates.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 470 Topic 5 rubric
For this discussion, GCU faculty look for an early answer backed by reasons and for posts that invite real exchange. Excellent posts give their answer in the opening sentence and define the terms that matter, such as what viability means for a nonprofit. The rubric rewards one specific service described with enough detail to argue about, reasons supported by credible sources, and a fair concession to the other side. Credit goes to connecting the argument to mission and evidence rather than to margin alone. The highest level asks peers about money-making services at their own employers that may still be the wrong choice, and it respects the length limit set for the thread.
Common HCA 470 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Discussion marks here go to posts that decide. Presenting both sides fairly and stopping is the most common contribution and the least useful, because nobody can reply to a position that was never taken. Arguments made about unprofitable services in general never reach a case a classmate can test. Treating the loss as a single figure misses whether the service feeds the rest of the organization, which usually decides the answer. Community consequence described as an impact on access says nothing, while a distance and a receiving facility say a great deal. Recommendations offered without their cost are free, and free recommendations are what this course exists to prevent. Unsupported claims about margins draw comment in most sections.
Get an HCA-470 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-470 Topic 5 discussion question, the participation rubric your section uses and the service line you want to argue about. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a position taken in the first line, the nature of the loss clarified, closure consequences given in real distances and the recommendation priced, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 470 papers and BS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 470 Topic 1: Mission Constraint Analysis
- HCA 470 Topic 2: Environmental Scan
- HCA 470 Topic 3: Competitive Position Analysis
- HCA 470 Topic 4: Strategic Trade-off Memo
- HCA 470 Topic 6: Implementation Roadmap
- HCA 470 Topic 7: Feasibility Stress Test
- HCA 470 Topic 8: Strategy Measurement Plan
- HCA 240 Topic 5: Claim Denial Discussion
- HCA 465 Topic 5: Authority Gap Discussion Post
- HCA 360 Topic 5: Access and Audit Discussion
- HCA 460 Topic 5: Demand Variability Analysis
HCA 470 Topic 5 questions, answered
Should a service that loses money always close?
No, and a post arguing that will meet the referral and contracting reality quickly. Some services lose money on their own accounts while producing admissions, physician relationships or employer contracts the organization would lose with them. Others are genuinely isolated losses. Establishing which kind you are dealing with is the analytic work the question is asking for.
How do I handle the mission argument here?
Use it where it binds and not as a closing flourish. If the organization has a published commitment covering this population, or a community benefit obligation, say so and quote it. If the argument is only that closing would feel wrong, admit that and move to what the organization would arrange instead, such as a partner, a transfer agreement or a reduced service.
Does a discussion post need a position?
In this course it does. Strategy is the study of choices under constraint, and a contribution listing considerations without weighing them models the failure the whole term argues against. Take the side you can defend, state what it costs, and leave your genuine uncertainty for the closing question rather than spreading it through the argument.
Where can I find a free HCA 470 Topic 5 sample paper?
Every part of the viability post appears here: the definition, the hyperbaric case, the three reasons, the concession and the closing question. Send the discussion prompt from your course and a model post is written for it at no cost.
Can a profitable service be not viable in HCA 470 Topic 5?
Yes, for a nonprofit. The post argues that a service can make money yet pull the organization away from its mission, rest on uncertain evidence or reward volume over outcomes, which makes it the wrong choice for now.