| Course | HCA 540 Health Care Research Methods, Analysis, and Utilization |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Design fit memo |
| Length | About 790 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 540 Topic 2
Memorandum
To: Chief Medical Officer and Quality Committee, Cedar Plains Medical Center
From: [Author Name], Quality and Research Analyst
Date: [Date]
Re: Choosing a study design for the weekend discharge and readmission question
The Claim Management Needs
The committee wants to know whether to change how Cedar Plains discharges medical patients on weekends. That decision needs two claims: first, whether weekend discharge is associated with more readmissions once differences in who leaves on a Saturday or Sunday are taken into account; and second, whether a specific change, such as adding weekend pharmacist and case management coverage, would reduce readmissions. The first is a claim about association. The second is a claim about cause. No single design supports both equally well, so this memo pairs each candidate design with the claim it can support and recommends a combination.
Candidate Designs and What Each Can Claim
Table 1 lists five designs the hospital could use, with the claim each can support and its main weakness for this question.
Table 1
Candidate Designs Matched to the Claims They Can Support
| Design | Claim it can support | Main weakness here |
|---|---|---|
| Cross-sectional snapshot of one month's discharges | Weekend discharge and readmission occur together | Cannot separate day of discharge from patient differences; too few cases |
| Retrospective cohort of three years of discharges | Weekend discharge is or is not associated with readmission after adjusting for measured patient factors | Cannot rule out unmeasured differences, such as readiness for discharge |
| Interrupted time series around a weekend service change | Readmission trends changed after the service began | Other changes at the same time could explain the shift |
| Stepped-wedge rollout of weekend services across units | Weekend services caused a change in readmissions | Takes months; requires staffing commitments |
| Qualitative interviews with patients and staff | How weekend discharge differs in practice and why readmissions might follow | Cannot estimate size of any effect |
Why the Snapshot Will Not Do
The readmission report that prompted the question is, in effect, a cross-sectional snapshot. It shows that weekend discharges and readmissions occur together more often than weekday discharges and readmissions. It cannot show why. Weekend discharges at Cedar Plains may include more patients discharged after short stays for chest pain or cellulitis, or fewer patients with complex needs who are held for Monday case management. Either would change the readmission rate without the day of discharge doing anything.
The Retrospective Cohort: Right for the First Claim
A retrospective cohort of all medical discharges over three years, about 14,000 patients, can estimate whether weekend discharge is associated with readmission after adjusting for patient factors such as illness severity, principal diagnosis, how long the stay lasted and where the patient went at discharge. This is the design used in the published Canadian studies: one found higher death or readmission after weekend discharge for heart failure (McAlister et al., 2013), and another found no difference among general medicine patients after adjustment (McAlister et al., 2015). It can be done in about eight weeks with existing data. Its weakness is unmeasured confounding: if weekend discharges are chosen because clinicians judge patients ready, or rushed because beds are needed, the record may not capture it.
The Stepped-Wedge Rollout: Right for the Second Claim
If the committee decides to add weekend pharmacist reconciliation and case management, the strongest way to learn whether it works is to introduce it on the four medical units one at a time, in a randomly chosen order, a few months apart. Every unit eventually receives the service, and each unit serves as its own comparison before and after, while units that have not yet started serve as concurrent comparisons for those that have. This stepped-wedge design is well suited to services an organization intends to implement anyway and cannot easily withhold (Hemming et al., 2015). An interrupted time series on one start date would be cheaper, but a single start date could coincide with another change, such as a new readmissions program, and confuse the result.
Recommendation
The quality department recommends a two-stage plan. First, a retrospective cohort to answer whether weekend discharge is associated with readmission at Cedar Plains after adjustment, together with brief interviews with weekend nurses and case managers to understand what differs in practice. Second, if the cohort shows an association and the interviews point to missing services, a stepped-wedge rollout of weekend discharge services across the four medical units, with readmission measured by unit and month. This combination answers both claims management needs, with a design fitted to each, and avoids the most tempting and least supported option: holding patients until Monday on the strength of a snapshot.
Resources and Timing
The cohort requires about 60 hours of analyst time and access to health information exchange data for readmissions elsewhere. The interviews require about 20 hours. The stepped-wedge rollout would run about 12 months and require the weekend staffing the committee would be funding anyway; its added research cost is mainly analysis.
References
Hemming, K., Haines, T. P., Chilton, P. J., Girling, A. J., & Lilford, R. J. (2015). The stepped wedge cluster randomised trial: Rationale, design, analysis, and reporting. BMJ, 350, Article h391. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.h391
McAlister, F. A., Au, A. G., Majumdar, S. R., Youngson, E., & Padwal, R. S. (2013). Postdischarge outcomes in heart failure are better for teaching hospitals and weekday discharges. Circulation: Heart Failure, 6(5), 922-929. https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCHEARTFAILURE.113.000336
McAlister, F. A., Youngson, E., Padwal, R. S., & Majumdar, S. R. (2015). Similar outcomes among general medicine patients discharged on weekends. Journal of Hospital Medicine, 10(2), 69-74. https://doi.org/10.1002/jhm.2310
What the HCA 540 Topic 2 instructions ask for
The Topic 2 instructions in HCA-540 ask students to evaluate research designs for a question relevant to health care administration. Students generally compare several designs, explain the strengths and limitations of each and recommend the most appropriate one. The assignment rewards reasoning about fit: which claim each design can support, whether association, sequence or cause, and which claim the decision actually requires. Students should consider practical constraints such as available data, time and cost, and should be clear about what the chosen design cannot establish. References to published studies that used similar designs, and to methods literature, strengthen the recommendation.
How the HCA-540 Topic 2 example is put together
The finished memo argues about fit rather than describing methods in turn. Each candidate arrives with the claim it can support written beside it: a survey taken at one moment can establish that two things occur together, a group followed forward can establish that one preceded the other, and only an assignment the researcher controls supports a claim that one produced the other. The memo then asks what claim the decision actually needs, which is often weaker than writers assume. Cost, access to records and the time left before the decision appear as constraints rather than as afterthoughts. It ends by naming the design chosen and the claim the organization therefore cannot make.
Reading the HCA 540 Topic 2 rubric
Marks on the design fit memo follow the logic of claims. Excellent memos pair each candidate design with the claim it can support and explain its main weakness for the specific question. The rubric rewards identifying what claim the decision needs before choosing a design, and credit goes to recognizing when one design cannot support every claim, leading to a staged or combined approach. Practical constraints should appear as real limits, not afterthoughts. The highest level names the design chosen, what the organization will still be unable to conclude, and the resources required, supported by methods sources.
Common HCA 540 Topic 2 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks follow fit, and the reliable failure is a design chosen for a question it cannot answer. Proposing a descriptive survey and then reporting that one program caused an improvement is the version markers see most, because the conclusion outruns everything the method could produce. Memos describing three designs in sequence without comparing them have written a chapter summary rather than an argument. Treating every limitation as something more observations would fix confuses precision with the kind of claim a design supports. Versions choosing the strongest available design, with no attention to access or calendar, propose studies nobody could run inside the time the decision allows. Memos naming no design at all, and closing on a recommendation that further study is needed, have declined the choice the topic asked for.
Get an HCA-540 Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-540 Topic 2 instructions, your rubric and the question or scenario the assignment gives you. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the required claim named first, each design read for what it can and cannot establish, and the choice made against real constraints, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HCA 540 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 540 Topic 1: Research Question Brief
- HCA 540 Topic 3: Sampling Plan
- HCA 540 Topic 4: Measurement Appraisal
- HCA 540 Topic 5: Significance Discussion Post
- HCA 540 Topic 6: Study Critique
- HCA 540 Topic 7: Transferability Analysis
- HCA 540 Topic 8: Research Utilization Proposal
- HCA 545 Topic 2: Dual Authority Case
- HCA 530 Topic 2: Market Failure Analysis
- HCA 610 Topic 2: Data Source Inventory
- HCA 515 Topic 2: Payment Pathway Trace
HCA 540 Topic 2 questions, answered
Is a stronger design always better?
Not when it cannot be run. A design the organization has no access to, or one reporting after the decision is made, supports nothing at all. The useful move is finding the weakest design that still carries the claim the decision needs, then stating plainly what it leaves unproven so nobody later reads more into the finding than it holds.
Why can a survey not show cause?
Because everything in it is measured at once. A survey can show that two things appear together in the same population, which is genuinely useful, but it cannot show which came first or rule out a third factor producing both. Reporting an association is honest work. Reporting that association as an effect is the error this topic exists to prevent.
Do qualitative designs belong in an administrative course?
Yes, where the question is about meaning, process or why something failed rather than about how much. Interviews with staff who abandoned a new workflow explain a failure that no count of usage ever will. What such a design cannot do is establish how widespread anything is, so a proposal relying on it should ask for that separately.
Where can I find a free HCA 540 Topic 2 sample paper?
The complete design fit memo is on this page, with the claims management needs, five designs and what each can claim, the recommendation and resources. Tell us the question your course gives and a free worked memo can follow.
Why use a stepped-wedge rollout in HCA 540 Topic 2?
Because the hospital intends to add weekend services anyway. Introducing them on one unit at a time, in random order, lets units that have not started serve as comparisons, which supports a causal claim a single start date could not.