| Course | HCA 616 Networking and Professional Readiness |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Informational interview record |
| Length | About 1,040 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 616 Topic 3
"I Would Not Hire You as a Manager Yet": An Informational Interview Record With a Practice Administrator Who Left Respiratory Therapy Eleven Years Ago
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-616: Networking and Professional Readiness
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
"I Would Not Hire You as a Manager Yet": An Informational Interview Record With a Practice Administrator Who Left Respiratory Therapy Eleven Years Ago
Why This Person
I asked for an informational interview with the practice administrator of a 14-clinician pulmonary and sleep medicine group in my city. I chose her for three reasons tied to my target role. She holds the job I am aiming at, practice operations manager, in the kind of practice my hiring criteria brief identified as my best fit. She was a respiratory therapist for eight years before she moved into practice management eleven years ago, so she has made the exact transition I am attempting. And her group had posted a practice manager opening in the spring, so she has recently decided what she looks for in a candidate. The most reachable person I could have asked was my own department director, who knows my work well but has never worked outside a hospital; she would have been the least informative choice.
The Approach
I did not know her. One of the pulmonologists I work with in the intensive care unit sees patients at her practice two days a week, and he agreed to forward my note. Granovetter (1973) argued that acquaintances, the weak ties outside a person's immediate circle, are more likely than close friends to connect people to new information and opportunities, because they move in different circles. This contact came through exactly such a tie. The note read, in full:
"Dr. Patel suggested I write to you. I'm a respiratory therapist and shift lead at Mesa Hills, finishing a master's in health care administration, and I'm trying to move into practice management. You made that move yourself. Could I have 20 minutes, by phone or at your office at any time that suits you, to ask how you learned the business side of a practice and what you look for when you hire a manager? I'm glad to work around your clinic schedule, including early mornings."
She replied the same day and offered 30 minutes at 7:15 the following Tuesday, before her clinic opened.
The Questions Asked
I prepared five questions, each one that only she could answer. What did you have to learn in your first year as a practice manager that respiratory therapy had not prepared you for? How did you learn the revenue cycle, and how long did it take before you felt competent? When you hired a manager this spring, what did you check for in candidates from clinical backgrounds? What would you want someone in my position to do in the next twelve months? And what is the hardest recurring conversation you have with physicians? I left out anything a job posting or a website would answer, such as the size of the practice or its services.
What Came Back
Her first answer was that she had underestimated how much of the job is money. In her first year she had to learn to read the practice's monthly financial report, work denied claims with the billing team and explain to physicians why their collections had fallen. Nothing in her clinical career prepared her for that, and she learned it by asking the billing supervisor to let her sit in on claim reviews every Thursday afternoon for six months.
Her answer about hiring was the most useful and the least welcome. She said that a candidate from a clinical background with my record would be a strong candidate for an assistant practice manager or a clinical operations supervisor, but that she would not hire me as a practice manager yet. The reasons were specific: I had never owned a budget, never hired or disciplined anyone, and never worked a billing queue. When she hired this spring, she asked every candidate to walk through a denied claim and to describe a time they had let someone go. Candidates from clinical backgrounds usually had good answers to the second question about difficult conversations with staff, and poor answers to the first.
Her advice for the next twelve months was to get close to the revenue cycle at my own hospital, ideally by volunteering to own a piece of it, such as prior authorizations for home oxygen or sleep studies, and to seek a supervisory role with real authority over hiring and evaluations, even a small one. She was blunt about the certification several postings mentioned: useful later, but not what would get me hired now.
On physicians, she said the hardest conversations are about schedules and templates, and that her clinical background helped her earn physicians' trust. But she warned that leading with my clinical title would pull me back into clinical questions and away from the business ones I needed to be seen handling. Spehar et al. (2012) described a similar tension among clinicians who become managers, who must build legitimacy in the managerial role while being drawn back toward clinical identity.
What I Changed
I made three changes as a result. First, I widened my target to include assistant practice manager and clinical operations supervisor roles in physician groups, as a realistic first step. Second, I asked my director and the hospital's patient access manager whether I could take over the prior authorization process for home oxygen orders from the respiratory department, which currently delays discharges; they agreed to a three-month trial starting in November. Third, I rewrote the summary at the top of my resume to lead with scheduling, supply cost control and the scheduling system rollout rather than with my respiratory credentials. Wolff and Moser (2009) found in a longitudinal study that networking behavior predicts later salary growth and career satisfaction, but the value here came less from the contact itself than from acting on what she said.
What I Sent Back
I sent a thank-you note that evening, naming the two pieces of advice I intended to act on. She had mentioned that her practice was struggling to staff its pulmonary function lab, so I sent her the contact for our hospital's respiratory care program coordinator, who places students for clinical rotations. I also asked whether I could write to her again in six months to report on the prior authorization work, and she said yes.
References
Granovetter, M. S. (1973). The strength of weak ties. American Journal of Sociology, 78(6), 1360-1380. https://doi.org/10.1086/225469
Spehar, I., Frich, J. C., & Kjekshus, L. E. (2012). Clinicians' experiences of becoming a clinical manager: A qualitative study. BMC Health Services Research, 12, Article 421. https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6963-12-421
Wolff, H.-G., & Moser, K. (2009). Effects of networking on career success: A longitudinal study. Journal of Applied Psychology, 94(1), 196-206. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0013350
HCA 616 Topic 3 instructions, in plain terms
HCA-616 Topic 3 asks students to conduct an informational interview with a professional in their target field and reflect on what they learned. Students typically identify a contact, prepare questions, conduct the conversation and summarize the insights gained. The assignment rewards records of something that actually happened: why this person was chosen, the request as sent, questions only this person could answer, and what came back, including advice the writer did not want. Students should report what they changed as a result and what they offered in return, supported by research on networks and career development, rather than writing a general discussion of why networking matters.
How the HCA-616 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished record is an account of something that happened rather than a discussion of why contacts matter. It names the person's role and organization, and it says why that seat was chosen: the person holds the job the writer is aiming at, or sits one level above it, or moved into the sector from somewhere similar. The request itself is reproduced, short and specific, because a request for general advice invites a polite decline. The questions asked are the ones only that person could answer, which rules out anything a public posting already covers. What came back is recorded including the parts that were unwelcome. The record closes with what the writer changed and what was sent back afterward.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 616 Topic 3 rubric
GCU faculty grading the informational interview record look for specificity. Excellent records explain why the contact was chosen in terms of the target role, reproduce a short and specific request and list questions that no website or posting could answer. The rubric rewards reporting what the person said honestly, including unwelcome advice. Credit goes to connecting the conversation to concrete changes in the writer's plans and to research on networking. The highest level closes with what the writer sent back afterward, since an informational interview is the start of a professional relationship rather than a single transaction.
Common HCA 616 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Marks depend on whether an exchange actually took place and can be seen on the page. Papers surveying the value of professional relationships, with nobody approached and nothing asked, have written about networking instead of doing any. Questions a public profile answers show the writer did no preparation and spent a stranger's time on it. Records reporting only agreeable answers read as edited, and the missing discouragement is usually the useful part. Contacts described without a role or an organization cannot be weighed, since who the person is decides what their answer is worth. Records ending at the conversation, with no change and no reply sent, leave a relationship that will be awkward to reopen when something is finally needed.
Get an HCA-616 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-616 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric your classroom lists and the role you are aiming at. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the selection reasoned, the approach reproduced, questions no public source could answer, and the change that followed, back in 24 to 48 hours. A conversation you had is yours to report; the first example is free.
More HCA 616 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 616 Topic 1: Hiring Criteria Brief
- HCA 616 Topic 2: Resume Evidence Audit
- HCA 616 Topic 4: Portfolio Artifact Selection
- HCA 616 Topic 5: Hiring Panel Dq Pair
- HCA 616 Topic 6: Judgment Scenario Response
- HCA 616 Topic 7: Dated Development Plan
- HCA 616 Topic 8: Online Presence Review
- HCA 615 Topic 3: Retention Plan
- HCA 610 Topic 3: Cost Structure Analysis
- HCA 545 Topic 3: Culture Assessment
- HCA 515 Topic 3: Integration Case Study
HCA 616 Topic 3 questions, answered
Who should I approach for one of these?
Somebody holding the job you want next, or the job one step past it, at an organization of the kind you are aiming at. A senior executive is flattering to reach and often less useful, because the work they remember is not the work you are about to do. Reachability matters, but it decides who you ask second rather than who you ask first.
What if nobody answers me?
Report that honestly and describe what you sent, because a record of three approaches and one reply is a real finding about how requests land. Most declines follow a message that asked for something vague or open ended. Shortening the ask, naming the specific thing you want to know and saying how long it would take usually changes the response rate more than a longer message does.
Can this record be written for me?
The example can, and the conversation cannot. What another person said to you is your own account, and a record we invented would misrepresent somebody who never spoke. Send the instructions and your rubric, and where you have already talked to someone, send your notes. What comes back is a finished structure with your material placed in it and the unwelcome parts kept.
Where can I find a free HCA 616 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page carries the full informational interview record, with why this person, the approach, the questions, what came back, what changed and what was sent back. A free model record built around your own target role can be requested.
Why did the HCA 616 Topic 3 writer approach a stranger?
A practice administrator who had made the same move from respiratory therapy could answer questions the writer's own hospital director could not. A physician acquaintance, a weak tie, made the introduction.