| Course | HCA 620 Business/Project Plan Evaluation and Development |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Committee presentation and defense |
| Length | About 1,060 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 620 Topic 8
The Motion on Slide One, the Assumption on Slide Two: A Committee Presentation and Defense Packet for a Staff Child Care Center, With a Smaller Fallback Motion
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-620: Business/Project Plan Evaluation and Development
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
The Motion on Slide One, the Assumption on Slide Two: A Committee Presentation and Defense Packet for a Staff Child Care Center, With a Smaller Fallback Motion
How the Deck Is Ordered
The Finance and Capital Committee meets for two hours and gives each item about twenty minutes, of which the presenter has eight. Trustees will form a view from the first two slides and may never see the last. The deck is therefore ordered by what the committee must decide, not by the order in which the plan was written: the motion, the assumption that carries it, then one slide each for the need, the model and the money. Everything else, including the operations detail, the full assumption schedule and the risk table, moves to backup slides held for questions. Five slides fit eight minutes with time to stop for a question.
Slide 1: The Motion
The first slide carries the motion in the words a committee secretary would minute: "Resolved, that the committee approves capital of $1,850,000 to renovate 214 Alder Street as a child care center for Larkspur Regional Medical Center employees, and an operating subsidy not to exceed $900,000 in any year for up to five years, with management to report enrollment and retention results quarterly and to return to this committee at month 18 with a recommendation to continue, restructure or close the center." Nothing else appears on the slide. Speaker note: read the motion aloud, then say, "Everything that follows is the evidence for that sentence." A member who knows the question from the start listens to the evidence differently.
Slide 2: The Assumption That Carries the Case
The second slide states the governing assumption and the value at which the case fails: "Each year the center must stop 12 nurse resignations that would otherwise happen. At 12, it roughly pays for itself. At 8, it costs the hospital about $244,000 a year more than it saves." Beneath it, one line says how the hospital will know: the one-year retention of enrolled nurse parents, reported quarterly, against the current 24 percent departure rate for nurses with young children. Putting the weakness second, before anyone asks, is deliberate. A trustee who discovers the key assumption in a question will distrust the rest of the deck; one who is shown it will judge it. The research behind it is candid about its limits: the pooled evidence finds benefits of this kind nudge employees' plans to stay upward, but only a little (Butts et al., 2013).
Slides 3 to 5: One Number Each
Slide 3, the need, is built around one number: 384 clinicians whose shifts fall outside ordinary child care hours are parents of preschoolers, and no licensed center within eight miles opens before 6 a.m. Slide 4, the model, is built around the break-even: about $942,000 a year in avoided turnover, overtime and agency cost against about $937,000 in subsidy and spread capital. Slide 5, the money, shows the ask by year, with the $900,000 cap drawn as a line and the first-year subsidy of about $980,000 flagged as the one year above it, funded from the human resources retention budget. Each slide has a single number in large type and no paragraph. Speaker notes carry the sources.
The Defense Packet
A separate packet, held by the presenter and not shown, lists the questions expected, grouped by who tends to ask them, with a short spoken answer and the backup slide each answer points to.
From trustees with business backgrounds: "Why not pay nurses a child care stipend instead?" Answer: a stipend cannot buy a seat that does not exist at 5:30 a.m.; the local market has none (backup slide B2). "What if enrollment stalls?" Answer: at three-quarters full the center still runs, with the annual result about $150,000 weaker, and 71 families have paid deposits (B4).
From the chief financial officer: "What stops the subsidy growing?" Answer: the cap written into the motion itself, with weekend hours cut first if costs approach it (B5). "What if the renovation overruns?" Answer: fixed-price contract, $185,000 contingency, and the hospital's last three renovations ran 9 to 22 percent over, which the contingency covers at the middle of that range (B7). Reference-class estimates of this kind are more reliable than a project's own optimistic forecast (Flyvbjerg, 2006).
From the trustee on the early childhood council: "What about community families?" Answer: a possible later phase for up to eight preschool seats, with a separate proposal after year two (B9).
From the chief nursing officer, who supports the plan but will ask on behalf of the nurses: "Will my nurses get the seats?" Answer: 70 percent of seats are reserved for clinical shift workers, with priority for units above 10 percent vacancy (B3).
If a question arrives that the packet does not cover, the presenter says so, names who will answer and by when, and does not guess.
The Fallback Motion
If the committee is not ready to approve the full center, the presenter offers a smaller motion rather than withdrawing. The fallback is a weekday-only pilot of 48 seats, two infant rooms, one toddler room and one preschool room, reserved entirely for clinical shift workers, in the same building with the remaining rooms left unfinished. It needs about $1.2 million in capital and an operating subsidy of about $430,000 a year, and it tests the governing assumption at smaller scale: if enrolled nurse parents stay at a higher rate in the pilot's first 18 months, the full center returns to the committee with local evidence instead of estimates. Kossek and Nichol (1992) found attitude benefits among users of on-site child care without clear effects on some other outcomes, and a pilot is the cheapest way for Larkspur to learn which of those findings applies to its own nurses. Presenting a smaller approvable option is a legitimate way to reduce a committee's risk without abandoning the case (Gapenski & Reiter, 2016).
After the Meeting
Whichever motion passes, the first quarterly report goes to the committee three months after opening, with enrollment, the share of seats held by nurses and the first retention figures. If neither passes, the presenter asks the committee what evidence would change its view and records the answer in the minutes, so that any future proposal starts from the committee's own terms.
References
Butts, M. M., Casper, W. J., & Yang, T. S. (2013). How important are work-family support policies? A meta-analytic investigation of their effects on employee outcomes. Journal of Applied Psychology, 98(1), 1-25. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0030389
Flyvbjerg, B. (2006). From Nobel Prize to project management: Getting risks right. Project Management Journal, 37(3), 5-15. https://doi.org/10.1177/875697280603700302
Gapenski, L. C., & Reiter, K. L. (2016). Healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Kossek, E. E., & Nichol, V. (1992). The effects of on-site child care on employee attitudes and performance. Personnel Psychology, 45(3), 485-509. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.1992.tb00857.x
The HCA-620 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The final topic of HCA-620 asks students to present their business plan to decision makers and defend it. Presentations generally summarize the plan, highlight key findings and prepare for questions. The assignment rewards decks ordered by what the committee must decide, opening with the motion and the total ask, followed at once by the governing assumption and the value at which the case fails. Students should build a few slides around single numbers, move detail to backup, prepare a defense packet of expected questions grouped by who asks them, and have a smaller fallback motion ready, supported by finance and planning research.
How the HCA-620 Topic 8 example is put together
The finished presentation assumes the committee will decide on the opening slides and may never reach the final ones. So the first thing on screen is the motion, worded the way a secretary would minute it: what is approved, how much, over what period, and when results come back. The governing assumption follows at once, with the volume below which the plan fails. Three or four slides carry the need, the model and the money, each built around a single number rather than a paragraph. Everything else moves to backup, held for questions. A separate defense packet lists the questions the presenter expects, grouped by who tends to ask them, with a short spoken answer and the backup slide each answer points to. A fallback motion closes it: the smaller pilot a hesitant committee could approve instead of refusing.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 620 Topic 8 rubric
The HCA-620 rubric for the presentation rewards decision-first design. Excellent decks state the motion in minutable form on the first slide and the governing assumption with its failure point on the second. Credit goes to slides built around one number each and to moving detail into backup. The rubric values a defense packet that anticipates questions by who asks them, with short answers and references to backup slides, and honesty when a question cannot be answered. The highest level offers a smaller fallback motion that tests the key assumption at lower risk.
HCA 620 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Presentations give up the most when they are simply the written plan moved onto slides. Decks opening with organizational background and reaching the ask on the last slide have spent the committee's time on material nobody needed in order to decide. Slides dense with text make members read instead of listen, and the presenter ends up competing with the screen. Assumptions saved for the question period look hidden until somebody found them, even where the writer meant to raise them all along. Defense notes written as paragraphs cannot be delivered under questioning, and answers that restate the plan without meeting the question lose the member who asked it. Versions carrying no fallback motion leave a hesitant committee with approval or deferral as its only choices, and deferral is almost always the easier vote to cast.
Get an HCA-620 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-620 Topic 8 instructions, your rubric, the time allowed and the final plan it draws on. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the motion first, the governing assumption shown early, one figure per main slide, backup slides indexed to questions, spoken defense answers and a fallback motion, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 620 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 620 Topic 1: Approval Criteria Memo
- HCA 620 Topic 2: Need Statement with Evidence
- HCA 620 Topic 3: Staffed Operations Section
- HCA 620 Topic 4: Projection Assumption Schedule
- HCA 620 Topic 5: Load-bearing Assumption Dq Pair
- HCA 620 Topic 6: Risk and Mitigation Table
- HCA 620 Topic 7: Objection-tested Final Plan
- HCA 616 Topic 8: Online Presence Review
- HCA 615 Topic 8: Integrated Workforce and Message Plan
- HCA 610 Topic 8: Analysis Defense Paper
- HCA 515 Topic 8: Operating Feasibility Brief
HCA 620 Topic 8 questions, answered
How many slides fit the time allowed?
Fewer than feels comfortable. Each main slide takes longer in the room than in rehearsal, because members interrupt, and the interruptions are where the decision gets made. The motion and the assumption slides do most of the persuading, so they deserve the time. Anything a member might ask about but will not decide on belongs in backup, where it costs nothing until somebody needs it.
What if the committee asks something I cannot answer?
Say so, say what would answer it, and say when the committee will have it. A presenter who improvises a figure under pressure creates a number that gets quoted back later, often at the review meeting. The defense packet should carry a short list of questions the plan genuinely cannot settle yet, so the honest reply is prepared ahead of time rather than invented at the table.
Do I need speaker notes as well as slides?
Where the rubric asks for them, yes, and they are often where the defense is actually scored. Notes that repeat the slide add nothing. Notes giving the point the slide makes, the question it tends to provoke and the backup slide that answers it show an instructor that the presenter expects to be challenged, which is the posture this whole course is built around.
Where can I find a free HCA 620 Topic 8 sample paper?
This page holds the full presentation and defense, with the deck order, the motion, the assumption slide, the single-number slides, the defense packet, the fallback motion and what happens after the meeting. A free model presentation for your own plan can be drafted.
What is the fallback motion in HCA 620 Topic 8?
A weekday-only pilot of 48 seats for clinical shift workers, needing about $1.2 million in capital and about $430,000 a year, which tests whether enrolled nurse parents stay before the full center is funded.