| Course | HCA 620 Business/Project Plan Evaluation and Development |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Approval criteria memo |
| Length | About 950 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 620 Topic 1
Memorandum
To: Chief Human Resources Officer and Chief Nursing Officer, Larkspur Regional Medical Center
From: [Author Name], Workforce Planning Analyst
Date: [Date]
Re: What the Finance and Capital Committee will need before approving the staff child care center plan
The Approving Body
The plan for an extended-hours child care center for staff will go to the Finance and Capital Committee of the board, not to the executive team. The committee's charter requires its approval for any capital project over $1 million and any new program needing an operating subsidy over $250,000 a year, and our draft needs both: about $1.85 million to renovate the vacant clinic building on Alder Street and an operating subsidy that will run between roughly $750,000 and $1.1 million a year. The committee has seven trustees, three of them from local businesses, and the chief financial officer attends without a vote. It approves on financial and strategic grounds. A memo aimed at the executive team would argue from our staffing problems; this committee will ask what those problems cost and whether this is the cheapest way to reduce them. What follows sets out its four questions in the order it will ask them.
Criterion 1: What Problem Does This Solve, and for Whom?
The committee will want the problem stated as a number for a defined group, not as a general difficulty with child care. Evidence that satisfies it: how many employees have young children and work shifts that start before 7 a.m. or end after 6 p.m., how many of our departures in the last year cited child care in exit data, how many shifts parents missed because care fell through, and how many licensed seats near the hospital open before 6 a.m. Evidence that sounds like evidence and is not: a staff survey in which 78 percent of respondents said they would be "interested" in on-site child care. Interest costs a respondent nothing. The 71 families who have paid a $100 refundable deposit to hold a place are a much better signal, and the committee will know the difference.
Criterion 2: What Does It Cost in Total?
The committee will want the whole cost over the life of the commitment, not the first-year operating budget. That means the capital cost, the operating subsidy each year for at least five years with the enrollment ramp shown, the operator's management fee and the cost of the space, which the hospital owns but could lease to a tenant. Evidence that satisfies it: a contractor's bid for the renovation, the operator's written fee proposal and a staffing model built on the state's child-to-staff ratios. Evidence that sounds like evidence and is not: a national average cost per child care seat, which says nothing about a center open 14 and a half hours a day. Large projects routinely overrun their estimates because planners underweight the experience of comparable projects (Flyvbjerg, 2006), so the committee will also ask what the budget looks like if the renovation runs 20 percent over.
Criterion 3: What Happens If We Do Nothing?
This is the criterion trustees from business backgrounds press hardest, because every new program competes with doing nothing and with other uses of the money. The committee will want the cost of the status quo in the same units as the cost of the plan: registered nurse departures attributable to child care, multiplied by what each departure costs us in recruitment, orientation and agency cover, plus overtime paid when parents miss shifts. It will also want the alternatives compared, such as a child care stipend, reserved seats bought at an existing center, or schedule changes. Evidence that satisfies it: our own exit data and our own turnover cost. Evidence that sounds like evidence and is not: published studies alone. Research on work-family policies has found that their availability has modest positive associations with job satisfaction, commitment and intention to stay (Butts et al., 2013), which supports the idea but cannot tell the committee what doing nothing costs Larkspur.
Criterion 4: Who Is Accountable If It Underperforms?
The committee will want a named executive who owns the result, measures that show whether the center is working and a date at which it will see them. It will also want to know what happens if enrollment or retention falls short: whether the hospital can reduce hours, close rooms or end the operator contract, and at what cost. Evidence that satisfies it: a named owner, the chief human resources officer, with quarterly reporting on enrollment, the share of seats used by clinical shift workers and departures among enrolled families, and a contract that allows the hospital to reduce capacity after year two. Evidence that sounds like evidence and is not: a promise to "monitor outcomes closely." Capital decisions should include a plan for measuring whether projected benefits arrive (Gapenski & Reiter, 2016).
Where the Current Draft Fails
Our draft would currently fail Criterion 3. It describes the child care problem well, and its costs are reasonably grounded, but it never puts a dollar figure on doing nothing. It cites the 31 nurse departures last year that mentioned child care without saying how many of those the center could realistically prevent or what each costs us, and it does not compare the center with a stipend or with buying seats elsewhere. Without that, the committee cannot weigh a subsidy of up to $1.1 million a year against anything. Before the plan goes forward, human resources finance needs to confirm our cost per nurse departure, and the plan needs a clear statement of how many departures it must prevent each year for the center to pay for itself. I will draft that section next, and I recommend we treat it as the heart of the plan rather than an appendix.
References
Butts, M. M., Casper, W. J., & Yang, T. S. (2013). How important are work-family support policies? A meta-analytic investigation of their effects on employee outcomes. Journal of Applied Psychology, 98(1), 1-25. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0030389
Flyvbjerg, B. (2006). From Nobel Prize to project management: Getting risks right. Project Management Journal, 37(3), 5-15. https://doi.org/10.1177/875697280603700302
Gapenski, L. C., & Reiter, K. L. (2016). Healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (6th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Reading the GCU HCA 620 Topic 1 instructions
Topic 1 of HCA-620 asks graduate students to identify the criteria decision makers use to evaluate business or project plans in health care. A typical memo names the approving authority, describes the standards it applies and explains how a plan should be prepared to meet them. The strongest memos are written for one specific body, since a department head, a capital committee and a board approve on different grounds. Students should state each criterion as a question the body will ask aloud, describe the evidence that satisfies it and the evidence that only appears to, and honestly assess which criterion their own draft would currently fail, with support from finance and planning research.
Inside the HCA 620 Topic 1 example
The finished memo reads like something written for a meeting rather than for a grade. It names the approving body it has in mind, because a department director, a capital committee and a board approve on different grounds and a memo aimed at all three persuades none. Four criteria are set out and each is written as a question the committee will ask out loud: what problem does this solve, what does it cost in total, what happens if we do nothing, and who is accountable if it underperforms. Under each criterion the memo states the kind of evidence that satisfies it, and the kind that sounds like evidence and is not. It ends by marking the criterion the writer's own draft would currently fail.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 620 Topic 1 rubric
GCU's rubric for the approval criteria memo rewards a memo aimed at a real decision. Excellent memos identify the approving body, its authority and its thresholds, and set out the criteria in the order the body will reach them. Credit goes to specifying, under each criterion, what evidence would satisfy the approvers and what would merely resemble evidence. The rubric values realism about how boards and committees actually decide. The highest level turns the criteria on the writer's own draft and names the criterion it would fail, which shows the memo is a working tool rather than a summary of good practice.
HCA 620 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks
Marks follow whether the memo has a reader. Papers describing business planning as a discipline, with no committee in view, have written about approval rather than working out what approval requires. Criteria lifted from a textbook list and never applied to a decision leave a reader unable to tell a satisfied criterion from an unsatisfied one. Memos that treat the do nothing option as obviously unacceptable have skipped the comparison a committee makes first, since doing nothing is free and always on the table. Cost sections covering purchase and omitting the recurring commitment understate the ask, and a finance member will find that in the first minute. Versions that mark no failing criterion in the writer's own draft have declined the honesty the seat is built on.
Get an HCA-620 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-620 Topic 1 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the approving body the assignment names. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the committee identified, the criteria in the order a room reaches them, evidence paired to each, and the failing item marked, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 620 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 620 Topic 2: Need Statement with Evidence
- HCA 620 Topic 3: Staffed Operations Section
- HCA 620 Topic 4: Projection Assumption Schedule
- HCA 620 Topic 5: Load-bearing Assumption Dq Pair
- HCA 620 Topic 6: Risk and Mitigation Table
- HCA 620 Topic 7: Objection-tested Final Plan
- HCA 620 Topic 8: Committee Presentation and Defense
- HCA 616 Topic 1: Hiring Criteria Brief
- HCA 615 Topic 1: Employer Promise Analysis
- HCA 610 Topic 1: Analysis Scoping Memo
- HCA 515 Topic 1: Delivery Model Analysis
HCA 620 Topic 1 questions, answered
What if my assignment does not name a committee?
Choose one and say why. A plan for a new outpatient service goes to a different table than a plan to replace a scheduling system, and the choice shapes every criterion that follows. Stating the assumption in the opening paragraph costs one sentence and gives your reader something to agree or disagree with, which is the whole point of this seat.
Is the do nothing option really a criterion?
It is usually the one that kills proposals. Every committee compares your plan against carrying on, which costs nothing new and carries no implementation risk. A plan that does not price the consequence of inaction is asking for money against an alternative it never examined, and an experienced member will raise that before anything else.
Can you use my organization in the example?
We can write to the setting you describe, and we will not put figures in it that you have not supplied. If your assignment allows a composite organization, that is often cleaner, since real internal numbers are usually confidential and a plan built on them cannot be shared. Send the instructions, your rubric and whatever context you are permitted to give.
Where can I find a free HCA 620 Topic 1 sample paper?
This page holds the complete approval criteria memo, with the approving body, the four criteria and the evidence for each, and the criterion the draft fails. Tell us who approves plans in your organization for a free worked memo.
Why is doing nothing a criterion in HCA 620 Topic 1?
Every proposal competes with the status quo and with other uses of the money. The committee needs the cost of doing nothing in the same units as the plan's cost before it can judge whether the plan is worth funding.