| Course | HCA 680 Leadership in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Escalation and deadlock memo |
| Length | About 880 words, 2 pages |
| Format | Memo with APA 7 references |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 680 Topic 5
Memorandum
To: Chief Nursing Officer and Chief Medical Officer, Juniper Ridge Regional Hospital
From: [Author Name], Director of Women's Services
Date: [Date]
Re: Routing the standoff between the Department of Obstetrics and nursing administration over scheduled inductions
The Dispute in One Sentence
The Department of Obstetrics and nursing administration disagree over who may stop scheduled elective inductions from starting when labor and delivery has no staffed room. The disagreement has been described to both of you as a breakdown in the relationship between the obstetricians and the unit. I think it is three separate disputes with different owners, and that only one of them is a genuine deadlock. Denis et al. (2001) observed that in organizations where physicians and managers each hold power of their own, strategic change stalls unless leadership is shared across those groups, and a standoff left undivided invites each group to defend all of it. This memo sorts them and recommends a route for the one that remains.
The Documents That Might Govern
I read five instruments before writing this: the medical staff bylaws and the Department of Obstetrics rules adopted under them; the board's resolution delegating operational authority to the chief executive, and the executive's delegation of nurse staffing to the chief nursing officer; the unit's nurse staffing plan, approved each year by the hospital's staffing committee; the professional services agreement with the laborist group; and the hospital's capacity management policy, which governs diversion from the emergency department but says nothing about scheduled procedures on labor and delivery.
Three Matters, Three Owners
Table 1
The Induction Dispute Sorted by Governing Instrument
| Matter in dispute | Governing instrument | Holder |
|---|---|---|
| Whether an induction is medically indicated and therefore exempt from deferral | Medical staff bylaws; department rules | Medical staff, through the Department of Obstetrics |
| How many nurses are staffed and whether more are called in | Board delegation; nurse staffing plan | Management, through the chief nursing officer |
| Whether scheduled elective inductions start when no staffed room exists | None | Nobody |
The first matter is not in dispute once the bylaws are read. Whether a given induction is medically necessary is a clinical judgment that belongs to the physicians, and nursing administration has no standing to second-guess it. The department should confirm that its members will mark indications at booking so the question never arises on the night. The second matter is equally settled in the other direction. The staffing plan and the call-in procedure belong to management, and the department's view that the unit is understaffed is a view the chief nursing officer can hear but is not bound by.
The third matter is the real deadlock. The department argues that deferring a patient's scheduled induction is a clinical decision because it changes that patient's care. Nursing administration argues that starting a procedure without staff to monitor it is an operational question of capacity. Both arguments are reasonable, and no document assigns the decision to either side. On the Saturday in January when three inductions were deferred, the decision was made jointly by the department chair and the administrator on call, which worked because both agreed. The next time they may not.
The Route for the Third Matter
The route runs through four levels, and each can settle some things and not others. The department chair and the chief nursing officer can agree an interim protocol for the next three months, but neither can bind the other's line permanently. The medical executive committee can adopt a rule binding the medical staff, and the chief executive can issue a policy binding employees, but a rule adopted by one without the other would leave the matter split. Weiner et al. (1996) found that quality improvement went further in hospitals where boards, managers and physicians were each involved in its governance, rather than any one group acting alone, and this matter touches all three. The governing body is the only authority to which both the medical staff and management answer. It can approve a capacity policy for scheduled procedures that incorporates a medical staff rule, which is the only form that would bind both lines.
What Each Step Costs
Each level upward has a price. The interim protocol costs little but lasts only as long as the two current office holders agree. Taking the matter to the medical executive committee and the chief executive costs two to three months and signals to the obstetricians that nursing has escalated, which the department chair has told me some members would read as hostile. Taking it to the governing body costs another quarter and a board presentation, and it teaches the whole organization that disagreements between the medical staff and management end with the board, which should be rare. Jha and Epstein (2010) found that board attention to quality varied widely among US hospitals, so a board asked to rule on scheduling may also be unprepared to do so.
Recommendation and the Standing to Protect
I recommend the interim protocol now, with the chair and the chief nursing officer jointly deciding any deferral by telephone, and the joint rule taken to the medical executive committee and the chief executive together, as one proposal, so that the governing body is asked only to approve an agreement rather than to settle a fight. The relationship to protect is the one between the department chair and the unit's charge nurses, who will face the next full Saturday night whatever the board decides.
References
Denis, J.-L., Lamothe, L., & Langley, A. (2001). The dynamics of collective leadership and strategic change in pluralistic organizations. Academy of Management Journal, 44(4), 809-837. https://doi.org/10.2307/3069417
Jha, A., & Epstein, A. (2010). Hospital governance and the quality of care. Health Affairs, 29(1), 182-187. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2009.0297
Weiner, B. J., Alexander, J. A., & Shortell, S. M. (1996). Leadership for quality improvement in health care: Empirical evidence on hospital boards, managers, and physicians. Medical Care Research and Review, 53(4), 397-416. https://doi.org/10.1177/107755879605300402
The HCA-680 Topic 5 assignment instructions
HCA-680 Topic 5 asks students to address a persistent disagreement between administrative and clinical leadership and explain how it should be escalated. Many responses decide which side should win. The assignment rewards memos that narrow the dispute to something assignable and then search the governing documents, such as bylaws, board delegations, staffing plans and contracts. Students should sort matters by whether the medical staff, management or no one holds them, route only the unassigned matter upward through each level that could settle it, and price every step in delay, working relationships and the precedent it sets for future disagreements.
How this HCA 680 Topic 5 example is built
The completed memo refuses the framing it was handed. Instead of deciding who wins, it asks which instrument governs the matter under dispute, because most standoffs were assigned to one side long ago and the argument continues only because nobody went and read the assignment. Three cases are worked through: a matter the bylaws give to the medical staff, a matter the board reserved to management, and a matter no document covers at all. Only the third is a genuine deadlock, and it travels to the governing body, the one authority both lines answer to. Every step upward carries a price paid in delay, in the working relationship afterward, and in what the whole organization learns about how disagreements end in this building.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 680 Topic 5 rubric
Faculty grading the escalation memo reward reading the documents before arguing. Excellent memos define the dispute narrowly and identify the instrument that governs each part of it, showing that most standoffs were allocated long ago. Credit goes to separating medical staff matters from management matters and isolating what no document covers. The rubric values a route that explains what each level can and cannot settle and reserves the governing body for the matter only it can decide. The highest level prices each step and names the working relationship that must survive the disagreement. Memos that send every dispute to the board, or end the standoff by having the manager direct physicians, generally fall to a lower band.
HCA 680 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Marks turn on whether the dispute was ever made assignable, and vague standoffs sink at once. A memo describing a tense relationship between administration and the medical staff offers nothing a route can carry, so no escalation inside it is real. Answering the question as posed, by declaring that one line outranks the other, misses that most matters were allocated in a document neither party has read lately. Papers escalating every disagreement to the governing body treat a board as a referee for operating decisions. Versions where the manager ends the standoff by directing the physicians have left the course again. The last frequent loss is an escalation with no price attached to it, written as though going upward were free.
Get an HCA-680 Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-680 Topic 5 instructions, your posted rubric, and the standoff your section supplied or asked you to build. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the dispute narrowed until it can be assigned, the governing instrument identified, the route upward named level by level, and each step priced, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 680 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 680 Topic 1: Authority Limit Brief
- HCA 680 Topic 2: Clinician Persuasion Memo
- HCA 680 Topic 3: Contested Decision Brief
- HCA 680 Topic 4: Divided Duty Analysis
- HCA 680 Topic 6: Trust Repair Plan
- HCA 680 Topic 7: Observable Leadership Commitments
- HCA 680 Topic 8: Clinical Objection Rebuttal
- HCA 515 Topic 5: Incentive Effects Post
- HCA 675 Topic 5: Single Veto Discussion
- HCA 530 Topic 5: Unintended Effect Post
- HCA 650 Topic 5: Approval Path Discussion Post
HCA 680 Topic 5 questions, answered
So who does win?
Usually whoever the document named already, which is why the hunt for the instrument comes before the argument. Where nothing names anybody, the governing body decides, since both the chief executive and the organized medical staff answer to it. That answer is unsatisfying in a discussion question and it happens to be the accurate one, and a post saying so and then showing the route earns more than a post picking a side.
Does this apply outside hospitals?
The shape does, though the instruments change. A large group practice, a federally qualified health center and a nursing facility each split authority between an administrative line and a professional one, and each keeps its own documents allocating matters between them. Ask what your case actually is before importing medical staff bylaws into an organization that has never had any.
How do I price a step in the escalation?
In terms somebody could dispute rather than in adjectives. Delay is measured by the decision the organization cannot make while the matter sits. The relationship cost is stated as the next request the writer will have to make of the same group. What the organization learns is stated as the precedent set, since people watch how the last disagreement ended before they start the next one.
Where can I find a free HCA 680 Topic 5 sample paper?
This page holds the full memo, with the dispute stated, the five documents read, a table of three matters and their owners, the route for the deadlock, the price of each step and the recommendation. A free model memo for your standoff is available.
Which matter is the real deadlock in HCA 680 Topic 5?
Whether scheduled elective inductions start when no staffed room exists. Obstetricians call it clinical and nursing calls it capacity, and no bylaw, delegation or policy assigns it, so only the governing body can bind both lines.