| Course | HCA 680 Leadership in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Contested decision brief |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MS in Health Care Administration |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 680 Topic 3
Deferring Three Scheduled Inductions at 9:40 on a Saturday Night: A Contested Decision Brief Written for the Review
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HCA-680: Leadership in Health Care
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Deferring Three Scheduled Inductions at 9:40 on a Saturday Night: A Contested Decision Brief Written for the Review
The Decision
At 9:40 p.m. on a Saturday in January, the administrator on call for Juniper Ridge Regional Hospital, who was also the director of women's services, decided with the chair of the Department of Obstetrics to defer three elective inductions scheduled to begin at 10 p.m. and midnight until the following morning. Each deferral was reviewed by the in-house laborist before the patient was called, and none of the three was medically indicated. The director owns the decision. This brief is written for the department's case review, which two attending obstetricians requested after the event.
What Was Known, Reported and Assumed at 9:40 p.m.
Table 1
Information Available When the Decision Was Made
| Item | Status at 9:40 p.m. | Source |
|---|---|---|
| All 14 labor rooms occupied; two laboring patients in triage | Known | Unit census board |
| Seven nurses on shift against eight needed for that acuity | Known | Staffing grid |
| One called-in nurse available from 11 p.m.; none sooner | Known | Staffing office call log |
| Two patients expected to deliver within two hours | Reported | Charge nurse, from bedside nurses |
| Rooms would free by midnight | Assumed | Charge nurse estimate |
| All three scheduled patients low risk, at 39 to 40 weeks | Known | Laborist chart review |
| One scheduled patient lived 70 miles away | Reported | Scheduling note |
The distinction between known, reported and assumed matters because the review is taking place after the outcome is known. Fischhoff (1975) showed that people told how events turned out judge that outcome as having been more predictable than they would have judged it beforehand, and do not recognize the change in their own judgment. The table records only what was available at 9:40 p.m.
The Options That Were Live
Four options were considered. The first was to admit the three patients to triage and start cervical ripening there. It was rejected because the triage bays are staffed for assessment, not for continuous monitoring during ripening, and the two triage nurses were already caring for laboring patients. The second was to call in more nurses and proceed. It was rejected because the staffing office had reached every nurse on the call list and found one available from 11 p.m., which would bring the unit back to its minimum for the patients already there, not above it. The third was to proceed with the 10 p.m. patient only. It was rejected because the one room expected to free first was already promised to a laboring patient in triage. The fourth, deferral until 7 a.m. with each patient's physician informed, was chosen.
Who Was Consulted and What They Said
The charge nurse was consulted first and recommended deferral. The laborist reviewed all three charts and agreed none required induction that night. The department chair agreed by telephone at 9:35 p.m. The physicians of the three patients were called. The physician for the 10 p.m. patient accepted the deferral. Two others objected. Dr. Kerrigan of Sagebrush OB-GYN argued that her patient, the one who lived 70 miles away, had arranged child care and time off, that deferral would damage trust in the hospital and that two rooms were about to free. Dr. Osei of Canyon Women's Health argued that deferring a patient past 39 weeks 4 days removed her from the conditions of the evidence she had used to counsel the patient, and that the unit was using scheduled patients to absorb a staffing problem. Both objections were recorded at the time in the administrator's log in those terms.
The Reasoning From Those Facts to That Call
The decision rested on the known staffing position rather than on the reported deliveries. With seven nurses against eight needed and one more arriving at 11 p.m., starting three inductions would have added patients requiring monitoring to a unit already short. The expected deliveries, if they happened, would free rooms but not nurses, because each delivered patient still needs recovery care for about two hours. Dr. Kerrigan's point about trust was accepted as a real cost but judged smaller than the risk of starting inductions without the staff to monitor them. Dr. Osei's point about the trial window was accepted in part: the ARRIVE trial's induction group was induced between 39 weeks 0 days and 39 weeks 4 days (Grobman et al., 2018), and one of the three patients would pass that window with an overnight delay. That was judged a smaller departure than an unmonitored ripening.
What Happened, and Why It Does Not Settle the Question
Two rooms freed by 12:40 a.m. The three patients began induction between 7 and 9 a.m. and delivered without complications. With hindsight, proceeding at midnight would probably have worked. That is the outcome, not the reasoning. Caplan et al. (1991) found that physicians reviewing identical care rated it as appropriate less often when told the outcome had been bad, and the same bias runs in the other direction here: a good outcome after deferral makes deferral look unnecessary, and a good outcome is equally consistent with a correct decision.
What Would Have Changed the Call, and What Would Reopen It Now
Two pieces of information would have produced a different decision: a second nurse available before 11 p.m., or a laborist finding that any of the three patients had a medical indication. The decision would be reopened now if the review found that the staffing office had not reached every available nurse, or if deferred patients at Juniper Ridge were shown to have worse outcomes than those started on time. The charge nurse on duty will record, for every future deferral, the nurse count, the call log and the physicians' responses, and the director will report all deferrals to the department each quarter so that the next contested night is reviewed against a pattern rather than a single case.
References
Caplan, R. A., Posner, K. L., & Cheney, F. W. (1991). Effect of outcome on physician judgments of appropriateness of care. JAMA, 265(15), 1957-1960. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1991.03460150061024
Fischhoff, B. (1975). Hindsight is not equal to foresight: The effect of outcome knowledge on judgment under uncertainty. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Perception and Performance, 1(3), 288-299. https://doi.org/10.1037/0096-1523.1.3.288
Grobman, W. A., Rice, M. M., Reddy, U. M., Tita, A. T. N., Silver, R. M., Mallett, G., Hill, K., Thom, E. A., El-Sayed, Y. Y., Perez-Delboy, A., Rouse, D. J., Saade, G. R., Boggess, K. A., Chauhan, S. P., Iams, J. D., Chien, E. K., Casey, B. M., Gibbs, R. S., Srinivas, S. K., . . . Macones, G. A. (2018). Labor induction versus expectant management in low-risk nulliparous women. New England Journal of Medicine, 379(6), 513-523. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa1800566
The HCA-680 Topic 3 assignment instructions
HCA-680 Topic 3 asks students to document a leadership decision made under pressure and disputed by clinicians. Students commonly narrate the events and conclude that the decision was right because things turned out well. The assignment rewards briefs written for a later review: the decision, its hour and its owner first, then the information available at that moment labeled as known, reported or assumed. Students should present each live option with the reason it was rejected, record consultation by name including dissent in the dissenter's own words, show the reasoning that joined facts to decision and set a condition under which the decision would be reopened.
How this HCA 680 Topic 3 example is built
The completed brief is written for the review rather than for the room, and that shows in its first section. Facts available at the hour of the call are fenced off from everything learned since, each one marked as known, reported or assumed, because hindsight rewrites a record faster than dishonesty does. Rejected options appear with the defect that removed them instead of as a list making the chosen course look inevitable. Consultation is recorded by name and role, including two physicians who argued the other way and the argument they actually made, since unanimity in a divided service invites a reviewer to hunt for what is missing. The final page states what evidence would have produced a different call and what would still reverse it now.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 680 Topic 3 rubric
Marks on the contested decision brief go to reasoning that survives hindsight. Excellent briefs separate what was known at the time from what was learned later and label the certainty of each fact. Credit goes to rejected options that carry a stated defect, since a list of alternatives with no reasons reads as decoration. The rubric rewards dissent recorded fully enough that the dissenting clinician would recognize it. The highest level acknowledges outcome bias explicitly, refuses to rest the defense on the result and names who will watch for the trigger that would reopen the decision.
HCA 680 Topic 3 help before you submit
The heaviest losses on this topic come from briefs that quietly know how it all turned out. Arguing that the decision was correct because the patient recovered has scored the outcome instead of the reasoning, and a reader trained in this material catches that in one pass. Records showing full agreement in a service where two attending physicians objected are either incomplete or managed, and both are treated the same way. Papers recommending what the manager should have ordered have wandered back into a course about employees. Options listed with no reason for rejection read as decoration around a conclusion. The last common failure is a brief with no reopening condition, which tells a reviewer the writer considered a contested call settled.
Get an HCA-680 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-680 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric your section posted, and the case or scenario you were given. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the hour of the decision fixed, rejected options carrying their objections, dissent recorded by name, and a stated trigger for reopening the matter, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HCA 680 papers and MS in Health Care Administration samples
- HCA 680 Topic 1: Authority Limit Brief
- HCA 680 Topic 2: Clinician Persuasion Memo
- HCA 680 Topic 4: Divided Duty Analysis
- HCA 680 Topic 5: Escalation and Deadlock Memo
- HCA 680 Topic 6: Trust Repair Plan
- HCA 680 Topic 7: Observable Leadership Commitments
- HCA 680 Topic 8: Clinical Objection Rebuttal
- HCA 515 Topic 3: Integration Case Study
- HCA 675 Topic 3: Evidence Threshold Memo
- HCA 530 Topic 3: Legislative Brief
- HCA 650 Topic 3: Administrative Evidence Review
HCA 680 Topic 3 questions, answered
Should the brief say the decision was right?
It should say the decision was defensible on what sat in front of the writer, which is a different and far more durable claim. Reviewers rarely ask whether a call produced a good result, since they already know the result. They ask what was known, what was weighed and who was consulted, and a record answering those questions survives an outcome that went badly.
How much detail belongs in the dissent section?
Enough that the dissenter would recognize the argument as their own. A single line reporting that a physician expressed concern gives a reviewer nothing and reads as management of the record. Naming the objection, the reasoning under it and what would have satisfied it shows a decision made in the open, which is the whole purpose of writing one of these down.
Can I build this on a real case from my workplace?
Many sections allow it once identifying details are removed, and the working standard is that no patient, colleague or employer should be recognizable to a reader. Check what your instructions permit before you begin, because a brief built on a real incident and stripped late tends to lose the specifics that made it worth writing at all.
Where can I find a free HCA 680 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full decision brief, with the decision, a table of what was known at 9:40 p.m., the options rejected, the dissent in the physicians' own terms, the reasoning, the outcome and the reopening conditions. Request a free model brief for your case.
Why doesn't the good outcome settle HCA 680 Topic 3?
Rooms did free by 12:40 a.m. and all three patients delivered well, but that is equally consistent with deferral being correct or unnecessary. The brief judges the call on the staffing facts available when it was made.