| Course | HCA 822 Building a Culture of Community in Health Care |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Unequal partnership analysis |
| Length | About 980 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | Doctor of Health Administration (DHA) |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HCA 822 Topic 3
Who Can Walk Away and Still Exist Next Year: An Unequal Partnership Analysis of Ridgeline Health's Produce Prescription Program
[Author Name]
College of Doctoral Studies, Grand Canyon University
HCA-822: Building a Culture of Community in Health Care
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Who Can Walk Away and Still Exist Next Year: An Unequal Partnership Analysis of Ridgeline Health's Produce Prescription Program
The Arrangement
In 2024 Ridgeline Health launched a produce prescription program with the Eastside Food Network, a coalition of nine congregations that run food pantries near Ridgeline's main campus. Ridgeline's clinicians screen patients for food insecurity and, for patients with diabetes or high blood pressure who screen positive, write a prescription for weekly produce. The network fills the prescriptions from its pantries, using produce bought with program funds. Both organizations describe the arrangement as a partnership, and the program's brochure calls the network "our community partner" four times. This paper asks what kind of arrangement it actually is, by counting who holds what. The question matters beyond labels. The foundation's renewal application, due next year, asks applicants to describe the community partner's role in governing the program, and a description that overstates the network's power would mislead the funder as well as the neighborhood.
The Inventory
Table 1
Who Holds What in the Produce Prescription Arrangement
| Resource or power | Ridgeline Health | Eastside Food Network |
|---|---|---|
| Holds the grant | Yes: $420,000 from a regional health foundation, awarded to Ridgeline | No |
| Employs the staff | Program coordinator and two community health workers | Volunteers; one part-time pantry manager paid from the grant through Ridgeline |
| Owns the data | All screening, referral and outcome data in its health record | Pickup logs on paper; receives no outcome data |
| Signs the lease or owns the space | No | Congregations own their buildings |
| Sets eligibility and the produce list | Yes, through its clinical protocol | Consulted once, in 2024 |
| Reports results | To the foundation and its board | Not asked to report; not shown the reports |
| Can walk away and still exist next year | Yes; program is 0.01% of its budget | Yes as congregations; the pantries would lose 40% of their food budget |
The inventory is lopsided in almost every row. The network's one decisive asset is its space and its presence in the neighborhood: it reaches households Ridgeline cannot, and the congregations would exist without the program. Everything else, the money, the staff, the data, the rules and the reporting, sits with Ridgeline.
Placing the Arrangement on the Ladder
Arnstein (1969) arranged forms of citizen participation as a ladder of eight rungs, from nonparticipation through degrees of tokenism, informing, consultation and placation, up to degrees of citizen power, partnership, delegated power and citizen control. Her test for partnership was that power is actually redistributed through negotiation, with shared planning and decision-making responsibilities, often backed by the community side holding some resources of its own. On the inventory, the produce program sits at placation. The network has two seats on an eight-member advisory committee, which Ridgeline convenes, and its advice has been sought, but Ridgeline retains the right to decide. The committee advised adding culturally familiar produce and extending pickup hours to Saturday; Ridgeline accepted the first and declined the second, citing staffing, without a vote.
Calling the arrangement a partnership therefore places it two rungs above where the inventory puts it. The label is not dishonest in intent, since both parties like it, but it describes the relationship both want rather than the one that exists.
A Partner That Has Never Refused Anything
One fact in the record is more telling than the rest. In two years, the network has agreed to every change Ridgeline proposed: a new referral form, a revised produce list, a requirement to log pickups by patient identification number and a data-sharing agreement drafted by Ridgeline's counsel. A partner that has never refused anything has not yet been tested. It may agree because the changes are sensible, or because 40% of its pantries' food budget depends on Ridgeline and refusing feels unaffordable. The record cannot tell which, and that uncertainty is itself a finding. Israel et al. (1998), reviewing community-based research partnerships, identified shared control over decisions and resources among the core principles of genuine partnership, and an arrangement in which one party's agreement cannot be distinguished from dependence does not yet meet it.
The Larger Partner's Real Constraints
The analysis would be unfair if it treated Ridgeline as free to share power however it chose. Its constraints are real. The foundation awarded the grant to Ridgeline and holds Ridgeline accountable for spending and results, so Ridgeline cannot simply hand the money over. Privacy law limits what patient information it can share with the network without authorization, which explains part of the data row. Its board has a fiduciary duty for funds it receives. And its clinical protocol for eligibility exists partly because the program's outcome measures, blood sugar and blood pressure, are clinical. These constraints explain some of the inventory. They do not explain all of it: nothing in the grant, the law or the board's duties prevents Ridgeline from sharing aggregate results with the network, giving the network a vote on pickup hours or naming it as co-applicant when the grant is renewed next year.
What Would Move the Arrangement Up a Rung
Wallerstein and Duran (2010) argued that community-based participatory approaches strengthen interventions by drawing on community knowledge and shared ownership, which is what the program needs to reach hungry households that Ridgeline's intake questions never touch. Three changes would move the arrangement toward partnership without breaching Ridgeline's constraints: a co-application for the grant renewal, with a defined share of funds held and spent by the network; quarterly aggregate outcome reports delivered to the network in the same form given to the foundation; and one decision, such as pickup days and hours, placed under the network's control. The third is the real test. If Ridgeline cannot give the network a single decision it may make without Ridgeline's approval, the word partnership should come out of the brochure. The grant renewal next year is the natural moment to make all three changes, since the foundation is already asking how the program is governed.
References
Arnstein, S. R. (1969). A ladder of citizen participation. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35(4), 216-224. https://doi.org/10.1080/01944366908977225
Israel, B. A., Schulz, A. J., Parker, E. A., & Becker, A. B. (1998). Review of community-based research: Assessing partnership approaches to improve public health. Annual Review of Public Health, 19, 173-202. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.publhealth.19.1.173
Wallerstein, N., & Duran, B. (2010). Community-based participatory research contributions to intervention research: The intersection of science and practice to improve health equity. American Journal of Public Health, 100(Suppl. 1), S40-S46. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2009.184036
What the HCA 822 Topic 3 instructions ask for
HCA-822 Topic 3 asks doctoral learners to analyze a partnership between a health care organization and a community organization. Papers often accept the partnership label and describe the relationship as collaborative. The assignment rewards analyses that inventory resources and powers on each side, such as funding, staff, data, rules and the ability to exit, and then place the arrangement on a participation framework using that inventory. Learners should consider what a partner's consistent agreement may reveal, account fairly for the larger organization's real constraints and propose specific changes that would redistribute some decision-making power.
Inside the HCA 822 Topic 3 example
The finished analysis is unusually concrete about resources. It opens with a two-column list: who holds the grant, who employs the staff, who owns the data, who signs the lease, who can walk away and still exist next year. Arnstein's ladder is used as a measuring instrument rather than as a slogan, so the arrangement is placed on it and the placement is argued from the list. The example is careful with the word partnership, since an agreement in which one side sets the agenda, funds the work and reports the results is a contract with a friendly name. It also gives the larger partner's constraints honestly: a board, a regulator and a payer are pushing on it too. The finding is a rung, not a verdict on anyone's motives.
Where the marks sit in the HCA 822 Topic 3 rubric
GCU's rubric for the partnership analysis rewards counting power rather than naming it. Excellent analyses produce a side-by-side inventory and argue the arrangement's placement on a framework such as Arnstein's ladder from that evidence. Credit goes to noticing when a smaller partner's agreement cannot be distinguished from dependence. The rubric values treating the larger partner's constraints, such as grant terms and privacy law, as real while separating them from choices it could change. The highest level proposes concrete shifts in control and names a test that would show whether partnership is genuine.
HCA 822 Topic 3 help: mistakes that cost marks
Marks turn on whether power was counted or merely mentioned. Papers asserting that the relationship is collaborative, with no inventory behind the word, have accepted the label both parties prefer. Consultation described as shared decision making misplaces the arrangement by several rungs, and a reader who knows the ladder will notice immediately. Analyses in which the community organization has agreed to everything on offer have found their answer without seeing it, since a partner who has never refused anything has not yet been tested. Treating the health system as unconstrained ignores the board, the regulator and the payer that shape what it can give away. The heaviest deduction goes to a paper that ends in praise or blame, because a rung with a next step attached is what the topic can actually use.
Get an HCA-822 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send us the HCA-822 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric your section posted and whatever partnership, coalition or case the assignment gives you. We write a custom example against those criteria, with the resources itemized on both sides, the arrangement placed on Arnstein's ladder, the refusal test applied and the larger partner's constraints stated, in 24-48h. First one free.
More HCA 822 papers and DHA samples
- HCA 822 Topic 1: Three-role Obligation Brief
- HCA 822 Topic 2: Sourced Need Estimate
- HCA 822 Topic 4: Hiring and Purchasing Footprint Analysis
- HCA 822 Topic 5: Community Voice Dq Post
- HCA 822 Topic 6: Trust Repair Position Paper
- HCA 822 Topic 7: Shared Authority Partnership Charter
- HCA 822 Topic 8: Community Accountability Mechanism
- HCA 827 Topic 3: Payer Mix Exposure Study
- HCA 817 Topic 3: External Contribution Dossier
- HCA 812 Topic 3: Intent Standard Application
HCA 822 Topic 3 questions, answered
Is an unequal partnership automatically a bad one?
No. Resources are rarely symmetrical, and an arrangement can be lopsided and still be worth having for the smaller organization. What matters is whether the inequality is acknowledged in how the work is governed: who sets the agenda, who can stop a piece of work, and whether the smaller partner keeps anything of value when the funding ends. Unexamined inequality is the problem, not inequality.
Do I have to use Arnstein's ladder?
Your assignment decides that. Where it leaves the framework open, the ladder earns its place because it forces a placement rather than an adjective, and a placement is something a reader can dispute. Another framework works as well if you apply it with the same discipline: name the instrument, place the arrangement, and show which items in your inventory rule out the rung below.
How do I write this without accusing my own employer?
Describe the arrangement rather than the people, keep the composite far enough from your own site that nobody is identifiable, and hold the constraints on both sides in view. An analysis showing that a system with a board and a payer contract can concede less than it would like is not an accusation; it is the kind of finding a doctoral reader expects, and it is easier to defend than a complaint.
Where can I find a free HCA 822 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full analysis, with the arrangement, the inventory table, its placement on the ladder, the partner that never refused, the larger partner's constraints and what would move it up a rung. Describe your partnership for a free worked analysis.
Where does the program sit on Arnstein's ladder in HCA 822 Topic 3?
At placation. The food network holds two advisory seats and its advice is sought, but the health system decides; it accepted culturally familiar produce and declined Saturday pickup hours without a vote.