| Course | HIM 425 Principles of Health Care Administration and Leadership |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Management approach defense |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 425 Topic 8
What the Plan Leaves Alone, and Four Objections From the People Who Know the Work: A Management Approach Defense to Mariposa's Coding Team
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HIM-425: Principles of Health Care Administration and Leadership
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What the Plan Leaves Alone, and Four Objections From the People Who Know the Work: A Management Approach Defense to Mariposa's Coding Team
The Plan in Brief
Over the past year, the director of health information management at Mariposa Regional Hospital has developed four changes: a weighted productivity standard that replaces the records-per-day target; monthly accuracy audits for every coder, weighted toward each coder's weaker record types; a supervision plan for the eleven coders who work from home; and a budget request for two new inpatient coding positions and a documentation review tool. This defense is written for the coders, auditors and documentation specialists who will live with those changes, all of whom know the work in more detail than the director does. It is delivered at a department meeting and then circulated in writing.
What the Plan Leaves Alone
The plan does not touch code assignment. Which codes a record receives remains the decision of credentialed coders applying the official guidelines and coding advice, with disputes resolved by the auditors and, where necessary, by external review. No measure in the plan rewards a particular code, a case mix index or a payment outcome, and none will. The director will not set a target on any figure that depends on which codes are chosen, because a coder under such a target would face pressure to choose the higher-paying option wherever the record allows two readings. Stating this first matters, because every objection below is, at bottom, a worry that the plan reaches into the work itself.
Objection 1: Monthly Audits Feel Like Suspicion
Several coders said that auditing every coder every month signals distrust, particularly after years in which audits followed only complaints. The objection is fair about how the audits have been used before. The answer lies in how they will be used now. Every coder is audited, so being audited says nothing about any individual. Findings go first to the coder, with the guideline behind each correction, and are discussed with an auditor, not the supervisor. An accuracy result below 95% leads to coaching, not discipline, unless it persists after coaching. Edmondson (1999) found that teams whose members felt safe to admit errors and ask questions engaged in more learning behavior, and the audits are designed to be the kind of routine, shared feedback that makes errors discussable rather than dangerous.
Objection 2: The Weights Will Be Used Against Slower Coders
The senior inpatient coders worried that a weighted productivity standard would penalize careful coders who take longer on difficult records. The director conceded part of this during the design. The weights were built from the team's own timed samples, the coders reviewed them and a complex inpatient weight was added after the senior coders showed that long intensive care stays took far longer than average. Accuracy is measured separately and is never traded against productivity. The standard runs as a three-month trial that counts in no one's evaluation. Kerr (1975) warned that organizations often reward what is easy to count while hoping for something else, and the design keeps accuracy as a floor so that speed cannot buy down quality.
Objection 3: Remote Supervision Will Become Surveillance
Remote coders asked whether the supervision plan would bring keystroke logging or cameras on all day. It will not. The plan relies on information the work already produces, audit results and the workflow tool's record of when records are opened and closed, and on scheduled contact: a weekly huddle, monthly one-on-ones and an in-person quarterly meeting. Allen et al. (2015) found that telecommuting generally has small positive effects on performance and satisfaction, and the plan is built to keep those benefits by treating remote coders exactly as on-site coders are treated, measured by the same standards from the same tools.
Objection 4: The Budget Request Uses Our Work to Serve Finance
Some staff read the budget request, framed in cash, denials and audit exposure, as proof that the plan serves finance rather than the department. The framing is deliberate, because it is the language in which the request can be approved. The substance is the department's: the positions address the Monday backlog that coders have lived with for years, and the documentation tool directs reviews to the records most likely to cause the denials coders spend hours appealing. If the request is approved, the added capacity goes to the queue, not to a higher productivity target. The director has put that commitment in writing in the request itself.
What the Director Concedes She Does Not Know
The defense would be incomplete without the limits of the director's own judgment. She does not know whether the weights are right for every record type; the trial exists because she expects some to be wrong. She does not know whether monthly audits will feel like support or pressure once they are routine; the six-month review will ask the coders directly. She does not know whether the budget request will be approved, and if it is not, the Monday backlog will remain, and the plan's other parts will not fix it. Saying so is not modesty for its own sake. A team of specialists will trust a plan more when its author is clear about where it could fail, because they will be the first to see it fail.
What the Director Asks in Return
The plan asks three things of the team. First, report problems with the weights, the audits or the supervision mechanisms as they arise, rather than waiting for the six-month review. Second, hold the director to the commitments above, including the one to leave code assignment alone, by raising any instance where a measure seems to reach into coding decisions. Third, judge the plan by its results: inpatient records coded within three days of discharge, accuracy at or above 95%, queries back to their earlier level and no record past the billing window. If those results do not come, the plan will change, and the team will help decide how.
References
Allen, T. D., Golden, T. D., & Shockley, K. M. (2015). How effective is telecommuting? Assessing the status of our scientific findings. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 16(2), 40-68. https://doi.org/10.1177/1529100615593273
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350-383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378
The HIM-425 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The final topic of HIM-425 asks students to defend a management approach to the staff it affects. Many defenses restate the plan's benefits for the organization. The assignment rewards defenses written for an expert audience that first state what the manager will not decide, then take the strongest staff objections one at a time, concede what is fair in each and answer with specific design features and evidence. Students should draw on leadership and workplace research, acknowledge the limits of the manager's own judgment and ask the team to hold the manager to stated commitments and results.
How this HIM 425 Topic 8 example is built
The finished defense is written to be heard by specialists, and every section assumes an audience that knows the work in detail. It opens with the plan in brief: weighted productivity standards, monthly audits for every coder, a remote supervision schedule and a request for new positions. The director first states what the plan leaves alone, code assignment, which stays with the coders and the official guidelines. The core of the defense takes four objections as staff raised them in a composite meeting: that weighting will be gamed, that audits signal distrust, that remote monitoring is intrusive, and that management has promised positions before. Each objection gets a direct answer, a concession where one is due and a mechanism staff can check. The closing section sets a review point where staff evidence can change the plan.
Reading the HIM 425 Topic 8 rubric
GCU's rubric for the management defense rewards respect for expertise. Excellent defenses begin by limiting the manager's reach into technical decisions, which is what specialists most need to hear. Credit goes to objections stated in staff's own terms and answered with concrete features, such as coaching before discipline or trial periods. The rubric values research on psychological safety, incentives and telework used for specific claims. The highest level concedes what the manager does not know and invites the team to measure the plan by outcomes they care about.
HIM 425 Topic 8 help: mistakes that cost marks
Falling back on positional authority is the surest loss in a defense like this, since credentialed staff hear an order as a sign that the argument was weak. Drafts that answer objections the staff never raised, or restate the real ones in softer terms, show the audience that it was not listened to. Papers where the director claims coding expertise to settle a technical objection invite correction from the room. A defense conceding nothing reads as a sales pitch, while one conceding everything leaves no plan to defend. Some examples could be delivered to any department, with objections about change in general rather than about audits, weighting and remote monitoring. A defense with no review point asks staff to accept the plan permanently, which is the one request specialists almost always refuse.
Get an HIM-425 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-425 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the plan, department or scenario the assignment sets. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the management boundary drawn first, staff objections quoted and answered, concessions made where due and a review point set, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one costs nothing.
More HIM 425 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 425 Topic 1: Technical Manager Authority Paper
- HIM 425 Topic 2: Workload Staffing Model
- HIM 425 Topic 3: Productivity Standard Proposal
- HIM 425 Topic 4: Credential Maintenance Plan
- HIM 425 Topic 5: Invisible Function Dq Post
- HIM 425 Topic 6: Remote Coding Supervision Plan
- HIM 425 Topic 7: Executive Resourcing Case
- HIM 415 Topic 8: Data Quality Function Review
- HIM 370 Topic 8: Installed System Evaluation
- HIM 355 Topic 8: Procedure Code Audit Rebuttal
- HIM 200 Topic 8: Plain Language Records Policy
HIM 425 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why state first what management will not decide?
Because credentialed staff often arrive expecting the manager to reach into their technical work. Stating at the outset that code assignment and query wording stay with the coders removes that concern before the plan is discussed. The rest of the defense is then heard as a discussion about workload and resources, which is where staff generally accept that the manager holds the decision.
How should the defense handle an objection it cannot fully answer?
Name it as open and say what would settle it. A director who admits that weighted standards may need adjustment, and commits to reviewing them with coders after a set period, is more credible than one claiming the weights are already right. Staff can accept uncertainty when they see a mechanism for resolving it; they rarely accept confidence that has not been earned.
Can this be written as a presentation rather than a paper?
Yes, if your instructions allow or require it. The same sequence works as speaker notes or slides: boundary, plan, objections, concessions and review. A presentation still needs the objections in the staff's own words and a checkable answer for each, since those carry the argument. Check whether your classroom expects a recorded presentation, a slide file or a written defense before choosing a form.
Where can I find a free HIM 425 Topic 8 sample paper?
The complete defense is on this page, with the plan in brief, what it leaves alone, four objections answered, what the director concedes and what she asks in return. Share your plan and audience for a free worked defense.
What does the plan leave alone in HIM 425 Topic 8?
Code assignment. Coders applying the official guidelines decide codes, disputes go to auditors or external review, and no target is set on any figure that depends on which codes are chosen.