| Course | HIM 425 Principles of Health Care Administration and Leadership |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Productivity standard proposal |
| Length | About 980 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 425 Topic 3
Rewarding Short Charts, Hoping for Accurate Ones: A Productivity Standard Proposal to Replace Mariposa's Records-Per-Day Target
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HIM-425: Principles of Health Care Administration and Leadership
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Rewarding Short Charts, Hoping for Accurate Ones: A Productivity Standard Proposal to Replace Mariposa's Records-Per-Day Target
What the Old Standard Produced
For five years, Mariposa Regional Hospital's coders were measured against one target: 25 records a day, whatever the record. Coders worked from a shared queue and could choose what to open next. The results were predictable in hindsight. Coders chose short outpatient and emergency records, which count the same as an inpatient surgical stay and take a fraction of the time. Complex inpatient records aged in the queue, some past the hospital's internal billing window, and they were often coded in a rush at month-end by whoever was assigned to clear them. Physician queries fell by a third over two years, because a query holds a record open and slows the count. Accuracy on inpatient records, measured by the auditors, fell from 95% to 89%.
Kerr (1975) diagnosed this pattern long ago: organizations pay for what is easy to count and then are surprised when people pursue it. The old standard rewarded records opened and closed, and hoped for accurate, timely coding of the records that matter most.
The Proposal: A Small System of Measures
Table 1
The Proposed Productivity Standard
| Element | What it is | How it is used |
|---|---|---|
| Weighted productivity | Records converted to work units by type, using timed samples: an inpatient stay counts about 7.6 units, outpatient surgery 2.8, an emergency visit 1 and a professional fee claim 0.6 | Expected range of 70 to 80 units a day, reviewed monthly |
| Accuracy | Share of audited codes correct, from a monthly sample of each coder's work | Standard of 95%; below it triggers coaching, not a productivity adjustment |
| Query practice | Queries sent per 100 inpatient records, with the share answered and the share that changed codes | Monitored for patterns, with no target |
| Assignment rule | The workflow tool assigns the next record by age and type; coders cannot choose | Removes cherry-picking |
The proposal replaces the single target with three measures, each doing a different job, and one workflow rule that removes the choice that the old target exploited.
Why Each Part Is Designed This Way
The weights come from the department's own timed samples, not from an industry table, so they reflect Mariposa's documentation and tools. A unit is roughly five minutes of coding, and a coder working 6.5 productive hours produces about 78 units if every minute is coding, which is why the expected range sits slightly below that. Weighting removes the reason to prefer short records, and the assignment rule removes the opportunity.
Accuracy is measured separately and never traded against productivity. A coder who is fast and inaccurate is not rewarded for speed, and a coder who is accurate and slower is coached on pace, not penalized on quality. Narrow goals can lead people to hit the number at the expense of what it was meant to protect (Ordóñez et al., 2009), and keeping accuracy as a floor rather than a factor in a combined score prevents speed from buying down quality.
Queries get no target at all. A target on queries would invite unnecessary ones, which burden physicians and can be seen as leading; a ceiling would repeat the old problem. Instead, the auditors review the query rate monthly for patterns, such as a coder who never queries, and the share of queries that changed codes shows whether queries are well chosen.
How the Proposal Will Be Introduced
The coders reviewed the weights before the proposal was written, and two weights were changed after they showed that outpatient surgery records with implants took longer than the sample suggested. The standard will run for three months as a trial, during which no one's evaluation depends on it. Each coder will see their own weighted productivity, accuracy and query figures every week, and the department's figures in aggregate. At the end of the trial, the weights and range will be adjusted with the coders' input before the standard counts in evaluations. Coders who work remotely will be measured by the same standard, from the same workflow tool, so the standard does not depend on where anyone sits.
Objections the Coders Raised
The coders raised three objections during the review, and the proposal answers each. First, several worried that the assignment rule would give them a run of the hardest records in a day. The workflow tool now mixes record types within each coder's queue in proportion to the day's arrivals, so no one receives only inpatient stays. Second, remote coders asked whether the weighted measure would expose them to closer scrutiny than coders on site. It will not: the same tool measures everyone, and the weekly figures go to each coder before they go to the supervisor. Third, two senior inpatient coders argued that some inpatient stays, such as long intensive care admissions with many complications, take far longer than the 38-minute average. They are right, and the proposal adds a complex inpatient weight, about 14 units, applied when a stay exceeds ten days or includes more than one major procedure, with the auditors checking a sample of records given that weight to confirm it is used only where it belongs.
What Success Looks Like
The proposal will be judged on the problems it was built to solve, not on the measures themselves. Within six months, inpatient records should be coded within three days of discharge on average, inpatient accuracy should return to 95%, query volume should recover to at least its level before the old standard and no record should pass the internal billing window. If weighted productivity rises while any of those worsens, the standard is being gamed in a way not yet anticipated, and it will be revised. Locke and Latham (2002) found that specific goals improve performance when people are committed to them and understand them, and involving the coders in setting the weights is meant to earn that commitment.
References
Kerr, S. (1975). On the folly of rewarding A, while hoping for B. Academy of Management Journal, 18(4), 769-783. https://doi.org/10.2307/255378
Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation: A 35-year odyssey. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705-717. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.57.9.705
Ordóñez, L. D., Schweitzer, M. E., Galinsky, A. D., & Bazerman, M. H. (2009). Goals gone wild: The systematic side effects of overprescribing goal setting. Academy of Management Perspectives, 23(1), 6-16. https://doi.org/10.5465/amp.2009.37007999
Reading the GCU HIM 425 Topic 3 instructions
HIM-425 Topic 3 asks students to propose a productivity standard for health information staff. Many proposals set a single volume target. The assignment rewards proposals that begin by showing what the current standard produced, then build a small system of measures in which each measure has a distinct job, such as weighted productivity, accuracy and query practice, supported by workflow rules that remove opportunities for gaming. Students should ground weights in local timed data, explain why some behaviors should be monitored rather than targeted, involve staff in the design and define success by the outcomes the standard is meant to improve.
How the HIM-425 Topic 3 example is put together
The finished proposal replaces one target with a small system of measures. It opens with the problem the old standard created in the composite department: coders selected short outpatient records from a shared queue, complex inpatient stays aged past their billing window, and physician queries fell because each one slowed the count. The new standard weights each record type by the effort it takes, using the department's own timed samples, so an inpatient surgical stay and an emergency visit earn different credit. Accuracy comes from a monthly audit sample per coder, and the proposal states that neither measure is read without the other. A mix report shows the share of complex records each coder handled. Release of information staff receive a parallel standard weighted by request type, because a subpoena and a patient's own request are not the same work.
Reading the HIM 425 Topic 3 rubric
GCU's rubric for the productivity proposal rewards measures designed against gaming. Excellent proposals explain how the old target distorted behavior and cite goal-setting research on narrow measures. Credit goes to weighting work by effort from local data and keeping accuracy as a floor rather than a factor to trade. The rubric values leaving behaviors such as queries untargeted and removing record selection. The highest level incorporates staff objections into the design and judges the standard by timeliness, accuracy and query outcomes rather than by the productivity figure itself.
Common HIM 425 Topic 3 mistakes, and how to avoid them
A proposal that simply sets a new number has missed the assignment, which asks what a standard does to behavior; a number alone answers nothing. A records-per-hour target applied across all record types rewards the coder who avoids inpatient charts, and papers that miss this have not examined the distortion at all. Accuracy mentioned as an afterthought, with no audit sample or owner, gives the count all the weight in practice. Drafts that import a benchmark from another facility without timing the department's own work produce credits coders reject on sight. Some examples ignore physician queries, which fall quietly when every query slows the count and documentation gaps then reach the claim. Proposals written only for coders forget that release of information staff are measured too, and their requests vary just as widely.
Get an HIM-425 Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-425 Topic 3 instructions and the rubric posted in your classroom, with any current standard or data the assignment provides. We write a custom example to those criteria, with output weighted by record type, accuracy paired with every count, the old target's distortion documented and safeguards named, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HIM 425 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 425 Topic 1: Technical Manager Authority Paper
- HIM 425 Topic 2: Workload Staffing Model
- HIM 425 Topic 4: Credential Maintenance Plan
- HIM 425 Topic 5: Invisible Function Dq Post
- HIM 425 Topic 6: Remote Coding Supervision Plan
- HIM 425 Topic 7: Executive Resourcing Case
- HIM 425 Topic 8: Management Approach Defense
- HIM 415 Topic 3: Registry Submission Plan
- HIM 370 Topic 3: Interface Failure Analysis
- HIM 355 Topic 3: Root Operation Selection Analysis
- HIM 200 Topic 3: Retention Schedule Analysis
HIM 425 Topic 3 questions, answered
Why weight records instead of counting them?
Because records differ widely in the effort they take. A complex inpatient stay with several procedures can take many times longer than an emergency visit, so a flat count rewards whoever chooses the short ones. Weighting gives each record type credit in proportion to its measured effort, which lets a coder working the hard queue show the same productivity as one working the easy one.
How is coding accuracy usually measured?
Through an audit of a sample of each coder's completed records, reviewed by an auditor against the documentation and the official guidelines. Errors are often classified by effect, such as whether a code change altered the payment grouping, so a reviewer can separate serious errors from minor ones. The proposal names the sample, the reviewer and the classification rather than stating an accuracy target with no method behind it.
Can a standard be set without data?
It can be proposed without data but not justified without it. Where the assignment gives no volumes or timings, the proposal describes how the department would collect timed samples and labels its weights as illustrative. Presenting invented rates as measured facts is the weaker choice, since an instructor can see that the method is what matters and the numbers are placeholders.
Where can I find a free HIM 425 Topic 3 sample paper?
This page contains the full proposal, with what the old standard produced, the measures table, why each part is designed this way, how it will be introduced, coders' objections and what success looks like. Describe your standard for a free worked proposal.
Why do queries have no target in HIM 425 Topic 3?
A target would invite unnecessary or leading queries, and a ceiling would repeat the old incentive to avoid them. Auditors review query rates and the share that changed codes for patterns instead.