| Course | HIM 430 Data Governance |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Decision right failure analysis |
| Length | About 1,000 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Health Information Management |
| Updated | September 2026 |
Free sample paper for HIM 430 Topic 8
3,412 Versus 3,690: A Decision Right Failure Analysis of Two Discharge Counts That Should Have Matched
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
HIM-430: Data Governance
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
3,412 Versus 3,690: A Decision Right Failure Analysis of Two Discharge Counts That Should Have Matched
Two Numbers That Should Have Matched
For the second quarter, Tamarisk Health's finance report counted 3,412 inpatient discharges and its quality report counted 3,690. Both were presented at the same executive meeting, and the chief executive asked which was right and why they differed by 278. The finance count came from billed inpatient accounts in the revenue cycle system. The quality count came from discharges recorded in the admission, discharge and transfer system. This analysis reconciles the two, finds where they fork and asks the governance question the reconciliation raises: who decided each fork, and should they have?
The Reconciliation
Table 1
Where the Two Discharge Counts Fork
| Fork | Quality count | Finance count | Difference | Who settled it, and when |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Newborns | Includes 214 newborn discharges | Excludes newborns from the inpatient discharge figure | +214 to quality | A report writer in quality, when the report was built nine years ago |
| Transfers between Tamarisk's two hospitals | Counts 41 system transfers once, as one patient stay | Counts them twice, one account per hospital | -41 to quality | A finance analyst, following billing practice, six years ago |
| Observation stays converted to inpatient | Counts 105 conversions twice, because the transfer system created a new encounter at conversion | Counts them once, as one billed inpatient account | +105 to quality | An interface analyst, during a system upgrade four years ago, without knowing reports depended on it |
| Net | +278 to quality |
Each Fork Was Settled, but by the Wrong People
None of the forks was an error in the ordinary sense. Each count followed a rule consistently. The newborn rule reflected a choice about whether healthy newborns are patients to be counted, a choice quality's report writer made reasonably and that finance made the other way for equally good reasons. The transfer rule followed billing practice, in which each hospital bills its own stay. The observation rule was not a choice at all: an interface analyst configured the transfer system to open a new encounter at conversion, to solve a problem with bed assignment, and did not know that any report counted discharges from those encounters.
The failure is that each fork was settled by someone who held the query or the system at the time, not by anyone with the right to decide what an inpatient discharge means for Tamarisk. Khatri and Brown (2010) described data governance as assigning decision rights across domains, including the meaning of data. The three forks show what happens without such an assignment: decisions about meaning are made anyway, by whoever is closest, one at a time, and no one knows the sum of them until two reports collide in front of executives.
What the Wrong Number Had Already Affected
Before the reconciliation, each count had been used for decisions. Quality's higher count, inflated by doubled observation conversions, had lowered its reported readmission and mortality rates slightly, since the extra discharges enlarged the denominators; the effect was under a tenth of a percentage point, but it had appeared in board reports for four years. Finance's count, doubled for internal transfers, had overstated the system's discharges in a regional market share report sent to a payer during contract negotiations. And staffing ratios for case management, calculated per discharge from the quality count, had understated case managers' workload in the units that convert many observation patients. None of these effects was large, and none was anyone's fault. Each was a consequence of numbers carrying meanings their users did not know, which is the risk governance exists to manage.
The Resolution Under the Governance Model
Under the operating model adopted earlier in this course, the definition of an inpatient discharge belongs to the encounters domain, owned by the vice president of revenue cycle, but it crosses into quality and clinical reporting, so it went to the governance council. The council decided three things. Newborn discharges are counted separately and never combined with adult and pediatric discharges in a single figure; each report shows both with labels. Transfers between Tamarisk's hospitals are counted once at the system level and once per hospital at the hospital level, and every report states which level it uses. Observation stays converted to inpatient are counted once, as inpatient stays, and the interface configuration was changed so that conversion updates the existing encounter instead of opening a new one. The steward drafted glossary entries for each, and the decision log records the reasons.
What Would Have Prevented It
Two features of the governance model would have prevented the collision. The business glossary would have required a single approved definition of an inpatient discharge before either report used the term, so the newborn and transfer choices would have been made once, deliberately, and labeled. And the change control rule that custodians may not alter how data are recorded in a way that changes meaning without a steward's review would have caught the interface change before it doubled the conversions. Weber et al. (2009) argued that governance must fit an organization's structure, and Tamarisk's structure, with separate finance and quality reporting teams drawing on different systems, is exactly the kind in which undecided meanings multiply. The DAMA body of knowledge describes metadata management as essential to consistent reporting across systems (DAMA International, 2017), and the glossary is Tamarisk's version of it.
The reconciliation took two analysts four days. A single decision, made once, would have taken an hour of a council meeting. The difference is the cost of decisions made by default.
A Check Going Forward
The governance office now runs a quarterly reconciliation of the discharge count between the two systems, with an expected difference of zero after the newborn and transfer labels are applied. Any difference is logged as a data quality issue for the encounters steward. The first run after the changes found a difference of three, all from late charge corrections that moved accounts between quarters, which the steward documented as a known timing rule rather than a new fork.
References
DAMA International. (2017). DAMA-DMBOK: Data management body of knowledge (2nd ed.). Technics Publications.
Khatri, V., & Brown, C. V. (2010). Designing data governance. Communications of the ACM, 53(1), 148-152. https://doi.org/10.1145/1629175.1629210
Weber, K., Otto, B., & Ă–sterle, H. (2009). One size does not fit all: A contingency approach to data governance. Journal of Data and Information Quality, 1(1), Article 4. https://doi.org/10.1145/1515693.1515696
The HIM-430 Topic 8 assignment instructions
The final topic of HIM-430 asks students to analyze a data failure as a failure of decision rights. Many analyses treat mismatched figures as report errors. The assignment rewards analyses that reconcile the conflicting numbers to specific forks, show that each count followed a consistent rule and identify who settled each fork and when. Students should explain why those people lacked the right to decide, trace what decisions the numbers had already influenced, describe how the governance model resolves the forks and what it would have prevented, and set a check that keeps the counts aligned.
Inside the HIM 430 Topic 8 example
The finished analysis begins with two numbers that should have matched. The finance report counted billed inpatient accounts; the quality report counted discharges recorded in the admission, discharge and transfer system. Reconciliation finds three forks: patients moved from observation to inpatient status, newborns counted separately or not, and transfers between the system's own hospitals counted once or twice. Each fork had been settled, but by the analyst building each report, reasonably and differently. The analysis then reads the governance charter, which created a council and a steward network yet gave no role authority over encounter and discharge definitions. That gap, not the report logic, is named as the cause. The corrective action assigns the decision right, publishes the definition with its variants and places the element under change control, then tests the fix on the next contested element.
Reading the HIM 430 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty grading the failure analysis reward locating the failure in decision rights. Excellent analyses reconcile the numbers precisely and show that each report was internally correct. Credit goes to identifying who settled each fork, including technical changes made without knowledge of reporting impact. The rubric values tracing downstream effects of the wrong numbers and resolving the forks through the governance model. The highest level shows which governance features would have prevented the collision and installs a recurring reconciliation.
HIM 430 Topic 8 help before you submit
Stopping at reconciliation is the most frequent shortfall here, since explaining the arithmetic of a gap says nothing about why nobody prevented it. Diagnosing the cause as a report error blames the analysts, who made reasonable choices no one had authorized anyone to make. Drafts proposing a single data source as the cure make the numbers agree while every definitional choice stays unowned. Papers that never examine the governance documents cannot show which decision right was missing, so the central finding never appears. Some examples blame the council for inaction when the charter never gave it authority over the element. A correction that names an owner without publishing the definition or placing it under change control repairs this failure and leaves the next one waiting, which an instructor checks by asking about the next element.
Get an HIM-430 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the HIM-430 Topic 8 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and any failure, reports or governance documents the assignment supplies. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the disagreement reconciled, each fork attributed, the missing decision right identified in the charter and a tested correction, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More HIM 430 papers and BS in Health Information Management samples
- HIM 430 Topic 1: Decision Rights Diagnosis
- HIM 430 Topic 2: Stewardship Role Charter
- HIM 430 Topic 3: Contested Definition Brief
- HIM 430 Topic 4: Data Quality Policy
- HIM 430 Topic 5: Definition Conflict Dq Post
- HIM 430 Topic 6: Classification and Access Policy
- HIM 430 Topic 7: Governance Operating Model
- HIM 425 Topic 8: Management Approach Defense
- HIM 415 Topic 8: Data Quality Function Review
- HIM 200 Topic 8: Plain Language Records Policy
- HIM 370 Topic 8: Installed System Evaluation
HIM 430 Topic 8 questions, answered
Why not treat this as a report error?
Because both reports were built correctly to definitions their builders chose. Each analyst made a defensible call about observation patients, newborns and transfers; they simply made different ones. Calling that an error points toward retraining analysts, who did nothing wrong. The analysis treats it as a governance failure because the real problem is that nobody had the authority to make those choices for everyone.
What if the scenario supplies no figures?
Then the analysis describes each fork and the direction of its effect without inventing any. Where a scenario does give two totals, the reconciliation divides the gap among the forks using only the numbers supplied, and adds none of its own. The argument rests on locating the missing decision right, and that finding holds whatever the size of the gap.
How does this differ from a process failure analysis?
A process failure analysis follows an error through the steps that produced it and redesigns those steps. This analysis asks a different question: whether anyone had the authority to settle the choice that caused the disagreement. The fix it reaches is an assignment of authority and a published definition, not a changed workflow. If your instructions ask for both perspectives, the process can be addressed briefly after the governance finding.
Where can I find a free HIM 430 Topic 8 sample paper?
The failure analysis is reproduced in full, covering the two numbers, the reconciliation, who settled each fork, what the wrong numbers affected, the resolution, what would have prevented it and a check going forward. Send your mismatched figures for a free worked analysis.
Why did the counts differ by 278 in HIM 430 Topic 8?
Quality included 214 newborns and counted 105 observation conversions twice, while finance counted 41 internal transfers twice, for a net difference of 278.