MGT 420 Topic 2 attribution error case analysis example

Organizational Behavior and Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 420 Topic 2 sample paper examines two explanations for a sales representative's missed quarter and the attribution error behind each. It belongs to GCU MGT 420, Organizational Behavior and Management, listed as MGT-420 in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management program. A regional manager blames lost drive; the representative blames three large accounts moved to a national team. The manager's view fits the fundamental attribution error and the representative's may be self-serving, so the paper asks what each could see. The review form, which asks mostly about personal traits, is examined too. Records on consensus, consistency and distinctiveness settle the dispute in the representative's favor.

CourseMGT 420 Organizational Behavior and Management
TopicTopic 2
Paper typeAttribution case analysis
LengthAbout 990 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 420 Topic 2

1

Lack of Drive or a Lost Territory? Two Attribution Errors Behind One Missed Sales Quarter, and the Review Form That Invites Them

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-420: Organizational Behavior and Management

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title sets the manager's explanation against the representative's and points to the review form as a third party to the dispute. The company, its people and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Lack of Drive or a Lost Territory? Two Attribution Errors Behind One Missed Sales Quarter, and the Review Form That Invites Them

Two Accounts of One Outcome

At a composite distributor of commercial cleaning supplies, territory representative Avery Collins finished the third quarter at 71 percent of quota after three years above 100 percent. In the quarterly review, the regional manager wrote that Avery "has lost drive and is coasting." Avery's response, written in the employee comments section, was that the result came from a territory change in July, when three of Avery's largest accounts, two hospital systems and a school district, were moved to a new national accounts team.

Both accounts are plausible. This analysis identifies the error each person may be making, asks why each was positioned to make it and lists the evidence that would settle the dispute.

The Manager's Error

The manager's explanation is dispositional: the cause lies in Avery's motivation. People judging others' behavior tend to overweight personal traits and underweight the situation, a tendency Ross (1977) called the fundamental attribution error. The manager's account fits the pattern. It names a trait, drive, and makes no mention of the territory change, even though the manager approved it.

Why was the manager positioned to make this error? The manager sees Avery's results on a dashboard that shows each representative's percentage of quota, ranked. The dashboard does not show territory changes, account transfers or the revenue history of the accounts each representative now holds. The manager rides along with each representative twice a year and has not visited Avery's territory since the change. What the manager sees is a number falling, attached to a name.

What this page is doingThe paper names the manager's error and then explains what in the manager's position made it likely, which is more useful than calling the manager biased.
3

The Representative's Error

Avery's explanation is situational: the cause lies in the territory. People explaining their own failures tend to attribute them to external causes and their successes to themselves, a pattern described as self-serving attribution (Miller & Ross, 1975). Avery's account may fit that pattern too. It explains the shortfall entirely by the transfer and says nothing about Avery's own activity.

Avery was also positioned to make this error. Avery sees the territory every day and feels the loss of the three accounts directly, but rarely sees other representatives' numbers. Avery does not know whether colleagues who also lost accounts in July recovered faster, which is exactly the comparison that would test the claim.

The Review Form

The quarterly review form contributes to the dispute. Its five rated items are initiative, attitude, communication, product knowledge and results against quota. Four of the five ask about the person; only one asks about outcomes, and none asks about the conditions under which the outcomes were produced. A form built this way invites dispositional answers. A manager filling it in for a representative who missed quota is led to look for a personal cause, because the form has no place to record a situational one.

Avery's comments box is the only place a situational explanation can appear, and it is filled in by the person with the most obvious reason to offer one, which makes it easy for the manager and the human resources reviewer to discount.

The dashboard and the form together create a pattern. A number falls, the form asks about initiative and attitude, and the manager fills in the boxes with the only explanation the form allows. Neither tool is designed to mislead, but both narrow what the manager considers.

Evidence That Would Settle It

Kelley (1973) suggested that people judge causes by looking at whether a behavior is distinctive to a situation, consistent over time and shared by others in the same situation. Those three questions translate into evidence the company can gather.

1. Consensus: did other representatives who lost large accounts in the July reorganization also fall below quota? Four others did; if their results fell by a similar amount, the territory explanation gains strength.

2. Consistency: did Avery's activity change? Call logs, visit counts and new-account proposals from the CRM for the quarters before and after July show whether Avery worked less.

3. Distinctiveness: how did Avery do on the accounts Avery kept? If sales to retained accounts held steady or grew, the drop is likely explained by the lost ones.

4. The arithmetic of the transfer: what share of Avery's prior-year sales came from the three transferred accounts? If they made up about 30 percent of sales, a fall to 71 percent of an unchanged quota is roughly what the transfer alone would produce.

What the Evidence Showed

The company's records answered all four questions. The three transferred accounts had produced 31 percent of Avery's sales the previous year, and Avery's quota had not been adjusted after the transfer. The four other representatives who lost accounts in July finished between 68 and 79 percent of quota. Avery's call and visit counts were level with prior quarters, and sales to retained accounts rose 4 percent. The evidence supports Avery's account and not the manager's. It also does not suggest Avery did anything special to offset the loss, which the self-serving account had implied by omission.

The finding does not make the manager careless or Avery blameless. It shows that each person's view was shaped by what their position let them see, and that the organization's tools reinforced the manager's view rather than correcting it.

What the Review Process Needs to Show

The dispute arose because the review process could not show the situation. Three changes would fix that. Quotas should be adjusted when accounts move, with the adjustment recorded on the dashboard. The review form should include a section on conditions, such as territory changes, product shortages or pricing changes, completed by the manager before the person is rated. And reviews of results below quota should include a comparison with representatives who faced the same conditions, so consensus information is in front of the reviewer rather than in an employee's comment that is easy to dismiss.

What this page is doingThe conclusion changes the process that produced the error rather than settling the individual case alone, so the next review is less likely to repeat it.
4

References

Kelley, H. H. (1973). The processes of causal attribution. American Psychologist, 28(2), 107-128. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0034225

Miller, D. T., & Ross, M. (1975). Self-serving biases in the attribution of causality: Fact or fiction? Psychological Bulletin, 82(2), 213-225. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0076486

Ross, L. (1977). The intuitive psychologist and his shortcomings: Distortions in the attribution process. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 10, 173-220. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(08)60357-3

Reading the GCU MGT 420 Topic 2 instructions

The Topic 2 instructions in MGT-420 ask students to analyze competing explanations for a work outcome using attribution theory. Deciding who is right by intuition misses the purpose. The assignment rewards an analysis that names the attribution error each party may be making, explains why each was positioned to make it and examines how organizational tools, such as review forms and dashboards, shape the explanations people reach. Students should identify evidence that could settle the dispute, ideally organized around consensus, consistency and distinctiveness, report what that evidence shows and recommend changes to the review process so that situational causes are visible before people are judged.

Inside the MGT 420 Topic 2 example

The paper opens with the two accounts of the missed quarter. The manager's dispositional explanation is examined first, with the dashboard identified as the reason the territory change was invisible. The representative's situational explanation is examined next as a possible self-serving attribution. A section shows how the review form, with four of five items about the person, invites dispositional answers. Kelley's three questions are turned into four pieces of evidence, including the share of sales lost with the transferred accounts. The results support the representative, and three changes to the review process close the paper. The evidence is reported with its limits, since it supports one account without proving the other wrong.

Where the marks sit in the MGT 420 Topic 2 rubric

Instructors grading the attribution analysis reward both errors named and explained by each person's vantage point. Strong papers show what the manager could and could not see, and why the employee might overweight external causes, without taking a side too early. Credit goes to examining the review form as a contributor and to turning attribution theory into evidence the organization can actually gather. The rubric values reporting what that evidence shows, including any doubt it leaves. The highest band recommends process changes that make situational information part of every review. Analyses that simply side with the manager or the employee usually land in the lower bands. Clear headings for each account also help a reader follow the argument.

MGT 420 Topic 2 help before you submit

Naming the fundamental attribution error and moving on forfeits most of the analysis credit, because recognizing the label is the easy part and the topic asks where the error came from. Cases analyzed from one side only miss that both parties to a review typically err, in opposite directions. Treating perception errors as carelessness or prejudice turns a systematic pattern into a moral failing and suggests the fix is better people. Ignoring the appraisal instrument overlooks a structural source of distortion sitting in plain view. Listing every bias from the textbook dilutes the analysis; three well-located errors are more convincing than nine mentioned. Recommendations to be more objective cannot be implemented, where a change to what the review form asks or what data reaches the rater can.

Get an MGT-420 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-420 Topic 2 instructions, your section's rubric and the case or review scenario you were given. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the errors on both sides named, each traced to what its author could see, the review form examined and the settling evidence listed, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 420 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 420 Topic 2 questions, answered

Why does the manager's position produce the attribution error?

Because managers usually see outcomes without seeing the conditions that produced them. A dashboard shows a missed quota but not the reassigned accounts, the delayed product or the vacancy on the support desk. With the situation invisible, the person becomes the most available explanation. The error follows from the information the role provides, which is why better data changes it more reliably than good intentions.

Is the employee's explanation just an excuse?

Not necessarily. Self-serving attribution means people credit themselves for success and blame circumstances for failure, but circumstances sometimes are to blame. The analysis should test the employee's claim with the same evidence used to test the manager's, rather than assuming either account is right. Treating both as hypotheses is what makes the case analysis fair to both parties.

How many perception errors should the analysis cover?

As many as the case actually contains, which is usually two to four. Each one should be located in a specific statement, traced to the position of the person making it and matched to evidence that could correct it. Listing every bias your textbook describes, most of which do not appear in the case, weakens the paper by making the real findings harder to see.

Where can I find a free MGT 420 Topic 2 sample paper?

Both accounts of the missed quarter, the two errors, the review form, the evidence list, what the records showed and the process changes are all here. If your case involves a different dispute, send the details and a free version can be written for it.

What settles the dispute in MGT 420 Topic 2?

The records: the transferred accounts produced 31 percent of the representative's sales, four colleagues who lost accounts also fell short, activity was steady and sales to retained accounts rose 4 percent.