MGT 420 Topic 3 expectancy chain diagnosis example

Organizational Behavior and Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MGT 420 Topic 3 sample paper diagnoses a claims team described as unmotivated by testing each link of Vroom's expectancy chain. It was prepared for GCU MGT 420, Organizational Behavior and Management, catalog code MGT-420, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Business Management. The team of fourteen adjusters closes about 21 claims a day regardless of effort, because the queue empties before the shift ends on 81 percent of days. The first link fails before rewards are even reached. Goal-setting and equity checks add smaller problems. The paper names work allocation, owned by operations planning, as the system to fix and advises against a cash incentive for now.

CourseMGT 420 Organizational Behavior and Management
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeMotivation diagnosis
LengthAbout 950 words, 4 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Business Management
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MGT 420 Topic 3

1

Effort That Cannot Move the Number: An Expectancy Chain Diagnosis of a Claims Team Described as Unmotivated, and the System That Owns the Broken Link

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MGT-420: Organizational Behavior and Management

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the finding, that effort cannot change the measured result, and promises to name who is responsible for fixing it. The insurer, its team and every figure are an illustrative composite; the sources are real.
2

Effort That Cannot Move the Number: An Expectancy Chain Diagnosis of a Claims Team Described as Unmotivated, and the System That Owns the Broken Link

The Complaint

The claims operations director at a composite regional property and casualty insurer describes one of her teams as unmotivated. The team of fourteen adjusters handles auto glass and minor collision claims, and its throughput, measured as claims closed per adjuster per day, has stayed flat at about 21 for a year while the director has tried a monthly spotlight award, a team lunch for good weeks and a pep talk at every huddle. The director wants to know whether a cash incentive would work.

Before recommending any incentive, this diagnosis turns the complaint into three testable questions, drawn from expectancy theory (Vroom, 1964). Motivation to put in effort depends on whether people believe effort will raise their performance, whether performance will bring outcomes and whether they value those outcomes. If any link is broken, effort falls, and a fix aimed at a different link will not help.

What this page is doingThe paper converts a vague complaint about motivation into three questions that can each be checked against the workplace.
3

Why Expectancy Theory

Expectancy theory was chosen because it treats motivation as a chain of beliefs about the workplace, which makes each link a claim that can be checked against records and observation. It has a long research record: a meta-analysis of studies testing the theory found modest but consistent relationships between its components and measures of effort and performance (Van Eerde & Thierry, 1996). It is not the only lens, so two others, goal setting and equity, are used below as checks.

Link One: Does Effort Change Measured Performance?

This link was tested first because the director's proposals all assume it holds. The claims system assigns work through a central queue. Each adjuster receives the next claim only after closing or pending the current one, and new claims enter the queue at a rate set by incoming volume, not by how fast adjusters work. Queue reports for the past twelve months show that on 81 percent of working days the queue emptied before the end of the shift. On those days, an adjuster who worked faster simply waited longer for the next claim.

Adjusters know this. In short interviews, ten of fourteen said some version of "there's no point rushing; the queue runs dry by two." Their belief is accurate. On most days, extra effort does not raise claims closed per day, because the number of claims available caps it.

This is the broken link. The throughput figure the director watches is controlled mainly by incoming volume divided among fourteen people, not by individual effort.

Link Two: Does Performance Bring Outcomes?

Even if effort could raise throughput, would higher throughput change what adjusters receive? The spotlight award goes to the adjuster with the highest monthly count, but the winner has rotated among the same four senior adjusters, who receive the most complex claims and are allowed to pull from a second queue. Annual raises are set by tenure bands with a small merit range that, according to human resources data, varied by less than one percentage point across the team last year. The link from performance to outcomes is weak.

Link Three: Do Adjusters Value the Outcomes?

The outcomes on offer are recognition at a huddle and a team lunch. In the interviews, adjusters said they valued schedule flexibility and the chance to handle more complex claims, which leads to promotion to senior adjuster, more than either. A cash incentive would likely be valued. But it would attach to a broken first link.

Two Checks From Other Theories

Goal setting. Specific, challenging goals generally lead to higher performance than vague exhortations to do one's best (Locke & Latham, 2002). The team's goal is "keep throughput up," which is neither specific nor within the adjusters' control. That is a second problem, but it shares a root with the first: a goal set on a number the adjusters cannot move would not motivate even if it were specific.

Equity. People compare what they put in and get out with what others put in and get out, and perceived unfairness reduces effort (Adams, 1965). Three adjusters mentioned that the four seniors can pull from a second queue and therefore post higher counts. That perception may contribute, but the queue data explain the flat throughput without it.

Which System Owns the Broken Link

The broken link belongs to the work-allocation system, which the operations planning team designs, not to the adjusters' character and not to the reward system. A cash incentive tied to throughput would pay out according to incoming claim volume and would mostly reward the senior adjusters with access to the second queue. It would cost money without changing effort, and it would probably worsen the equity problem.

The fix starts with the queue. If operations planning gives every adjuster access to the second queue of more complex claims once their primary queue is empty, effort above the minimum would produce more closed claims and more experience with complex work, which the adjusters say they value. The performance measure could then change from claims per day to a weighted measure that counts complex claims more heavily. Only after effort can move the measure does it make sense to revisit rewards.

What this page is doingThe diagnosis ends by naming which organizational system owns the broken link, which tells the director whose decision the fix requires.
4

Conclusion

The team is not short of motivation in any sense a pep talk or a bonus could fix. Its members correctly believe that working harder does not change the number they are judged by, because the queue sets the pace. Repairing that first link is a job for operations planning. The director should hold off on a cash incentive until it has been repaired, and then test whether throughput, measured in a way effort can move, responds.

References

Adams, J. S. (1965). Inequity in social exchange. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 2, 267-299. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0065-2601(08)60108-2

Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (2002). Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation: A 35-year odyssey. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705-717. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.57.9.705

Van Eerde, W., & Thierry, H. (1996). Vroom's expectancy models and work-related criteria: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 81(5), 575-586. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.81.5.575

Vroom, V. H. (1964). Work and motivation. Wiley.

The MGT-420 Topic 3 assignment instructions

MGT-420 Topic 3 asks students to diagnose a motivation problem using a recognized theory. Recommending an incentive because effort seems low misses the analysis. The prompt rewards a diagnosis that turns the complaint into testable questions, such as whether effort changes measured performance, whether performance changes outcomes and whether people value those outcomes, and checks each against records and interviews. Students should explain why they chose the theory, cite research on its support, check the diagnosis against other theories such as goal setting and equity, and name which organizational system owns the broken link so the right people can fix it.

Inside the MGT 420 Topic 3 example

The diagnosis opens with the director's complaint and the incentive she is considering. A short section explains the choice of expectancy theory and its research support. The first link is tested against twelve months of queue reports and adjuster interviews, showing that the queue, not effort, sets throughput. The second link examines who wins awards and how raises are set. The third asks what adjusters value. Goal-setting and equity checks follow. The final sections name work allocation as the owner of the broken link, explain why a throughput bonus would backfire and propose giving all adjusters access to the second queue. Each link is reported with the source that tested it, so a reader can see what the verdict rests on.

MGT 420 Topic 3 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty grading the expectancy diagnosis reward links tested in order with evidence from the workplace. The strongest papers find which link breaks first and show why fixes aimed at later links would fail. Credit goes to explaining the choice of theory and citing its research record, and to using other theories as checks rather than as a list of definitions. The rubric values naming the system that owns the broken link, since that tells the manager whose decision the fix requires. The highest band advises against a tempting solution with reasons and proposes what to change first. Diagnoses that jump straight to incentives usually lose points. Interview quotes used as evidence should be short and tied to a specific link.

MGT 420 Topic 3 help before you submit

Explaining low effort as a motivation deficit in the people concerned costs the most, since it restates the complaint and leaves the reward system unexamined. Reciting the expectancy formula without testing each link against the case shows recall of a model rather than use of it. Treating every theory in the chapter as equally established misreports the research, and the rubric generally rewards a reason for choosing one account over another. Diagnoses that examine rewards but never ask whether effort can move the measure miss the break that occurs most often in routinized work. Ignoring equity comparisons overlooks a cause that operates even when the chain is intact. Conclusions calling for motivational initiatives, such as recognition events, treat a structural break as a morale problem.

Get an MGT-420 Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the MGT-420 Topic 3 instructions, the rubric posted in your classroom and the case or workforce your section described. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each link from effort to reward tested, goals and fairness checked as rivals and the broken link assigned to the system that owns it, back in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MGT 420 papers and BS in Business Management samples

MGT 420 Topic 3 questions, answered

Why use expectancy theory rather than a needs-based model?

Because its links can be tested against a case, and it has held up reasonably well in research, whereas hierarchies of needs have little empirical support for their ordering. Expectancy theory also points straight at organizational systems, since each link depends on measurement, reward allocation or reward design. Your section may require other theories as well; the diagnosis can use them as rivals to test.

What if employees simply do not care about the rewards?

Then the third link is broken, and the diagnosis should say which rewards fail and why. A bonus paid a year later may matter little to people who value schedule flexibility now. That remains a finding about the organization, not a judgment of the employees, because the organization chose what to offer and can choose to offer something else instead.

Can the chain be intact and motivation still low?

Yes. Effort may reliably produce performance and performance may reliably produce valued rewards, yet employees can still withdraw effort if they believe comparable colleagues are rewarded more for the same work. Equity comparisons and unclear goals operate alongside the chain, which is why the diagnosis checks them before concluding. Finding the chain intact is itself a useful result.

Where can I find a free MGT 420 Topic 3 sample paper?

Every part of the claims team diagnosis appears above, from the complaint and the choice of theory through all three links, the two checks, the system that owns the problem and the conclusion. Share your team's situation, and we can prepare a free diagnosis of it.

Which link breaks in MGT 420 Topic 3?

The first one. The central queue sets the pace and runs dry before the end of the shift on most days, so working harder does not raise claims closed, and adjusters know it.