| Course | MGT 460 Workforce Planning |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Succession bench review |
| Length | About 970 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BS in Business Management |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for MGT 460 Topic 6
Names With Evidence Beside Them: A Succession Bench Review of Twelve Plant Positions, Five With No One Ready and One Candidate Carrying Two Slates
[Author Name]
Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University
MGT-460: Workforce Planning
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
[Date]
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Names With Evidence Beside Them: A Succession Bench Review of Twelve Plant Positions, Five With No One Ready and One Candidate Carrying Two Slates
Why Evidence Matters on a Slate
Northfield Foods, a composite snack food manufacturer, keeps a succession list for twelve key positions at its main plant, from plant manager to quality assurance manager. The list names possible successors for each position and rates them as ready now, ready in one to two years or ready in three or more years. What it does not record is why anyone was given those ratings. In practice, readiness ratings on many succession lists reflect a manager's impression of a person rather than what the person has done (Rothwell, 2015).
This review adds an evidence column. For each name, it records what the person has actually done that bears on the target role: covered it during an absence, made its budget decisions, led its response to a line shutdown or managed its people. A rating without evidence is marked as such. All names and results are illustrative.
The Slates
Table 1
Succession Slates With Evidence
| Position | Ready now | Ready in 1 to 2 years | Evidence for leading candidate | Bench strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plant manager | 1 | 1 | Operations manager covered for 6 weeks during plant manager's leave; ran budget review | Two or more |
| Operations manager | 2 | 0 | Both production managers have run the plant's daily meeting and weekend operations | Two or more |
| Production manager, line A | 1 | 1 | Shift supervisor led line A through a 3-day changeover | Two or more |
| Production manager, line B | 1 | 0 | Shift supervisor; covered 2 weeks | Single |
| Maintenance superintendent | 1 | 0 | Senior planner led the response to a 14-hour line shutdown | Single, shared |
| Plant engineer | 1 | 0 | Same senior planner; managed two capital projects | Single, shared |
| Quality assurance manager | 1 | 0 | Lab supervisor led last FDA inspection response | Single |
| Safety manager | 0 | 0 | None identified | None |
| Warehouse and logistics manager | 0 | 1 | Shipping lead; no budget experience yet | None ready |
| Human resources manager | 0 | 0 | Generalist has 1 year of experience | None ready |
| Controller | 0 | 1 | Senior accountant; has not closed a quarter alone | None ready |
| Sanitation manager | 0 | 0 | None identified | None |
Table 1 summarizes the review for each position, with the strongest evidence for the leading candidate.
The slates were reviewed with each position's current incumbent and with the plant manager. Incumbents were asked to give one example of what each named successor had done that showed readiness, and where they could not, the rating was lowered or marked as unsupported.
What the Bench Shows
Three positions, plant manager, operations manager and production manager for line A, have two or more credible successors. Four rest on a single name: production manager for line B, maintenance superintendent, plant engineer and quality assurance manager. Five have nobody ready within two years: safety, warehouse and logistics, human resources, the controller and sanitation.
The evidence column changed several ratings from the original list. The original list had rated the shipping lead as ready now for warehouse and logistics manager; the evidence shows strong operational experience but no budget or staffing decisions, so the review moves that rating to one to two years. Two names on the original list for safety manager had no evidence at all beyond their manager's recommendation, and the review records them as unrated rather than ready.
The five empty slates are not equally urgent. The safety manager and controller are the most pressing, because the plant cannot operate legally without a qualified safety lead and cannot close its books without a controller. The sanitation and human resources roles could be covered temporarily by corporate staff if they fell vacant.
The Overlap
The review caught a problem the original list hid. The only ready-now candidate for maintenance superintendent, the senior maintenance planner, is also the only ready-now candidate for plant engineer. On the original list, both positions looked covered. In reality, one resignation would empty both slates, and if both incumbents left in the same period, only one position could be filled internally. Counting names position by position, without checking whether the same name appears twice, overstates the bench.
The overlap was found by sorting the slates by candidate name rather than by position. Every succession review should include this step, because a name that appears on several slates is a single point of failure for all of them.
Development Actions
Each gap gets an action with an owner and a date.
1. Plant engineer: the plant manager will identify a second candidate from the engineering team and assign that person the next capital project, beginning in the first quarter, so that the senior planner is not the only option for both roles.
2. Quality assurance manager: the lab supervisor will be paired with a second technician who will lead the next internal audit, owned by the current quality manager, by June.
3. Safety manager: the HR manager will recruit externally for an assistant safety manager this year, since no internal candidate has the required certification.
4. Controller: the controller will have the senior accountant close two quarters under supervision before year-end.
5. Warehouse and logistics manager: the operations manager will give the shipping lead responsibility for the warehouse budget for one quarter.
Succession planning works best when it is tied directly to development experiences that build readiness, rather than kept as a separate list reviewed once a year (Groves, 2007).
How Often to Review
The bench should be reviewed twice a year, and the evidence column updated as people complete the actions above. Positions with no ready successor should be reviewed quarterly until at least one name has evidence behind it. Where the internal bench cannot be built in time, the plan should say so and prepare for external hiring, since relying on an empty slate is itself a decision (Cappelli, 2008).
References
Cappelli, P. (2008). Talent on demand: Managing talent in an age of uncertainty. Harvard Business Press.
Groves, K. S. (2007). Integrating leadership development and succession planning best practices. Journal of Management Development, 26(3), 239-260. https://doi.org/10.1108/02621710710732146
Rothwell, W. J. (2015). Effective succession planning: Ensuring leadership continuity and building talent from within (5th ed.). AMACOM.
What the MGT 460 Topic 6 instructions ask for
The Topic 6 instructions for MGT-460 ask students to assess an organization's succession bench. Listing names with readiness ratings is not enough when nobody can say what the ratings rest on. The assignment rewards a review that records evidence for each candidate, such as covering the role, making its decisions or leading through a crisis, and adjusts ratings where evidence is missing. Students should summarize bench strength across positions, check for candidates who appear on more than one slate, set development actions with owners and dates for the gaps, and decide how often the bench should be reviewed and what happens where no internal successor exists.
How this MGT 460 Topic 6 example is built
The review opens by explaining what the existing list lacks and adds an evidence column. Table 1 shows twelve positions with readiness counts, evidence for the leading candidate and bench strength. A section summarizes the three groups of positions and shows how evidence changed several original ratings. The overlap section explains that one senior planner is the sole successor for two positions. Five development actions follow, each with an owner and a date, supported by research on linking succession to development. A closing section sets review frequency and the fallback of external hiring. The original list's ratings are shown beside the revised ones where they changed.
MGT 460 Topic 6 rubric: what Excellent looks like
Instructors grading the bench review reward readiness ratings tied to evidence of what candidates have done. Strong reviews adjust ratings where evidence is missing and explain why. Credit goes to checking for names that appear on several slates, since that reveals single points of failure. The rubric values development actions with owners and dates, prioritized by which empty slates matter most. The highest band sets a review schedule and acknowledges when external hiring is the honest answer. Reviews that repeat a list of names and ratings without evidence usually lose marks. Showing which original ratings changed, and why, also earns credit.
MGT 460 Topic 6 help before you submit
Bench reviews typically lose their marks at the evidence column. A slate listing names in readiness bands, with nothing saying what any candidate has done, records managers' optimism and tends to rate people as more ready than they are. Counting the same person on several slates inflates bench strength, and markers look for that overlap because real organizations make the error constantly. Reviews that rank positions by title rather than by vacancy cost often spend their attention on the executive team and miss a technical role that would stop production. Single-successor positions treated as covered overlook that one resignation turns them into empty benches. Development actions without owners or dates are intentions. The review also weakens when it never says how often it will be repeated, since readiness changes as people move.
Get an MGT-460 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the MGT-460 Topic 6 instructions, the rubric from your classroom and any organization or position list the assignment provides. A custom example is written to those criteria, with key positions justified, readiness bands, evidence for each candidate, overlaps caught and development actions dated, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More MGT 460 papers and BS in Business Management samples
- MGT 460 Topic 1: Planning Horizon Memo
- MGT 460 Topic 2: Headcount Demand Forecast
- MGT 460 Topic 3: Internal Supply Projection
- MGT 460 Topic 4: Build Buy Borrow Comparison
- MGT 460 Topic 5: Critical Role Dq Post
- MGT 460 Topic 7: Multi-year Workforce Cost Model
- MGT 460 Topic 8: Freeze-tested Workforce Plan
- MGT 455 Topic 6: Economic Order Quantity Problem
- MGT 440 Topic 6: Risk Register with Triggers
- MGT 434 Topic 6: Corrective Action Record
- BUS 317 Topic 6: Budget Commitment Review
MGT 460 Topic 6 questions, answered
What is bench strength in succession planning?
The number and readiness of internal candidates able to step into a key position. A deep bench has several people ready now or soon; a thin bench has one or none. Measuring it position by position shows where the organization is exposed, and counting each candidate only once, even when they appear on several slates, keeps the measure honest.
How should readiness be judged?
By what the candidate has done that the role requires: acting in the position, handling its decisions, managing its crises, or being evaluated against its demands. A manager's belief that someone could do it is a starting point, not evidence. The example downgrades candidates whose readiness rests on impression alone, which is where most succession lists are overly generous.
Why focus on positions with only one successor?
Because they look covered and are not. A single candidate may leave, decline the role or be needed elsewhere, and the position then has no successor at all. Positions with no successor are at least visible as gaps. Single-successor positions hide their risk, which is why the review isolates them and assigns development to widen each bench.
Where can I find a free MGT 460 Topic 6 sample paper?
The plant review is above in full, with the evidence table, what the bench shows, the overlap, the development actions and the review schedule. Share the positions you are reviewing, and a free bench review can be prepared for them.
What overlap does MGT 460 Topic 6 find?
The only ready-now candidate for maintenance superintendent is also the only one for plant engineer. One resignation would empty both slates, and only one position could be filled internally.