MKT 315 Topic 5 positioning dq post example

Introduction to Marketing Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MKT 315 Topic 5 sample paper holds a discussion post whose claim is simple: every positioning statement shuts out whoever it was not written for, and it shows this with a composite family hardware store. It answers a prompt in GCU MKT 315, Introduction to Marketing, catalog code MKT-315, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Marketing. The statement targets homeowners attempting first repairs, with staff who explain the fix. Three shoppers are left out by name: the contractor buying by the case, the confident self-server and the flyer-comparing bargain hunter. The reply rewrites a classmate's coffee shop statement so it excludes the rush-hour commuter.

CourseMKT 315 Introduction to Marketing
TopicTopic 5
Paper typePositioning discussion post
LengthAbout 450 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Marketing
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 315 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

A Position Excludes Whoever It Was Not Written For: A Hardware Store's Statement and the Three Shoppers It Leaves Out

Initial Post

A positioning statement excludes whoever it was not written for, and a statement that excludes nobody has not taken a position. Ries and Trout (2001) described positioning as what a brand does to the mind of the prospect, and a mind can only hold a clear idea if the idea is narrow enough to be remembered.

Here is a statement for a composite family hardware store, in the four-part form our text uses: target, frame of reference, point of difference and reason to believe (Kotler & Armstrong, 2021). For homeowners attempting their first repairs, the store is the neighborhood hardware store where staff explain how to do the fix, not just sell the part, because every floor employee has completed a hands-on repair course and walks customers to the aisle.

Three shoppers should read that and feel unaddressed. The contractor buying fasteners by the case wants the lowest price per box and no conversation; the store cannot match warehouse pricing and should not try. The confident do-it-yourselfer who knows exactly what they need may find staff attention slow; the store accepts that this shopper will often go to a big-box store. The bargain hunter comparing weekly flyers is chasing discounts the store will not run, because its value is advice rather than price.

Adopting the statement would change the store, not just its signage. It would mean training every floor employee, staffing more people on Saturday mornings when first-time fixers come in, and dropping the bulk pricing tier the store added last year to compete for contractors. If the store would not make those changes, the statement is a slogan rather than a position.

Reply to Jordan

Jordan, I like that your coffee shop statement names a specific neighborhood and that you lead with quality, since your shop's single-origin beans are a real point of difference. My concern is that great coffee for everyone in the neighborhood rules nobody out, so it is hard to see what the shop would do differently because of it.

What if the statement excluded the commuter who wants a fast drink on the way to the train? For people who want to sit and taste coffee made with care, your shop is the neighborhood cafe that brews every cup to order, because every barista is trained to dial in each bean. That version gives up the rush-hour grab-and-go customer, which is a real cost, but it tells your staff why the line moves slowly and why that is fine. It also gives you a reason to skip the drive-up window idea you mentioned.

References

Kotler, P., & Armstrong, G. (2021). Principles of marketing (18th ed.). Pearson.

Ries, A., & Trout, J. (2001). Positioning: The battle for your mind (20th anniversary ed.). McGraw-Hill.

What the MKT 315 Topic 5 instructions ask for

MKT-315 Topic 5 asks students to discuss what a positioning statement includes and leaves out. A strong post answers the question in its first sentence, writes a statement in the standard four-part form of target, frame of reference, point of difference and reason to believe, and names the customers it excludes with the reason for each. Students should cite the reading on positioning and explain what the business would have to change to live up to the statement. The reply should credit what works in a classmate's statement and then propose a specific exclusion that would turn it into a position.

How this MKT 315 Topic 5 example is built

The finished post opens with a direct answer: a positioning statement excludes whoever it is not written for, and a statement that excludes nobody has not taken a position. The hardware store's statement follows, aimed at homeowners attempting their first repairs and promising staff who explain the fix, not only sell the part. The post then names three shoppers the statement leaves out on purpose: the contractor buying fasteners by the case, who wants the lowest price per box; the confident shopper who finds staff attention slow; and the bargain hunter comparing flyers. Each gets a sentence on why the store is better off without courting them. The reply engages a classmate whose coffee shop statement promised great coffee for everyone, and proposes one customer that statement could exclude to make it mean something.

Where the marks sit in the MKT 315 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward a post whose exclusions are the answer. An Excellent post opens with the claim that a position excludes someone and cites Ries and Trout. Credit goes to a four-part statement for the hardware store with each part filled in. The rubric values naming the contractor, the confident shopper and the bargain hunter with a reason for each. Strong posts state the staffing and pricing changes the statement would require. Top marks go to a reply that rewrites the classmate's statement to exclude one group.

MKT 315 Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks

General answers are the usual casualty in this discussion: saying a statement excludes the wrong customers, without naming any, restates the question. Posts that write a positioning statement and never test it leave the central claim untouched. A statement that promises quality, service and value at once is the familiar weak version, since every competitor says the same and no shopper is turned away by it. Confusing positioning with a slogan produces a catchy line with no target or reason to believe. Replies that praise a classmate's statement without testing its exclusions add length and little else, and faculty in many sections read them as participation only. Missing the citation to the assigned reading costs marks as well, because discussion rubrics typically ask for one.

Get an MKT-315 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-315 Topic 5 discussion question and the rubric from your classroom, with the brand or business your section is using. We write a custom example to those instructions, with the positioning statement in standard form, the excluded customers named, the operational consequence stated and a classmate reply that tests exclusions, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 315 papers and BS in Marketing samples

MKT 315 Topic 5 questions, answered

What are the parts of a positioning statement?

Most introductory texts use four: the target customer, the frame of reference or category the offering competes in, the point of difference that sets it apart, and a reason to believe that difference. Filling each part precisely is what makes exclusions visible, because a narrow target and a specific difference each leave somebody out.

Does excluding customers mean losing them?

Some of them, yes, and that is accepted as the price of being chosen by others. The hardware store will sell fewer boxes of screws to contractors once it stops competing on bulk price. What it gains is a reason for first-time repairers to drive past the big-box store, which a statement aimed at everyone could never supply.

What makes a good reply in this discussion?

One that tests the classmate's statement against the same question the post answered: whom does it leave out? Pointing out that a statement excludes nobody, then offering a version that excludes one named group, moves the thread forward. Agreement alone, or a restatement of the classmate's idea, usually earns little in discussion rubrics at this level.

Where can I find a free MKT 315 Topic 5 sample paper?

The post and its reply appear here in full: the answer, the hardware store's statement, the three shoppers left out, what adopting it would change and the reply that rewrites a classmate's statement. Paste in your section's prompt and the first post we draft for it is free.

Who does the hardware store exclude in MKT 315 Topic 5?

The contractor buying fasteners by the case, who wants the lowest price per box; the confident shopper who finds staff attention slow; and the bargain hunter comparing flyers. The store values advice over price.