MKT 462 Topic 5 incrementality dq post example

Digital Marketing and Advertising Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

In this MKT 462 Topic 5 sample paper, a discussion post contends that most bookings credited to a composite regional moving company's branded search ads were witnessed rather than caused, and a classmate's defense of the ads is answered below it. It was written for GCU MKT 462, Digital Marketing and Advertising, catalog code MKT-462, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Marketing. Branded search reports about 11 dollars per dollar, but people typing the name already intend to book and the free listing sits just below. The post cites the eBay experiment and proposes a four-week pause in two matched regions.

CourseMKT 462 Digital Marketing and Advertising
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeIncrementality discussion post
LengthAbout 470 words, 1 pages
FormatDiscussion post, APA 7 citations
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Marketing
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 462 Topic 5

1

Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply

Witnessed, Not Caused: Why a Moving Company's Best-Returning Ads Probably Produced Few of the Bookings They Report

Initial Post

My verdict: most bookings credited to our composite regional moving company's branded search ads were witnessed by the ads, not caused by them. The figures are illustrative, but the logic is general.

Branded search ads appear when someone types the company's own name. People who do that already know the company and are usually looking for it. The company's free listing sits directly below the ad, so when a searcher clicks the ad, that click often replaces one that would have landed on the free listing at no cost. The ad was present at the booking, and the report credits it, but the booking would likely have happened anyway.

That explains why branded search reports about 11 dollars in bookings per dollar spent, the highest return in the account. The figure measures who was searching, people already intending to book, rather than what the ad did. Any ad shown only to people about to buy will report a high return.

There is strong evidence for this. Blake et al. (2015) ran a large field experiment at eBay in which brand-keyword search ads were switched off. Most of the traffic those ads had been credited with arrived through the free search results instead, so the ads' true effect was a small fraction of what the reports showed. They also found that paid search worked better for new and infrequent users, who did not already know where they were going.

My proposal is to find out rather than argue. Pause branded search ads for four weeks in two of the company's regions, matched to two others on past bookings and season, and compare total bookings, from every source, across the four regions. If bookings in the paused regions hold up, most of the reported return was witnessed. One caution: if a competitor starts bidding on the company's name during the pause, the ad may protect bookings, and the test should note any such bidding.

Reply to Jamie

Jamie, you argue that we should keep branded search because its return is so high, and that cutting the best channel makes no sense. I understand the appeal, and I agree that turning it off without evidence would be a mistake, which is why I propose a test rather than a cut. Where I differ is on what the 11-dollar figure measures. A return calculated from bookings that follow a click includes bookings that would have happened without the click. Even with experiments, advertising returns are notoriously noisy to estimate (Lewis & Rao, 2015), and without one we cannot know how much of the 11 dollars is real. If the pause shows little change in bookings, would you still want to keep the full budget there?

References

Blake, T., Nosko, C., & Tadelis, S. (2015). Consumer heterogeneity and paid search effectiveness: A large-scale field experiment. Econometrica, 83(1), 155-174. https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA12423

Lewis, R. A., & Rao, J. M. (2015). The unfavorable economics of measuring the returns to advertising. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 130(4), 1941-1973. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjv023

The MKT-462 Topic 5 assignment instructions

MKT-462 Topic 5 asks students to distinguish advertising that causes sales from advertising that is merely present. A strong post gives its verdict first, explains the mechanism by which a high reported return can reflect who sees the ad rather than what it does, and cites field-experiment evidence. Students should propose a practical test with matched comparison and note what could complicate it. The reply should acknowledge the classmate's concern, explain what the reported return actually measures and end with a question about acting on the test's result.

Inside the MKT 462 Topic 5 example

The verdict arrives before any evidence: most bookings credited to the mover's branded search ads were witnessed, not caused. The evidence follows, all figures illustrative. People typing the company's own name already know it, and the mover's free listing sits directly below the ad, so a click on the ad often replaces a click that would have landed anyway. Branded search reports about eleven dollars in bookings per dollar spent, the highest return in the account, and the post explains that the figure measures who was searching rather than what the ad did. It cites the large eBay field experiment by Blake, Nosko and Tadelis, in which pausing brand-keyword ads sent most of that traffic through free results instead. The post then proposes a short pause in two matched regions to find out.

Where the marks sit in the MKT 462 Topic 5 rubric

Faculty reward a post that separates the witness from the cause. An Excellent post opens with its verdict and explains how a brand ad replaces a free click. Credit goes to reading the 11-dollar return as a measure of who was searching. The rubric values Blake, Nosko and Tadelis's eBay experiment, including its finding for new users. Strong posts propose a four-week pause in matched regions measured on total bookings and flag competitor bidding. Top marks go to a reply that answers a defense of the high return with Lewis and Rao.

Common MKT 462 Topic 5 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Posts that accept platform-reported return as proof of effect lose the most here, because the question exists to separate a channel's presence at a conversion from its contribution to it. Declaring branded search worthless is the opposite error, and markers commonly reward the post that says when brand ads do earn their cost, such as when rivals bid on the name. Many drafts define incrementality correctly and never apply it to a specific channel with a specific number. Citing a study without saying what it measured, or stretching it into proof that search ads fail, weakens an otherwise sound post. A test proposed with no comparison group, simply pausing everywhere and watching, leaves seasonality free to explain the result. Replies that accept a classmate's return figure without asking who was being targeted add little to the thread.

Get an MKT-462 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-462 Topic 5 discussion question and the rubric shared in your classroom, with the channel or scenario your section named. We write a custom example to those instructions, with a verdict in the opening line, intent separated from effect, evidence cited accurately, a test with a comparison group and a classmate reply, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 462 papers and BS in Marketing samples

MKT 462 Topic 5 questions, answered

What is incrementality in digital marketing?

The share of results that would not have happened without the marketing activity. If a campaign is credited with 1,000 sales and 700 of those buyers would have purchased anyway, its incremental effect is 300. Platforms report the first figure; only a comparison between people or places that received the activity and similar ones that did not can estimate the second. The example's proposed pause is a small version of that comparison.

Do branded search ads ever pay off?

Sometimes. If competitors bid on a company's name, its own ad may be needed to keep those searchers from clicking a rival. Brand ads can also carry a promotion or a phone number the free listing lacks. What the evidence questions is the reported return, which counts bookings from people who were already looking. A regional pause is how the example proposes to learn which situation the mover is in.

Why is retargeting's reported return so high?

Because retargeting shows ads to people who have already visited the site, and recent visitors are far more likely to buy than the public at large. Many of them would have returned and purchased without another ad, and the platform credits the ad for those purchases all the same. A holdout, in which some eligible visitors are deliberately not shown the ads, is the usual way to measure how much of the return is real.

Where can I find a free MKT 462 Topic 5 sample paper?

The discussion post and reply appear here: the verdict, why brand ads witness bookings, the 11-dollar figure explained, the eBay evidence, the proposed test and the reply to a classmate. Tell us your course's discussion question and we will prepare the first post for it at no cost.

Why might the branded ads still matter in MKT 462 Topic 5?

Where a rival bids on the company's name, its ad can appear above the free listing and draw searchers away. The test notes any such bidding, because there the brand ad protects bookings.