MKT 433 Topic 1 sales manager role analysis example

Sales Management Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This MKT 433 Topic 1 sample paper analyzes what went wrong when a composite industrial-supply distributor promoted its best seller to manage a district of eight. It was written for GCU MKT 433, Sales Management, catalog code MKT-433, in the Grand Canyon University BS in Marketing. Her week shows about 28 of 50 hours on customer calls, one observing sellers and none recruiting for a territory vacant two months, while the district slid from 97 to 91 percent of plan. Her 1.4 million dollars of personal sales is treated as a cost, and the analysis proposes a 45-hour calendar built around coaching and one-on-ones.

CourseMKT 433 Sales Management
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeSales manager role analysis
LengthAbout 1,010 words, 2 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramBS in Marketing
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for MKT 433 Topic 1

1

Her Best Deals Now Count as a Cost: Separating a Promoted Top Seller's Habits From the Sales Manager's Actual Work

[Author Name]

Colangelo College of Business, Grand Canyon University

MKT-433: Sales Management

Topic 1 Role Analysis

[Instructor Name]

[Date]

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the analysis's central claim about the promotion. The distributor, the manager and every figure are a composite; the sources are real.
2

Her Best Deals Now Count as a Cost: Separating a Promoted Top Seller's Habits From the Sales Manager's Actual Work

The Case

A composite industrial-supply distributor promoted its best seller, Renee, to manage a district of eight salespeople. For six years she had led the company in sales, and her customers trusted her. Two quarters after the promotion, the district reached 97 percent of plan in the first quarter and 91 percent in the second. Renee personally closed about 1.4 million dollars of business in those two quarters, about 18 percent of the district's total, including the three largest deals. This analysis treats the promotion as a case about two different jobs rather than a story about one person, and asks what the district manager's job requires that the seller's did not. All figures are illustrative.

What She Actually Did

Renee's calendar for a typical week, reconstructed from her schedule and expense reports, shows where about 50 working hours went. About 28 hours were customer calls and meetings, most of them with accounts she had served as a seller, often without the assigned seller present. About 9 hours went to approving expenses, pricing exceptions and other administration. Internal meetings took about 7 hours. Forecasting took about 3 hours, mostly compiling the numbers sellers sent her. Coaching, in the sense of working with a seller on a specific skill, took about 2 hours. Observing sellers on their own calls took about 1 hour. Recruiting took none, although one territory had been vacant for two months.

What the Role Requires

Sales management texts describe the manager's work through a set of functions: recruiting and selecting salespeople, organizing and deploying them across territories and accounts, training and coaching them, motivating them through pay, recognition and goals, and forecasting and evaluating results (Johnston & Marshall, 2016). Zoltners et al. (2008) described the same idea as a set of drivers of sales force effectiveness, including who is hired, how they are developed, how they are deployed and how they are managed, and argued that first-line managers sit at the center of all of them.

Table 1

Management Functions Against a Typical Week

FunctionWhat the role requiresHours in Renee's weekGap
Recruiting and selectionFill the vacant territory; build a bench of candidates0Vacancy two months old
DeploymentAssign accounts and territories so each seller has a full, fair loadLittle; she kept key accounts herselfSellers lose their largest accounts to the manager
Training and coachingObserve calls; work on one skill per seller3 including observationUnder half an hour per seller a week
MotivationSet goals, recognize progress, manage payWithin admin timeNo regular one-on-one meetings
Forecasting and evaluationJudge each deal and each seller's pipeline3, compiling onlyNumbers passed up without judgment
Personal sellingNot a core function28Most of the week

Table 1 sets each function against Renee's week.

Why Her Sales Now Count as a Cost

As a seller, every deal Renee closed was output. As a manager, every hour she sells is an hour the district goes unmanaged. Her 1.4 million dollars of sales is real revenue, but it came with costs that do not appear beside it. Eight sellers received almost no coaching. The vacant territory stayed empty, losing an estimated 300,000 dollars of sales a quarter. And by taking over the largest deals, Renee taught her sellers that big accounts belong to the manager, which reduces their incentive to develop them. The district's slide from 97 to 91 percent of plan is consistent with these costs.

This is a common pattern when a top seller is promoted: the skills that made her successful pull her back toward selling, especially when results slip and she feels she can fix them herself. The analysis does not suggest she was a poor choice. It suggests that the job changed and her calendar did not.

What Good Coaching Would Look Like

Coaching is not the same as telling a seller what to do. Kluger and DeNisi (1996) found in a large review that feedback improves performance on average but actually reduces it in about a third of cases, particularly when it focuses on the person rather than the task. Coaching that works focuses on a specific behavior observed on a real call. That requires the manager to be present on the seller's calls, as an observer rather than the lead, which is the activity Renee's week almost entirely lacked.

What the Company Could Have Done

Part of the problem lies with the distributor rather than with Renee. She received no training for the new role, kept the same commission-heavy pay plan with an override on district sales, and was told by her own manager to make sure the big accounts were not lost in the transition. Each of these signals pointed her back toward selling. A better transition would have included a short program on coaching and forecasting before she started, a pay plan weighted toward district results and seller development, and an explicit handover plan moving her former accounts to sellers over her first quarter, with joint calls to protect the relationships.

A Calendar She Could Keep

The analysis proposes a weekly calendar that reflects the role. About 12 hours of field time riding with sellers, observing rather than leading. About 8 hours of one-on-one meetings, one hour with each seller, covering pipeline and one development goal. About 4 hours reviewing and judging the district forecast. About 4 hours on recruiting until the vacancy is filled. About 6 hours of joint calls on key accounts, always with the assigned seller leading. About 6 hours of administration, and about 5 hours of internal meetings. The total is about 45 hours, with personal selling limited to the joint calls.

The change will feel like a loss at first, because Renee's own deals will shrink and the district's results may not improve for a quarter. The analysis recommends that the regional director judge her on the district's results over a year, not on her personal sales, and say so to her directly.

References

Johnston, M. W., & Marshall, G. W. (2016). Sales force management: Leadership, innovation, technology (12th ed.). Routledge.

Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254-284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254

Zoltners, A. A., Sinha, P., & Lorimer, S. E. (2008). Sales force effectiveness: A framework for researchers and practitioners. Journal of Personal Selling & Sales Management, 28(2), 115-131. https://doi.org/10.2753/PSS0885-3134280201

Reading the GCU MKT 433 Topic 1 instructions

Topic 1 in MKT-433 asks students to distinguish the work of a sales manager from the work of a salesperson. Strong analyses reconstruct what the manager in the case actually does with her time, set it against the functions sales management texts describe, such as recruiting, deployment, coaching, motivation and forecasting, and identify the gaps. Students should explain why personal selling becomes a cost once someone manages others, describe what effective coaching looks like with evidence, consider what the company did to cause the problem and propose a realistic weekly calendar.

How this MKT 433 Topic 1 example is built

A promotion is treated here as a case, not as a story about one person. The analysis lists what the new district manager did in a typical week, reconstructed from her calendar: most hours on customer calls, some on expense approvals, almost none observing her eight sellers. It then sets out what the role requires, drawing on the functions most sales management texts name, recruiting and selecting salespeople, organizing and deploying them across territories, training and coaching, motivating through pay and recognition, and forecasting and evaluating results. Each function is matched against the calendar, and the gaps are plain. The analysis argues that her personal sales, however large, now count as a cost, since every hour she sells is an hour the district goes unmanaged. It closes with a proposed weekly calendar she could realistically keep.

MKT 433 Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward an analysis that separates two jobs with evidence. An Excellent paper reconstructs the manager's week in hours and sets it against each function in a table. Credit goes to Johnston and Marshall's functions and Zoltners, Sinha and Lorimer's effectiveness drivers. The rubric values treating her 1.4 million dollars of sales as a cost of an unmanaged district. Strong papers cite Kluger and DeNisi on feedback and name the company's own signals that pulled her back to selling. Top marks go to a 45-hour calendar she could keep and a year-long basis for judging her.

MKT 433 Topic 1 help: mistakes that cost marks

Analyses that describe the manager as a super-seller, the person who closes the hard deals, give up the largest share of credit, since the topic asks what changes when the job becomes other people's selling. A list of management functions with no evidence of how time is actually spent reads as a textbook summary. Drafts often praise the manager's personal sales figures without noticing that they hide the team's decline. Recruiting is frequently left out entirely, although the people a manager hires set the limits on everything the district can do later. Blaming the individual, as though she lacked leadership qualities, skips the structural point that the firm promoted her into a different job. Recommendations such as better time management, naming no specific change to the week, end the paper without a usable answer.

Get an MKT-433 Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the MKT-433 Topic 1 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with the company or case your section assigned. We write a custom example to them, with the manager's actual time reconstructed, the management functions set against it, personal selling treated as a cost and a redesigned week proposed, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More MKT 433 papers and BS in Marketing samples

MKT 433 Topic 1 questions, answered

How does a sales manager's work differ from a salesperson's?

A manager works through other people. A salesperson's output is their own deals; a manager's output is the combined result of a team they hire, assign, coach and forecast for. Time a manager spends selling is time not spent on those tasks. Most sales management texts organize the role around recruiting, deploying, developing, motivating and evaluating the sales force.

Is it wrong to promote the best salesperson?

Not necessarily, but it is a bet that the skills transfer, and often they do not. Closing deals rewards personal effort and control, while managing rewards patience and a willingness to let others handle accounts imperfectly. The example does not argue against the promotion. It argues that the firm should have described the new job clearly and judged her by the team's results.

Why include recruiting in a role analysis?

Because it is the manager's function with the longest reach. A poor hire can take a year to show and longer to replace, and every quota, territory and coaching plan afterward is limited by who is on the team. The example notes that the manager filled one vacancy by hiring the candidate who most resembled her, which becomes part of the analysis.

Where can I find a free MKT 433 Topic 1 sample paper?

The role analysis appears here complete: the case, what she actually did, what the role requires, why her sales count as a cost, what good coaching looks like, what the company could have done and a calendar she could keep. Describe the manager in your case and we will analyze the role at no cost.

Why are her sales a cost in MKT 433 Topic 1?

Every hour she sells is an hour eight sellers go uncoached, a territory stays vacant and big accounts move away from her team. The district's fall from 97 to 91 percent of plan is consistent with those costs.