NRS 445 Topic 5 qualitative appraisal example

Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NRS 445 Topic 5 sample paper appraises Sun and colleagues' 2020 phenomenological study of 20 nurses caring for patients with COVID-19 in a negative pressure ward. It was prepared for GCU NRS 445, Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice, catalog code NRS-445, a core course of Grand Canyon University's RN to BSN. Design is checked against the question. Purposive sampling and recruitment are examined. Repeated interviews of 40 to 60 minutes are analyzed with Colaizzi's method. Lincoln and Guba's four trustworthiness criteria are applied, the quotations are tested against the themes and a verdict is reached with the limits of transfer to a community hospital stated, using the CASP checklist.

CourseNRS 445 Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice
TopicTopic 5
Paper typeQualitative study appraisal
LengthAbout 1,040 words, 5 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramRN to BSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NRS 445 Topic 5

1

Appraising a Phenomenological Study of Nurses Caring for Patients With COVID-19: Design, Sampling, Trustworthiness and Transfer to a Community Hospital

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NRS-445: Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice

Topic 5 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

September 21, 2026

What this page is doingThe title names the design being appraised and the four questions the appraisal will answer, ending with the one that matters most to a working nurse: whether the findings travel to a different hospital. A reader knows this is a judgment of one study rather than a summary of the pandemic literature, which is the distinction the rubric for this topic is built on.
2

Appraising a Phenomenological Study of Nurses Caring for Patients With COVID-19: Design, Sampling, Trustworthiness and Transfer to a Community Hospital

The Study and Whether Its Design Fits Its Question

The study appraised here is Sun et al. (2020), which set out to explore the psychological experience of nurses caring for patients with COVID-19 in a hospital in Henan Province, China, in the first weeks of the outbreak. Its question is about lived experience: what caring for these patients felt like and how nurses coped. The authors chose a phenomenological design and analyzed interviews using Colaizzi's seven-step method, which moves from significant statements to formulated meanings, clustered themes and an exhaustive description of the phenomenon (Colaizzi, 1978).

The pairing of question and design is sound. A question about how an experience is lived cannot be answered well by a survey that fixes the categories in advance, because the categories are what the study is trying to find. Phenomenology asks participants to describe the experience in their own words and looks for the structure shared across those descriptions (Polit & Beck, 2021). A reader should therefore judge this study by the standards of phenomenology, rich description, closeness to participants' words and a defensible path from statements to themes, rather than by the standards of a trial.

What this page is doingThe appraisal names the design before judging anything and identifies the specific analytic method, because phenomenology answers to different expectations than ethnography or grounded theory. The second paragraph judges the fit between question and design and then states which standards the rest of the appraisal will apply. That sets up every later criterion and prevents the most common error, judging a qualitative study as if it were a failed experiment.
3

Sampling and Recruitment

The researchers used purposive sampling and enrolled 20 nurses who had entered the negative pressure ward and cared for patients with confirmed COVID-19 between January 20 and February 10, 2020 (Sun et al., 2020). Seventeen were women and three men, aged 25 to 49, with 1 to 28 years of experience, and three were head nurses. Recruitment continued until no new topics emerged, which the authors report as data saturation.

For this design, a purposive sample of 20 is not a weakness to be excused. Twenty nurses chosen because they had actually worked inside the isolation ward could describe the experience; twenty nurses chosen at random from the hospital could not, because most of them would never have entered it. Randomness serves generalization to a population, and generalization is not the aim of phenomenology. The sample's limits lie elsewhere. Every participant held a bachelor's degree and worked at one hospital, and all were volunteers, so nurses who declined to join, perhaps those struggling most, may be missing. The authors acknowledge the single site and a nurse-only sample among their limitations.

What this page is doingPurposive sampling is defended on the logic of the design rather than apologized for, and the highlighted sentence makes the argument in concrete terms. The appraisal then locates the real sampling limits, one site, uniform education and self-selection, and notes which of these the authors themselves acknowledged. Separating the false weakness from the real ones is what the sampling criterion rewards.
4

Data Collection and Analysis

Each participant was interviewed one to one, face to face or by telephone, for 40 to 60 minutes, with an average of about three interviews per nurse spread across the study period. The interview guide asked about psychological feelings, coping strategies and insights, and was refined through consultation with experts and two pilot interviews. Recordings were transcribed within 24 hours. Two researchers independently extracted significant statements and formulated themes, and disagreements were resolved by a group including nurses with master's and doctoral preparation (Sun et al., 2020).

Two features strengthen the analysis. Repeated interviews over three weeks captured change over time, which is how the authors could report that negative emotions dominated the first week and positive emotions emerged gradually. Independent coding by two researchers means the themes did not rest on one person's reading. One feature calls for caution. The interviewer was a senior nurse with psychological consulting credentials who had worked in a SARS isolation ward, and the report describes her as able to carry out the research independently. Nurses speaking to a senior colleague in their own hospital during a crisis may have been inclined to emphasize coping and professional pride.

The Four Trustworthiness Criteria

Lincoln and Guba (1985) proposed four criteria for judging qualitative work: credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability. Credibility is supported by prolonged engagement through multiple interviews and by two independent coders, but weakened by the absence of any reported member checking. Colaizzi's final step returns the description to participants for validation, and the report does not say this was done. Transferability depends on thick description of the setting and participants, and here it is moderate: the sample is well described in numbers, but the ward, staffing ratios and the supply situation are sketched rather than detailed. Dependability is supported by a described interview guide, a stated analytic method and a resolution process for disagreements, which together would allow an audit. Confirmability is the weakest criterion. The report does not describe how the researchers set aside their own expectations, a process called bracketing in phenomenology, which matters because the interviewer's own isolation ward history could shape what she heard.

What this page is doingEach of the four criteria is applied separately and tested against what the report actually says, with evidence for and against. The appraisal notices an omission a careful reader would catch, no member checking even though the chosen method includes it as a final step, and connects the weak confirmability to a specific fact about the interviewer. That is appraisal, not definition.
5

Do the Quotations Earn the Themes

The first theme, significant negative emotions early on, is earned. The quotations are specific and physical: nurses describe shifts of 12 to 16 hours, wearing protective clothing for eight hours without eating or drinking, and headaches, chest tightness and palpitations. Those words would support the theme even if the authors had not named it. The theme of growth under pressure is supported less strongly. Much of its evidence is reported as counts, such as the number of nurses who expressed gratitude, rather than as extended quotations showing what growth meant to them, and it is the theme most exposed to the interviewer effect described above. Appraisal tools for qualitative research ask directly whether the data support the findings (Critical Appraisal Skills Programme, 2018), and for this theme the answer is only partly.

Verdict and the Limits of Transfer

This is a credible, well-matched phenomenological study with honest reporting of its sample, weakened by the lack of member checking and by limited attention to researcher influence. Its findings are useful to nurse leaders in my setting, a 180-bed community hospital that expects future surges of respiratory illness, in one specific way: they suggest that distress peaks before and during a nurse's first exposure, which argues for concentrating support at orientation to an isolation unit rather than spreading it evenly. What does not transfer easily is the social context, including a centralized national response, strong collective framing of the work and reward systems described by the authors. Findings about growth and gratitude should therefore be carried to a U.S. community hospital with care, while findings about early fear, fatigue and concern for family are the part most likely to hold.

References

Colaizzi, P. F. (1978). Psychological research as the phenomenologist views it. In R. S. Valle & M. King (Eds.), Existential-phenomenological alternatives for psychology (pp. 48-71). Oxford University Press.

Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. (2018). CASP qualitative checklist. https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/

Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1985). Naturalistic inquiry. Sage.

Polit, D. F., & Beck, C. T. (2021). Nursing research: Generating and assessing evidence for nursing practice (11th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

Sun, N., Wei, L., Shi, S., Jiao, D., Song, R., Ma, L., Wang, H., Wang, C., Wang, Z., You, Y., Liu, S., & Wang, H. (2020). A qualitative study on the psychological experience of caregivers of COVID-19 patients. American Journal of Infection Control, 48(6), 592-598. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajic.2020.03.018

What the NRS 445 Topic 5 instructions ask for

Topic 5 in NRS-445 asks students to appraise a qualitative study. Strong appraisals check whether the design fits the question, examine sampling and recruitment, describe data collection and analysis with the named method and apply the trustworthiness criteria of credibility, transferability, dependability and confirmability with evidence from the paper. Students should test whether the quotations earn the themes the authors report and reach a verdict that names strengths and weaknesses, such as missing member checking. The appraisal should end with the limits of transferring findings to the student's own setting, since a small sample is normal in qualitative work. Page numbers should accompany quotations.

How the NRS-445 Topic 5 example is put together

The finished example names the qualitative design before judging anything, since a phenomenological study and an ethnography answer to different expectations. Sampling is discussed as purposive rather than deficient, and the example explains why twelve participants chosen for their experience can be exactly right when twelve chosen at random would not be. Trustworthiness is then applied criterion by criterion: credibility through the checks the researchers made, transferability through how thickly the setting is described, dependability through whether the process could be audited, confirmability through what kept the analysis anchored to the data. Participant quotations are examined for whether they support the themes or merely decorate them. The verdict says how far the findings would carry to the writer's own patients and what would be lost in the transfer.

NRS 445 Topic 5 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward trustworthiness judged from the paper's own evidence. An Excellent appraisal checks that phenomenology fits a question about experience and describes purposive sampling of 20 nurses. Credit goes to describing repeated 40 to 60 minute interviews analyzed with Colaizzi's method. The rubric values applying Lincoln and Guba's four criteria with the CASP checklist and Polit and Beck. Strong appraisals test whether quotations about 12 to 16 hour shifts earn the first theme. Top marks go to a verdict noting missing member checking and limits of transfer to a community hospital. Transfer limits are stated.

NRS 445 Topic 5 help before you submit

Criticizing a qualitative study for its small sample is the error the topic exists to prevent, and it costs marks immediately. So does calling the findings ungeneralizable as though that were a flaw, when transferability was the intended standard all along. The second loss is a paper that names the trustworthiness criteria and applies none of them, which reads as a definition list. Papers lose marks for summarizing themes rather than appraising them, since the assignment asks whether the themes were earned. Ignoring the researcher's own position, where a nurse studied colleagues on their own floor, misses a genuine threat to the analysis. The strongest versions say what the study would need to be trusted more.

Get an NRS-445 Topic 5 example written to your instructions

Send the NRS-445 Topic 5 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, together with the qualitative article your section assigned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the design named, sampling defended on its own logic, all four trustworthiness criteria applied to the paper and a verdict reached, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More NRS 445 papers and RN to BSN samples

NRS 445 Topic 5 questions, answered

Is a study with twelve participants too small?

Not for qualitative work, where the aim is depth rather than a representative sample. What matters is whether the participants were selected because they could speak to the question and whether data collection continued until new interviews stopped producing new ideas. A study of twelve people chosen deliberately can be stronger than one of forty chosen conveniently.

What is the qualitative equivalent of validity?

Trustworthiness, usually broken into four criteria. Credibility asks whether the findings represent what participants meant, transferability whether enough context is given for a reader to judge the fit elsewhere, dependability whether the process could be followed by an auditor, and confirmability whether the conclusions come from the data rather than the researcher. Apply all four and name the evidence for each.

Can qualitative findings change practice on their own?

They can change how you approach patients even when they cannot tell you which treatment works better. A study of what patients found frightening about a procedure should alter how it is explained, without settling any clinical question. Say precisely what kind of change the evidence supports, because claiming a qualitative study justifies a protocol change overstates it.

Where can I find a free NRS 445 Topic 5 sample paper?

The qualitative appraisal for NRS 445 Topic 5 for NRS 445 Topic 5 covers the study and whether its design fits, sampling and recruitment, data collection and analysis, the four trustworthiness criteria, whether quotations earn the themes and the verdict. Your own NRS 445 Topic 5 prompt gets a free paper.

Is a study of 20 nurses too small in NRS 445 Topic 5?

Not for qualitative work, which aims for depth rather than representativeness. The question is whether the sample was appropriate and whether data reached saturation.