| Course | NRS 445 Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 6 |
| Paper type | Evidence appraisal table |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | RN to BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NRS 445 Topic 6
Evidence Appraisal Table: Virtual Reality Distraction for Needle Pain in Children Undergoing Venipuncture or IV Placement
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NRS-445: Nursing Research and Evidence Based Practice
Topic 6 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
September 28, 2026
Evidence Appraisal Table: Virtual Reality Distraction for Needle Pain in Children Undergoing Venipuncture or IV Placement
Question, Hierarchy and Appraisal Tool
The question behind this table is: In children aged 4 to 17 undergoing venipuncture or intravenous cannulation, does virtual reality distraction, compared with standard care, reduce child-reported procedural pain? It arose in a pediatric emergency department where needle procedures are the most common source of distress, and where the unit has been offered headsets by a hospital foundation.
Two tools are used, and both are named because different tools can rank the same study differently. Levels of evidence follow the seven-level hierarchy described by Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt (2023), in which a pooled analysis of several randomized controlled trials sits at Level I, a well-designed randomized controlled trial is Level II, and a controlled trial without randomization is Level III. Quality is judged separately using the questions of the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklists for randomized trials and systematic reviews (Critical Appraisal Skills Programme, 2018), which ask about allocation, comparability of groups at baseline, blinding, attrition and precision of the result.
How Levels Were Assigned
A study's level was assigned from its design alone. The size of the sample, the reputation of the journal and the strength of the abstract's conclusions did not move a study up or down. A large, well-publicized trial with poor allocation remains Level II on this scale, and its weaknesses are recorded in the quality column instead. Level describes what a design can prove at its best; quality describes how close this particular study came to that best. Keeping the two apart prevents a common mistake, in which a small but randomized study and a large but uncontrolled one are treated as equally strong because both reported a significant result.
The Appraisal Table
Table 1 lists the four studies retained after screening, one per row, with the design, sample, key finding, level and a one-sentence quality verdict.
Table 1
Studies of Virtual Reality Distraction for Pediatric Needle Pain
| Study | Design | Sample and setting | Key finding | Level | Quality verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tas et al. (2022) | Systematic review and meta-analysis | 26 studies of children undergoing medical procedures; 21 pooled for pain | Virtual reality distraction reduced patient-reported pain, standardized mean difference -0.67 | I | Good: broad search updating an earlier review, but pools many procedures and devices |
| Chan et al. (2019) | Two randomized controlled trials | Children 4-11 years, emergency department and outpatient pathology, two Australian hospitals; about 250 randomized | Pain reduced relative to standard care in both settings; minor adverse events equal between arms | II | Good: prespecified primary outcome and registered trial; blinding of children not possible |
| Gold and Mahrer (2018) | Randomized controlled trial | 143 patients 10-21 years, outpatient phlebotomy, one pediatric hospital | Reduced pain and anxiety; larger benefit in children with high anxiety sensitivity | II | Moderate: randomized with multiple informants, but older age range than the question and one site |
| Piskorz and Czub (2018) | Posttest-only quasi-experiment | 38 children 7-17 years, pediatric nephrology clinic | Lower pain and stress scores in the virtual reality group | III | Weak: no randomization, no baseline measure and a small sample |
Note. Levels follow Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt (2023). Quality verdicts use the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme questions for each design.
Two Studies Appraised in Full
The strongest single study is Chan et al. (2019), which ran two randomized trials in parallel, one in an emergency department and one in an outpatient blood collection service. In the emergency department, 64 children received virtual reality and 59 standard care; in pathology, 63 and 68, with 2 children in the standard care arm withdrawing assent. The primary outcome, change from baseline pain on the child-rated Faces Pain Scale-Revised, was set in advance and the trial was registered. Attrition was small and reported. The one question it cannot answer well is blinding: a child wearing a headset knows which group they are in, and so does the nurse, which may shade self-reported pain. That limit applies to every study in this table, so it weakens the body rather than this study alone.
The weakest is Piskorz and Czub (2018), a posttest-only comparison of 38 children at a nephrology clinic. Children were not randomized and pain was measured only after the procedure, so the groups may have differed in fear or in prior needle experience before the procedure began, and the study has no way to show otherwise. Its large reported effect is therefore less trustworthy than a smaller effect from a randomized trial. It is kept in the table because it tests a hands-free headset design relevant to procedures where a child's arm must stay still, but its finding carries little weight on its own.
Reading the Body as a Whole
The studies agree in direction. Every one found less pain with virtual reality, and the meta-analysis by Tas et al. (2022), which updated an earlier review and pooled 21 studies of virtual reality distraction, found a moderate effect on self-reported pain. Agreement proves less than it appears, however, because all four share the same limitation: pain is reported by the child, and neither the child nor the person delivering the intervention can be blinded. A shared bias pushes every study in the same direction, so consistency across them does not rule it out. The body also differs from the question in age. Gold and Mahrer (2018) enrolled patients up to 21 years old, and most trials were in planned blood draws rather than emergency cannulation, where pain and fear are often greater.
What the Evidence Supports
The evidence supports offering virtual reality distraction to children aged about 4 to 12 for venipuncture and intravenous placement in the emergency department, as an addition to topical anesthetic and comfort positioning rather than a replacement for them, with Level I and Level II support and no signal of harm. It does not support claims that virtual reality makes needle procedures painless, that it works equally well for every child, or that it reduces the need for sedation in difficult cannulations, since none of these studies measured those outcomes. A unit that adopts headsets should measure its own child-reported pain scores before and after, which is the only way to learn whether the published effect holds in its own hands.
References
Chan, E., Hovenden, M., Ramage, E., Ling, N., Pham, J. H., Rahim, A., Lam, C., Liu, L., Foster, S., Sambell, R., Jeyachanthiran, K., Crock, C., Stock, A., Hopper, S. M., Cohen, S., Davidson, A., Plummer, K., Mills, E., Craig, S. S., ... Leong, P. (2019). Virtual reality for pediatric needle procedural pain: Two randomized clinical trials. The Journal of Pediatrics, 209, 160-167.e4. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpeds.2019.02.034
Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. (2018). CASP checklists. https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/
Gold, J. I., & Mahrer, N. E. (2018). Is virtual reality ready for prime time in the medical space? A randomized control trial of pediatric virtual reality for acute procedural pain management. Journal of Pediatric Psychology, 43(3), 266-275. https://doi.org/10.1093/jpepsy/jsx129
Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
Piskorz, J., & Czub, M. (2018). Effectiveness of a virtual reality intervention to minimize pediatric stress and pain intensity during venipuncture. Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing, 23(1), Article e12201. https://doi.org/10.1111/jspn.12201
Tas, F. Q., van Eijk, C. A. M., Staals, L. M., Legerstee, J. S., & Dierckx, B. (2022). Virtual reality in pediatrics, effects on pain and anxiety: A systematic review and meta-analysis update. Pediatric Anesthesia, 32(12), 1292-1304. https://doi.org/10.1111/pan.14546
What the NRS 445 Topic 6 instructions ask for
Topic 6 in NRS-445 asks students to appraise and level a body of evidence in a table. Strong papers state the question, the evidence hierarchy and the appraisal tool used, then assign each study's level from its design alone, not from its sample size or journal. Students should present a table with design, sample, key finding, level and a short quality verdict for each study, appraise the strongest studies in full and read the body as a whole, noting where studies agree and what limits them. The paper should end with what the evidence supports and for whom, since a lower-level study can still be useful when its limits are stated.
Inside the NRS 445 Topic 6 example
The finished example is mostly a table, and the table is doing work rather than storing citations. Each row carries one study with its design, its sample, its findings and the level it occupies on a named hierarchy, and the level is assigned from the design rather than from how convincing the abstract sounded. An appraisal tool then runs down the column of quality questions, and the answers are specific: whether allocation was concealed, whether the groups were comparable at baseline, whether attrition was reported and where the missing participants went. The verdict per study is written in a sentence, and the example is willing to record that a study is weak. A final passage weighs the body as a whole, noting where several studies share the same limitation.
Where the marks sit in the NRS 445 Topic 6 rubric
Faculty reward levels assigned from design alone. An Excellent table names the question, Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt's hierarchy and the CASP tool, then levels four studies without regard to journal or sample size. Credit goes to appraising Chan and colleagues' two parallel randomized trials in full. The rubric values reading the body together with Tas and colleagues' meta-analysis and Gold and Mahrer's trial. Strong papers note limits such as unblinded raters. Top marks go to recommending virtual reality for children about 4 to 12 alongside topical anesthetic.
NRS 445 Topic 6 help before you submit
Levels assigned by impression rather than by design are the standard error, most often by promoting a large well written cohort study above a small randomized trial. The hierarchy ranks designs, not quality, and quality is what the appraisal tool is for. The second loss is a table that summarizes without appraising, where the quality column reads good for every row. Papers lose marks for naming an appraisal tool and then not answering its questions, so the reader cannot tell what was checked. Failing to record any weakness is read as not having looked, since a body of five studies with no limitations does not exist. Missing the shared limitation across studies costs the synthesis mark.
Get an NRS-445 Topic 6 example written to your instructions
Send the NRS-445 Topic 6 instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the articles your section assigned or the ones your search returned. We write a custom example to those criteria, with each study leveled from its design, the appraisal tool answered question by question and a verdict recorded per study, in 24 to 48 hours. Free the first time.
More NRS 445 papers and RN to BSN samples
- NRS 445 Topic 1: Evidence Based Practice Comparison
- NRS 445 Topic 2: PICOT Question Paper
- NRS 445 Topic 3: Literature Search Log
- NRS 445 Topic 4: Delirium Prevention Evidence Appraisal
- NRS 445 Topic 5: Qualitative Appraisal
- NRS 445 Topic 7: Translation Model Application
- NRS 445 Topic 8: Synthesis and Dissemination Plan
- NRS 450 Topic 6: Telehealth Access Review
- NRS 425 Topic 6: Health Policy Brief
- NRS 455 Topic 6: Case Study Analysis
- NRS 420 Topic 6: Multi-system Exam Documentation
NRS 445 Topic 6 questions, answered
Which levels of evidence hierarchy should I use?
Whichever your section names, and there are several in circulation that number their levels differently. What causes trouble is mixing them, citing one hierarchy and then using another's numbering, so state which you are following in a line near the start. Once chosen, apply it consistently, because a level means nothing without the scale it came from.
Can a low level study still be useful?
Yes, and saying so carefully is a mark of a good appraisal. A well conducted qualitative study or a careful case series can be the best available evidence on a question nobody has trialed, and dismissing it because of its level misunderstands the hierarchy. What the level tells you is how much confidence a design can carry, not whether the study is worth reading.
How much detail belongs in each table cell?
Enough to be checked and little enough to be scanned. A findings cell that reports the effect with its size beats one that says the intervention was effective, and a sample cell should carry the number and the setting. Long paragraphs inside a table defeat the format, so put the reasoning in the prose section and keep the table as the comparison.
Where can I find a free NRS 445 Topic 6 sample paper?
The appraisal table paper for NRS 445 Topic 6 for NRS 445 Topic 6 covers question, hierarchy and tool, how levels were assigned, the appraisal table, two studies appraised in full, the body read as a whole and what the evidence supports. Forward the NRS 445 Topic 6 prompt you received for a free paper.
Can a lower-level study still be useful in NRS 445 Topic 6?
Yes, when its limits are stated. A smaller trial can support a finding that stronger studies show in the same direction, and the table records both its level and its verdict.