| Course | NSG 310 Introduction to Professional Nursing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 7 |
| Paper type | Professional issue position paper |
| Length | About 960 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NSG 310 Topic 7
Position Paper: Arizona Should Adopt a BSN-in-Ten Requirement for Newly Licensed Registered Nurses
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NSG-310: Introduction to Professional Nursing
Topic 7 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
October 12, 2026
Position Paper: Arizona Should Adopt a BSN-in-Ten Requirement for Newly Licensed Registered Nurses
Position
Arizona should require registered nurses who enter practice with an associate degree or diploma to earn a baccalaureate degree in nursing within ten years of initial licensure, while keeping every current route into the profession open. The debate over entry into practice is older than most nurses working today; the American Nurses Association called for the baccalaureate as the minimum preparation for professional nursing in 1965, and the question has never been resolved. A ten-year requirement is a narrower claim than making the baccalaureate the only entry route, and it is the claim this paper defends.
The Evidence for the Position
The central evidence is outcomes research. Aiken et al. (2003) examined surgical outcomes across 168 Pennsylvania hospitals. Where the proportion of bachelor's-educated staff nurses was higher by 10 percentage points, 30-day surgical deaths and deaths following complications were about 5 percent less likely, after adjustment for patient and hospital differences. Later work in other states found similar associations; a study of California hospitals, for example, reported lower rates of several adverse outcomes, including congestive heart failure mortality and failure to rescue, in hospitals with more baccalaureate-prepared nurses (Blegen et al., 2013). The Institute of Medicine (2011) used this body of evidence to set a national goal that 80 percent of registered nurses hold a bachelor's degree by 2020.
An association is not proof of cause. Hospitals that hire more baccalaureate nurses may also differ in staffing, resources and culture, and although these studies adjusted for many factors, they cannot rule out all of them. What the evidence supports is that a better-educated nursing workforce is consistently associated with safer patient outcomes, and no study has found the reverse. A policy that moves the workforce in that direction is justified by the consistency of the finding, even without proof of mechanism.
There is also a precedent. New York enacted a law in 2017 requiring future registered nurses who enter with an associate degree to earn a baccalaureate within ten years of licensure, while grandfathering current nurses and students. Arizona could adopt a similar structure.
The Opposing Case
Three arguments against the position deserve full weight. First, access: associate degree programs, many in community colleges, are the most affordable and geographically available route into nursing, especially in rural Arizona and for working adults, and they bring many first-generation and minority students into the profession. A requirement to continue to a bachelor's degree could discourage some from entering. Second, cost: completing a baccalaureate adds tuition and time, a burden that falls on nurses earning an entry-level salary, some of whom support families. Third, workforce supply: Arizona has faced nursing shortages, and any policy that makes becoming or staying a nurse harder could reduce the supply of nurses when patients need them most.
Rebuttal, Point by Point
Access. A ten-year requirement keeps the associate degree as an entry route, so it does not close the door that community colleges open. It asks new nurses to continue their education while they work, which is already common: online RN-to-BSN programs, many designed for working nurses, allow completion without leaving employment or relocating.
Cost. The cost is real, but it can be offset. Many hospital employers already offer tuition assistance, and a statewide requirement would strengthen the case for employer and state support, particularly for nurses in rural and underserved areas. Ten years is long enough to complete a degree part time while earning a nurse's salary.
Workforce supply. Because the requirement applies only to new licensees and allows ten years, it does not remove anyone from the workforce immediately. New York's experience will provide evidence on whether supply is affected, and Arizona could build in a review after five years to adjust the rule if shortages worsen.
What the Policy Would Look Like in Arizona
A workable Arizona version would have four parts. It would apply only to registered nurses first licensed after a set future date, so that no current nurse or current student would be affected. It would allow ten years from initial licensure to complete the degree, with extensions available for documented hardship such as military deployment or serious illness. It would be enforced at license renewal by the Arizona State Board of Nursing, which already tracks renewal requirements, rather than by employers. And it would be paired with a state commitment to expand tuition assistance for nurses working in rural and medically underserved counties, where associate-degree graduates are most needed and least able to pay for further education. A review after five years would report on enrollment in associate and baccalaureate programs, the diversity of new licensees and vacancy rates, so that the legislature could adjust the rule if it harmed supply.
This design takes the opposing arguments seriously before any rebuttal is offered. It keeps the community college door open, puts the burden of support on the state and employers rather than on individual nurses alone, and builds in evidence about unintended effects.
An Honest Remainder
The paper cannot fully answer one part of the opposing case. Some nurses, particularly those with family responsibilities in rural communities, may find ten years insufficient or the cost impossible even with support, and the policy could push a small number out of the profession or discourage them from entering it. The outcomes research also cannot say how much of the benefit comes from the degree itself and how much from the kinds of hospitals and nurses who pursue it. These are genuine uncertainties. They argue for pairing the requirement with funding and flexibility, and for measuring its effects, rather than for abandoning a policy supported by two decades of consistent evidence about patient outcomes.
References
Aiken, L. H., Clarke, S. P., Cheung, R. B., Sloane, D. M., & Silber, J. H. (2003). Educational levels of hospital nurses and surgical patient mortality. JAMA, 290(12), 1617-1623. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.290.12.1617
Blegen, M. A., Goode, C. J., Park, S. H., Vaughn, T., & Spetz, J. (2013). Baccalaureate education in nursing and patient outcomes. The Journal of Nursing Administration, 43(2), 89-94. https://doi.org/10.1097/NNA.0b013e31827f2028
Institute of Medicine. (2011). The future of nursing: Leading change, advancing health. The National Academies Press.
Reading the GCU NSG 310 Topic 7 instructions
Topic 7 in NSG-310 asks students to take a position on a professional nursing issue. Strong position papers declare their stance in the opening paragraph, present the evidence for it with the studies' findings and give the opposing case its full strength before rebutting it point by point. Students should describe what the policy would look like in practice, including who it applies to and when, and admit honestly any part of the opposing case they cannot fully answer. The issue should be one the course raises, sources should follow the number the assignment sets and arguing against a program's position is acceptable if the evidence supports it.
How this NSG 310 Topic 7 example is built
The finished example states its position in the first paragraph and spends the rest of the paper earning it. The issue is framed historically in a few sentences, since the baccalaureate entry debate is decades old, and then narrowed to the claim being defended. The supporting section draws on outcomes research, with Aiken and colleagues cited for the association they reported between baccalaureate-prepared nursing staff and surgical patient mortality, and on the Institute of Medicine's Future of Nursing recommendations, described without figures the writer cannot verify. An opposing section presents the counterargument seriously: associate degree programs widen access, cost less, and supply much of the workforce, and every candidate sits the same NCLEX. The rebuttal responds point by point. The final section admits which opposing point the paper could not fully answer, and the references are current and peer-reviewed.
Reading the NSG 310 Topic 7 rubric
Faculty reward a position argued against its strongest opposition. An Excellent paper states the BSN-in-ten position, then cites Aiken and colleagues and Blegen and colleagues on education and patient outcomes and the Institute of Medicine's 80 percent goal. Credit goes to giving access, cost and shortage arguments full weight. The rubric values rebuttals such as keeping the associate degree as an entry route. Strong papers sketch an Arizona policy for nurses licensed after a future date. Top marks go to admitting that ten years may not suffice for some rural nurses.
Common NSG 310 Topic 7 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Opinion without sources is the steepest loss on a position paper, and it is common because the issue feels personal to students on the baccalaureate route. A paper that says BSN nurses are better prepared, with no study behind the claim, has asserted what the rubric asks it to demonstrate. Treating correlation as proof costs a quieter amount, since outcomes research reports associations and a careful writer says so. Omitting the opposing argument, or reducing it to a sentence, is marked as one-sided in almost every section. Dated or non-scholarly sources weaken otherwise solid papers, particularly advocacy websites cited as if they were research. Marks hold up best when the thesis is precise, the evidence is primary, and the opposition is stated well enough that its own supporters would recognize it.
Get an NSG-310 Topic 7 example written to your instructions
Send the NSG-310 Topic 7 instructions and rubric, and the issue your section assigns or the one you have chosen. We write a custom example to those criteria, arguing from primary sources and answering the strongest opposing case, and deliver it in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NSG 310 papers and BSN samples
- NSG 310 Topic 1: Profession Criteria Essay
- NSG 310 Topic 2: Licensure History Paper
- NSG 310 Topic 3: Nurse Practice Act Analysis
- NSG 310 Topic 4: Code of Ethics Application
- NSG 310 Topic 5: License Accountability DQ
- NSG 310 Topic 6: Delegation Decision Analysis
- NSG 310 Topic 8: Competency Gap Plan
- NSG 318 Topic 7: Medication Administration Case Study
- NSG 300 Topic 7: Nursing Care Plan
- NSG 320 Topic 7: Multiple Problem Care Plan
- NSG 448 Topic 7: Nurse Manager Proposal Memo
NSG 310 Topic 7 questions, answered
Which professional issue should the paper take on?
Use the issue your prompt assigns, or choose one with a real debate and a research literature behind both sides. Entry into practice, mandatory staffing ratios, workplace violence and multistate licensure all qualify. Avoid issues where nobody seriously disagrees, since the rubric usually expects an opposing argument, and a topic with no credible opposition leaves that section with nothing to engage.
How many sources does a position paper need?
Follow the number in your instructions, and treat it as a minimum. More important than the count is the kind: peer-reviewed research for empirical claims, professional organizations for positions, and regulatory bodies for anything about licensure. Each source should be doing specific work in the argument, and a reference list padded with sources the paper barely uses tends to be noticed quickly.
Can I argue against the position my program holds?
Yes, if the evidence supports your case and you engage the other side as seriously as you would expect it to engage you. Graders assess the quality of the argument rather than its conclusion. The example takes one side, but the same structure of claim, evidence, opposition and rebuttal would serve the opposite position equally well.
Where can I find a free NSG 310 Topic 7 sample paper?
The position paper for NSG 310 Topic 7 for NSG 310 Topic 7 covers the position, the evidence, the opposing case, rebuttal point by point, what the policy would look like and an honest remainder. Send your NSG 310 Topic 7 prompt and a paper follows free.
Can I argue against my program's position in NSG 310 Topic 7?
Yes, if the evidence supports it. Faculty grade the reasoning and use of sources, not agreement, so a well-argued opposing position can score well.