| Course | NSG 310 Introduction to Professional Nursing |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 1 |
| Paper type | Nursing as a profession essay |
| Length | About 1,020 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NSG 310 Topic 1
Is Nursing a Profession? Testing the Claim Against Flexner's and Greenwood's Criteria
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NSG-310: Introduction to Professional Nursing
Topic 1 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
September 7, 2026
Is Nursing a Profession? Testing the Claim Against Flexner's and Greenwood's Criteria
Occupation and Profession
An occupation is paid work done under the direction of an employer. A profession, in the sociological literature, is something more: an occupation whose members share a specialized body of knowledge learned through extended education, apply it with considerable independence, regulate their own conduct through a code of ethics and a licensing system, and are trusted by society to act in the public interest. The difference matters for nursing because it determines who decides what nurses may do, who judges whether they did it well, and whether a nurse's obligation runs first to the employer or to the patient. This essay tests nursing against published criteria and reaches a verdict: nursing is a profession, with autonomy as its weakest criterion.
The Criteria
In 1915, Abraham Flexner proposed criteria for a profession, including intellectual activity with individual responsibility, a base in science and learning, practical application, teachable technique, self-organization and altruistic motivation (Flexner, 1915/2001). Greenwood (1957) later refined the idea into five attributes: a systematic body of theory, professional authority, sanction of the community, a regulative code of ethics, and a professional culture. Greenwood's list is used here because it is more specific and because each attribute can be tested with evidence.
Testing Nursing Against the Criteria
A systematic body of theory. Nursing has developed its own theories and research base, from Nightingale's environmental theory through the work of Henderson, Orem and Peplau, and a growing body of nursing research on questions medicine does not ask, such as how to prevent pressure injuries or how to teach a patient with limited literacy. Baccalaureate education builds this knowledge through years of study that combine theory and supervised practice. This criterion is met.
Sanction of the community. Licensure is the clearest evidence. Every state regulates nursing through a nurse practice act administered by a board of nursing. In Arizona, the Nurse Practice Act in Title 32, Chapter 15 of the Arizona Revised Statutes defines the scope of registered nursing, and the Arizona State Board of Nursing licenses nurses, investigates complaints and disciplines those who violate the standards. Candidates must pass the national licensing examination developed by the national organization of state nursing boards before practicing (NCSBN, n.d.). Society does not allow just anyone to call themselves a registered nurse; it grants that right through a legal process that can also take it away, which is the definition of community sanction.
A regulative code of ethics. The American Nurses Association's Code of Ethics for Nurses sets out the profession's obligations, beginning with compassion and respect for the inherent worth of each person and including the nurse's primary commitment to the patient (American Nurses Association [ANA], 2015). Boards of nursing treat unethical conduct as grounds for discipline. This criterion is met.
A professional culture. Nursing has professional organizations, specialty certifications, journals, conferences and shared values that are taught and reinforced from the first semester. This criterion is met.
Professional Authority and Autonomy: A Partial Score
Greenwood's second attribute, professional authority, is where nursing's case is weakest, and the essay should say so. Registered nurses exercise independent judgment in assessment, nursing diagnosis, patient teaching, delegation and many interventions, and they are accountable for those decisions under their own license. But much of what nurses do in hospitals depends on orders from physicians or advanced practice providers, nurses work as employees whose schedules and assignments are set by the organization, and the scope of practice is defined by a state board and statute rather than by nursing alone. Autonomy in nursing is real but bounded. It is exercised within collaborative practice, which is also true, to a lesser degree, of other professions such as medicine, where physicians are increasingly employees and follow institutional protocols.
The Case Against, Answered
The strongest argument that nursing is an occupation rather than a profession runs like this: nurses are employed by organizations that control their work, many tasks are carried out on orders from others, and entry into practice is possible with an associate degree, so the educational requirement is lower than in medicine or law. Each point has force. The response is that employment does not by itself remove professional status, since many physicians, lawyers and engineers are employees; that carrying out orders is only part of nursing's work, and the parts that are independent, such as assessment and patient teaching, require specialized knowledge; and that every licensed registered nurse, whatever the degree, passes the same national examination and is held to the same code and practice act. The argument about education is a fair criticism of how the profession has organized entry, not proof that nursing lacks professional standing.
Why the Question Still Matters
The question can look academic, but it has practical consequences. If nursing is a profession, a nurse who is told by a manager to take an unsafe assignment, or by a provider to give a medication the nurse believes is dangerous, has an obligation that comes from the license and the code, not only from the job. Boards of nursing discipline nurses for actions taken on an employer's instruction if those actions fall below the standard of care, which shows that the law treats nurses as professionals accountable for their own judgment. Professional status is also the basis for nursing's voice in health policy, in hospital committees that set practice standards, and in decisions about staffing and safety. A nurse who thinks of the work as an occupation may defer where a professional would speak up, and patients depend on nurses who speak up.
Verdict
Measured against Greenwood's criteria, nursing meets four fully, a body of theory, community sanction, an ethical code and a professional culture, and one partially, professional authority. That record supports calling nursing a profession. The partial score on autonomy is best read as an honest description of how nursing is practiced, within teams and within organizations, rather than a disqualification. For a new nursing student, the practical meaning of the verdict is personal: a license makes each nurse accountable for their own judgment, even when working under another person's orders.
References
American Nurses Association. (2015). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements. American Nurses Association.
Flexner, A. (2001). Is social work a profession? Research on Social Work Practice, 11(2), 152-165. https://doi.org/10.1177/104973150101100202 (Original work published 1915)
Greenwood, E. (1957). Attributes of a profession. Social Work, 2(3), 45-55. https://doi.org/10.1093/sw/2.3.45
National Council of State Boards of Nursing. (n.d.). NCLEX and other exams. https://www.ncsbn.org/exams.page
Reading the GCU NSG 310 Topic 1 instructions
Topic 1 in NSG-310 asks students to examine whether nursing meets the criteria of a profession. Strong essays define occupation and profession, then measure nursing against recognized criteria, such as Flexner's or Greenwood's, citing evidence criterion by criterion. Students should be honest where nursing's case is weakest, often professional authority and autonomy, answer the strongest argument against nursing's professional status rather than ignoring it and explain why the question has practical consequences for a nurse facing an unsafe assignment. The essay should end with a verdict that reflects the evidence, including partial scores, and licensure should feature in the argument because it is how the public grants a profession its authority.
Inside the NSG 310 Topic 1 example
The finished essay argues toward a verdict and is not a celebration. It opens by distinguishing an occupation, work done for pay under an employer's direction, from a profession, which in the sociological literature typically carries a specialized body of knowledge, extended education, autonomy over its own practice, a code of ethics, and public accountability enforced through licensure. Flexner's early list of criteria is cited as the familiar starting point, with a note that later writers revised it. Nursing is then measured against each criterion in turn, and the essay does not award every point: autonomy is treated as partial and argued with evidence from the way scope is set by state boards rather than by nurses individually. The legal side is named throughout, the practice act, the board, the NCLEX, so professionalism never reduces to admirable traits.
Where the marks sit in the NSG 310 Topic 1 rubric
Faculty reward criteria applied one at a time with honest scores. An Excellent essay distinguishes occupation from profession, then tests nursing against Greenwood's five attributes and Flexner's criteria. Credit goes to evidence for each, such as NCSBN licensure for community sanction and the ANA's ethical code. The rubric values scoring professional authority as only partly met and answering the argument that employers control nurses' work. Strong essays explain what the answer means for refusing unsafe assignments. Top marks go to a verdict of four attributes met and one partly met.
Common NSG 310 Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Essays in this topic are marked down hardest when professionalism becomes a list of virtues. Compassion, integrity and dedication describe a good employee in almost any field, and an essay built from them never reaches what makes nursing legally a profession: a defined scope, a licensing board and personal accountability for practice. Leaving the criteria unnamed costs credit next, because the grader is then holding only the writer's opinion about what counts. Awarding nursing every criterion without qualification also costs credit, since the rubric typically rewards engagement with the harder cases, autonomy above all. Some papers cite a single textbook for every claim, while stronger ones bring in at least one source from the professional literature. The essays scored highest reach a verdict and defend it against a real objection.
Get an NSG-310 Topic 1 example written to your instructions
Send the NSG-310 Topic 1 instructions and rubric from your classroom, plus any criteria or reading the prompt assigns. We write a custom example to those requirements, arguing from named sources and treating licensure as evidence, and return it in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NSG 310 papers and BSN samples
- NSG 310 Topic 2: Licensure History Paper
- NSG 310 Topic 3: Nurse Practice Act Analysis
- NSG 310 Topic 4: Code of Ethics Application
- NSG 310 Topic 5: License Accountability DQ
- NSG 310 Topic 6: Delegation Decision Analysis
- NSG 310 Topic 7: Professional Issue Position Paper
- NSG 310 Topic 8: Competency Gap Plan
- NSG 318 Topic 1: Pharmacokinetics Application Paper
- NSG 300 Topic 1: Nursing Knowledge Paper
- NSG 320 Topic 1: Pathophysiology to Assessment Paper
- NSG 448 Topic 1: Picot Narrowing Paper
NSG 310 Topic 1 questions, answered
Is nursing actually a profession?
Most of the literature concludes that it is, and the example agrees, but the useful answer explains why. A specialized body of knowledge, a code of ethics, standardized education and licensure enforced by a state board are strong evidence. Autonomy is the criterion most often debated, because scope is set externally and much practice is collaborative. An essay that engages that debate reads as professional argument.
Whose criteria of a profession should I use?
Start with any list your course reading supplies. Flexner's is the familiar historical reference, and nursing textbooks commonly offer a revised set drawn from later sociology of the professions. Whatever list is chosen, it needs a citation and it needs to be applied in full, since an essay that tests nursing only against the criteria it passes easily will usually be marked as one-sided.
Why does licensure matter so much to the argument?
Because it is the mechanism that makes accountability personal and enforceable. A professional code with no body able to act on it is aspiration, whereas a license can be restricted or revoked by a board for practice that falls below its standards. For a student who does not yet hold one, grasping that the license is issued to an individual is the first step into the role.
Where can I find a free NSG 310 Topic 1 sample paper?
The profession essay for NSG 310 Topic 1 for NSG 310 Topic 1 covers occupation and profession, the criteria, nursing tested against them, professional authority as a partial score, the case against answered, why the question matters and the verdict. Send your NSG 310 Topic 1 prompt and a paper follows free.
Where is nursing's case weakest in NSG 310 Topic 1?
Professional authority and autonomy. Nurses are employed by organizations that shape their work, so the essay scores that attribute as partly met rather than claiming more.