| Course | NSG 448 Evidence-Based Project Capstone |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Objection response paper |
| Length | About 990 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | BSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NSG 448 Topic 8
"Another Checklist": Answering a Night Charge Nurse's Workload Objection With a Time Ledger That Admits the First Month Costs More
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NSG-448: Evidence-Based Project Capstone
Topic 8 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
November 15, 2027
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
"Another Checklist": Answering a Night Charge Nurse's Workload Objection With a Time Ledger That Admits the First Month Costs More
The Objection
At the practice council meeting, the night charge nurse said: "We already do a falls checklist, a skin checklist and a restraint review every shift. Now you want another one. Every one of these is a minute here and a minute there, and at 0300 with five patients those minutes are real. Who's giving us that time back?"
The objection is fair, and this response does not dispute it. Nurses on this floor already complete several structured checks, and each was introduced with the promise that it would take only a moment. The question she asked was about time, so the answer has to be in time.
The Ledger
Table 1 lists the time the pilot adds and the time it removes, per month, with the assumptions behind each figure. The floor sends about 15 C. difficile samples a month.
Table 1
Time Ledger (Illustrative Estimates)
| Item | Added or removed | Minutes per month | Assumption |
|---|---|---|---|
| Completing the check for each sample | Added | 15 | 1 minute per sample, 15 samples |
| Calling the provider when a sample is held | Added | 25 | 5 held samples, 5 minutes per call |
| Huddle teaching, first two weeks only | Added (month 1) | 170 | 2 minutes a day for 14 days, about 6 nurses present |
| Reading the one-page guide, first month only | Added (month 1) | 90 | About 3 minutes each for 30 nurses |
| Collecting samples that are held and later canceled | Removed | 40 | 4 samples, 10 minutes each to collect from an incontinent patient |
| Contact precautions for a patient who was colonized, not infected | Removed | 150 | About half a case a month avoided; about 20 room entries a day for 10 days, with 1.5 minutes each for gown and gloves across nurses and assistants |
| Isolation paperwork, signage and room transfer | Removed | 20 | About half a case a month; about 40 minutes per case |
The Net, With Assumptions
In an ongoing month, the check adds about 40 minutes across the floor and removes about 210, for a net saving of about 170 minutes, almost three hours. In the first month, it adds about 300 minutes, including training, and removes about 210, so the first month costs roughly an hour and a half more than it saves, and the proposal should say so plainly.
The largest saving, contact precautions, rests on the biggest assumption: that the check prevents about half a case a month of a colonized patient being labeled as infected. That figure comes from the floor's own data, in which 7 of 20 hospital-onset cases over a year followed a laxative, roughly 0.6 a month, and assumes the check catches most of them. Patients with C. difficile infection are placed on contact precautions for the duration of illness under current guidance (McDonald et al., 2018), and each gown-and-glove entry takes time from nurses and assistants alike, which is why the saving falls partly on the assistants. If the check catches fewer cases than assumed, the saving shrinks; if it catches none, the ledger shows a small ongoing cost of about 40 minutes a month.
The ledger also moves some work rather than removing it. The calls to providers when a sample is held fall on the nurse, often at night, and on the covering provider. That is why the night-call count is a balancing measure and has a stop rule.
Something Given Back
The objection deserves more than arithmetic. The floor currently keeps a paper stool log taped to the door of any patient with diarrhea, a practice left over from before the electronic flowsheet recorded stool frequency. Nurses chart each stool twice, once on the door and once in the flowsheet. The check uses only the flowsheet. I propose that the practice council retire the paper door log as part of the pilot, which removes a second entry for every stool on every patient with diarrhea, not only those being tested. The infection preventionist has confirmed that the paper log is not used in any reporting. This returns time to the night shift from the first week, before the other savings begin, and it answers the charge nurse's question directly: this is the time we give back.
What the Ledger Does Not Count
Two things are left out of the ledger because they cannot be timed honestly. The first is the interruption cost of a night call. A five-minute call at 0300 may cost more than five minutes if it breaks a medication pass or delays a turn, and the ledger cannot measure that. The second is the benefit to patients of not being isolated when they are only colonized: fewer staff entering with gowns and gloves, less time alone in a room, and no unnecessary antibiotic. Those benefits are real but are not measured in nurse minutes, so they are named here rather than added to the saving side. Leaving both out keeps the ledger to what can be counted, and the council can weigh the rest for itself.
The Decision, Restated
The practice council is being asked to approve a 12-week pilot of the pre-test check, with the paper stool log retired at the same time, the night-call count reviewed weekly, and a pause for review if held samples generate more than three night calls in each of two weeks running. The first month will cost the floor about an hour and a half of net nurse time; after that, the ledger suggests a saving of about three hours a month, most of it in contact precautions avoided. The prevention compendium supports testing stewardship as an essential practice (Kociolek et al., 2023), and in one retrospective study, patients whose tests were stopped fared no worse than those who tested negative (Madden et al., 2020). If the ledger turns out wrong, the 12-week data will show it, and the council can stop the pilot. I am asking for a vote to begin on December 1.
References
Kociolek, L. K., Gerding, D. N., Carrico, R., Carling, P., Donskey, C. J., Dumyati, G., Kuhar, D. T., Loo, V. G., Maragakis, L. L., Pogorzelska-Maziarz, M., Sandora, T. J., Weber, D. J., Yokoe, D., & Dubberke, E. R. (2023). Strategies to prevent Clostridioides difficile infections in acute-care hospitals: 2022 update. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 44(4), 527-549. https://doi.org/10.1017/ice.2023.18
Madden, G. R., Enfield, K. B., & Sifri, C. D. (2020). Patient outcomes with prevented vs negative Clostridioides difficile tests using a computerized clinical decision support tool. Open Forum Infectious Diseases, 7(4), Article ofaa094. https://doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofaa094
McDonald, L. C., Gerding, D. N., Johnson, S., Bakken, J. S., Carroll, K. C., Coffin, S. E., Dubberke, E. R., Garey, K. W., Gould, C. V., Kelly, C., Loo, V., Shaklee Sammons, J., Sandora, T. J., & Wilcox, M. H. (2018). Clinical practice guidelines for Clostridium difficile infection in adults and children: 2017 update by the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America (SHEA). Clinical Infectious Diseases, 66(7), e1-e48. https://doi.org/10.1093/cid/cix1085
Reading the GCU NSG 448 Topic 8 instructions
Topic 8 in NSG-448 asks students to respond to an objection to their capstone. Strong papers quote the objection fairly, then answer it with evidence suited to its substance, for a workload objection a time ledger that lists minutes added and removed with the assumptions behind each figure. Students should admit where the change costs more, for example in the first month, consider giving something back to the staff and state what cannot be counted honestly. The paper should restate the decision being asked for, and if the change really does add work overall, it should say so and explain why it is still worth doing.
How this NSG 448 Topic 8 example is built
The objection is quoted first, in the words a night charge nurse might use at the practice council: the floor already runs a falls checklist, a skin checklist and a restraint review, and this adds another. The response does not dispute it. It builds a time ledger instead. On the added side sit the huddle check per catheterized patient, the follow-up check after removal, toileting help for patients newly without a catheter, and training hours in the first month. On the removed side sit catheter care, emptying and measuring drainage bags, and the documentation each catheter requires every shift. The net is shown with its assumptions, and the paper concedes that the first month costs more than it saves. It then offers to retire a redundant step from an existing checklist, and closes by restating the pilot decision.
Where the marks sit in the NSG 448 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward an objection answered with honest arithmetic. An Excellent paper quotes the night charge nurse and tables minutes added and removed per month with assumptions, based on about 15 tests. Credit goes to showing a net saving near 170 minutes in an ongoing month while admitting the first month costs more. The rubric values retiring the paper stool log as something given back. Strong papers name uncounted costs, such as night call interruptions, with McDonald and colleagues and Madden and colleagues. Top marks go to restating the decision requested.
Common NSG 448 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Dismissing the objection loses this topic faster than anything else. A response that calls the protocol quick and simple, or promises it will barely be noticed, confirms the charge nurse's suspicion that the proposer has never worked the shift. Arguing from benefits alone, fewer infections and better outcomes, misses the point, because the objection was about time. A ledger that counts only what is saved looks rigged, and one that ignores work moved onto assistants is incomplete. New theory introduced at this stage also costs marks, since the capstone integrates rather than adds. A defense that ends in reassurance rather than a restated request leaves the decision hanging. The most persuasive examples concede the first month's cost plainly and offer something back.
Get an NSG-448 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the NSG-448 Topic 8 instructions and the rubric from your classroom, with your proposal and the objection your instructor or unit contacts expect. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the objection stated fairly, a two-way time ledger, the real cost conceded and the request restated, in 24 to 48 hours. Your first one is free.
More NSG 448 papers and BSN samples
- NSG 448 Topic 1: Picot Narrowing Paper
- NSG 448 Topic 2: Evidence Search Audit Trail
- NSG 448 Topic 3: Evidence Quality Appraisal
- NSG 448 Topic 4: Intervention Fit Analysis
- NSG 448 Topic 5: Unit Sign-off Dq Post
- NSG 448 Topic 6: Workflow-embedded Measurement Plan
- NSG 448 Topic 7: Nurse Manager Proposal Memo
- NSG 300 Topic 8: Professional Identity Reflection
- NSG 444 Topic 8: First-year Transition Plan
- NSG 310 Topic 8: Competency Gap Plan
- NSG 440 Topic 8: Falsifiable Evaluation Plan
NSG 448 Topic 8 questions, answered
What if the protocol really does add work overall?
Then say so and make the case anyway, if it holds. A change can be worth added minutes when it prevents harm, and a decision-maker is more likely to accept an honest net cost than a claim of zero burden. State the size of the cost, who carries it, and what the floor gets in return, then let the manager weigh it.
Can I introduce a new framework to answer the objection?
It is better not to. The capstone integrates what earlier topics established, so the defense should draw on the appraisal, the fit analysis and the measurement plan already written. If a change theory has been part of your course materials, it can be named briefly, but the answer to a workload objection is arithmetic and honesty, not a model introduced at the last step.
Are there other objections worth answering?
Usually one or two besides workload. For a nurse-driven removal protocol, physicians may question nurses removing catheters without an individual order, and some staff worry about urinary retention after removal. A short paragraph on each, pointing to the committee approval and the balancing measure, is enough. Keep the main effort on workload, since that is the objection most likely to decide the vote.
Where can I find a free NSG 448 Topic 8 sample paper?
The objection paper for NSG 448 Topic 8 covers the objection, the ledger, the net with assumptions, something given back, what the ledger does not count and the decision restated. Share your NSG 448 Topic 8 prompt for a free paper.
What if the protocol really adds work in NSG 448 Topic 8?
Say so and explain why it is still worth doing. Here the first month adds time, and the paper shows the ongoing saving and offers to retire the paper log.