NUR 324 Topic 2 PICOT question defense example

Research and Evidence-Based Practice Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 324 Topic 2 sample paper drafts three PICOT questions about IV administration set intervals on a composite medical floor and defends the narrow one that survives. It belongs to GCU NUR 324, Research and Evidence-Based Practice, listed as NUR-324, part of Grand Canyon University's MSN. The uncertainty is quoted from a night nurse. Candidate one is too wide; candidate two, coated tubing, is unobtainable. Candidate three is narrower, duller and usable. The comparison is written down as the floor's actual routine. Phlebitis replaces bloodstream infection as an outcome the floor can count, scored with Gallant and Schultz's scale. Ullman and colleagues' Cochrane review supports the question, and the eight-week timeframe is argued.

CourseNUR 324 Research and Evidence-Based Practice
TopicTopic 2
Paper typePICOT question defense
LengthAbout 1,000 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 324 Topic 2

1

Three Drafts, One Survivor: Defending a Narrow PICOT Question About IV Administration Set Intervals on a Medical Floor

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-324: Research and Evidence-Based Practice

Topic 2 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

January 17, 2028

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the method: three candidate questions are printed and tested, and the narrowest and dullest wins. Most of the attention goes to the comparison, because usual care is only a placeholder until someone writes down what the unit actually does. The floor is a composite.
2

Three Drafts, One Survivor: Defending a Narrow PICOT Question About IV Administration Set Intervals on a Medical Floor

The Uncertainty, as the Floor Says It

The uncertainty came from a night nurse on the composite medical floor examined in Topic 1: "If we stopped changing the tubing every night, would the IVs get infected?" The question is vague on purpose; it is how nurses actually raise a doubt. It does not say which tubing, which patients, what counts as infected or compared with what. A searchable, answerable question has to supply each of those, and the choices determine whether the answer will be usable on this floor (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023).

Candidate One: Too Wide

In hospitalized patients with intravenous therapy (P), does less frequent administration set replacement (I), compared with more frequent replacement (C), reduce infection (O)?

This question names a population so wide that no unit could recruit it and no search could settle it: it includes central and peripheral lines, adults and neonates, blood products, lipids and parenteral nutrition, each with different risks and different evidence. A search returns thousands of records across incompatible settings. The answer, if there were one, would not tell the floor what to do with its peripheral maintenance infusions.

Candidate Two: Unobtainable

In adult medical patients with peripheral infusions (P), does antimicrobial-coated administration tubing replaced every 7 days (I), compared with standard tubing replaced every 24 hours (C), reduce catheter-related bloodstream infection (O) over one year (T)?

The population is better, but the intervention is one the floor cannot obtain: the hospital's supply contract does not include coated tubing, and the value analysis committee has no plan to add it. Whichever way the answer came out, the floor could not act on it. A question worth searching is one whose answer could change practice here.

Candidate Three: Narrower, Duller, Usable

In adult medical patients with continuous peripheral maintenance infusions not containing blood, blood products or lipids (P), does replacing the primary administration set at 96 hours (I), compared with the floor's current practice of replacing the primary set and extension set every night at 2200 regardless of dwell time (C), change the rate of peripheral catheter phlebitis, measured as a Visual Infusion Phlebitis score of 2 or higher per 100 catheter days (O), over eight weeks (T)?

It is narrower and less exciting than either draft. It wins.

The Comparison, Written Down

Usual care is a placeholder until somebody writes down what usual care currently is on the unit, and a comparison left as "standard practice" hides the very thing being tested. On this floor, usual care is not simply 24-hour replacement. It is replacement of the primary set every night at 2200 regardless of when the set was hung, so a set hung at 1800 is changed after four hours; replacement of the extension set at the same time; and discarding of any partly used bag. The comparison in candidate three names all of that, because each element opens the line and each could affect the outcome. A search can then look for studies whose comparison resembles it, and the floor can see exactly what it would stop doing.

What this page is doingEach draft is printed and taken apart for the specific element that fails. The highlighted sentence explains why the comparison gets most of the attention, and the section writes down usual care exactly as the floor performs it.
3

The Outcome, Checked Against What the Floor Collects

Catheter-related bloodstream infection is the outcome that matters most, but on a single medical floor with peripheral lines it is too rare to measure; the floor has recorded none in three years. Phlebitis is more frequent and is already collected. Nurses on this floor document a Visual Infusion Phlebitis score every shift, a scale developed to guide when a peripheral catheter should be removed (Gallant & Schultz, 2006), and the score is in the electronic record. Using catheter days as the denominator adjusts for how long lines stay in, which the intervention could itself change. The outcome therefore needs no new data collection, and bloodstream infection can still be tracked as a safety measure.

The Timeframe, Argued

Eight weeks was not chosen to fill the letter T. Phlebitis in peripheral catheters typically appears within the first few days of dwell, so each catheter's outcome is known within about a week. The floor places about 40 peripheral catheters a week on maintenance infusions, so eight weeks yields roughly 320 catheters and 900 catheter days, enough to see a meaningful difference in phlebitis if one exists and short enough to report within a term. A longer period would add little; a shorter one would leave too few catheters to compare. Evidence from trials of administration set intervals suggests no difference is expected at 96 hours for these sets (Ullman et al., 2013), so the question is really whether the floor's own data confirm that locally.

What the Question Leaves Out

Narrowing has a price, and the discarded ground should be visible. The question excludes central lines, which the floor rarely manages and which carry different risks; infusions of blood, blood products and lipids, for which current guidance still calls for shorter replacement intervals; and intermittent infusions, which are disconnected and reconnected and so raise a separate question about how often the line is opened. It also leaves aside the two steps that Topic 1 found no source for, the daily extension set change and the discarding of partly used bags. Those could be folded into the intervention, but testing three changes at once would make any result impossible to attribute. They are better handled as policy corrections, since no evidence supports them, while the question tests the one change with a real, if dated, evidence history.

How the Answer Would Be Used

If the floor's phlebitis rate at 96 hours is no higher than under the nightly change, the result supports adopting the national interval and returns about 90 minutes of night-shift time. If it is higher, the floor has learned something the published trials did not show for its patients, and the practice council would look at why before changing anything. Either answer is usable, which is the test the first two drafts failed.

References

Gallant, P., & Schultz, A. A. (2006). Evaluation of a visual infusion phlebitis scale for determining appropriate discontinuation of peripheral intravenous catheters. Journal of Infusion Nursing, 29(6), 338-345. https://doi.org/10.1097/00129804-200611000-00004

Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.

Ullman, A. J., Cooke, M. L., Gillies, D., Marsh, N. M., Daud, A., McGrail, M. R., O'Riordan, E., & Rickard, C. M. (2013). Optimal timing for intravascular administration set replacement. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (9), Article CD003588. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD003588.pub3

Reading the GCU NUR 324 Topic 2 instructions

Topic 2 in NUR-324 asks students to develop and defend a PICOT question. Strong papers begin with the uncertainty as it is voiced on the unit, show candidate questions that failed and explain why, then defend the surviving question element by element. Students should write down what usual care actually is rather than leaving the comparison vague, choose an outcome the unit can measure and argue the timeframe from the clinical course of the outcome. The paper should state what the question leaves out and how the answer would be used, since a correctly formatted question earns only part of the marks and the defense earns the rest.

How the NUR-324 Topic 2 example is put together

The finished example prints all three questions and then takes them apart. The uncertainty is stated first as a nurse on the floor would put it, which is vague on purpose. Candidate one names a population so wide that no unit could recruit it. Candidate two names an intervention the unit cannot obtain, so the answer would be unusable whichever way it came out. Candidate three is narrower and duller, and it wins. The comparison is where the example spends most of its attention, because usual care is a placeholder until somebody writes down what usual care currently is on that unit, and here it is written down. The outcome is checked against what the unit already collects. The timeframe is argued from how long the outcome takes to appear rather than chosen to fill the letter.

Where the marks sit in the NUR 324 Topic 2 rubric

Faculty reward a question defended element by element. An Excellent paper quotes the night nurse's uncertainty and shows a too-wide draft and an unobtainable draft about coated tubing. Credit goes to writing the comparison as the floor's nightly change of primary and extension sets. The rubric values choosing phlebitis, scored with Gallant and Schultz's scale, over bloodstream infection, which is too rare on one floor, with Ullman and colleagues' Cochrane review. Strong papers argue eight weeks from when phlebitis appears. Top marks go to naming what the question leaves out.

NUR 324 Topic 2 help before you submit

The reliable loss is a question that satisfies the format and answers nothing, and it is visible in the comparison, which reads usual care and stops. A second failure is an outcome nothing on the unit records, since an answer that cannot be observed is not worth the search that finds it. Questions written so broadly that any patient qualifies return thousands of results and settle nothing, and graduate readers treat that as a failure of judgment rather than a search problem. Papers presenting one question with no rejected drafts have not shown the choice being made. A timeframe attached because the letter demanded one, with no reasoning about how long the outcome takes to appear, is decoration.

Get an NUR-324 Topic 2 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-324 Topic 2 assignment instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the clinical area your section assigns. We write a custom example to those criteria, with three candidate questions drafted, current practice written out as a real comparison, and the surviving question defended, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More NUR 324 papers and MSN samples

NUR 324 Topic 2 questions, answered

Why is the comparison the hardest element?

Because it is the one people write without thinking. Usual care names nothing until somebody describes what the unit currently does, step by step, and units differ. Once it is written out, two things happen: you can tell whether your intervention is actually different, and you can tell whether anyone would be able to detect a change if it worked.

Does the question have to be answerable where I work?

For a graduate paper, yes, in the sense that the answer has to be usable. A question about an intervention nobody can obtain produces a search, a synthesis and no decision. Narrowing until the answer would change something is not a retreat; it is what separates a question a unit can act on from an interesting one.

Is a correctly formatted question enough?

It gets the marks the rubric assigns to format, which is rarely most of them. What faculty read next is whether each element was chosen or merely filled in: whether the population could be assembled, whether the outcome is recorded anywhere, whether the timeframe follows from the biology. A question can be perfectly lettered and still ask for something nobody could find.

Where can I find a free NUR 324 Topic 2 sample paper?

The PICOT paper for NUR 324 Topic 2 covers the uncertainty as the floor says it, three candidate questions, the comparison written down, the outcome checked against what the floor collects, the timeframe, what the question leaves out and how the answer would be used. Share your NUR 324 Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.

Why is the comparison the hardest element in NUR 324 Topic 2?

Because usual care is rarely written down. Until the floor's actual routine is described, the comparison hides what is really being tested.