| Course | NUR 324 Research and Evidence-Based Practice |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 4 |
| Paper type | Research design comparison |
| Length | About 1,010 words, 3 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 324 Topic 4
What Each Design Bought and What It Cost: A Randomized Exercise Trial and an Observational Mobility Program Compared for One Floor's Question
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-324: Research and Evidence-Based Practice
Topic 4 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
January 31, 2028
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
What Each Design Bought and What It Cost: A Randomized Exercise Trial and an Observational Mobility Program Compared for One Floor's Question
The Floor's Question
A composite 30-bed medical floor admits many older adults who leave the hospital weaker than they came in. The nurse manager asked whether a nurse- and assistant-led walking program would help older patients keep their function during a hospital stay. Two studies address the question: a randomized trial of a multicomponent exercise program for very old inpatients in Spain (Martinez-Velilla et al., 2019), and an observational evaluation of an assisted early mobility program for older veterans in the United States (Hastings et al., 2014). The textbook ranking places the trial above the cohort. This comparison asks instead what each design did and what that bought and cost, since a design label describes a method, not the value of the answer for a particular floor (Melnyk & Fineout-Overholt, 2023).
The Trial: What It Did
Martinez-Velilla et al. (2019) randomly assigned 370 patients with a mean age of 87 on an acute care unit to usual care or to individualized resistance, balance and walking exercises in two supervised sessions a day, for a median of five days. Randomization means the two groups were alike on average in every characteristic, measured or not, before the intervention began, so a difference at discharge can be attributed to the exercise. The exercise group finished with higher scores on the Barthel Index of independence, by about 7 points, and on the Short Physical Performance Battery, by about 2 points, than the usual-care group, and no adverse effects were observed.
What that claim cost. To run a trial safely and cleanly, the investigators had to exclude patients who could not take part: those unable to walk or stand, those with severe dementia, those expected to stay only briefly or with a terminal illness. Exercise sessions were supervised by trained staff, twice a day. The trial therefore shows that exercise works in very old patients who can walk, can follow instructions and stay long enough to receive it, but many of the patients the floor actually admits, including those with advanced dementia and those who cannot stand on admission, were not in it.
The Cohort: What It Did
Hastings et al. (2014) described an assisted early mobility program for veterans aged 60 and older admitted to medical wards, in which a therapist or trained assistant walked each enrolled patient daily. Enrollment was part of routine care, not a research protocol, and the outcome was where patients went at discharge. Program participants were compared with patients who were eligible for the program but did not receive it, and more of the participants were discharged to their own homes, fewer to skilled nursing care.
What that design bought and cost. Because the program enrolled patients as they came, its sample looks like a real ward, older men with multiple conditions admitted for ordinary medical reasons, and its staffing model resembles what a floor could run. But the two groups were not assigned by chance, so they differed before anything happened. Confounding is the specific list of reasons they might have differed: patients referred to the program may have been less ill, more mobile at baseline, more cognitively intact, or more motivated; they may have had family support that made discharge home possible regardless of walking; and patients not enrolled may have been those admitted on weekends or to units where the program was less active. Any of these could produce the difference in discharge destination without the program having caused it.
What Each Measured, and Why It Matters
The two studies also measured different things. The trial measured function directly, with standard scales scored at admission and discharge by assessors who did not know which group a patient was in, which protects the result from the hopes of the people delivering the exercise. The cohort measured discharge destination, which is recorded for every patient and matters greatly to families, but depends on much more than function: the availability of a caregiver at home, insurance coverage for a skilled nursing stay, and the discharge planner's judgment. A walking program might improve function without changing where a patient goes, or appear to change destination because of who was enrolled. For the floor, both measures are useful, but only the first isolates the effect of walking.
Setting the Two Side by Side
The trial establishes that a supervised exercise program causes better function at discharge in very old patients who can take part. It cannot say whether the effect holds in the patients it excluded. The cohort suggests that a walking program run with ordinary staff is associated with more patients going home in a population that looks like the floor's, but it cannot show that the program caused it. Sample sizes alone do not help the comparison: the trial's 370 patients were highly selected, and the cohort's participants were self-selected in a different way. The question in each case is who was in the sample, not how many.
Neither study alone would justify the change. The trial provides the causal evidence the cohort lacks; the cohort provides evidence of feasibility and of a similar direction of effect in a real-world population that the trial lacks. Together, they support a program for patients who can walk with help, with the honest caveat that the evidence is weakest for the patients the floor most worries about.
What the Floor Should Do
The floor could begin a walking program modeled on the cohort's staffing, using a nurse and an assistant rather than a separate exercise team, for patients aged 70 and older who can stand with help, and measure function at admission and discharge with a simple tool it already uses. It should not claim the trial's effect size for its own patients, and it should record function in the patients it cannot enroll, so that the gap the trial left, and the gap between who is walked and who is not, becomes visible in its own data.
References
Hastings, S. N., Sloane, R., Morey, M. C., Pavon, J. M., & Hoenig, H. (2014). Assisted early mobility for hospitalized older veterans: Preliminary data from the STRIDE program. Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 62(11), 2180-2184. https://doi.org/10.1111/jgs.13095
Martinez-Velilla, N., Casas-Herrero, A., Zambom-Ferraresi, F., Saez de Asteasu, M. L., Lucia, A., Galbete, A., Garcia-Baztan, A., Alonso-Renedo, J., Gonzalez-Glaria, B., Gonzalo-Lazaro, M., Apezteguia Iraizoz, I., Gutierrez-Valencia, M., Rodriguez-Manas, L., & Izquierdo, M. (2019). Effect of exercise intervention on functional decline in very elderly patients during acute hospitalization: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 179(1), 28-36. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.4869
Melnyk, B. M., & Fineout-Overholt, E. (2023). Evidence-based practice in nursing & healthcare: A guide to best practice (5th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
Reading the GCU NUR 324 Topic 4 instructions
Topic 4 in NUR-324 asks students to compare research designs and what each can establish. Strong papers present two studies on the same practical question, describe what each did and measured and explain what the design allows each to conclude, including the role of confounding in observational studies. Students should set the studies side by side and recognize that the highest level of evidence is not always the most useful for a particular unit's question, since feasibility and setting matter. The paper should end with what the unit should do, drawing on the strengths of each design, at a level suited to graduate study.
How the NUR-324 Topic 4 example is put together
The finished comparison refuses to rank the two studies by their labels. Both address the same composite question, and both are described by what they did rather than by what they are called. The trial randomized, which buys it the claim that the groups differed only by the intervention, and the example says what that claim cost: strict eligibility that excluded the older, sicker patients the floor actually admits. The cohort study enrolled everybody, which makes its sample recognizable and its causal claim weak, since the two groups differed before anything happened. Confounding is treated as a specific list of variables rather than as a word. The finding is split. One study establishes that the effect exists and the other suggests it survives in patients like ours, and neither alone would justify the change.
Reading the NUR 324 Topic 4 rubric
Faculty reward designs judged by what each can establish. An Excellent paper describes Martinez-Velilla and colleagues' trial of 370 patients with a mean age of 87 and Hastings and colleagues' assisted mobility cohort. Credit goes to explaining that randomization shows the exercise program causes better function while the cohort shows feasibility with nurses and assistants. The rubric values comparing what each measured and naming confounding in the cohort. Melnyk and Fineout-Overholt frame the hierarchy. The best papers recommend a walking program modeled on the cohort's staffing.
Common NUR 324 Topic 4 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Papers that rank designs by a published hierarchy and stop there lose marks, because the hierarchy answers a general question and the assignment asked about one. A second failure is describing a design instead of judging it, recognizable when the paragraph would fit any study of that type. Treating an observational finding as worthless ignores that its patients look like the ones on the floor, and treating a trial as settled ignores everybody it excluded. Sample sizes reported with no comment on who was in them tell a reader nothing about transfer. Confounding used as a verdict rather than as a list of variables is a word standing in for the work. Verdicts with no acknowledged trade have not compared anything.
Get an NUR-324 Topic 4 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-324 Topic 4 assignment instructions and the rubric your classroom posts, with the articles your section assigns or the ones you selected. We write a custom example to those criteria, comparing what each design can establish about your question, with the transfer problem argued and the verdict left divided, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NUR 324 papers and MSN samples
- NUR 324 Topic 1: Evidence Versus Tradition Paper
- NUR 324 Topic 2: PICOT Question Defense
- NUR 324 Topic 3: Reproducible Search Protocol
- NUR 324 Topic 5: Thin Evidence DQ Pair
- NUR 324 Topic 6: Rapid Critical Appraisal
- NUR 324 Topic 7: Single Patient Decision Brief
- NUR 324 Topic 8: Practice Adoption Defense
- NUR 502 Topic 4: Middle Range Theory Evaluation
- NUR 648EA Topic 4: Earned Independence Rationale
- NUR 504 Topic 4: Quantitative Critique Paper
- NUR 646EA Topic 4: Evaluation Method Justification
NUR 324 Topic 4 questions, answered
Is the highest level of evidence always the best answer?
Not for a specific patient population. A trial sits high because its design supports a causal claim, but that claim covers the people it enrolled. If those people are younger and healthier than the ones you admit, a weaker study on a recognizable sample may tell you more about what to expect. Read the hierarchy as a starting point, not a verdict.
What does confounding actually look like in a paper?
A list, not a label. It means naming the ways the two groups differed before the intervention, saying which of those differences could plausibly produce the outcome, and reporting whether the authors adjusted for them. A paragraph that says the study was confounded without naming a single variable has used the word to avoid doing the reading.
How is this different from the undergraduate design topic?
The undergraduate version asks you to recognize designs. This one asks whether a design supports a decision you are about to make on real patients, which means the exclusions matter as much as the results, and a study that is technically stronger can still be the one you set aside. In current classrooms that judgment carries most of the marks.
Where can I find a free NUR 324 Topic 4 sample paper?
The design comparison for NUR 324 Topic 4 covers the floor's question, the trial, the cohort, what each measured, setting the two side by side and what the floor should do. Your own NUR 324 Topic 4 prompt gets a free paper.
Is the highest level of evidence always best in NUR 324 Topic 4?
Not for every question. The trial proves the exercise program works, but the cohort shows how a floor with ordinary staff can run something similar.