| Course | NUR 621 Principles of Health Care Financial Management |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 8 |
| Paper type | Program financial analysis |
| Length | About 1,230 words, 5 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 621 Topic 8
Worth It Only if the Empty Beds Fill: A Financial Analysis of a Six-Bed Hospital-at-Home Pilot
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-621: Principles of Health Care Financial Management
Topic 8 Benchmark Assignment
[Instructor Name]
November 26, 2029
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Worth It Only if the Empty Beds Fill: A Financial Analysis of a Six-Bed Hospital-at-Home Pilot
The Situation and the Decision Required
The health system has asked each of its hospitals whether to open a hospital-at-home program in fiscal year 2031. At this composite 310-bed hospital, the proposal is a six-bed program run from 5 West, the 32-bed medical unit I manage, for adults admitted through the emergency department with heart failure, exacerbations of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, pneumonia, cellulitis or urinary tract infection. Patients would receive hospital-level care at home: two nurse or paramedic visits a day, daily physician video rounds, remote monitoring, intravenous medication and courier laboratory service. The decision is whether to approve a two-year pilot or decline. All figures below are illustrative.
The Financial Facts
Table 1 assembles the figures that bear on the decision. Payment is the same for a home episode and an inpatient stay under Medicare's hospital-at-home waiver and the two commercial contracts the finance office has confirmed, so the difference lies entirely in cost and in what the freed beds can do.
Table 1
Financial Facts for the Hospital-at-Home Decision
| Item | Figure | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Average payment per episode, target conditions | $9,800 | Finance office, fiscal year 2029 claims |
| Variable cost per inpatient episode on 5 West, 4.2-day stay | $5,600 | Cost accounting |
| Variable cost per home episode, 5.0-day stay | $4,700 | Vendor quotes and staffing model |
| Fixed program cost per year: 4.2 command center nurse positions at $130,000, medical director stipend $90,000, program manager $120,000, monitoring platform $180,000, logistics contract $64,000 | $1,000,000 | Proposal budget |
| One-time startup: training, 12 monitoring kits, credentialing | $110,000 | Proposal budget |
| Transfer requests declined for lack of a bed, fiscal year 2029 | 240 | Transfer center log |
| Average contribution margin of a declined transfer, 4.6-day stay | $7,400 | Finance office |
Methods Chosen and Methods Set Aside
Two methods fit this decision: incremental contribution margin analysis, which asks how much each episode adds toward fixed costs compared with what would happen without the program, and break-even analysis, which asks how much activity the program needs to cover those fixed costs (Reiter & Song, 2021). Net present value was set aside because the capital outlay is small, $110,000, and the decision turns on annual operating margins rather than on a large purchase recovered over many years. Ratio analysis of the hospital's statements was also set aside, since the question concerns one service rather than the organization's overall financial position, and a change in the operating margin ratio would say nothing about whether this program caused it.
The Analysis
Volume comes first. Six virtual beds at 80 percent occupancy provide 1,752 patient days a year. Home episodes last longer than inpatient stays, which matches the pooled finding that treatment at home lasted about 5.45 days longer in trials of patients with chronic disease (Arsenault-Lapierre et al., 2021); the proposal's local estimate of 5.0 days gives 350 episodes a year.
The program creates value in two ways. The first is the cost difference on each shifted episode. An inpatient episode contributes $9,800 less $5,600, or $4,200; a home episode contributes $9,800 less $4,700, or $5,100. Each episode moved home therefore adds $900, or $315,000 a year across 350 episodes. The local cost saving of about 16 percent is deliberately conservative next to the 38 percent lower direct cost found in the one U.S. randomized trial, which studied a small and highly selected group at two sites (Levine et al., 2020).
The second is capacity. Moving 350 episodes home frees 1,470 inpatient bed days a year, enough in principle for about 320 transfer admissions at 4.6 days each. The hospital declined 240 transfers last year, but not every declined patient would still come, and some would need a surgical or cardiac bed that a freed medical bed does not directly supply. The analysis assumes half are recaptured, 120 a year at $7,400 each, or $888,000.
Together the program adds $1,203,000 a year in steady state against $1,000,000 in fixed costs, a gain of $203,000. The first year is weaker. At 60 percent of planned volume while referrals build, the program would add $189,000 from shifted episodes and $532,800 from 72 recaptured transfers, and after fixed and startup costs would lose $388,200. The two-year pilot therefore ends $185,200 behind and recovers its losses during year 3.
Table 2
Annual Result of the Hospital-at-Home Program Under Four Scenarios
| Scenario | Shift value | Capacity value | Fixed and startup costs | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1, 60 percent volume | $189,000 | $532,800 | $1,110,000 | ($388,200) |
| Steady state, 350 episodes | $315,000 | $888,000 | $1,000,000 | $203,000 |
| Steady state, no transfers recaptured | $315,000 | $0 | $1,000,000 | ($685,000) |
| Steady state, 6.0-day home stay | $262,800 | $888,000 | $1,000,000 | $150,800 |
Interpreting the Result
The finding that matters is that the cost saving on each episode cannot pay for the program by itself: covering $1,000,000 in fixed costs from a $900 saving would take about 1,111 episodes a year, more than three times what six beds can provide, so the program is worth approving only in a hospital that is turning patients away. This hospital is. Its occupancy averaged 93 percent last year, and the transfer center declined 240 requests. Break-even requires about 93 recaptured transfers a year, since $1,000,000 less the $315,000 shift value leaves $685,000 to be covered at $7,400 each. The planning assumption of 120 sits about 29 percent above that line.
The clinical evidence supports the substitution. Pooled trials found no difference in mortality and a lower risk of readmission for hospital-at-home patients (Arsenault-Lapierre et al., 2021), and the U.S. trial found fewer readmissions within 30 days, 7 percent against 23 percent (Levine et al., 2020). A lower readmission rate helps patients but, because each admission is paid as its own episode, it also means fewer paid episodes, so it is noted here and not counted as revenue.
The Decision
Approve a two-year, six-bed hospital-at-home pilot, on the condition that the transfer center is directed to accept declined transfers into the beds the program frees.
The reasoning is that the program adds about $203,000 a year once established, carries a known two-year loss of $185,200 that is small against the hospital's operating budget, and addresses the capacity problem that turns patients away. Without the transfer condition, the same program would lose about $685,000 a year, so the condition is part of the decision rather than a hope attached to it.
What Would Reverse It and What I Still Need to Know
Four conditions would reverse this recommendation. If recaptured transfers fall below about 93 a year by the end of the first year, the program cannot cover its fixed costs. If hospital occupancy falls below about 85 percent, freed beds would stay empty and the capacity value would disappear. If the Medicare waiver lapses without a replacement, home episodes would no longer be paid at the inpatient rate. And if home stays stretch well past six days, volume would fall, though Table 2 shows this matters far less than the other three.
Before committing, I would want three facts I do not have: how many of last year's declined transfers needed a bed type a freed medical bed can supply once patients are moved between units, what share of eligible patients will agree to care at home, since refusal was high in the U.S. trial, and whether the remaining commercial payers will pay the inpatient rate for a home episode. Each can be answered in the first quarter of the pilot, and the program should report all three to the finance committee at six months.
References
Arsenault-Lapierre, G., Henein, M., Gaid, D., Le Berre, M., Gore, G., & Vedel, I. (2021). Hospital-at-home interventions vs in-hospital stay for patients with chronic disease who present to the emergency department: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open, 4(6), Article e2111568. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.11568
Levine, D. M., Ouchi, K., Blanchfield, B., Saenz, A., Burke, K., Paz, M., Diamond, K., Pu, C. T., & Schnipper, J. L. (2020). Hospital-level care at home for acutely ill adults: A randomized controlled trial. Annals of Internal Medicine, 172(2), 77-85. https://doi.org/10.7326/M19-0600
Reiter, K. L., & Song, P. H. (2021). Gapenski's healthcare finance: An introduction to accounting and financial management (7th ed.). Health Administration Press.
Reading the GCU NUR 621 Topic 8 instructions
Topic 8 in NUR-621, the benchmark assignment, asks students to apply financial analysis to a decision. Strong papers state the decision required, assemble the relevant financial facts in a table and choose analytic methods because they fit the decision, explaining why other methods were set aside. Students should run the analysis step by step, interpret the result honestly, for example that savings per episode cannot by themselves pay for a program, and make a recommendation with conditions. The paper should state what would reverse the recommendation and what information is still needed, since the recommendation should be certain in its reasoning while open about its assumptions. Methods should be matched to the decision rather than chosen from habit.
How this NUR 621 Topic 8 example is built
The finished example is an analysis that concludes. A situation is chosen with a real decision inside it, whether to continue a service, expand a program, replace a staffing model or accept a contract, since a situation with nothing to decide gives the paper nowhere to arrive. Statements are read, costs are classified, and the relevant method is applied rather than all of them, which is a judgment the benchmark is testing. Assumptions are visible throughout. The decision is then stated in one sentence, followed by the reasoning that supports it and, crucially, by what would reverse it. The example says what it would need to know that it does not, which reads as competence rather than as hedging.
Where the marks sit in the NUR 621 Topic 8 rubric
Faculty reward methods chosen by the decision and an honest result. An Excellent paper tables the facts, noting equal payment for home and inpatient episodes under Medicare's waiver, and chooses incremental contribution margin. Credit goes to computing 1,752 patient days from six beds at 80 percent occupancy. The rubric values finding that per-episode savings cannot cover $1,000,000 in fixed costs, with Levine and colleagues and Arsenault-Lapierre and colleagues. Strong papers make approval conditional on recaptured transfers. Top marks go to four conditions that would reverse it. Conditions are stated.
Common NUR 621 Topic 8 mistakes, and how to avoid them
Analyses that stop at the numbers are the failure this benchmark exposes, and a paper computing three ratios and concluding that the organization should monitor its position has decided nothing. The second loss is applying every method the course covered regardless of fit, which reads as coverage rather than as judgment. Papers lose marks for assumptions hidden inside calculations, since a reader who cannot see an input cannot evaluate a conclusion built on it. Recommendations with no reversal condition treat a projection as a certainty. Arithmetic errors carry more weight in this benchmark than elsewhere, because the decision rests directly on the figures. Decisions stated in conditionals leave the committee to make the call the paper was asked to make.
Get an NUR-621 Topic 8 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-621 Topic 8 instructions and the benchmark rubric from your classroom, with the situation your section assigned and any financial reports you have been given. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the methods selected for the decision, assumptions visible, and a recommendation stated in one sentence with its reversal condition, in 24 to 48 hours. The first is free.
More NUR 621 papers and MSN samples
- NUR 621 Topic 1: Financial Statement Analysis
- NUR 621 Topic 2: Revenue Cycle Trace
- NUR 621 Topic 3: Break-even Analysis
- NUR 621 Topic 4: Operating Budget Build
- NUR 621 Topic 5: Variance Analysis
- NUR 621 Topic 6: Productivity and Staffing Analysis
- NUR 621 Topic 7: Capital Request Analysis
- NUR 630 Topic 8: Benchmark Improvement Project
- NUR 600 Topic 8: Management Plan Defense
- NUR 631 Topic 8: Integrated Case Analysis
- NUR 590 Topic 8: Benchmark Project Proposal
NUR 621 Topic 8 questions, answered
How do I choose which methods to apply?
From the decision rather than from the syllabus. A question about whether a service covers its costs needs contribution margin and break-even; a question about a large purchase needs a capital method; a question about performance against plan needs variance work. Saying in a line why you selected these and not the others demonstrates the judgment a benchmark is designed to assess.
What if the numbers point one way and clinical judgment the other?
Say so explicitly, and make the tension part of the analysis. A service that loses money may still be the right thing for the organization to run, and the honest version states the loss, states the reason for continuing, and identifies what would make it unsustainable. What loses marks is manipulating the figures until they agree with the preferred answer.
How certain does the recommendation need to be?
Certain in its statement and honest about its basis. State the decision plainly rather than in conditionals, then say what it rests on and what would change it. A recommendation surrounded by qualifications reads as an unwillingness to decide, while one presented as beyond question reads as not having understood how much the assumptions are carrying.
Where can I find a free NUR 621 Topic 8 sample paper?
The financial analysis for NUR 621 Topic 8 covers the situation and decision, the financial facts, methods chosen and set aside, the analysis, interpreting the result, the decision and what would reverse it. Share your NUR 621 Topic 8 prompt for a free paper.
What if numbers and clinical judgment disagree in NUR 621 Topic 8?
State both. The program may be good care, but the paper shows it pays only if it fills beds the hospital would otherwise turn away, and recommends on that condition.