NUR 648EA Topic 1 dual duty position paper example

Nursing Education Seminar II Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 648EA Topic 1 sample paper takes a position on the clinical educator's two duties, to the patient and to the learner, and tests it at three bedsides on one medical-surgical morning. It was written for GCU NUR 648EA, Nursing Education Seminar II, catalog code NUR-648EA, a course in Grand Canyon University's MSN. The position comes first: a learner may cost a patient time, patience and some comfort, never safety or the right to refuse. Each duty is traced to the ANA Code of Ethics. Waiting with Mr. R., stopping a heparin connection for Mrs. G. and honoring a refusal by Mrs. K. test it, after Gaberson and colleagues and Santen and colleagues.

CourseNUR 648EA Nursing Education Seminar II
TopicTopic 1
Paper typeClinical teaching position paper
LengthAbout 980 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 648EA Topic 1

1

Time, Patience and Some Comfort, Never Safety or the Right to Refuse: A Position on the Clinical Educator's Two Duties, Tested at Three Bedsides

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-648EA: Nursing Education Seminar II

Topic 1 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

January 14, 2030

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title states the whole position, including its limit, so each bedside moment that follows can confirm it or break it. The learners, patients and moments are composites.
2

Time, Patience and Some Comfort, Never Safety or the Right to Refuse: A Position on the Clinical Educator's Two Duties, Tested at Three Bedsides

The Position

A clinical educator owes a duty to the patient in front of the learner and a duty to the learner's development, and the two are not weights on a scale. A learner's development may cost a patient time, patience and some comfort, with the patient's agreement. It may never cost the patient's safety, and it may never override the patient's right to refuse a learner. No amount of benefit to the learner justifies any amount of added risk to the patient. What follows tests that position at three moments on a composite medical-surgical unit.

Where Each Duty Comes From

The duty to the patient rests on the nurse's primary commitment to the patient and on the patient's right to self-determination, including the right to decline care from a particular person (American Nurses Association, 2015). The duty to the learner rests on the program's obligation to prepare nurses who have practiced under supervision, since a graduate who has only watched cannot practice safely. The second duty is real, but it is exercised inside the first, not beside it.

First Moment: Waiting While a Stable Patient Has Agreed

A second-semester learner is performing a full respiratory and cardiac assessment on Mr. R., a composite 70-year-old man admitted two days earlier with cellulitis, now stable. The assessment takes her 25 minutes, where a staff nurse would take eight. Before she began, I asked Mr. R. whether a student could do his assessment and told him it would take longer; he agreed and said he was glad to help. Halfway through, she loses her place and restarts the lung fields. I wait.

Waiting is what the position permits. The cost to Mr. R. is his time and some tedium, which he accepted; nothing in his condition made the delay a risk. What was permitted to the learner was to be slow and to repeat. What was asked of the patient was patience, with the chance to stop at any point, which I checked once more at the 15-minute mark.

Second Moment: Stopping First, Explaining Afterward

Later that morning, the same learner reaches to connect a new bag of heparin to Mrs. G.'s infusion without the independent double-check the unit requires, and my hand reaches the line before I say a word about why; the teaching can wait until the patient is safe, and it happens a few feet away, afterward. I said, "Stop, please," put my hand on the tubing, and we completed the check together at the bedside. The explanation came in the medication room: what the check is for, why heparin is on the list and what an error would have meant for Mrs. G.

The order is the point. A learner could have learned something by being allowed to continue and discovering the mistake, but the discovery would have been paid for by the patient. The position does not allow the learner's development to cost safety, even briefly, even when the error would probably have been caught downstream.

What this page is doingThe educator stops the action before any teaching begins, and the paper defends that order as the whole point of the position: the patient's safety is not spent on a learning opportunity.
3

On Consent

Consent is the part of the dual duty that classroom teaching never meets, because simulated patients have already agreed. On a unit, every patient is asked whether a learner may be involved, and the question is asked in a way that allows no. Patients generally agree: in one study, 90 percent consented to procedures by medical students even after being told of the student's inexperience, but refusals clustered where it was the student's first attempt, and two thirds of patients believed they should be told (Santen et al., 2005). Asking is therefore not a formality; the answer is sometimes no, and the patient is entitled to know what they are agreeing to.

Third Moment: A Refusal Honored Without Argument

Mrs. K., a composite 58-year-old woman with a wound after abdominal surgery, is asked whether a student may change her dressing. She says, "I'd rather the nurse did it, if that's all right." It is all right. I thank her, the staff nurse changes the dressing, and the learner stays in the room with Mrs. K.'s permission to watch. Afterward, she changes a dressing for a patient who has agreed, and she and I talk about what Mrs. K.'s refusal told us: that she was anxious about the wound, which is a nursing finding in its own right. Trying to persuade Mrs. K. would have treated her consent as an obstacle to the learner's progress rather than as part of the duty I owe her.

Classroom Habits That Do Not Transplant

Three strategies that work in a skills lab change meaning at the bedside. Letting an error run so that the learner discovers it is sound in simulation and unacceptable with a patient, as the second moment showed. Long silent wait time after a question is useful in a classroom; at the bedside, silence while a patient watches the learner struggle can alarm the patient, so questions that need thinking time are asked outside the room. Correction in front of peers helps a group learn in the lab; in front of a patient, it can undermine the patient's trust in the learner and the learner's standing with the patient, and it is kept for afterward unless safety requires otherwise (Gaberson et al., 2018).

Where the Line Will Be Hardest to Hold

The line will be hardest to hold where comfort shades into safety: a patient in pain whom a learner is slow to reassess, or a confused patient who cannot meaningfully consent. The position does not yet say exactly where time becomes risk in the first case, and the second requires a surrogate's consent and a narrower role for the learner. Both need more thought than a position paper can give them.

References

American Nurses Association. (2015). Code of ethics for nurses with interpretive statements.

Gaberson, K. B., Oermann, M. H., & Shellenbarger, T. (2018). Clinical teaching strategies in nursing (5th ed.). Springer.

Santen, S. A., Hemphill, R. R., Spanier, C. M., & Fletcher, N. D. (2005). "Sorry, it's my first time!" Will patients consent to medical students learning procedures? Medical Education, 39(4), 365-369. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02113.x

NUR 648EA Topic 1 instructions, in plain terms

Topic 1 in NUR-648EA asks nurse educators to take a position on the clinical educator's duties to patients and to learners. Strong papers state the position in a sentence that could be wrong, trace each duty to its source, such as the profession's ethical code and the patient's right to self-determination, and test the position against specific bedside moments rather than abstract principles. Students should show a moment where both duties are served, one where the patient's safety ends the teaching and one where a patient's refusal is honored, and explain which classroom habits change meaning at the bedside. The paper should name where the position will be hardest to hold, such as where comfort shades into safety. Consent deserves its own section, since simulated patients have already agreed and every patient on a unit must be asked whether a learner may be involved.

Inside the NUR 648EA Topic 1 example

The position is stated in its first paragraph: a learner's development may cost a patient time, patience and some comfort, and may never cost safety or the right to refuse. Three composite moments then put it under pressure. In the first, a learner takes far longer than usual over an assessment of a stable patient who has agreed to it, and the educator waits. In the second, the learner reaches to hang an infusion without the independent check, and the educator stops the action before explaining anything. In the third, a patient asks that the learner not do her dressing, and the educator honors the request and finds the learning elsewhere. A final section names classroom habits that fail at the bedside, among them letting an error run so the learner discovers it.

NUR 648EA Topic 1 rubric: what Excellent looks like

Faculty reward a position tested at real bedsides. An Excellent paper states that learners may cost patients time and some comfort but never safety or refusal, citing the ANA Code of Ethics. The paper earns credit for three moments, waiting while a stable patient agrees, stopping a heparin connection without a double-check and honoring a refused dressing change. The rubric values a section on consent. Strong papers explain why letting an error run works in simulation but not on a unit, with Gaberson and colleagues and Santen and colleagues. Top marks go to naming where the line is hardest to hold.

Common NUR 648EA Topic 1 mistakes, and how to avoid them

Treating the two duties as weights on a scale is the reading this topic marks down hardest, because it implies some amount of learner benefit could justify some amount of patient risk. Papers that argue the position abstractly, with no moment in which it is tested, leave the reader unsure what the writer would actually do. Consent is often the missing element; a paper where no patient is ever asked has quietly assumed the learner's right to practice. Classroom strategies carried to the bedside unexamined, discovery learning especially, show the patient left out of the reasoning. Overcorrecting costs marks as well, since a position that lets learners do nothing risky produces graduates who have done nothing. The practicum itself is not the subject; hours and site forms appear nowhere in a strong submission.

Get an NUR-648EA Topic 1 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-648EA Topic 1 instructions, your rubric and the clinical setting your section works in. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the position stated early, tested on composite bedside moments, consent treated as part of the duty, and classroom habits examined for what the patient changes, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More NUR 648EA papers and MSN samples

NUR 648EA Topic 1 questions, answered

Is the dual duty really not a balance?

In most moments of a clinical day nothing forces a choice, and both duties are served together. The paper's claim concerns the moments that do force one. There, the patient's safety is not traded against learning at any rate, and a position that talks about weighing them has left open a door the educator must keep shut.

Can a patient refuse to have a learner involved?

In the composite setting the paper describes, yes, and the example treats that as a feature of the duty rather than a disruption to it. The educator's response is shown, not the policy: accepting at once, thanking the patient, and moving the learning to another patient or to a debrief. Your own program's policy governs the real situation, and the paper does not stand in for it.

Does the paper draw on my own practicum?

It can draw on the kind of moment a practicum produces, written as a composite with nothing identifying a patient, learner or site. What it never includes is the practicum record itself. Your hours, logs, preceptor evaluations and signatures belong to you and your program, and no sample is written to replace or fill in any of them.

Where can I find a free NUR 648EA Topic 1 sample paper?

The paper for NUR 648EA Topic 1 covers the position, where each duty comes from, three bedside moments, consent, classroom habits that do not transplant and where the line will be hardest to hold. Send your NUR 648EA Topic 1 prompt and a paper follows free.

What if a patient's comfort and a learner's practice conflict in NUR 648EA Topic 1?

Some comfort may be traded for learning when the patient agrees, but the paper names that boundary as the hardest one to hold.