NUR 648EA Topic 3 clinical questioning sequence example

Nursing Education Seminar II Grand Canyon University Free custom sample in 24 to 48h

This NUR 648EA Topic 3 sample paper analyzes a hallway questioning sequence with a learner who noticed new confusion in Mrs. H., a composite 79-year-old two days after hip repair, but missed a new urinary catheter. It forms part of GCU NUR 648EA, Nursing Education Seminar II, catalog code NUR-648EA, taken within Grand Canyon University's MSN. The situation comes first. The exchange is annotated through Tanner's model of noticing, interpreting, responding and reflecting. Four questions exposed reasoning, after Phillips and Duke. One leading question, could it be delirium, failed. Inouye and colleagues inform the delirium content. A reassessment decision follows, and a steering question asked too early is noted.

CourseNUR 648EA Nursing Education Seminar II
TopicTopic 3
Paper typeClinical questioning analysis
LengthAbout 990 words, 3 pages
FormatAPA 7 student paper
SchoolGrand Canyon University (GCU)
ProgramMSN
UpdatedOctober 2026

Free sample paper for NUR 648EA Topic 3

1

In the Hallway, Not the Room: A Questioning Sequence With a Learner Who Noticed New Confusion and Missed the New Catheter

[Author Name]

College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University

NUR-648EA: Nursing Education Seminar II

Topic 3 Assignment

[Instructor Name]

January 28, 2030

The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.

What this page is doingThe title names where the exchange happened and the finding that reframed it. The patient, learner and exchange are composites written for teaching.
2

In the Hallway, Not the Room: A Questioning Sequence With a Learner Who Noticed New Confusion and Missed the New Catheter

The Situation

Mrs. H., a composite 79-year-old woman, is two days after a hip repair. At 0800 the learner, a third-semester student, reports that she is "confused this morning, she thought I was her daughter." The overnight nurse's note mentions that a urinary catheter was inserted at 0200 for retention. I chose to question rather than simply to check the patient myself because the learner had noticed something important and I needed to know what she would do with it before deciding what she could safely do next. The exchange took place in the hallway, away from the door. A confused patient who hears a learner reason aloud about what might be wrong with her mind is frightened by it and helped by nothing in it.

The Exchange, With Notes

The questions follow Tanner's model of clinical judgment, which moves from what the nurse notices to how she interprets it, then to how she responds and finally to how she reflects on the result (Tanner, 2006).

Table 1

Hallway Questioning Exchange, With Annotations on What Each Answer Showed

ExchangeWhat the answer showed
Educator: "What did you notice when you went in?" Learner: "She called me Karen, that's her daughter. She didn't know she was in the hospital. Yesterday she was fine."Noticing is good: she compared with yesterday, which is the key cue. Readiness: she can recognize a change.
Educator: "What else is different from yesterday?" Learner: "Her pain was a 6 last night. She had oxycodone at 0100." Pause of about 10 seconds.She found the opioid, a real possibility. She has not mentioned the catheter, which is in the night note and in the room.
Educator: "Walk me around her bed. What's there now that wasn't there yesterday?" Learner: "The IV, the call light... oh. The Foley. They put it in at 2."Steering without naming it worked. She now has two new events overnight. Readiness: she needs prompting to survey systematically.
Educator: "Could it be delirium?" Learner: "Yes, I think it's delirium."No information: the question contained its answer. See below.
Educator: "What would you do first?" Learner: "Check her vitals, her oxygen, her blood sugar, and look at the urine in the bag."Responding is sound and in a safe order; oxygen and glucose first are right. Readiness: she can do a focused reassessment.
Educator: "What would tell you you're wrong about the cause?" Learner: "If her urine looks fine and her vitals are normal... then maybe the oxycodone. I'm not sure."Reflection is beginning; she can name what would change her mind for one cause but not yet for a second.
What this page is doingEach question sits beside a note written in terms of readiness: what the educator now knows the learner could safely do next. That ties the questioning to a supervision decision rather than treating it as an end in itself.
3

Questions That Exposed Reasoning and Questions That Did Not

Four questions exposed reasoning. The first showed that she compares with a baseline, the second and third showed that she does not yet survey systematically, the fifth showed a safe order of priorities and the sixth showed the edge of her ability to hold more than one explanation. None of them could have been answered from memory, because each depended on this patient.

Questions that could be answered from memory, such as "What are the risk factors for delirium?", were deliberately not asked. She could have listed them and still missed the catheter, which is exactly what happened before the third question. Studies of clinical teachers' questioning have found that most questions asked in practice call for recall rather than higher-level thinking (Phillips & Duke, 2001), and recall questions tell the educator what a learner knows, not what she will do.

The Question That Failed

"Could it be delirium?" drew only agreement, because it handed the learner the interpretation and asked her to accept it; a learner who had never thought of delirium would have answered the same way, so the answer told me nothing about her reasoning. Delirium is the most likely explanation for an acute change in attention and awareness in an older adult after surgery, and its common precipitants include drugs such as opioids, urinary retention and infection, and the catheters and other devices used to treat them (Inouye et al., 2014), which is why the question was tempting. The rewrite: "What could be causing a change like this overnight?" and then silence until she has a list. When asked that way the next day, about a different patient, she named four causes before I spoke.

The Decision

The learner may reassess Mrs. H. with me present, starting with oxygen saturation, glucose, vital signs and the catheter and urine, and then report to the staff nurse and the surgical team using a structured format. She may not yet reassess alone, because she needed prompting to find one of the two overnight changes. Her reassessment found a temperature of 37.9 degrees Celsius and cloudy urine; the team was called and the plan changed.

Her report to the surgical resident, which I listened to, was organized and specific: the change in mental status since yesterday evening, the catheter inserted at 0200 for 800 mL of retained urine, the oxycodone at 0100, the new low-grade temperature and the cloudy urine, and a request for the resident to assess her and consider a urine culture. She did not suggest a diagnosis, which was appropriate, and she answered the resident's question about Mrs. H.'s baseline from her own assessment the day before. That report is the best evidence in the exchange that the questioning moved her from noticing to acting.

What I Would Ask Differently Tomorrow

I asked the steering question, "What's there now that wasn't there yesterday?", before she had finished describing what she noticed. Tomorrow I would wait longer after the second question, perhaps 20 seconds, before steering, to see whether she finds the catheter herself. I would also ask the reflection question about each possible cause, not only the first she named, so that she practices holding two explanations at once.

References

Inouye, S. K., Westendorp, R. G. J., & Saczynski, J. S. (2014). Delirium in elderly people. The Lancet, 383(9920), 911-922. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60688-1

Phillips, N., & Duke, M. (2001). The questioning skills of clinical teachers and preceptors: A comparative study. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 33(4), 523-529. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2648.2001.01682.x

Tanner, C. A. (2006). Thinking like a nurse: A research-based model of clinical judgment in nursing. Journal of Nursing Education, 45(6), 204-211. https://doi.org/10.3928/01484834-20060601-04

Reading the GCU NUR 648EA Topic 3 instructions

Topic 3 in NUR-648EA asks nurse educators to analyze their own questioning of a learner in a clinical setting. Strong papers describe the situation, report the exchange with notes and organize it with a model of clinical judgment, such as Tanner's. Students should separate questions that exposed the learner's reasoning from questions that did not, explaining what each revealed, and analyze any question that failed, often because it handed the learner the answer to accept. The paper should state the decision that followed and what the educator would ask differently next time. Holding the exchange outside the room matters because the patient is part of the reasoning even when not part of the conversation, and the paper should say why it was placed there. A reasoning question is one a learner could not answer correctly without thinking about this patient.

How this NUR 648EA Topic 3 example is built

The patient is a composite older adult, two days after surgery, who has become confused overnight, and the learner has just reported it. The exchange takes place in the hallway, since a confused patient hearing a learner reason aloud about her mind helps no one. Questions follow the order of Tanner's clinical judgment model: what the learner noticed, how they interpret it, what they would do first, and what would tell them they were wrong. Each question sits beside a short note on what the answer showed. The learner noticed the confusion and missed the new urinary catheter, which reframes the whole exchange. One question, whether it could be delirium, is flagged as a failure, since the learner simply agreed, and the rewritten version asks what else could cause it.

Where the marks sit in the NUR 648EA Topic 3 rubric

Faculty reward questions sorted by what they revealed. An Excellent paper sets the situation, new confusion two days after hip repair, and annotates the exchange through Tanner's model. Credit goes to four questions that exposed reasoning, drawing on Phillips and Duke on questioning. The rubric values analyzing why could it be delirium drew only agreement, with Inouye and colleagues on delirium. Strong papers state the reassessment decision. Top marks go to admitting the steering question about the new catheter came too early.

NUR 648EA Topic 3 help before you submit

Sequences made of what-questions, normal values and drug classes, lose the most, because a learner can answer every one and still be unready to act. Next is the transcript without annotation, which shows questions being asked and leaves the reader to guess what they revealed. Questioning at the bedside of a confused or anxious patient, with no thought for what the patient hears, brings a classroom habit into a room where it can do harm. Leading questions are easy to miss in one's own transcript, and graders reward the writer who finds one and repairs it. A sequence that never connects to a decision about what the learner may do next has treated questioning as an end in itself. Transcripts tidied into perfect exchanges tend to be read as invented.

Get an NUR-648EA Topic 3 example written to your instructions

Send the NUR-648EA Topic 3 instructions, your rubric and the clinical situation your section asks you to question a learner about. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a composite exchange printed in full, each question annotated for what it revealed about readiness, and one flawed question found and rewritten, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.

More NUR 648EA papers and MSN samples

NUR 648EA Topic 3 questions, answered

What separates a reasoning question from a recall question?

Whether a learner could answer it correctly without thinking about this patient. What is a normal sodium can be answered from memory anywhere. Why does this patient's new confusion worry you, and what else might explain it, can only be answered by someone who has looked at her and connected what they saw. The example sorts its own questions by that test.

Why does the exchange happen outside the room?

Because the patient is part of the reasoning even when she is not part of the conversation. Hearing a learner speculate about her confusion could frighten her, and a correction delivered at the bedside undermines the learner in front of the person they are caring for. The example moves the questions a few steps away, and says so, rather than treating location as incidental.

Is Tanner's model required for the sequence?

Not necessarily; your rubric decides whether a named framework is expected. The example uses Tanner's clinical judgment model because its four phases, from noticing through reflecting, put the questions in an order a reader can follow and check. A grader looks for the order doing work, each answer shaping the question after it.

Where can I find a free NUR 648EA Topic 3 sample paper?

The paper for NUR 648EA Topic 3 covers the situation, the exchange with notes, questions that exposed reasoning and those that did not, the question that failed, the decision and what to ask differently. Post your NUR 648EA Topic 3 prompt and get a free paper.

What was wrong with asking could it be delirium in NUR 648EA Topic 3?

It offered the interpretation instead of drawing it out, so agreement showed nothing about whether the learner had reached it alone.