| Course | NUR 643EA Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 3 |
| Paper type | Documentation feedback paper |
| Length | About 960 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 643EA Topic 3
Written for the Nurse Who Arrives at 7 p.m.: Two Notes on the Same Bibasilar Crackles and Four Questions Instead of a Rewrite
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-643EA: Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators
Topic 3 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
January 28, 2030
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Written for the Nurse Who Arrives at 7 p.m.: Two Notes on the Same Bibasilar Crackles and Four Questions Instead of a Rewrite
The Reader
The note is for a specific person: the nurse who takes over Mrs. K., a composite 81-year-old woman admitted with a urinary tract infection, at 7 p.m. That nurse has never met her, will not remember the day's handoff by 3 a.m., and will open the record if Mrs. K. becomes breathless overnight. What counts as enough in the note is whatever lets that nurse decide, alone, whether what she hears at 3 a.m. is new. Every judgment below is made against that reader.
The Expert Note
"14:20. Fine crackles, late inspiratory, at both posterior bases, right to about the tip of the scapula, left lower, did not clear with two coughs. No wheeze. Breath sounds otherwise vesicular throughout. RR 20, SpO2 95% on room air, speaks full sentences. No JVD visible at 45 degrees. Trace ankle edema bilaterally, unchanged from admission. Weight 61.2 kg, up 0.4 kg from yesterday. Not concluding heart failure from this alone; crackles at both bases are common at this age after bed rest. Recheck at 18:00 and after ambulation. Call if crackles extend above mid-scapula, RR above 24 or SpO2 below 92%."
The Novice Note, as the Next Nurse Would Meet It
"14:30. Lungs: decreased breath sounds noted. Patient appears comfortable. Will monitor."
Four Places the Novice Note Fails Its Reader, Each as a Question
The novice note is not wrong in any single word. It fails the 7 p.m. nurse in four places, and each is marked with the question I would ask the novice rather than the sentence I would write for her.
First, a finding with no location. "Decreased breath sounds" where? Question: "If the night nurse listens at 3 a.m. and hears something at the left base, how will she know whether it was there at 2:30 this afternoon?"
Second, an interpretation offered as an observation. The novice heard crackles, as she told me afterward, but wrote decreased breath sounds, which is a different finding with a different meaning; crackles and reduced breath sounds point to different processes (Bohadana et al., 2014). Question: "What did you actually hear, and what word would another nurse use for that sound?"
Third, a plan with no trigger. "Will monitor" tells the reader that something should be watched but not what, how often or what would prompt action. Question: "What would have to change tonight for you to want someone to call?"
Fourth, a judgment standing where a measurement belonged: "appears comfortable" is the one phrase in the note the 7 p.m. nurse cannot check, compare or act on, because the rate, the saturation and whether Mrs. K. could speak in full sentences were all available and none were written down. Question: "If she looks uncomfortable at 3 a.m., what numbers will the night nurse compare with yours?"
Why the Rewritten Note Is Not Handed Back
The fastest correction would be to hand the novice the expert note and ask her to write like that. It would teach her my phrasing and not the standard behind it, and the next note she wrote about a different finding would be no better. Feedback does most good when it shows learners where they stand against the goal and what to try next, rather than supplying the answer (Hattie & Timperley, 2007), and feedback that shifts attention to the teacher's version or away from the task can even reduce performance (Kluger & DeNisi, 1996). The four questions leave the thinking with her. Her second draft, written after we talked, in her words:
How the questions were delivered mattered as much as their content. We sat down at the end of her shift, away from the station, with the note on the screen and the expert note not shown. I asked the questions one at a time and waited for her answer to each before asking the next; when she answered the second question by saying she had heard crackles, she began rewriting the first line before I asked anything else. The questions were not a test of whether she knew the vocabulary, which she did, but of whether she had written for a reader. She had written for herself, as a reminder of what she had done, and the questions moved the reader to the front of her mind.
"14:30. Crackles at both lower back of lungs, R more than L, heard at end of breath in, still there after she coughed twice. RR 20, O2 95% RA, talking in full sentences, says she's not short of breath. Legs a little swollen same as admit. Not sure what's causing crackles, could be from lying in bed. Will listen again at 6 and after she walks. Call if RR over 24, sat under 92, or she says she's short of breath."
The second draft is hers. Its phrasing is not mine, and it does not need to be: the night nurse can now tell whether anything has changed.
One Disagreement Left Open
The novice argued for keeping one phrase: "says she's not short of breath." I would cut it, because a patient's denial of breathlessness is a weak signal in an older adult and could reassure the night nurse falsely. She argued that it is the patient's own report, that the night nurse will ask the same question and that a change in the answer is itself a finding. Her argument is reasonable, and my objection rests on my experience rather than on a standard I can point to. The phrase stays in her note, and the disagreement is recorded here rather than settled by the fact that I am the instructor.
References
Bohadana, A., Izbicki, G., & Kraman, S. S. (2014). Fundamentals of lung auscultation. New England Journal of Medicine, 370(8), 744-751. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMra1302901
Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81-112. https://doi.org/10.3102/003465430298487
Kluger, A. N., & DeNisi, A. (1996). The effects of feedback interventions on performance: A historical review, a meta-analysis, and a preliminary feedback intervention theory. Psychological Bulletin, 119(2), 254-284. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.119.2.254
The NUR-643EA Topic 3 assignment instructions
Topic 3 in NUR-643EA asks nurse educators to give feedback on a novice's documentation of an examination. Strong papers name the reader the note is for, such as the nurse who takes over at the next shift, and judge both an expert note and the novice note by what that reader needs. Students should identify where the novice note fails its reader and phrase each failure as a question the novice can answer, rather than handing back a rewritten note that teaches phrasing without the standard behind it. The paper should leave any genuine disagreement open with both positions stated, and it should draw on feedback research to justify the approach. Each note should be quoted as written, with times, so the comparison rests on the actual words, and the expert note should show the specific descriptors, such as timing and location of crackles, that make a finding useful to the next nurse.
How this NUR 643EA Topic 3 example is built
The finding is crackles at both bases in a composite older adult, and the expert note is short. It gives location, timing in the cycle, what changed with a cough, what the rest of the examination did and did not show, and one line stating what the writer is not concluding. The novice note beside it says decreased breath sounds noted, patient appears comfortable, will monitor. The paper marks four places where the second note fails a reader: a finding with no location, an interpretation offered as an observation, a plan with no trigger, and a judgment about comfort standing where a measurement belonged. Each mark carries the question an instructor would ask rather than the sentence an instructor would supply.
Reading the NUR 643EA Topic 3 rubric
Faculty reward feedback judged by the note's reader. An Excellent paper names the nurse arriving at 7 p.m. and quotes an expert note on fine late inspiratory crackles at both bases, using Bohadana and colleagues. Credit goes to quoting the novice note as written. The rubric values four failures phrased as questions, drawing on Hattie and Timperley and Kluger and DeNisi on feedback. Strong papers explain why a rewritten note is not handed back. Top marks go to leaving open the disagreement over keeping the patient's denial of breathlessness.
NUR 643EA Topic 3 help before you submit
Both notes are graded, and the second one carries the teaching weight. A submission that documents the finding beautifully and then adds a sentence about the importance of clear documentation has produced one note and no teaching. Marking the novice note by rewriting it is the frequent miss: the corrected version is the instructor's, the novice learns the phrasing rather than the standard, and nothing in the paper shows otherwise. Failure points named in general terms, as lacking specificity, do not locate anything a novice could fix. A second draft in the instructor's voice gives away that the questions were rhetorical. Papers that resolve every disagreement in the writer's favor tend to lose the credibility the rest earned.
Get an NUR-643EA Topic 3 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-643EA Topic 3 instructions, your rubric and the finding your section is documenting. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the note written for a named reader, a novice version left whole, and corrections delivered as questions rather than rewrites, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NUR 643EA papers and MSN samples
- NUR 643EA Topic 1: Skill Performed and Taught
- NUR 643EA Topic 2: Think Aloud Examination
- NUR 643EA Topic 4: Variant Versus Finding Judgment
- NUR 643EA Topic 5: Expert Blind Spot Dq Pair
- NUR 643EA Topic 6: Reflex Exam Across Three Ages
- NUR 643EA Topic 7: Learner Technique Correction
- NUR 643EA Topic 8: Single Skill Teaching Plan
- NUR 646EA Topic 3: Content Dependency Sequence
- NUR 641EA Topic 3: Confusable Drug Class Contrast
- NUR 648EA Topic 3: Clinical Questioning Sequence
- NUR 635 Topic 3: Cardiovascular Prescribing Analysis
NUR 643EA Topic 3 questions, answered
Why not simply give the novice a better sentence?
Because the sentence transfers and the standard behind it does not. A novice handed a rewrite can reproduce that phrasing on an identical finding and stall on the next one, since nothing told them what the note was for. A question makes them supply the missing piece, and the second draft then belongs to them, which is what the rubric is looking at.
Is the example a real note about a real patient?
Neither note describes anyone. Both are composites written for a page that a stranger can read, and no identifying detail appears in either. Composites also keep the messy parts a real chart would force out, which is what makes the comparison worth printing at all. Nothing here is documentation for anyone to file or act on.
Should the disagreement at the end be settled?
It is stronger left open in this example. The novice defends a phrase on grounds the writer finds weak but cannot dismiss, and recording that is more honest than a paper in which the instructor is right about everything. Graders on this course read an unresolved point as evidence the exchange happened rather than as a loose end.
Where can I find a free NUR 643EA Topic 3 sample paper?
The paper for NUR 643EA Topic 3 covers the reader, the expert note, the novice note, four places it fails its reader as questions, why the rewrite is not handed back and one disagreement left open. Post your NUR 643EA Topic 3 prompt and get a free paper.
How long should the feedback questions be in NUR 643EA Topic 3?
Short enough to answer at the bedside. The four in the example each take one line and point to one thing the 7 p.m. nurse needs.