| Course | NUR 643EA Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 2 |
| Paper type | Think-aloud examination analysis |
| Length | About 950 words, 4 pages |
| Format | APA 7 student paper |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 643EA Topic 2
Every Move and Why, Then Only Three: A Think-Aloud Posterior Chest Examination Filtered for a Novice
[Author Name]
College of Nursing and Health Care Professions, Grand Canyon University
NUR-643EA: Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators
Topic 2 Assignment
[Instructor Name]
January 21, 2030
The organization, setting and figures below are a composite written as a model document. No real employer, client, colleague or patient is described.
Every Move and Why, Then Only Three: A Think-Aloud Posterior Chest Examination Filtered for a Novice
The Examination, Move by Move, With the Reasoning Beside It
Mrs. D., a composite 57-year-old woman, came in coughing since Sunday, with a temperature reaching 38.6 degrees Celsius and right-sided chest pain on deep breaths. Her respiratory rate is 24 and her oxygen saturation 93 percent on room air. The posterior chest examination was performed in the usual order of inspection, palpation, percussion and auscultation (Bickley et al., 2021) and narrated as it happened (Table 1). Nothing in the right-hand column was added afterward; where I could not remember the reason for a move when I wrote the record up, the move is marked as habit rather than given a reason it did not have at the time.
Table 1
Posterior Chest Examination With Moment-by-Moment Reasoning
| Move | Reasoning at the moment of the move |
|---|---|
| Watch her breathe for 30 seconds before touching her | Rate, depth and effort now, before anxiety about the examination changes them; splinting on the right would point to pleural pain |
| Ask her to sit forward and cross her arms over her chest | Moves the scapulae apart so more of the lung fields are reachable; if she cannot sit forward, that is itself a finding about how unwell she is |
| Hands flat on the lower back, thumbs at about the tenth rib, ask for a deep breath | Unequal movement of my thumbs suggests the right side is not expanding, from pain, fluid or consolidation; equal movement does not exclude any of them |
| Place the side of my hand on the chest and ask her to say ninety-nine, comparing sides | Increased vibration over one area suggests consolidation conducting sound; reduced vibration suggests fluid or air between lung and wall; this move is what separates those two if the next move finds dullness |
| Percuss side to side, at the same level, from top to bottom | Comparison at matched levels is the point; dullness at the right base narrows the problem to something denser than air-filled lung |
| Percuss above each clavicle | Performed from habit; see below |
| Measure diaphragmatic excursion by percussing at full inspiration and expiration | Performed from habit; see below |
| Ask her to breathe in and out deeply through an open mouth, not quickly | Nose breathing adds noise and fast breathing makes her dizzy within a minute; slow, deep, open-mouth breaths let the base be heard clearly |
| Listen side to side at the same levels, including the lateral bases | Bronchial breath sounds at the right base, harsh and with a gap between inspiration and expiration, suggest consolidated lung conducting airway sounds; crackles would support fluid in the alveoli |
| Ask her to say ee over the abnormal area | An ee heard as ay, egophony, suggests consolidation; if it were absent over a dull area, fluid would become more likely |
| Ask her to cough, then listen again | Crackles that clear with a cough suggest secretions in large airways; crackles that persist favor alveolar fluid |
Findings
Reduced expansion on the right, increased vibration and dullness at the right base, bronchial breath sounds and egophony over the same area and crackles that persisted after coughing. The findings suggest right lower lobe consolidation. They raise the probability of pneumonia without establishing it, since individual findings on examination shift the probability only modestly and cannot rule pneumonia in or out alone (Metlay et al., 1997); a chest radiograph was ordered.
Two Moves Performed From Habit
Two moves in the record were not reasoning. Percussing above the clavicles is something I do on every posterior chest because I was taught to, and in this patient, with an illness clearly at the base, nothing it could have shown would have changed the next step. Measuring diaphragmatic excursion is the same: I did it, I recorded 4 cm on the left and could not measure the right because of dullness, and none of that changed what I did. I am recording them as habit rather than inventing a rationale, because a record with no habit in it would not be believable.
The Teaching Layer: A Rule for What a Novice Hears
A novice hearing the full right-hand column would hear nothing, because it asks for more attention than a first examination has to give. Working memory is limited, and instruction that loads it with material not needed for the task in hand interferes with learning the task (Sweller, 1988). The rule for the filter is: an item stays only if it governs a decision the novice will have to make alone, on a real patient, within the next month. Everything else waits.
Three items survive the rule: compare side to side at the same level, because that governs the decision of whether anything is abnormal at all; if one base is dull, test vibration or egophony, because that governs whether to report possible consolidation or possible fluid; and have the patient breathe slowly through an open mouth, because that governs whether what is heard can be trusted. Chest expansion, the cough-and-relisten move and the mechanism of bronchial breathing are good teaching but govern no decision a novice will make alone this month.
What Happened When the Narration Was Spoken Aloud
I then examined a composite patient with a novice beside me, speaking only the three items. The first two worked as intended. The third did not. I said it while listening, and the novice could not attend to the breathing instruction and the sounds at the same time; she asked afterward what I had meant about the mouth. The item was moved: it now belongs before the stethoscope touches the chest, as a setup instruction to the patient, not as narration during auscultation. The rule survived, and the order changed.
References
Bickley, L. S., Szilagyi, P. G., Hoffman, R. M., & Soriano, R. P. (2021). Bates' guide to physical examination and history taking (13th ed.). Wolters Kluwer.
Metlay, J. P., Kapoor, W. N., & Fine, M. J. (1997). Does this patient have community-acquired pneumonia? Diagnosing pneumonia by history and physical examination. JAMA, 278(17), 1440-1445. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.1997.03550170070035
Sweller, J. (1988). Cognitive load during problem solving: Effects on learning. Cognitive Science, 12(2), 257-285. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15516709cog1202_4
Reading the GCU NUR 643EA Topic 2 instructions
Topic 2 in NUR-643EA asks nurse educators to narrate an examination's reasoning and then adapt the narration for a novice. Strong papers record each move with the reasoning beside it, state the findings and what they suggest and admit any move performed from habit rather than reasoning, since a record claiming a reason for every step invites challenge. Students should explain why the full narration would overwhelm a novice and state a rule for selecting what the novice hears, grounded in research on cognitive load. The paper should report what happened when the filtered narration was spoken aloud during an examination, including which items worked as intended and which did not, so the rule can be revised. Findings should be stated in the vocabulary a reader would use to act on them, and the sources should support both the examination's interpretation and the teaching rule.
How this NUR 643EA Topic 2 example is built
The examination proceeds in its ordinary order and the page carries two columns. On the left, the move: the patient sat forward, the hand placed, the request to breathe through an open mouth. On the right, the reasoning: what this move could rule out, what it could not, and what result would send the next move somewhere else. Two moves are marked as habit rather than reasoning, performed because they always are, and the paper says so instead of inventing a justification. The teaching layer then cuts the narration down. Most of the right column is judged too much for a novice at a first pass, and three items are kept, chosen because each one governs a decision the novice is about to have to make alone.
Where the marks sit in the NUR 643EA Topic 2 rubric
Faculty reward reasoning recorded beside each move. An Excellent paper examines a 57-year-old with fever and pleuritic pain and records dullness, bronchial breath sounds and egophony at the right base, using Bickley and colleagues and Metlay and colleagues. Credit goes to admitting two moves performed from habit. The rubric values a rule limiting what a novice hears to three items, grounded in Sweller on cognitive load. Strong papers test the narration aloud beside a novice. Top marks go to reporting which item failed and why.
NUR 643EA Topic 2 help: mistakes that cost marks
The examination column is checked for accuracy and the reasoning column is where the marks move. Rationales written after the fact, so that every move turns out to have been necessary, read as tidy and a grader will test one or two against the sequence. A record with no habit in it is rarely believed, because experienced examiners all carry some. The filter is the part most often skipped: papers hand a novice the entire narration and call it modeling, which is the failure this topic sits on. Items kept without a decision behind them read as favorites. A teaching layer built on an examination the writer never performed leaves the second column with nothing to filter, and it shows within a paragraph.
Get an NUR-643EA Topic 2 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-643EA Topic 2 instructions, your rubric and the system your section examines. We write a custom example to those criteria, with the reasoning printed move by move, the habitual steps admitted, and a stated filter deciding what a novice hears, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NUR 643EA papers and MSN samples
- NUR 643EA Topic 1: Skill Performed and Taught
- NUR 643EA Topic 3: Documentation for the Next Clinician
- NUR 643EA Topic 4: Variant Versus Finding Judgment
- NUR 643EA Topic 5: Expert Blind Spot Dq Pair
- NUR 643EA Topic 6: Reflex Exam Across Three Ages
- NUR 643EA Topic 7: Learner Technique Correction
- NUR 643EA Topic 8: Single Skill Teaching Plan
- NUR 646EA Topic 2: Outcome to Objective Breakdown
- NUR 641EA Topic 2: Mechanism Misconception Map
- NUR 648EA Topic 2: Bedside Interval Teaching Plan
- NUR 635 Topic 2: Antimicrobial Selection Rationale
NUR 643EA Topic 2 questions, answered
Is every step supposed to have a reason behind it?
No, and a record claiming that is the one graders push on. Some of a systematic examination is sequence held by habit, which is efficient and worth keeping, and saying so costs nothing. The distinction matters for teaching, because a novice told that everything is reasoned will hunt for reasons that were never there and slow down.
Why cut the narration down at all?
Because a novice hearing an expert's full internal commentary is being handed the output of a skill they do not have yet. The cut is the teaching decision on this topic, and rubrics tend to credit the rule that produced it more than the items themselves. An unfiltered transcript shows a competent examiner and no teacher.
Does the write-up count as clinical documentation?
It is a sample paper, not a note anyone should act on, and it is written about a composite patient who does not exist. Nothing on the page is guidance for a reader's own practice. What the example demonstrates is the shape of a graded deliverable: an examination recorded honestly, then made teachable without losing what made it accurate.
Where can I find a free NUR 643EA Topic 2 sample paper?
The paper for NUR 643EA Topic 2 covers the examination move by move with its reasoning, findings, two moves performed from habit, a rule for what a novice hears and what happened when the narration was spoken aloud. Share your NUR 643EA Topic 2 prompt for a free paper.
Why admit moves performed from habit in NUR 643EA Topic 2?
Because a novice will copy them as if they were reasoning, and naming them lets the teacher decide which deserve teaching.