| Course | NUR 643EA Advanced Health Assessment for Nurse Educators |
|---|---|
| Topic | Topic 5 |
| Paper type | Expertise reflection discussion post |
| Length | About 640 words, 3 pages |
| Format | Discussion post, APA 7 citations |
| School | Grand Canyon University (GCU) |
| Program | MSN |
| Updated | October 2026 |
Free sample paper for NUR 643EA Topic 5
Topic 5 DQ 1: Initial Post and Reply
My Memory Wrote the Textbook: What a Silent Colleague Saw in My Knee Examination That I Did Not
Initial Post
Claim first: when I recalled my own examination, I wrote the textbook, and the moves worth teaching only showed up in a colleague's record of what I actually did.
The examination was a composite 29-year-old man with right knee pain two days after twisting it playing basketball. That evening I wrote my account from memory: inspection, effusion check, palpation of joint lines, range of motion, Lachman and anterior drawer, varus and valgus stress, McMurray. It is accurate and nearly useless for teaching, because it is the order in the course text.
A colleague had watched silently and written down every move. Her record contains three moves my memory left out. First, I examined his uninjured left knee before touching the right, which gave me his own normal for laxity and range; people differ, and a Lachman end point is only soft or firm compared with something. Second, during every stress test my eyes were on his face, not the knee, because guarding shows in the face a moment before it shows in the muscles, and a test performed against guarding is a test of the hamstrings. Third, before the drawer test I waited about 10 seconds with the knee flexed and my hands resting until the hamstrings relaxed; a tense hamstring can hold the tibia back and hide laxity. The ligament tests themselves perform best when the knee is relaxed, and the Lachman is more sensitive than the drawer in the acute knee (Benjaminse et al., 2006), which makes the pause more than a courtesy.
Her record also shows a shortcut: I did not perform McMurray, although I listed it in my recalled version. The history, a noncontact pivot with a pop and rapid swelling, pointed to the ligament, and the joint lines were not tender.
The sort is the point. The first three moves go to a novice as habits: baseline knee first, eyes on the face, pause before the drawer. The skipped test does not. A novice who skips McMurray because the story sounds like a ligament has no pattern recognition to license the skip and will miss the meniscus tear that comes with the ligament injury. Experts omit a large share of the steps and decisions they use when they describe a procedure from memory (Sullivan et al., 2014), and some of what they omit should be taught while some should not be imitated yet.
Question for the board: when should a withheld shortcut like this finally be handed to a learner, and what would the learner have to show first?
Reply to Classmate
Emily, your list of the automatic moves in your abdominal examination is clear, and I tried the same test on it that my colleague's record forced on mine. I traced each of your seven items to the course text: warm hands, patient supine with knees flexed, inspect before touching, auscultate before palpating, light before deep palpation, tender area last, watch the face. All seven are on the same two pages of our assessment text. That does not make them wrong. It suggests the list came from what you have read about examining an abdomen rather than from what you do, which is the blind spot our readings describe: expertise makes some knowledge invisible to the person who holds it (Nathan & Petrosino, 2003).
Could a classmate watch one of your examinations and write down every move without comment? My guess is that at least one move you make, perhaps how you decide when to stop palpating an area the patient guards, is not on those pages and is the one a novice most needs. And if the record turns up a shortcut, which one would you withhold, and until when?
References
Benjaminse, A., Gokeler, A., & van der Schans, C. P. (2006). Clinical diagnosis of an anterior cruciate ligament rupture: A meta-analysis. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy, 36(5), 267-288. https://doi.org/10.2519/jospt.2006.2011
Nathan, M. J., & Petrosino, A. (2003). Expert blind spot among preservice teachers. American Educational Research Journal, 40(4), 905-928. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312040004905
Sullivan, M. E., Yates, K. A., Inaba, K., Lam, L., & Clark, R. E. (2014). The use of cognitive task analysis to reveal the instructional limitations of experts in the teaching of procedural skills. Academic Medicine, 89(5), 811-816. https://doi.org/10.1097/ACM.0000000000000224
NUR 643EA Topic 5 instructions, in plain terms
Topic 5 in NUR-643EA asks nurse educators to reflect on what an expert's automatic habits hide from a novice. Strong posts open with a claim, compare the expert's recall of an examination with a record made by an observer and identify moves that only the record revealed. Students should explain why experts are poor sources on their own habits and decide which automatic moves a novice should copy and which should not be taught. Replies should test a classmate's list against the same standard, for example tracing each automatic move to its purpose, rather than simply praising it. Posts should cite research on the expert blind spot and on how much experts omit when describing their own procedures, and the examination itself should be accurate, with each move's purpose stated in terms a novice could act on at the bedside.
Inside the NUR 643EA Topic 5 example
The examination is a knee examination on a composite adult with pain after a twisting injury, and the post opens with the writer's account written from memory that evening. That account is accurate and nearly useless, because it reproduces the order a textbook gives. The colleague's record, kept without comment, holds three moves the remembered version lacks: the uninjured knee handled first, as a baseline for that person; the eyes kept on the patient's face rather than the joint during each stress test; and a pause to let the hamstrings settle before the drawer test, since a guarded muscle can hide laxity. A fourth move is flagged as a shortcut, a special test skipped because the history pointed elsewhere. In reply, a classmate's list compiled from recall is traced item by item to the course text.
Reading the NUR 643EA Topic 5 rubric
Faculty reward an expert's habits tested against an observer's record. An Excellent post claims that recall reproduced the textbook and compares it with a colleague's record of a knee examination, using Benjaminse and colleagues. Credit goes to moves only the record revealed. The rubric values explaining why experts omit steps, citing Sullivan and colleagues and Nathan and Petrosino on the expert blind spot. Strong posts refuse to teach every automatic move. Top marks go to a reply that traces each of seven moves to a purpose.
NUR 643EA Topic 5 help: mistakes that cost marks
Most of the credit on this discussion sits with where the list came from rather than how long it is. A post naming automatic moves from memory has, in nearly every case, written the textbook sequence in the first person, and a grader here usually recognizes it at once. Moves named without what each one protects read as trivia about the writer's habits. The sort is what most posts leave out, and one that hands every discovered move to a novice has missed that some automatic behavior is expertise nobody should imitate early. A reply that endorses the classmate's list and tacks on one more recalled move repeats the original method along with its blindness. Careful citations for the anatomy, with nothing behind the claims about expertise, leave the more heavily weighted half of the post unsupported.
Get an NUR-643EA Topic 5 example written to your instructions
Send the NUR-643EA Topic 5 discussion question, the rubric your classroom posts and the examination your section is studying. We write a custom example to those criteria, with a remembered account checked against an observed one, the surfaced moves sorted into inherit and withhold, and a reply that audits a classmate's source, in 24 to 48 hours. The first one is free.
More NUR 643EA papers and MSN samples
- NUR 643EA Topic 1: Skill Performed and Taught
- NUR 643EA Topic 2: Think Aloud Examination
- NUR 643EA Topic 3: Documentation for the Next Clinician
- NUR 643EA Topic 4: Variant Versus Finding Judgment
- NUR 643EA Topic 6: Reflex Exam Across Three Ages
- NUR 643EA Topic 7: Learner Technique Correction
- NUR 643EA Topic 8: Single Skill Teaching Plan
- NUR 646EA Topic 5: Exam Alignment DQ Pair
- NUR 641EA Topic 5: Unseen Mechanism Dq Pair
- NUR 648EA Topic 5: Unsafe Learner DQ Pair
- NUR 635 Topic 5: Apixaban Drug Selection Paper
NUR 643EA Topic 5 questions, answered
Why is an expert a poor source on their own habits?
A move performed thousands of times stops registering as a decision, so recalling the examination returns the version that was once learned rather than the one now performed. An observer who says nothing and writes everything down catches what memory has absorbed. The example treats the gap between the two records as its finding, not as an embarrassment to be tidied away before posting.
Should a novice copy everything an expert does automatically?
No, and the post is built around that refusal. Some automatic moves are protective and transfer well once somebody names them. Others only look like efficiency, because they rest on hundreds of earlier patients the novice has not met. Handing those over early produces a learner who skips the test without the recognition that made skipping it safe for the person they copied.
Does the post need a named source on expertise?
Benner's novice-to-expert work is the reference many sections expect, and its central claim, that experienced nurses respond to whole situations rather than to rules, fits the argument here. The citation belongs at the sorting decision rather than parked in the opening paragraph. Where the classroom asks for more than one source, the instructions posted there settle how many and of what kind.
Where can I find a free NUR 643EA Topic 5 sample paper?
The post for NUR 643EA Topic 5 covers the claim, the knee examination as recalled and as observed, the moves worth teaching and a reply that tests a classmate's list of automatic moves. Forward the NUR 643EA Topic 5 prompt you received for a free paper.
How was the knee examination recorded in NUR 643EA Topic 5?
A colleague watched silently and wrote down every move in order, without prompting, so the record could be set beside the examiner's recall.